Mille Fiori Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everyone today i'm taking a look at milifiori which is a two to four player board game designed by dr reiner kenitzia this one takes 60 to 90 minutes to play the key mechanisms of this game are pass and draft and i suppose everything else is a big point salad which takes place on this big board here which is divided up into these individual mini games all of which offer points in different ways so the objective of course is to get more points than your opponents do by the time the game ends um during the setup of the game you're going to have a bunch of these bonus cards put to the side which kind of acts as a pool of options you can take should you unlock a bonus action each player is also going to have their own unique color of these plastic diamonds which you're going to use to claim spots on the board and get points accordingly now during the start of the game or each round each player is going to get given five cards to draft from you're going to pick one of those you're going to resolve the action and then you're going to pass the rest to your opponent on the left so the cards are going to look like this and they all relate to a different part or section of the main board and they all quite clearly depict what they do and how you gain points for doing so but additionally if you don't want to play for the main action you can actually just forfeit it and move along this boat track at the bottom and get the corresponding amount of points but let's talk about what all the different actions you can take and how they score so this top left-hand part of the board is quite simple where you're trying to create chains of your pieces so let's just say i drafted this card and resolved this action i'm going to have a look at the matching symbol in this case this fire one i'm going to place my
piece there and then i'm going to get a point for each of my corresponding pieces in a chain there so in this example i'm going to get three points but then in the future if i want to place another one i'm going to get four points and then five points now if i ever place a piece of mine on this pestle and mortar symbol then i'm going to get double the amount of points so it's quite valuable if you create a network connecting to one of these symbols now additionally if you ever create a triangle like this around one of these stars it means you're going to get a bonus action and going to get to draft from the kind of communal pool on the side and get a follow-up action for free so that's a very valuable way to get more actions chained together additionally if you get one of each of the different sybils here then you can claim the spot in priority order so if i'm the first person to get one of these one of these one of these in one of these then i'm going to place that piece on the highest amount of point and the next person to do or take the next lowest and so on these key cards correspond to this track going around the right hand side of the board here like so and when you do that you are simply going to place your player piece on the next available number in the row here like so and now you're going to have a look for any of your pieces adjacent to each other or adjacent to the one you've just placed and calculated calculate the total value of that so in this example the red player will gain seven points because they've got the three here and a touching four so you want to be trying to create as many of these in a row as you can without any interruptions now additionally if you ever gain three different numbers
you're going to get a bonus action again using those communal cards at the side of the board and if you gain four different numbers you are going to claim the um 20 points and then so on 15 10 and 5 depending on how quick you achieve that and after that if you get five different numbers you're going to get another bonus action these two parts of the board here work in the exact same way where you're trying to create these pyramids of your colors so let's just say that the yellow player played this um this symbol here they're going to have a look for the matching shape on the board and then they're going to place their place on that so they could have go here here or they can actually go here now because you can actually build from the bottom up but i couldn't go straight in say build here because that doesn't have a foundation of a pyramid to build on now when you do that you're going to have a look at the card here and see how many points you get so on a base level you're only going to get one point for each one on the middle level you're going to get three points and on the top level you're going to get six points however if you play the exact right symbol because and this this is like the only exception where you can play any card to place anywhere here but if you match that symbol perfectly you're going to get double the amount of points but you have to bear in mind that whenever you complete a perfect pyramid like this not only are you going to score but also the people below you in that pyramid are going to score their amount of points as well so um again you've got to be careful about what you take because um somebody else might benefit more than you do now additionally much like the other sections if you get one of each symbol you are going to get the 20 15 10 or 5 points and again this part of the board works in the exact same method
additionally when a player completes that third level of the pyramid they are going to get a bonus action and the final section of the board is where these two different cards come into play these boat cards and these good cards and these kind of work harmoniously with one another so basically these good cards again you're going to have a look at the type of good or the the particular type and you're going to play one of your pieces on that type of good so in this one you've got this kind of chalice thing you're going to put your piece on that chalice so let's say i put it here like so and then you're going to get a number of points equal to the amount of these ones that have already been claimed so that's going to get me one point but say someone puts a second one down they're going to get two points and then three points and so on but also everybody else in that column is also going to get the points based on that so you've got to be careful again about what you're going to award your opponent however this one does have a slightly different incentive to give your opponent more points than you do because if you ever do that you're going to get a bonus action and again just like the other ones if you get one of each different type of good then you're going to get the 20 15 10 or 5 points depending on how quickly you do that now these boats um tokens here which correspond to these boat cards you are going to again put one of our player pieces on that spot so let's just say the green player played a boat card and wanted to claim this first spot of the boat here now this is like the only region that doesn't dish out points instantly so this one they only actually score once each of these spots has been claimed by the same or different players and then
you're going to get a number of points based on how many goods are on that boat so you can see using this um card as a guide here if there's only one good on that boat before they know when these three places are filled up you're going to get one point per boat you've got there or three points or six points or ten points depending on how many goods are there so additionally when you do take that boat action you are always going to move along the boat track and um you know the corresponding amount of spaces which is um illustrated on the card and get the amount of bonus points there either one three ten five or even a bonus action if you land perfectly on one of those spots so once each player has taken four turns and taken the corresponding card action the remaining card you're left with is going to get placed into the communal card row meaning that other people can potentially access it should they get a bonus action for taking another one and as i said earlier you're going to keep on playing so somebody has placed all of their glass diamonds here or until the draw deck runs out and then you're going to calculate who's got the most points and that player is going to be the winner okay so let's get in some thoughts on miller fiore so pass and draft is something i tend to enjoy but i tend to like those games more when the passing draft is just a smaller part of it whereas in this game it is quite a big feature of the game and plays a quite a pivotal part on what you can do because of course there are so many things you need to consider here not only for yourself but for the other people as well and how they are going to benefit from your draft because there are so many different ways you can score here and some of which will give your
opponents quite a hefty amount of points if you are not careful and something as well that i'm not normally too fussed about in drafting games is the idea of hate drafting or drafting just despite somebody else getting a particular card this one i think that's unavoidable i think you need to be on the ball and be careful about what your opponents are getting and be careful not to give those players certain cards if for example this part of the board up here you are going to get a hell of a point a lot of points if you do manage to get a big chain together because again this yellow player here has got one point then he's got two points and he's got three points and he's got four points and then he's got 10 points because this is a doubling spot so this idea of snowballing can really run away with you and you can get a hell of a lot of points if you do not stop that meaning that you might want to start drafting cards on your turn simply to stop that yellow player from getting the next one in their chain and potentially even from cutting them off their route completely just to stop them in their tracks and again to stop that snowballing of points from happening but that being said although you are trying to create these roots of points and you've always got to be careful about trying to diversify somewhat because there is a big swing of points available here as well so this idea of spinning these plates and considering so many things with each draft is a really strong thread throughout the game you know how am i going to stop my opponents how am i going to be the first person to get this big bunch of points here and how am i even going to get my own chain built as well at the same time you want to be trying to complete these diamonds so that you can get this bonus action so again just layers and layers of choices here that you need to consider with each
draft and that is only one facet of the game you've got so many different things going on here you've got this big chain of keys here that i really enjoy and particularly when you have these big high points next to each other like this you know if you get a big chain going here that's again a huge chunk of points that you cannot avoid but at the same time you might be conflicting yourself you know i really want this um next one in the chain here so i can get loads of points here but at the same time there's a really inviting spot here or there's a really inviting spot down here on the boats that i need to claim so again just so many things you need to consider and um not only with the idea of getting the points from straight up the action but again the diversification and the bonus actions themselves because there could be a great car just sitting there waiting to be used should you get a bonus action now i do think some of these um games work a little bit more interestingly than others now that's not saying i i dislike any of them i think all of them are interesting but again some of them are just a bit more inviting than others like i think this um this pyramid part of the game is probably my least favorite again i'm not saying i dislike it because it's it's still quite fun but this one you are going to be kind of inviting other people to get more points with each of your placements but i understand why they did that perfect matching thing where if you match that symbol perfectly you get double the amount of points meaning that you're more invited to go there and that incentive to go there is stronger and again that also relates to the top spot here now if you build that perfect pyramid you're gonna get double the amount of points and which i think is like 12 points and get the bonus action but again considering the net gain that the red player is going to get three points here the yellow player's gonna get three points here and a point at the
bottom one as well so again i love that idea that even when it's not your turn you can start getting this little engine of points just passively when it's even when you're not even involved in that decision which is really cool and again adds a new level of engagement now the boat part of the map here is probably one of the most involved parts of the game that lets you or makes you just sit back and think a bit more with each placement because this is almost like a game of chicken where again you are building this incentive appoints before they actually get you actually get those points because again the only the points are only dished out once the fleet of ships is complete meaning that if you put say two pieces down there just to secure your spot somebody else might shove the last one down before there's even any goods on there to stop you getting so many points so it's kind of striking this balance between the two of having a healthy amount of goods on that ship before you put your ships there but claiming the ships at the same point you reserve your space so again that kind of tension of what you want to do first and keeping the um the two balance is cool because again there's a lot of points that can be had here but i do love that carrot that the designer dangles in front of you to want to load the goods up because it does cascade it does snowball the more you put these things down and even if you award your opponent more points than you get for placing these things down then you get a bonus action which could reward you more in other parts of the game so again all that idea of who's gaining the most of each placement is um is where the decision space really lies because you are showered in points in this game and um you know sometimes you have to be prepared to give your
opponent points for you to gain more so the decisions in this game are plentiful there's so much you need to think about but i do love the fact that it is tied back to this draft system so you are somewhat tunnel vision to what you can do you can't just pick and choose which one to do each turn again you are restricted to the cards you have in your hand now despite there being quite a bit going on here i do think the game does a good job of being digestible because individually each of these parts of the game are very easy to understand and i think it's only going to take once to uh explain maybe with the exception of the shipping area that's going to take maybe a ton of a go or two but still nothing um terribly complex here and this is one of those games that's almost bigger than the sum of its parts because again if you break it down very easy to understand but once it comes together that's when the magic starts to come into play i think the time investment for this game is spot on it only takes 60 to 75 minutes to play and you get a lot done in that time and you can really sink your teeth into some of these mini games get a lot of points in return but at the same time it's not too generous to the point where you can achieve you can achieve too much and start getting bored with it so i think that balance is very delicately done and um it pulls it off well so i do like that idea of you know the game always being on the uh kind of that tension of the game ending anytime soon because you know that deck of cards is depleting or people are getting a string of bonus actions and placing a bunch of their tokens down and that is going to make you prioritize certain actions so you can get as many points as you can as quickly as you can without wasting any turns and before the
game ends i think the replayability of the game is decent because there are so many different things you can try and go for and it really helps that you are restricted to the cards in your hand so that you cannot just follow the same strategy every single time if this was just a free flow you can go where you want when you want i could see the game getting quite tiresome quickly but because again you will have that draft and you do have that set of cards in your hand that is going to completely almost make that part of the game void and keep it feeling fresh i think the player interaction in this game is very strong you cannot avoid um stepping on other people's toes and you have to be on the pulse and try to stop other people from getting these big chains as i discussed earlier um but i would say that i do think the game does start to shine when it gets to that three or four player count i do feel like you need that extra wild card in play in order to spice up the mini games to make the the pyramids more interesting otherwise you clearly know who's benefiting the most of each placement and it becomes a bit tighter as well with more players additionally i think like if you have that third player in the game or the fourth player it's not always going to fall to you in order to stop those combos and things so i think that's a more pleasant experience rather than being constantly paranoid about what your opponent's doing and constantly cutting each other off and if you have that third or fourth player you probably have a bit more wiggle room to do what you want to do and maybe leave it to the other players a turn or two to stop people from running away from things so i think the production for mili fiore is generally of a high quality um i think the game looks very appealing maybe a little bit busy to start with but once
you understand and how the games are broken down it's a bit more digestible and the actual player pieces themselves are very nice and still not not overly um you know superfluous or expensive which is good strike some nice bounce of being affordable but still having a good polished look to it you know these transparent um tokens look great when they fill up the board they start to build up this nice kind of mosaic of color and you can see the symbols beneath them which is a which is a good choice i think the cardstock is um is nice now they do have a linen finished cards they're a good size they're not sprawling everywhere because you do build up quite a big pool of cards at the side of the board so it's nice that they are made that choice to make the cards smaller um and yeah generally i'm very happy with things i think the only exception maybe is that i would have liked the board itself to be a bit thicker cardboard because it's a little bit thin and it doesn't lay perfectly flat at least the version i have here doesn't so it would be nice for that to be a little bit more deluxified but other than that very happy with the production and i think it fits the look of the game very well okay so final thoughts on miller fiore so i think this game is extremely enjoyable i think it does a good job of feeling satisfying with each turn you take but it does still does a good job of making the game feel tense and being careful and on the pulse with what other people are doing so i do like that level of interaction now i don't know if this is like a new niche of game that kenitsia is starting to dive into this idea of these point salad um combo riffix style games you know we recently saw that in which stone which was actually one of my favorite games from last year i thought it's a truly excellent game this one is almost comparable to that
where you have that same get that those dopamine hits of doing all these big satisfying turns but this one i think is a bit more um a bit more interactive in respect of being careful about what you award your opponents but i do like the way you are showered in points in these games i do like the way that you get these follow-up turns and even a couple in a row if you pull it off by getting these bonus actions and i love that tenseness of the draft you know what are you going to take as a priority who knows what you're going to get next you know and again that being restricted really does work for the game and and you have to weigh up you know what you're going to gain from each single placement and that makes me feel engaged it makes me enjoy it from start to finish it has a great degree of progression in the game as you can build up more chains and build up these pyramids and get a big row of these for example and it all comes together in a very nice polished kind of harmonious package really that i think is a lot of fun it's accessible and it might just be one of my favorite examples of a pass and draft style game because again every choice is important so again if it's not clear to you this one game this game is going to get a shield of quality from me i recommend it i think it's a lot of fun and it's going to fit that nice kind of niche of a medium to lightweight point salad style game that i think a lot of people are going to enjoy so that is miller fiore i don't sleep on this one i think it's kind of going to fly under the radar a little bit and i don't think it should because it is very good that is mili fiore