Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board Game Face-off - Isle of Skye Vs El Caballero Vs Okanagan

Transcript 15:30

hey everybody today i'm doing something a little bit different and what i'm going to be doing is that i'm going to be putting three board games against each other in a kind of face-off to decide which one i'm going to keep and which two i am going to cull from my collection so essentially what this video is is me thinking out loud about my culling process so why these three games so the three games i'm talking about are el caballero uh the isle of skye and okanagan now all of these are medium lightweight tile placement games all of which have their own strengths and their own weaknesses but i suppose the catalyst for this video is that i'm always trying to stream like streamline my collection as much as possible and if i can have one game that can scratch the same itch as the three games in their entirety then i'll certainly look at doing that so let's start by taking a look at el caballero so this one is as i said designed by kramer and ulrich who are the designers of my favorite game of all time el grande and this game does have some shared dna with el grande especially when it comes to the initiative system and the kind of um worker economy system i suppose you can call it so essentially what you're doing in this game is that you are of course building a map of tiles which are coming two different terrains you've got the land type and you also have the the sea type and what you're trying to do is that once you replace your tile you are going to be always donating these um control tiles onto the board to show your influence in these different regions and

the idea is that you want to be controlling the bigger regions because they're going to give you more victory points however there's this constant back and forth between the other players you know as you need to keep on increasing your bid i suppose to control uh these reasons to make sure you come out on top and get those big points however there is a kind of contrasting mechanism here through the use of this carplay which is taken from el grande where if you go lower in initiative you can build up your supplies of workers but if you go for the you know go for the jugular and almost guarantee yourself on getting the tile you want then you're only going to take a small intake of workers which can quickly run out so that's kind of the unique thing here i'm also i i really am enamored with the way that these control markers work where you're constantly kind of rotating them to again increase your bid but you also have one use of your i believe it's called a grande actually where you can actually place a tile and it can control all the region that it touches so you can see here this has a the red play here has a influence of three in this region four in this region and one in this region and i've never seen anything like that being used before so i think that's definitely the strength of the game is that mix of the initiative system and the way that these influence markers work now let's talk about some of the negatives here so this game actually does take longer than the other two to play and the box advertises this game to take 90 minutes i think in actuality it does take a bit quicker than that i think in my experience it's taken about you know 60 to 75 minutes play on

average um further weaknesses about this game is that this game does actually date back to the um 1990s and in one way that's going to attract a lot of people because it has a lot more of a dusty aesthetic that's not so appealing to you know more you know more casual gamers they're going to look at this and think it's going to be a boring game and might be a bit of a deterrent for them additionally the rules in this book aren't as concrete as a lot of more modern games so it basically gives you a bunch of mechanisms and ways you can play the game and it doesn't give you that again that solidified solidified version of this is the optimal way of playing the game you do kind of have to use your own judgment and tinker a few things about how many rounds you want to play when is when it's going to be a scoring round which mechanisms you want to add in and which ones you want to take out so that for me is taking that it's taking a few games of this to kind of um work out my head what i want to weight things at and how i want to play a cabrillo which again it might be a bit of a deterrent for some people so that is kind of where my thoughts base is on el cabierro some awesome mechanisms but some loosey-goosey rules at time and it does take a bit longer so let's move on to the second game here which is the isle of skye so this has been a real mainstay in my collection for many many years and i've even gone in the past saying this is borderline essential to have in your collection um i always say this is almost like a next step on from a game like carcassonne which i'm sure a lot of you guys have um used as a tool to get you into the hobby and really kind of blew your mind about how you could build the board as the game goes on

the idle sky is a bit more puzzly than the other games this one also takes about 40 or so maybe 45 minutes to an hour to play um and it is pretty tight in the way it plays so you're actually building of course a little um a little grid of tiles and this one you're building up your own grid so these two games here you are building a communal board with the tiles you place on this one you are only focusing on your own little aisle and what you're trying to do is essentially put these tiles out each of these towels have a different kind of bunch of symbols on them and or or like rows or terrains and what you're trying to do is you're trying to build your little isle up to match with these public objectives which are variable each game so you've got a good degree of variability here and i suppose the coolest thing about this game and the unique thing is the way that the tiles are acquired in the first place as before you even start placing tiles you are going to draw three tiles from the bag you're going to put them in front of your screen here and then behind your player screen you are going to basically place a number of money um behind two of the tiles and one of the tiles you're going to basically cull from the game um and what this means is that in play order the players are going to choose um the tiles from the other players to either buy them off the matching the coins they've they've put their themselves and if they match it they can take the tile however if any tiles that you've put points next to are not bought by the other players then you have to play those costs yourself so it really is a delicate balance of how much am i

going to donate here i want this tile i don't want to pay too much for it i don't want to put it too low because somebody else might buy it from me and again another strength is the variability of the scoring because there's a bunch of different tiles here making each game feel quite a bit different and it's also a very snappy game you know it's over before you know it now as i've played more and more or the other sky i have kind of seen some chinks in the armor and i am being ultra nitpicky here because i do think this is a very solid game um and that is the the looseness of the money towards the end of the game becomes a bit too much for me so it does have some catch-up mechanisms where the players losing on on points are going to get more money than the other players and it becomes quite difficult to map things out compared to the beginning of the game where you only have a few coins each you think you know each placement feels a bit more more meaningful at the end of the game you're placing huge stacks of money next to tiles and it becomes a bit a bit vague and a bit messy um in my opinion additionally i also think that sometimes the objectives do not match well with the scoring method of the game because some of these objectives are quite a lot more difficult to pull off than others and what that means is that if the scoring category triggers first or second then you actually haven't had enough time to almost complete that objective at all um meaning that you've kind of wasted well not wasted but it feels like you're not doing much so those are the kind of nitpicks for me in terms of the isle of skye and additionally i have played this one a

lot over the years so maybe that's worked against it as well as in i'm kind of ready to move on from it already to try something else and get something else to the table more often so there we have the isle of skye now the third game i'm talking about is okanagan now this one is the most recent game i've had in my collection um and this one is more of a set collection game but mixed with the air and majority so this one takes around 45 minutes to play and i suppose i would say this was probably the lightest game of the three or maybe comparable to um to the isle of skye this one has some super cool mechanisms that i haven't seen before um and they're just very simple and quite sophisticated twists on area majority and tile placement of course so this one you are building a shared grid however whenever you place a tile and these tiles are as with most games broken down into different terrain types you've got four different drain types in this one um you are forced to play one of your control markers on these tiles now these can come in three different types you've got one that goes right in the middle of the tile which controls has one influence in all of the regions on that tile you've got one that's worth two influence which actually goes in between two different terrain types and you've got one that has three influence that only goes on one terrain type so the more niche of a control that you go for the more concentrated that control is so if you are really focused on something you can really go all in on it

and maybe start doing it in your farms or if you're not so sure you can start putting your i think they're called silos where you can touch all of the regions so i love that trade-off and it works very well and it's very well balanced and this also has a kind of dual system because why are you trying to control these regions it's actually not for points the reason you want to control these regions is because each of these terrain types has a um has a resource on or a symbol on it which are depicted by these tokens and as you close these regions if you have the most influence in that region you're going to start acquiring these tokens which synergize with these cards that you get at the beginning of the game and halfway through the game and the more of those sets you collect the more points you're going to get so again it has that layer upon layer and something that's completely different to other games as well is that if you lose a region in terms of the control you actually get rewarded by taking one of these um bonuses on the back of the stacks of towels so enough more engagement there when it comes to not being invested in a region scoring some very clever things going on here again this game is quicker it's very easy to explain and it has some good decisions from start to finish because again you are forced to play a control marker every single time you play a tile so it's nice and tight nice simple round structure and some cool little twists on the on the tile placement genre now this one for me i was very impressed with it when i started with it and i still think it's very good um i have recently played a game in this one which did kind of rub me the wrong way and that is

that when i um well basically you collect these cards somewhat randomly at the start of the game you know randomly distributed and sometimes those cards work really well with each other because you can score these tiles multiple times and contribute them to multiple cards meaning that if you are collecting all the same symbol and that symbol appears on multiple cards then you're almost getting fast tracks fast tracked into scoring big points as compared as if your scoring pools were a bit more diluted so what happened in this game was that i was working towards something i really stockpiled one of my objective cards got a big bunch of points from it and then just by pure sheer luck i drawed another card which almost was identical from what i already had meaning i almost doubled my um double my points based on a random card draw and for me i'm not quite happy that that can happen and it feels like all that hard work that the other players put in was just completely nullified by the fact that i drew the right card at the right time so that was a bit of a shame for me and um it really did dampen my overall impression of the game that i'm very impressed by in every other aspect so there we have the uh the three games there so i think from my comments there you can probably assume that one game that's going to be an automatic dismissal for me is okanagan um i again i'm not quite comfortable with that being a possibility of just the pure swinginess of the right card draw um affecting the game so significantly and downright determining the winner so unfortunately despite me really loving so much about this game with a heavy heart i have to say that okanagan is

gonna leave the collection so that's one i can dismiss straight away right so now we're down to two absolutely fantastic tile placement games got either sky and el cabiarro so i kind of have to go further afield here and start thinking you know what else in my collection is going to affect my um you know my thought process in keeping these games and i think what i'm going to lean back to is the fact that i have a bunch of bidding style games um and this game you know you are buying stuff with other people which obviously you know it always feels like a bidding style game um and i think because i you know if i'm going to play a pure tarpon game i'm going to play something a bit heavier if i'm going to play a bidding style game i'd rather play something a bit meaty as well and this one it kind of does both well but i think other games do it better than this one does um maybe i'll leave a few um examples at the bottom of the screen just for you to take a look at so and additionally something i didn't consider as well something i didn't mention so far is that i do have another game in my collection called cartographers which uses the same scoring system as the isle of skye does and i think there's even more variability with the um cartographers game so again that's another thing that's just has some crossover with other games that is making me lean towards keeping el caballero over isle of skye i just think i don't get to play that cool card system enough with our grande because it

requires such high player counts and additionally i've never seen that control tile placement thing used before um and it's just some real interesting things going on in this game this game does everything exceptionally well but there are other games that do every facet of it better than the isle of skye does which has kept this one from hitting my table as much as it used to so i used to replay this game so regularly but as i've acquired more games my collection it gets getting pushed down and down on my priority list i have played it recently and i really enjoyed it but those few little things start started to you know bubble to the surface of you know being a bit too quick in a way and um you know not being able to pull off enough and also that vagueness of the economy just started to become a bit messy and not as precise as i'd have liked it to be so for that reason with a very heavy heart i'm going to have to say bye bye to isle of skye and we have a kind of a new king of the medium lightweight tar placement games in my collection with el caballero so there we have it ready um this is actually a game that not that many people talk about in fact nobody talks about and i think it's so good and i'm very happy to have it in my collection and it's no it's beating two fantastic games to keep its place so there we have it there's that that's the video hopefully you've enjoyed it something a bit different and it's been useful for you and if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like and subscribe my channel and check out my other content too also be sure to check out the show sponsor kianda dot co dot

uk we can pick up great games i believe you can pick up el caballero and if you use my discount code in the show notes you can get five percent off your first order but for everybody else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye bye

Progress saved