Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 19:37

viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for whistle mountain uh which will not be a comparison to whistle stop because i've never played whistle stop um this was a game that man i wish i had played last year this would have made the top 10 of uh this game's great i i really really like this game it's like right it's it's like right up it's like oh because it's like you don't play enough engine builder games with me but uh cat and my friend devin do and then they'll sit there and they'll be like oh there it is there's the ott moment where he figured it out i love engine builders and i think this is actually one of those that's incredibly unique um what do you guys think cat didn't like it it was all right yeah i didn't like it i'm not i'm just not a big engine builder i this is the third time i've played here this is the third time i've played it um it's the closest i've ever come to winning what really eight points you had one fifty i had one four one i had i didn't even one figure and i had maybe the sky strategy the thing with this game that i like is that it's different every time yeah there's so much so many different machines you can build so many cards some different upgrades yeah you know and people are going to build different ways because they're trying to get different resources because every scaffold has different

different combination of resources on it um and then it's just how i mean even even change it just one scaffold one space is going to change oh i may be able to put my one on my my tube size balloon whatever they want to call them right in that spot and sweep a bunch of materials right i mean even what your starting ability is is going to kind of dictate the route at least that you're going to star that well and i think that's why you won is because you used your ability to the fullest like i used to try is mine three times yeah you you were getting four or eight points whenever but here's here's here's the difference between mine and yours i only get four points max eight right right uh if if you guys place right mine's easily stoppable if you guys right right don't place nearby or the other thing i was noticing was because it takes me about uh well you get a you got it you well it actually takes me probably two movements to equate to your ability because not only do you get points off of this you also get a free build so what one of my favorite things about this game is is the players dictate the speed of the game and it does it if it's a well-balanced game because there's some of those games where it's all over the place um and there's no balance but this game is gonna start off slow because people are gonna uh want to build a certain way and then it's going to pick up at the end and i i've slowly started to realize because you were getting a [ __ ] ton of points for big things i was just

accumulating points throughout the whole game uh i was like my ability's starting to lose steam right so i need to try and end this and hope that i'll have the most points uh at the end of the game because it also has end game victory points which i i always like so uh so yeah i yeah i completely agree with you the fact that you will do like the game will be different every single time um whether in in terms of what you ignore on what you're doing what special abilities you're going to want to use uh because the only real engine building part of it is what you're personally getting right because like you this goes into that and then some things change you know i've seen a chain of four things all happen yeah because you did this you got this because there's another thing that says when you get a small building somewhere in here then you can do this yeah so it's just like you could every time you know if i had that it would be gain an upgrade then get that and then get that yeah and it's just like kind of like arnac you know you're trying to be the most efficient with because you only have three workers oh yeah you know so it's like you're just trying to maximize your your stuff yeah cat what do you like about it oh it's just not my speed like i just i'm not a huge fan of engine builders like this that are just strictly the engine um i just felt kind of limited when i did want to build something i was like oh well i would build that but there's nowhere to put it out and then by the time i build a scaffold it's like well i really just open it up for somebody else to put something there

kind of thing you know it's funny that you actually say that because i disagree respectfully because this isn't ting garden a garbage game disrespectfully i disagree with you i'm i get the [ __ ] out of my house uh because while you would be right initially in that oh i'm just gonna place a scaffold you know once the fact that you can do multiple builds in any order cancels out that because unlike 10 garden where it's like oh i guess i'll place a tile oh okay there's a greenery spot there your turn oh i'm gonna draw oh look i got a tree the place of greenery so i took your your entire turn the fact that you can sit here and be like okay i'm gonna get you know oh i'm gonna get i'm i'm gonna go here spend a whistle uh to get two things and then my i'm gonna forge i'm gonna spend two other than you can place and place and then build your thing that you you are able to control what you build um and yeah of course like every single one of us used a spot that uh someone had set up before he didn't build my scaffolding at all no i built one right there i know but like early game you weren't really oh yeah no not at all well because i my initial strategy was okay i just want to move people um like i want to see and then it became a ha maybe not halfway through but i was like i wonder how far i can go without actually contributing to going up the mountain and building up upon your

guys's things and it eventually started to because i wasn't using this location at all and then i eventually had to start going there because you guys quit building scaffolding and i'm like ah [ __ ] and then i was like wait a minute i can do a sweet power move with my ability okay i'm gonna build a scaffold move a person over get four points and then build on top of that and then move them over uh just the free flowing of what i really like about engine builders is in this game um with the fact that when you forge you can do anything in any order uh and having to make that crucial moment of there was a time where you forged literally without having any of your workers there and i'm like i'm like ooh brad yeah i was like [ __ ] he's gonna take that spot uh and i was actually clutch the fact that i i ended it because i knew i had to end it on my turn i was going to try to probably end it oh yeah i was like not that next turn but yeah because i was because i was like [ __ ] he's gonna i thought you were gonna be able to build here and then i'm like oh wait he can't yes because that you would have won the game with uh cause you would have gotten i would have gotten six points well because you you took my spot because i was going to put this up here and right right and then i was going to build a two instead of get or just build a one yeah you put my black people over there black meeples and your reds on there and that would have been the difference because i would have had two over in the top oh yeah yep but you built there and then i kind of actually you could have put that here and then you could have built it only solely to where your guy moves over yeah which would have been you at 148.

well and i will tell you oh we know the points there as well the obvious thing on the board if you look at where the board stands right now you and i both have one worker that didn't make it over to the wrong yeah that's that's where the separation happened oh because like you if you had three workers that were over there that would have i mean that's a lot of points there was a lot of points over there you know that was the yeah and all the time you didn't take any negative points i like that this is your only negative uh the whirlpool area and it's easy to get them out like i like how this this and it's not super punching yeah 10 points uh is 10 points and it could have literally been make or break if you had gotten one more build action um but it's not like great western trail where it's like oh you went to kansas city again negative 30 points and you're like what the i got three points this whole game yeah uh but you can just okay you just have to take one of your precious actions to go there and get them out or spin the gold yeah um man this game is just so solid and there's no expansions there's no nothing it's just you have variety right out of the gates it just came out like it came out like at the very very end of 2020 and i don't even know if whistle stop has the expansions it has a one or two but it doesn't change this difficulty it's a really do you know yeah i heard i heard this is the law it's more training yeah i like building tracks for trains and stuff that's right here i've never played it but i know chad was talking about it a lot gotcha from what i've heard this is a lot more involved the fact that they used whistle

mountain is like more just like pandemic fall of rome or something where it's like a pandemic rapid response where it's like you literally use that name to sell because people know oh whistle stop let me get whistle mountain right yeah i don't don't if whistle stop is your level don't get this yeah yeah from what we i guess we technically don't know because we haven't played with a game yeah that's pretty that's that's what i've heard that this should not be the title now let's talk about some negatives oh oh brad go ahead and go i'll do one we'll go back and forth because this game is actually trash i i had like three main concerns with the game my biggest one was we're not going back and forth well i'm gonna say one because i figured they're probably the same he'll save one mine was the the height factor of the of the tiles yeah you know like in a two you know a two player game it's a little easier but when you start like if there was somebody sitting at the bottom when these are stacked up you can't see the first row yeah you know i'm they're certain you know we haven't we modified the setup because technically these are supposed to be on the ground here so you would have been able to see yeah i i cannot see that right and this was supposed to be over here and i definitely can't see that yeah here like even though we modified it like can you guys can you guys see this one not without yeah right like i literally those are like perfect to work i can't see it so just just the the placement of the tiles it almost needed to be like they needed to say you know set them off to the side or something or something i don't know

it's that it's again usability is not it's not this game's strong suit um that is weird yeah and then just you know it's an icon based game so like when you've set out your [ __ ] your ships are even blocking the view of a lot of the icons you know like huh like i can't like when you play your ship like if i played this oh yes yes then you won't be able to see that tile you know there's a lot of picking up moving around yeah like oh god i can't [ __ ] so i mean that's that's and like they said these are very minor yeah so they're not gonna but they are something where it's like we're past that it's 20 21 we're past something blocking other [ __ ] um yeah that that is one of them the other one is uh probably another one of your your three is the fact that it's like okay i'm gonna place this oh no and it's like all right the game's over it's just we we're just past the fact that one bump [ __ ] up the game yeah uh obviously that is one of those infomercial extreme examples but it's still it's still there we had that multiple times throughout the run through where yeah like i kept pulling my sleeves up because i was like i know my sleeves are knocking it down and with you being able to build the scaffolding that it's just like oh god okay look at that it's really tiny even it out yeah um that that's just it is it is tedious that part is it's the action itself is not fiddly but the fact that they're there is fiddly like having to set them and accidentally bump and uh then the board i mean it's minor again like i said not be in a folding board

that is weird puzzled together yeah it's four separate i don't know if there's a creation variant video because they had to put all the different notches on the sides or or something i don't know but but i don't see that it's just odd yeah that's just that's just kind of stupid there's always something odd in a bezier game though you know like the weird the weird like triangular yeah you're right everything they're like ooh we're unique it's like no come on just make the full this easily could have been a folding board because nothing else requires it to be four separate sections it's not like they tried to condense this into a weird box shape it's a standard board game box it could have been the folding board um other than that everything else is is great the fact that your player your player ability slots in there your your six uh you know upgrade action slot in there um there's a whole bunch of stars yes starting abilities that kind of totally change how you play they easily could have made like personal player aids this was incredibly handy yeah having it having the extra stuff so i yes obviously it's available and you can print it off but that's using up your ink and your ink costs eight hundred dollars so huh school sync oh i used to do that too you just use my old jobs ink uh i used to print off all that [ __ ] print everything yeah yeah so but i can't i have my own printer now because i work from home so it's my team you're praying everything at work i guess so yeah you're right um i i i see we were saying with these as

well the fact that they're stars it could have easily been a track board especially you know what they could have no they couldn't actually with these notches because you know what i just said there's a separate board at the true just a separate scoreboard just down at the bottom yeah yeah oh what they could have done is they could have made it like uh like a cart going up the mountain yeah uh and make it themed yeah it is what it is it's not no it's it's easy other games easily do this so it's not it's not it's just some weird design decisions mind you they were saying negative things about it right now but this that it's not because like all these things would take away from a lot of games it doesn't the gameplay no yeah not all over shadows yeah it's first it's not like we were sitting here like pissed off that something was go what was going on we easily made it work to where everyone could see so there are workarounds but it is something to bring up that what isn't a big deal to us might be a big deal to a lot of players they don't want they don't have a table space so this is [ __ ] annoying yeah um they are three feet tall so they can't look over it just see you know uh yeah like i love the resource management i the fact what makes engine builders great because sometimes there's engine builders where it's just too much um or uh where the game when your engine finally kicks off is where the game ends um like uh factory no not factory fun um oh [ __ ] this the short the the small game we played over at uh steve's that i didn't really

it's the one that brett really likes i don't remember um it is an engine builder but the one that pops into my head right now is gizmos where it's just like uh it's like oh yeah everything's got to pop up and game's over so you don't really get to feel your engine actually kick off mine i know that castles is like that like you don't get to totally finish your castle no it never and never fully finished that it's not engine right but it's but it leaves you empty a little bit yeah and and here you get to feel fulfilled you get to have your engine go off and you get to finish out the game and uh i i just i really really like that so um yeah i mean i don't really have anything else like i think the abilities are cool what makes this game even more unique i did want to bring this up is the fact that you get the points for building the machine but everyone else can use it and that's in that's incredibly intriguing because there's one where it's like oh that's really good that's worth a lot of points oh [ __ ] anyone else can go there and get five points uh do i want to because i put this one down with the intent of using it and i never used it two or three times yeah i think yeah so i'm like crap that's why i have all these awards over here i'm surprised you can go for the duplicator to take this and start using my ability i had so many things i was like i was trying to think three or four moves ahead of what i needed to get and that was last of my brothers well cat you're here hope you at least had a good time uh the game says it's 90 minutes that's about right

i think ours was like 145 maybe almost two hours yeah it was longer than i was expecting um but i was i was into it the whole time well and you can also like again it's it's a because it's controlled by the players oh you could just build scaffolding up and just start building [ __ ] up in the mountains and then yeah you're right game could be over that is true um mind you that would be that'd be kind of a waste it's like why do you have all this stuff if you're not going to play the game yeah but you know it's because we took it slow i actually i jumped it i started it because i went up in the mountains and built one but yeah it was like really slow after that because we were you know right it wasn't any any harm but yeah right all right uh let's see yeah i can't really think of anything else uh all right on a scale of one to ten cat um i'll still give it a seven because it is a i mean it's a solid game yeah yeah just not for you all right uh let's see i am gonna give this i'm gonna give it an eight i i very much uh enjoy this i uh yeah it's like i i have no reason to not give it a nine but for some reason i think a nine is still a little too high for it yeah i'm gonna knock it down for usability i think that is just you know come on come on that's stupid so i'm good with nate i had 8.5 8.5 is what i've been had in my head right you know it's solid it's good you know it's i mean i didn't touch it the art is kind of weird but

it's very minimalistic it's very mechanic this game is very mechanical yeah um i mean you could almost put i guess not anything because the water rising and stuff is it's kind of a loose themed engine building game but true it works yeah i'd say 8.5 for sure i really think that the water rising is unique in the fact that you kind of want to keep your workers above otherwise they'll fall in yeah and then you're like oh god i gotta save my mother want to lose points uh so yeah awesome so 7 8 8.5 so that's our thoughts on whistle mountain everyone i hope you enjoyed let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day that's for you

Progress saved