Skip to main content
Loading video...

I left my heart in YOKOHAMA - old vs new review!

Transcript 16:52

have you ever wondered what it feels like to be a wealthy Merchant maybe you want to be a merchant during the Magi period in a place called Yokohama one of the first foreign trade ports in Japan Yokohama is a board game where you'll be sending your assistance to all of the different stores to gather Goods to make trades upgrade your technology and to ultimately gain the most money possible hi my name is Danny I'm an avid modern board gamer from Australia who love Shar my passion for board gaming with you my friends and my family hey Danny do you want to trade board games uh sure excellent Yokohama is a game that I've been wanting to try for a very long time and a little bit of a backstory about Yokohama at my local board game store which actually unfortunately is not open anymore uh actually had a copy of Yokohama about 10 10 years ago I think and I actually went into the store and I was looking and I was like what is this game with an orange box and some cool abstract art on the cover and I picked it up I was like oo this looks fun turned around saw the picture of the area tiles in the back and it looked like a lot of icons and it looked very complicated and I put it back on the Shelf and I didn't think about it until

more recently when one of my friends actually had a copy of yok and said hey I've got this great fun uh game about being a merchant Trader and I was like wo I really want to look into this game again and so I tracked down a secondhand copy of the original yokahama and I also tracked down a second copy where uh someone was selling it on uh eBay and they basically had 3D printed some of their own custom components I thought wow this is a great version to own and then we've got this new version that just came out I guess the big comparison that Yokohama can be compared to in terms of game play is uh the game Istanbul if you've ever played Istanbul where you kind of have a merchant and you place your little assistance around these different stores on this grid and then you kind of move and pick your assistant up along the way and Trigger effects at places that you stay Yokohama has that kind of same concept except the area tiles kind of form a pyramid you've got a canal in the middle which if you travel over them you're going to have to pay um a a Yen and basically when you land at a particular area tile you already have to have an assistant there and then you get to power up that tile based on how many shops uh if you've got a warehouse there if you've got assistance already there and based on that total power value you get a certain level of resource or conversion effect or ability ility to purchase certain

number technology cards and I think that concept itself that each aerial tile has different power levels based on what influence you have there really creates this interesting parameter effect to the game and so it really brings me to this sense of geography in Yokohama every single game because the game is quite modular in terms of how the area tiles are going to be configured and the order and the spatial Arrangement is going to vary from game to game you're going to get a really different geographical layout each time so you might have the customs house near the top one game or you might have the tea Farm down at the bottom and but then the next game they all might be shuffled around in different positions so what I really like about this game is that your actions are really simple you basically either place two assistants in one area and then send your uh Merchant to an area where you have assistant and then resolve the action of that tile your alternative action is to place three assistants in three different areas and the reason why you're placing assistants down is so that those assistants create a pathway across or a network across the game map so that your Merchant can kind of travel to different location and bounce back and forth because if your Merchant is ever kind of is is in an isolated location you actually have to take the merchant back into your hand before deploying it again on your next turn so you want to kind of be geographically as efficient as possible you got to pre-plan ahead one or two steps so you know like okay I need three tea leaves I'm going to have to commit

maybe one Merchant there now one Merchant on the next round and then maybe build a shop later on and so everything really accumulates in power and this beautiful eban flow of like wow I can you know build a warehouse now so that whenever someone uses it they have to I get a Yen or I can you know commit two assistance now in this region and then in two rounds Town time I'll be able to afford a shop in that area and I love the sense of multi-stage long-term planning where your actions have an effect on where you can go how much value you're going to get out of the area tiles and also what you can activate too now we all know that quite a lot of Euros in our Collections and if you are an avid Euro gamer it's really quite common for eurus to be very highly non-confrontational and kind of feel like you're playing your own game even though you're competing against other players Yokohama just really strikes that nice balance of player-to-player interaction and I love the fact that it's kind of got this worker placement mechanic where if a player has activated a tile in their last turn you can't go to that tile so that kind of area is blocked off until that player leaves that area and so you've got like two or three different merchants or action tiles that are blocked off every time it comes to your turn and so that creates an interesting timing element it's like do I prioritize getting uh the silk

before I head to the technology area will the other players also need to go to the technology area and this is the really cool twist in the game you might think well how will I know if the other players need a technology card how will I know if the other players need silk the fact that players have to place their assistance on different area tiles means that you have that open information if the P player has already placed three assistant tiles in this silk tile area you might be thinking hang on a minute it's going to be maybe one more turn before they might prioritize going to that area so you might decide to go to that area first and so that might delay how quickly they can get that resource so you get these really cool blockages on the actual game map and if you place an assistant in another area where a merchant is already there from another player that Merchant has to get get paid one yen so you can kind of earn income in that way too and so this game has this really tactical nature to where it's like okay do I prioritize this uh action first or do I really need these resources to fulfill those order cards now because Yokohama was one of the first foreign trade ports in Japan at the time it's kind of integrated in this interesting mechanism in the game basically when you fulfill order cards or when you gain technology cards those cards have different flags on them and if you ever get a pair of flags you'll actually get a little agent

token that comes from that particular country think of it as like someone who represents that country but then goes around and helps you know gain resources and bars for you in Yokohama and so what's intriguing about this mechanic is that when you acquire these tokens it allows you to activate any tile or any area tile on your turn as an additional bonus action if you have an assistant in that tile so if I've got three assistants at you know the silk Factory and I have my little um British worker I might flip over my British agent and then I can activate power three of that tile it might seem overpowered at first but the fact that you're spending these assistant resources means that your Merchant leader isn't going to be able to visit those tiles later on so you kind of have to think strategically about which ones you're going to activate which ones you're going to which one you're going to leave and so having that extra flexibility is really cool and at the end of the game the number of different flags that you own in sets of your cards that you've acquired through technology and your order cards you get this cool differentiation Victory Point bonus so if I've got five different countries that I've kind of traded with you get a really big sum of points and you're building these sets you're collecting these orders and the order cards themselves also have bonuses at the bottom and and so you've got this brilliant layered design where you're vying for these objectives you're then collecting these um cool synergies between getting the same two flags but

also getting a set of different flags which creates a very interesting board game M dilemma now there are lots of ways that the end game is going to trigger and I'm always intrigued about how Euros decide to end a game there is some games where the money token has to cross over with the victory Point token some just basically have set rounds what I love about Yokohama is there are no definitive number of rounds I was playing this with my hobby and basically we're like oh we're close in in the game then another 45 minutes later we were still churning and getting things out of the tiles and so I love games where the end game is determined by the plays themselves so there are five different kind of like end game conditions there is this church tile like if you basically fill up a certain number of them it's kind of this area majority mechanism as well at the end of the game if you empty the order card deck or if you go to the Customs uh board and you fill up certain numbers based on player count the fact that there's multiple endgame triggers means that you're like ooh I feel like I am in the lead I feel like I am winning so I'm going to really gun it home and just really try and push for one of the endgame triggers so that I can guarantee my victory and so it really creates this endgame climactic tension that some euros seem to just be like Oh by the end of round five now cut up your points the technology cards in Yokohama are really cool and when I played with my hobby my hobby realized that there are certain cards that really combo well together there was one card

that allowed you to place four assistants out rather than three that kind of expanded some of the choices that he was able to make and he thus won the game yet again he's very good at these kind of games maybe I should up my game a little bit but yeah the combos of those cards help to kind of signify the industry that you're building in Yokohama and I love it when games really have these card synergies that really accentuate what you can do now for those of you who might be wondering what the difference between the original version of Yokohama and the newer version of Yokohama there is a couple of subtle differences and it's mainly to do with the functionality in the game first of all the rule book has been updated just to I guess Express certain con conepts about the game a little bit more clearly uh they've also introduced uh modular building tiles instead of the cards that get overlaid on the area tiles you've now got these little strips at the bottom where you get to place your shops you've also got recess playboards they've taken away the big victory Point track from the original game which was this really big like number look like this really big score track and basically now everyone's tracking them points on their own personal player board the other thing I wanted to mention is that this game comes with two mini expansions there are these little achievement flag tiles that if you're the first to claim an achievement you can grab one of these flag tiles and

these flag tile icons contribute to that pairing mechanism I mentioned earlier that allows you to get these cool uh International agents the other uh little twist is those little fivepoint tokens and I didn't really mention as much about those tokens earlier on but if you're first to trigger a power level five area you get this little cool purple 5 bonus token in the expansion you've got these cool little agents that now appear on these fivepoint tokens too so if you're the first to build in a silk area and it has an agent on you can take that fivepoint token and use that agent as um something to help you trigger another area so considering my final thoughts for Yokohama I just want to say that this new edition has a a very excellent production quality to it all the way down to uh recess playboards uh recessed little shop tiles color palette that they've chosen is vibrant the icons are super easy to read and if you get the deluxe tokens which are sold separately uh they do enhance the experience um overall I think there are two main points I wanted to say about the production the first one is that the little assistants are actually probably a little bit too small and I don't really have big hands but even I struggled to pick up the assistance and place them in my player board and so I felt like that was something that could have been maybe deluxified a little bit

more I also like the fact that they've actually put the point track on the playboard which saves a lot of table space and there actually a much quicker and more efficient way to keep track of how many points you got the other thing I wanted to mention is the art style if you look on Board Game Geek there's a lot of discussion on there about how well represented this area is of that time I feel like the art does feel quite europeanized and upon you know looking online for photos and pictures of yokoh in that period I feel like the art that's in this new edition kind of marries up with some of the photos that I've seen online with how Yokohama looked at that time 1860s and so feel like maybe the artist might have been inspired by a lot of that photography uh there also was a very big art movement during that time as well which could have been used for the this upgraded edition of the game which I think I would have personally preferred I own the first edition of II which has like a yukoh um art um theme to it a lot of these newer games that are coming out with this new modernized art does feel a little bit um Bland it probably could be a little bit more evocative but in terms of the art and the way it looks on the table the Aesthetics of the game still look really really good and so I really like this

version of the game I will still keep my original uh TMG version of the game so I think they both have a place in my collection and yeah in terms of the actual gameplay of yok hmer I would give it a 4 out of four my hubby also gave it a four out of four I just think the game play itself really outshines some of the issues with the art style and I think that the game itself feels really functional it's easy to pick up easy to learn and feels less intimidating than when I first saw the original copy so what do you think of this new modernized edition of Yokohama are you someone who's owned the original Yokohama with the original art or maybe you're someone who you know owns the deluxe version maybe you've got your own kind of 3D printed version that no one else has please let me know your thoughts about Yokohama in the comment section below is are you interested in getting Yokohama to the table for the first time or is this your first middleweight year that you've ever considered playing I'd love to hear your stories and opinions now if you really found this content super helpful and enjoyable please consider subscribing uh to my Channel or heading over to my patreon page and accessing some patreon only videos there there's also hundreds of other board game videos on my main page so feel free to check those out this is Danny signing up I hope your next board gameing experience is an amazing one goodbye

Progress saved