Star Wars: Battle of Hoth Review
Transcript
Hey everybody, welcome to Drive-Through Review 818. Today we're going to take a look at Star Wars Battle of Hoth. This is a new game from Days of Wonder designed by Richard Borg who is famous for the Command and Color series which is this is a part of and it's a co-design with Adrien Martino. It also had this little icon here that says Galactic Battles. I don't know if you can see that on the box cover. So, I'm not sure if this is a new series of games that are Star Wars games or space command and colors series, something like that. I'm not sure what that is for, but this is a two to four player game. I've only played a two-player and if you play four players, it's in teams of two. And you'll run through a bunch of scenarios set in the Hoth system in the Star Wars universe.
One side plays Empire, one player plays the Rebellion, and uh yeah, so let's go down to the table. It's not really that much different at all from normal Commands and Color. So, the overview will be uh pretty quick and I'll come back and tell you what I think. Okay, so I've got kind of a pseudo game setup here on the board with various different pieces. You've got the Imperial side on that side, Rebel on this side. The game does come with these cool card holders which come apart in two pieces. You can store them back in the box and you can just put your hand of cards here, which is pretty nifty for such a small box game. And you'll actually notice if you're familiar with Commands and Colors games, this board size is actually pretty compact and small compared to, you know, some of the other games. Uh, which is nice actually. Uh, one thing that is also nice is if we plop down here, you can see the insert in the boxer. So, all of the Empire and Rebel units are all in these nice little plastic totes. And you have space here for dice. Here's spot for terrain. The card holders go in here. The cards themselves will go into here. And you've got some spot for some different terrain tokens there. Then you put the board and everything in there. It all packs away very nicely. Now, the reason I bring that up is on first blush, it seems like it might just be kind of a smaller portable maybe lighter version of a Command and Colors game. Not the case.
If we take a look here, look at the scenario book. We have here 18 different scenarios. Now, the last scenario here requires two copies of the game. And I'm not sure how I feel about that. I'll talk about that in the review. But even if you leave that one out, still 17 different scenarios that you can play through. You can just go through and play through those in in order randomly. But then you also have two separate campaigns where you'll play multiple games in a row and you have a book, I should say a booklet for the rebels and the Imperials for each campaign. So there's campaign one. Here's campaign 2. And then as you play, it's got a just a couple extra little rules there for campaign play. And then you'll have this kind of branching narrative where you'll set up different battles. The battles will come out of the the book. So there's not like new scenarios in here necessarily, although some of the objectives and some some of the uh decorations for the scenario will be a little bit different when you play it in the campaign, which I'll explain in a second. And you've got various different endings and stuff like that. So, for such a small compact box, you've got 17 scenarios and then two full campaigns where you play, I think, three or four games. I've not played any the campaign, just looked through the rules for it. I just play some one-off games. Now, if we just take a look here, just real quickly, it's the same kind of Command and Color style game. Uh, I believe Roger Smith has a walkthrough of actually how to play the game. So, if you're not familiar with Command and Colors, I'm not going to go over it here, but you can watch that just for some detail. Uh but basically be playing
cards and activating units in one of the three kind of flanks here or maybe just you know doing what the card says on the text. This is just exactly like you know the other dozen games uh in that kind of series. The difference is though each player has their own deck instead of a shared deck of cards. So in that case if somebody you know draws a card that you you know you really need or you're planning to kind of use towards the end of the game they're not going to keep that away from you. you're going to have your own sort of copy of it in here. So, you don't have to worry about that. It's still random, you know, based on the deck that you have, but that's kind of an interesting part of it. One of the reasons that they did that is because you also have these leader cards. So, here we'll look at some Imperial leaders. And if we look here at the bottom, you can see Darth Vader. So, there's three Darth Vader cards. There's three of these Maxim Million Veers, three Admiral Piet, and so on. And then we also have here for the Rebels. So here's three Han solo cards. And so you can based on the situation that you're doing either play without those or each player can choose a set in secret. And if they do, they'll choose the three cards that go with that particular leader. Shuffle it into their deck and that'll just give you some cool special abilities and so on.
And then if you're playing through the campaign, it will actually kind of tell you based on the scenario to include or not include uh leaders and specific leaders and so on. The other part that's going to happen is you also have these cards here which are Imperial and Rebel. These will get added to your hand. You will be able to basically have these in the course of the campaign. So these are not for just one-off games, although why not play with them? There's no reason you couldn't. So typically what will happen is that you'll get a reward as you know for various scenarios of the campaign and then shuffle up these decks and draw a random one. And these were going to act as like augmentations or auxiliaries to your normal hand of cards here. So they don't count as part of your hand because each scenario will give you kind of a hand limit that you'll have. So you may add, you know, let's say this in this case for the rebels, you might have this one extra card and you will play these along with uh, you know, a normal card to sort of juice that up. So it's just kind of cool little flavorful pieces uh, you know, that work into the campaign in that way.
Now, some other differences that are pretty neat is you also have, you know, you got your typical stats for the units. So, let's look at one of the stat cards. There's actually two of these in the game, and they're double-sided, so each player can reference uh, you know, what your units can do and what your opponent can do. And so, you can see here they've got the movement speed, what their amount of dice rolls that they roll in terms of range. So if you look at the um infantry here, you know, adjacent spaces will roll three dice, then two, then one, and then anything beyond three is, you know, is out of range. Or instead of, you know, moving once and shooting, you can move twice. And then this one here for the speeders, these can move three spaces and so on. This gives you the dice that you can roll short range, but you can do a lot of damage. And then here are the dice that will actually damage that particular unit. And you can see for like the atat, you just need one hit to kill it. But you've got to kind of like roll this symbol or this symbol and then roll another hit after that based on the number of symbols that you roll. So it's you you got to kind of double roll to kill the ad at and then it'll go away.
And it moves very slow, but you can see the range doesn't, you know, affect the number of dice that it rolls. So you have these sort of basic sort of loadouts for the unit. And then over the depending on the scenario, you might have these other little tokens here that you will add, you know, adjacent to the unit, put it in their little hex there. And so that's going to give them another special ability that'll be dictated by the scenario there. So that's kind of a cool way to sort of, you know, add some variability and stuff like that to the game, beef up those units a little bit. So these these cards are very handy. Just a very easy quick reference. You've also got here this one double-sided, although it's the same on both sides, uh, reference for all the different terrain. Very easy to digest. I mean, they really have the system nailed down and ironed out. And as you can see, you know, I'm spoiling the review here, but the production level is is really really good, especially for the the size of the box and the price of the box and everything. It's it's a really good deal in that way. Uh, the only other thing I would mention is how you score points. And this isn't different from every Command and Colors games, but it's just how it works in in this case. So depending on the scenario, you might score points in different ways, which isn't really a new thing, but not all Command and Colors work like that. So if you typically wipe out a unit and then you as the opponent, so let's say this speeder unit was wiped out by my opponent, they would take one of these. And then if you look here, in this case, the rebel player has a little track here for victory point. So let's say I wiped out, you know, one of their infantry. So I keep that one. So that would count as a victory point, but they
might get victory points in other ways. So you might take a point that way. And so usually you play to a certain number of victory points. And it's not always going to be, hey, if you remove this unit, you get a victory point. Or if you do this objective, you get a victory point. It's going to vary from scenario to scenario. So in a lot of ways, I would say this is in terms of that part of the game most like memoir 44 as compared to some other things like, you know, battle lore, samurai battles, and other things like that. Uh, and also because you've got some fast moving units and a lot of range units, there's not really the concept of melee in this case. So, it's going to feel a lot more like Memoir 44 in terms of how the units kind of work and then of course some of the special abilities are very similar and then also kind of how you generally score points and how it's going to get changed up by the scenarios. Okay, so that is Battle of Hoth. We'll just jump into my pillars of review. Uh, first we'll talk about player count. I've only played a two-player, not tried the team game. Like I said at the beginning, uh I've come to find out there's actually kind of a universal solo mode um that is meant to be work with just about any Command and Colors game. I don't know that it would apply to that. It would came out for various GMT games uh that they've released over the years cuz GMT's probably released the most uh variations on the Command and Colors.
Uh, if you look up, I think it's called Stuka Joe's Command and Color Solo Mode or GMT solo mode. The rules are like two pages. I glanced through them. I was like, I think that would work, but I'm not sure. So, you could theoretically play the solo. I've not tried it. Um, I don't I don't even want to hazard a guess if if it would work or not, but as a two-player game, uh, it works really well, and I like that player count uh, with this. The play time, the box is 30 minutes. I would say yes, definitely because it plays very snappy and very quick, especially once you kind of get to know, you know, what all the terrain does and the different units and that kind of thing. And, you know, splashing in the variability of some of the support cards or the leader cards or the different specialized units and different scenarios. Not a lot of overhead there, especially if you've got like a game or two under your belt. um just you know I just jumped right ahead and we played through I was like scenario seven or eight or something and I was like oh this is really cool you know how all these different little wrinkles and variables are adding to the game. So yeah I don't think I need more than 30 45 minutes at most uh for a two-player game for sure. Now, there is an epic game where you actually flip the board over, get another copy of the game, flip that board over, and then use units from both games, and you have like a big epic battle. Um, in that case, I didn't try that and I'm kind of two minds about that. But let's go ahead and jump into the third pillar, which is like what is this game like? Or basically, how would I compare this to
other Command Colors games? And I really like like 90% of this. Uh, and I don't often talk about the price of the game. Uh, but I think in this case it it makes some sense because I think MSRP is $60. I've seen it on sale for $60. I've seen it on sale for like $48. And if you look at the amount of scenarios, you got the two campaigns, you got some nice plastic and components and all that stuff. you have a lot of things to kind of tinker with and play with in terms of the leaders, the support cards, the different scenario, uh, special abilities, the different objectives, the campaign objectives, all that stuff packed into this like really tight box. It's a really cool production from that point of view. And I often don't talk about production necessarily cuz, you know, it gets sticky, I guess.
And sometimes it's not interesting. And I think in this case it is interesting because like I said there's so much in the box for around 50 bucks you know and you know it's 2025 and that is just a sweet sweet deal and hours and hours and hours of gameplay for a really cool fun system. So at the end of the day I really have enjoyed Command and Colors over the years. I've played I don't know how many different games in the system. Uh but it's a lot of fun. It's just a very quick, easy game that doesn't have zero strategy, but doesn't have like an immense amount of strategy. Uh it it doesn't bore you at all. Like from the word jump all the way to the end of the scenario, it's not boring at all. That's the main thing. you're always kind of like screwed over by your deck, but like working around that and trying to get around that, trying to be smart about holding cards and, you know, letting the game kind of fish out cards for you.
And, you know, taking stock of what other abilities are in play and that kind of thing. And then you add on top of that the two campaigns, which is just like, man, this is like butter on top. It's really, really neat. And frankly, I kind of came into the game uh thinking like, I don't know, this just feels like it's a very small little light game. not really knowing what was in the contents. It's just like ah it's just kind of a one-off thing. But to the credit of the folks that were involved with the production of this game, they added all these extra elements where I think even if this doesn't have an expansion, which was which is what what I was kind of thinking was this game's going to need expansions down the road to make it, you know, to make it a full game. I don't think that's the case at all. I think if they never come out with anything else for this, this is a nice compact complete experience that you're going to get a lot out of. You can there's going to be a lot of replayability here with all the different variables and everything I've spoken about 100 times already, but it's a really cool little package. Now, could they add expansions to it? Oh, of course they could, and they they probably will. Um, and so I'm going to leave with my recommendation recommendation and then jump ahead a second. So, do I recommend this? 100%.
Especially for the price and if you like Star Wars or you have kids. Um, and I will say this, my kids are all grown, but I used to play Memoir uh with my youngest son and he used to love it. We used We used to love it. And what I would do is I would take out all the cards with words on them at the beginning and because he was eight or nine at the time and so he could read, but you know, kids don't want to read when they play a game. So we took out all the cards with the with the text for the first I don't know a few games of it and it was just like you know do this flank do that flank. So I think you could do something similar here and then you can start introducing the extra cards and then it's good to introduce it because then they're they are reading and they're able to learn how to read as well from playing games. So I recommend this is too if you have like kids that are into Star Wars 100%. But yeah just easy recommend across the board. I mean if your lies light up at all Battle of Hoth do just get it like that. Now the one thing that's interesting now the one thing that's interesting about it is in terms of the expansions and theoretically what kind of ecosystem would come up out of this because some Commander Colors games have no expansions I think and then some have countless and this is most like memoir in terms of the gameplay which I just kind of talked about in the walkthrough.
So, because the box so kind of small, I can almost see them releasing like different theaters. Like, so we could have an Endor box. We could have like a Clone Wars box, like a Gungan versus Robots box. We could have then a um I don't know, whatever different scenarios in Star Wars that there are. You could have like Clone Wars like from the cartoon, you know, and that kind of stuff, which I don't know anything about. So, just Clone Wars cartoon stuff. And that would be kind of neat to just have like a little series of little boxes, maybe like four or five or whatever over the next few years that you can kind of pick and choose your theaters because some of these units here, well, all of them are very specific to, you know, the cold weather setup. So, as far as like compatibility with other stuff, it's going to be kind of weird. I mean, the ADA ads is about the only thing you could swap out in the probe droids. Everything else is like Hoth stuff.
So, it would be kind of strange. And then also, if they just came out with more and more Hoth stuff, I feel like I'm going to get bored of that pretty quick cuz it's snow, you know? Okay, more snow. Great. But if they do different terrains, you got because you got snow, you can have big trees and forest, you could have desert or whatever. You could do like a Tatooine thing like the huts versus the black sun or something. um or like uh I forget what the other gangster group is, but you can do cool stuff like that and that would be kind of neat. Just have different theaters and then that's it. The one thing that bugs me about it is that last scenario where it's like, oh, hey, go buy a complete other copy of the game to play one scenario. I was like, "Huh, guys, you had everything going for you with all of the compactness and the just the fullness of the game, you know, everything for the price, and then you just tack on that like little bit of chase to buy an extra copy for like maybe something you would do once or twice." I was like, "I mean, I get it.
It's just like a nice to have for rich people." Like, you know what I mean? I just This is weird. Like why would you? It's just it just strikes a discord against you know the rest of the presentation. It's very strange. But I don't know. I mean I don't know what their plans are. Maybe they will do stuff that would like beef it out and would make it worth having two copies and I don't know it just something about I can't quite put my finger on it. Just this just sort of irks me a little bit. But anyway, so yeah. So this that's my only kind of like question about it I guess or criticism which isn't even really a criticism it's just kind of something I'm sort of wondering about cuz just taking it on its own on its own merits throwing out that last scenario it's a great little package and I would recommend it across the board if you start wondering about the ecosystem and expansions and whatever the life of the game whatever you know then okay then then there are questions about kind of how they would do it. And I'm more just curious than anything, not really being critical other than that last scenario thing. Um, but yeah, so I think that's really cool. I think just get it like it is and then yeah, there's some questions about how they would expand this. Are they just going to make it a bunch of boring snow stuff or could they do different theaters and um and that kind of thing? I don't know. I personally think I'll stop now is it would be neat to just have boxes like this, little small affordable boxes that really excel
at doing it. You know, the one theater, the one set of games with lots of cool different options and variables and all that stuff and just cram all that goodness into one little box that's affordable and then jump to the next one. And then you can go and pull things out as you want. And maybe they could do like a um a big campaign across all of them, you know, kind of similar to something like oh, I don't know, you think of it in a couple of different I'll throw out a few examples like there's a game called the British way where you play like four games across different theaters all over the world and then you kind of score victory points out of each of them and then there's a winner at the end. or something like a map campaign where you're doing a Warhammer or other miniature game where it's like, okay, you scored points here, won some campaigns there, so you scored some points and then now you jump over here and do that. I mean, you could get all convoluted with that. I don't know if that's really a cool idea cuz it just that doesn't it seems again to go antithetical to what what this is telling me when I look at this little box. But I'd love to see different theaters, different units, and all that stuff. And hopefully it sells well and they can kind of do what they want. But uh anyway, I recommend it. Thanks.