Up or Down? Review! (A Game where you can only go up... or down!)
Transcript
Hi everybody.
Hello. I'm Ryan.
I'm Bethany.
And we are Ryan and Bethany Board Game Reviews.
And today we will be talking about Up or Down. Not down or up, just up or down. Um, this is designed by Wolf Gate Kramer and Michael Caseine. And it is published by Capstone Games.
The theme of this game is all about just going up and down on an elevator.
No theme
or or not, but elevators are involved. All right. So on your turn, you have a hand of cards. They're all numbers, right? And you are going to have a ring of cards around the deck of cards. And you're going to have them all arranged sequentially in in order. You're going to place a card and you're going to place it between any gap that you that it fits in that it belongs in. And then from there, you can draft either the card from the left or to the right. And you're going to take that card that you've drafted, put it into your own personal tableau. So the game flow is a card from your hand onto the board and then from the board you're drafting a different card to put down into your own tableau. Now once it's in your tableau now that's what's officially yours.
Yes.
You can have up to three of those little tableaus, three little columns. And once you start adding cards to them, they have to go keep on going all going up in number or all going down in number. And you have up to three of them. If you ever need to add a card to one of your tableau and it doesn't fit, let's say you had a really high number uh and all of your cards are actually all of your columns are going down at this point, um you have to get rid of one of your columns. You have to discard it off to the side of and then start a new column. At the end of the game, your columns are going to be what scores you points. Uh you going to have multiply out how many cards are in each column and multiply them by how many of a certain color is in that column. So let's say you have five cards in one of your columns and red is the most prominent color in that column. There's three red cards. So you multiply three times five, you get 15 points for that column. So you do that with all three of your columns. And then if you had any extra cards that were in your discard pile that you had to get rid of, those are just going to be worth one point a piece. So they're worth something, but not as much as they had been if they had been part of a big old column.
Okay.
Whoever has the most points wins the game. So, I gotta say like this has nothing to do with gameplay, but the first time we played it with our friends, we were very fascinated by the card art. So, it's all this like theme, this elevator, and it's all these different people. And when you start at the very low numbers, it's like an extremely sketchy elevator. Like, nobody in their right mind should enter that machine because you are going to drop down and die. Nobody should do it. But then when you get up, it gets all golden and beautiful and so pretty. But then at some point there's this lady and her dog, right? This lady and her dog are on the elevator, but when you reach the very top level, she's gone. So we're like, did she die? Did are they is this little boy, this robot, and this dog, are they in heaven now? What is happening with this? So I um we had a long adventure going through all of the Cardar and like trying to figure out what the story is here. What is happening? What happened to the little old lady? Why is the dog left behind?
What does the robot have to do with anything? So, we uh we just had a a great discussion about what was actually like happening behind the scenes
in this game. It feels so good when you were able to draft the exact right card you need at the exact right time. Maybe you need the number 29 card and it happens to be red like in our example earlier because you wanted more red cards in that particular column and you are able to put a card down that allows you to draft the 29 red. Oh my gosh, it feels so good. You know that column is going to score a ton of points because you're able to build them incrementally. But on the converse side though, uh it feels so bad when you can't get what you need, which is more often than not. you are trying to get the right cards and they're never there for you to need them. You see it out there.
You know it's a possibility
and then by the time it comes around to your turn, the person right before you took it, not even because they're hate drafting, just because it was just happened to be the best choice for them at the time.
Yep.
Or maybe the card you want is out there, but the cards in your hand that you used to get them
can't get it
doesn't line up with how you can play to get it. it. There's a lot of frustration points with trying to get the right thing, but if you do it the right thing, oh, how sweet it is.
Well, and sometimes you try to set yourself up. So, you're going to like you have cards in your hand, you're like, "This card in my hand would go great in my column." So, you kind of want to place it so that way you can take it in two or three turns time. So, you're trying to like set yourself for that stuff. But, um, like Ryan said, that doesn't always happen. In fact, that like rarely ever happens. you are unintentionally setting everybody else up for their play instead of setting yourself up. So, you can't even like really plan ahead, but you kind of also want everything at the same time. So, it's just I don't know. It's that that's really interesting.
One of the things that kind of helps you a little bit is when you're refreshing your hand at the end of your turn, uh you can draw either from the the face down pile of cards or there's also a face up draw pile. So, you kind of can either go with the card that you know exactly what it is and you figure out whether that's going to be helpful to you or not. Yeah. Or just take a mystery dive and just see what you get, what you get. Um, so I like how you have two options. A lot of games have done that before as like the top part of this card pile or this other one. This from the game from the very beginning of the game. You take the draw pile, cut it in half, flip over half of it, and it's face up, half face up, half face down. So, you get a little bit of information to work with as you are refreshing your hand to kind of help that programming to kind of help you draft what you need. if you can pull it off.
Yeah, overall this game mechanically works perfect. It's very smooth. It's very seamless. But I just found myself frustrated the whole time. I remember just being mad at everybody and everybody was mad at me while we were playing because you are taking cards that are going to work the best for you. You're like Ryan said earlier, you're not hatedrafting because you really are thinking about yourself and only yourself in this game. And yet at the same time, you keep you keep taking cards that other people also need. And so you're just really frustrated that you're trying to do this thing and you can't do it. It's not like one of those puzzles where you're frustrated because you know there's a solution here, but you're just not able to come up with it. It wasn't that type of frustration. It was a frustration because you were thwarted at every turn. Like you could not plan. You could not do what you wanted. And to be perfectly honest, this is like horrible. I had so much more fun um creating a story with the card art than I had actually playing the game.
Maybe it was intentional. You know,
maybe they're distracting you.
Yeah, exactly. We play this at multiple player counts. Um I'd say they're all equally frustrating in terms of being able to get what you want. I'd say the two player player count is ever so slightly more likely to get what you want
because the game's shorter.
Well, no, because there's less people to take what you want in between your turn. Um, so that's that's a factor. Uh, but there there is uh you the cards you use in the game are based off of how many play people are playing, but there's also a short version of the game and a long version of the game. And so there's a little chart in the rule book that tells you how many cards to use, which numbers of cards to use. I would almost always, unless you and your group just really like this game for whatever reason, I would almost always go with a short version of the game. It's not going to be as frustrating. It's not going to be as it's not going to overstay its welcome. If there is fun to be had here, you want to have the fun and get out and move on to the next one rather than sit in it and just kind of get stale and a little bit frustrating.
Yeah. And go to robot heaven.
There you go.
Everybody, thank you so much for watching. Don't forget to subscribe so you can see our videos as they come out. Until then, you can find us in all of these places.
You guys, thanks for watching and we will see you next time.
Bye
bye.
You guys, thanks so much for watching. Uh, this game was provided to us by a publisher for in exchange for a fair and honest review. And if you want to see more stuff, check out over here to see something we think you might like.
And over here, we think that YouTube has picked out a great video for you. You're going to love. Thanks, guys. See you next time. Bye.