Puerto Rico Review - Still Worth It?
Transcript
hello welcome back to the ball games poker YouTube channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews play for his unboxings and we generally talk a lot about likes about tabletop gaming in general and in this video we're gonna be talking about what a lot of people call a seminal achievement in the board gaming industry we're going to be talking about Puerto Rico and this is a game that stood at the top of the BoardGameGeek rankings for many many many many years and in this game you'll be taking a role which will allow you to take a specific action and then you'll be building buildings in order to gain resources that you were used to ship or goods to far-off lands loss which which will give you enough victory points to win the game and in this video we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules we'll be telling you what we do like what we don't like and then we will come back and we'll tell you whether or not Porto Rico it's still worth playing many many many many many many years after it was first released nothing as 2003 so remember if you know it then please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below and we'll see you after this board games for K so Puerto Rico how'd you play this game that's when you're gonna do is you're gonna perceive a player and this is devoted answer a grid system and you on
this grid you'll be placing our plantations in order to get resources that will allow you to ship these Goods often to fire flowers right and also at the top here player board you've got areas for buildings that these will allow you to place workers on to harvest resources and also they will give you game braking ability so cruxit is game the the meat and potatoes of this game are these roll carts and what you'll do these will all be displayed out depending on how many players around you'll have one or two prospector cards and the first thing you do on your turn it's the the first player a gardener will choose one of these roles they will take the action and they will get a specific benefit for being the person that chose the action everyone else will get to do the same action but I won't get the benefit so we just go through what these roles are and what they do so the first row is the Sailor action and what this allows you to do it allows you to take a plantation token and it allows you to place it on your player ball and if you're the governor and you take this role then you will be able to take a quarry instead of a plantation token so the next role that you can choose is the mayor and what you'll do you look at the the colonists ship and on that there may be some little disks you can use to populate your buildings or your plantation as well so if you were to marry if you take this action then you will take one of these disks off the colonist ship and you'll place it on one of your plantations or on one of your buildings to activate that build and then everyone else will do that but the mayor will get a special bonus that they will be able to take one additional colors and you'll keep doing this until all the colonists are gone so it may be the case that some people may end up with more or less colonists than everyone else right so the next action is the Builder action and what you'll do you everybody will get the opportunity
to build one build it but the governor and I take this fall we'll be able to pay one less doubloon then it's listed on the building each building has got a cost and it's got some of them have got a certain number of victory points most buildings I've got spaces where you could put colonists to active a building and there's different types of buildings obviously got the plantations which match the color of each resource are indigo coffee tobacco etc etc you've also got these purple buildings which will allow you to break the game and some of these buildings that will give you a flavor of course some of these buildings today so you've got these small market which will allow you to get +1 to bloom with any sale you got the hospice we're we'll give you plus one colonists for settling and you've got a factory which will give you a variety of doubloons with the production floating across my face which we talked about in a bit and you've also got a harbor which will give you one victory point per delivery in the captain's face sir you've also got these quite large buildings occupy more than one spot and they give you just victory points at the end of the game so the next action that you can do is the craftsman it's what will allow you to take goods from the supplier called in steel production there Billy so you look at all the plantations that have been activated by workers and then you will take that many resources from the supply bonus of this is the governor will take one extra resource haffley so the next thing you can do you've got the trader role this water now to sell one good trade now the governor will be able to sell one extra good we gotta member in the trade nothing is there only there's only room for four goods but the trading house will only buy different goods so you can't put say two corn on there or two coffee on there so you've got be careful about when you take this action so the
next action you can do is the captain action it's one Halley's ship you're all resources off to far-off lands and you got remembers the sort of inverse of the previous action each ship can only carry one type of goodies only empty our Wendy's ship is full of one top good so again you've got be careful we could be wary about when you take this action when you place goods onto these ships you will get one victory point but good but the governor will get an extra victory borne it doesn't matter what could you ship out so if you ship corn then you'll still get one but your point even if you say ship coffee or tobacco so you've got remember as well right at the end of every round any goods that you got on your player book they're left over they will spoil but you get to keep one of them so you really is in your interest to try and get goods into your system and then get out your system as quickly as possible so the final action you could do is the prospector and what'll happen here is that you will just get one doubloon from the bank and the governor will get two so once everyone's taking these actions there will be some left over and what you'll do any actions any roles that are left have you put butter on them to make them a little bit more liquid in Scrolls so there's a variety of ways in which a game can end you end the game when all the victory points have run out all the victory point tokens run out when it all the colonists tokens have been used up or when one player has built their 12th city so that's where the game ends what you'll do you'll add up all of all your victory point tokens you had a Auto victory point values of all your buildings and the player with the most victory points will be victorious in Puerto Rico so what do we like about Puerto Rico so the first thing that we really like
about Puerto Rico is the way that the roles allow everybody to take the action and it's the case of not just the case of say you were first in there you get to take the action right you everybody gets the choice of taking this action and there's at the time back in 2002 2003 whenever this of all comers made out was revolutionary because before that I think everybody was just sort of well I'm having that you can't have a so the wonderful thing about this is if you do take your first you get that lovely benefit that extra benefit and everybody's still really envious supporting but you get an F you're not the governor when you take the action you still get to take the action and that's great so the second thing that we really like about this is the way to buildings give you these game-breaking abilities and it could be the case that they and put their buildings in there would have just been sort of get resources ship them off get resources ship them off but these buildings everybody's got the opportunity don't know I mean obviously you could there are limited again if you can get in there faster then you can have the building that you want and there may be and may be the case that if you leave it too long you're going to miss out because the buildings are finer but they're all there ready for you to Nick in it so it's a case of do you wait for your engine to be more efficient or do you invest in the building's first and then hope that you can get your plantation up and running later in the game so it's a nice toss out no obviously it all DePaul so depends whether you can tie their name with the way that you're choosing the roles and get the benefits from the rocks so the third thing that we really like about this is the way that when you're going to the trading house or trying to ship goods off you have to wait all the talc to be completely clear so the way that this works is is obviously the trade nest it only takes one of each type of
good but the the export ships they only take one good so you've got the option never both ways of doing it but it may be the case that you might be investing a lot in coffee and then somebody goes and puts a corn on one of the ships in you're like really I was just about ship all my coffee out but that's the wonderful think about this going so the final thing that we really like about this is that even though this game gets criticized for just being sort of like a a multi player solo game if that makes sense but we don't agree with that what we think is that you've got constantly Bush the way that other players are so building are their engine so that you can plot against China blocking because obviously if you see that a player is investing heavily in indigo then it's in your interest to go for maybe a different resource so you can dump that on the export market before they do so that that that blocks off that ship right there is a tremendous amount a skill in trying to develop your engine in the most efficient manner and that's probably why this guy is cyber laughter right so what don't we like about Puerto Rico so the first thing that we thinks quite feeble about Puerto Rico is the component quality it's kind of looking kind of tired in this day and age and I know you've got this deluxe edition which costs absolute army-like but I'm not willing to give up one of my kidneys in order to get that but it could do with a complete refresh Clare boards are very flimsy the artwork is kind of old and dated I mean okay this doesn't affect the gameplay too much doesn't really feel that great you know so it could do with a second edition so the second thing that we don't like about
Puerto Rico is it's questionable Beaman and I know this is a contentious issue in a lot games I mean we had the same sort of issue with acappella going away but the colonists ship is essentially like a slave ship right and it's quite uncomfortable enjoyin again that essentially sort of reminds you of a sort of a tainted history and I don't want to dwell too much on this obvious reason but it's it's in there this it's just it's just an uncomfortable kind of theming there's this inserting the game in it when you look at the counters and you look at the ships it's just it's not very pleasant thing to have staring back at you at the table and in a sense you know I don't really like feeling that uncomfortable and playing games right so the thing that we don't like about it is this for alternative reality things I mean everybody is playing on the same island it's almost like sort of doesn't really make sense you know like I know you could say you could argue that you've got the the island is big enough for everybody to have a plantation in the same square but it seems after the bat though because everybody's got the same map everyone's sort of playing in the same space and it's almost like there's these sort of four alternative universe is going on it doesn't really make sense to me so it just seems a bit odd it would have been better maybe so you have four different islands but then that wouldn't have been poor Rico right so it's just a bit weird so the fourth thing probably the main thing that we find a bit crap about poor Rico is the game essentially rewards repeat play
right so you're the more experienced you are with this because there's sort of like a one true path in a sense as well there's not much randomization in this apart from the way that the resources all these halls come out so it's it rewards people that could identify that best method through the game and if you're new to this and you plan with experienced players you are going to get your ass handed to you no doubt about it and that sort of puts new people off play earnest if you'll plan it with somebody who's experienced but obviously if everybody's come into it from the same level of experiencing that that's not problem but the fact that game does reward you repeat plays and you play this more than you the other members again group then it's a non-starter so that's a really really big downer so to summarize is Puerto Rico still worth playing today and in the future so we are going to say yes Puerto Rico is without doubt an all-time classic strategy game and one of the pieces of evidence of this is the way that this sat at the top of the ballgame geek right yes regardless what you think about a ballgame keep talking lungis it's out there for a very long time I think was displaced by Agricola I think but yeah this is an all-time classic it does feel dated and it needs to be refreshed because it feels quite tired and it does have some quite questionable content so that's another thing to consider if if that's or think bothers you then there are other alternative games to play a lot of castles of Burgundy or other sort of engine building games right so we're gonna give this 4 out of 5 we do like Puerto Rico aside from the problems with the game we
do really really like this it's a excellent game because we've all come to this from the same position that's Puerto Rico is still a solid you're a game and remember if you're new here and please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below right and we'll see you next time