Skip to main content
Loading video...

La Isla Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 14:28

hey everybody today i'm talking about la isla which is a design going back to 2014 um designed by uh stefan feld and published by ravensberger this one um accommodates two to four players and it's definitely one of stefan feld's lighter games in terms of its rules complexity and overhead and to be honest my track history with failed lighter games isn't the best and not because they're not great designs but because i normally want you know i prefer his more crunchy um you know heavily involved games with loads of kind of strategic options but la isla is one that i've heard good things about and it is very simple to play and simple to explain and they're going to take place on a board that looks like this so it's a kind of a weird shape for all these different modules kind of snap together like that and the idea is that we're trying to i suppose with these explorers trying to research these different rare animals you've got all these different animals depicted on these tokens here you've got these frogs these dodos these moths i don't know what the hell these little chipmunk things are but um yeah it's going to take place on this board and you're going to get points by collecting them so in terms of player pieces everybody is going to be given one of these um these player boards here you're going to get a starting animal which is a larger token version and you're going to get one of each resource now these resources correlate to the different spots on the board like so so for example the the green token corresponds to these areas on the board and you're also going to get a number of explorers here

represented by these little plastic tokens and you start with five of these but you've got the potential to um to unlock more and there's also a scoreboard here like this which shows the value that each animal is going to going to be worth at the end of the game and also shows how many points you've got throughout so the the flow of the game is pretty simple in fact it's very simple all you're going to do is you're going to draw three cards from this huge stack of cards here i've actually had to divide it in two and you know each player is going to draw three and then you are going to choose out of those three how to or where you want to allocate each of these three so the the cards depict three different types of information they've got the power here an ability that it gives you you've got a resource cube that it's going to give you and you've also got the animal that's going to move up the track if you put it in a certain spot so let's say for example i put this one here so you well what i do first sorry is i put them all face down into these different slots as as as everybody's doing the same and then everybody's going to reveal and you're going to put them in their relevant or all the appropriate spaces so for example let's say i put this one in my slot a which means i'm going to be using it as a permanent power or a power throughout the game so from now on whenever i take one of those one of those wood colored cubes i'm gonna get going to get two points uh the second spot you know i might do this one so that means i've taken it as a resource and i'll take a another green cube from the supply and add it to my supply here and the third one would be to um in spot

d i would be moving up the little chipmunk thing on this track here like so but before that before that d takes place there's going to be a step c and that step c is going to be how you're going to acquire the new animal tokens and to do that you're going to have to spend a number of resources so say for example here you're going to have to spend two resources to put it on that relevant space or a matching color so let's say i spent two of these green tokens i could take one of my adventurers and i can put it on this spot here and the idea is that you're trying to allocate more and more um adventures onto the board to surround these animals so for example in here to to capture this frog here i need to put it in this spot and this spot here and this this two symbol represents how many how many areas you need to be in to collect it so say i ended up putting a worker here i'll take this one and put it into my supply and the idea is that you're trying to collect sets of these animals because if you get all five animals you're going to get an additional 10 points for each set at the end of the game um but naturally you're also trying to increase the value of the animals of the most kind of the most frequent animals you have in your collection and as that's going to be how around is going to play out but eventually as the rain rounds go by again and again and again you're going to start you know adding up these abilities here which can often really work well together you know for example you know whenever i my brown cubes can now count as any cube or whenever i place a worker in one of

these spots um on the kind of outer rim or the the outer rim here you're going to get an additional two points and so on so you get more and more of these really great abilities you know whenever i get a moth i get a cube of my choice whenever i put a worker onto this color i get three additional points and the weird thing is that as soon as you get more than three of these objectives you're going to have to start covering them up so for example i might say you know what i've got i've got plenty of these resources now so now i'm going to cover that one up and say you know whenever i place a worker on the same spot or somebody else i'm going to get two points and i love this fact that you've got this limited engine here that you can only ever have three powers at once and eventually you're going to have to start sacrificing powers that are going to be good so as soon as you get something good going it's going to be taken away from you i also like the fact that the um the way that the actual board is constructed because you can really kind of make these almost kaleidoscopic and snake-like maneuvers in order to branch out and get other things so for example here when i took the or place these two workers and got this animal you can see i'm already in a good position to take this other frog here by just you know allocating here and here i know when i do that i've got these four surrounded and take that one and something i should have said as well is that whenever you take an animal you get the points depicted on the tile here so i would have got two points for this one four points for this one and now i've got um i've got these two these this one's surrounded which again gets me that one for an additional two points and that's going to be how the game's going to flow until

eventually there is going to be you know these tracks are going to go higher and higher and higher making more animals worth different points and as depending on the player count and depending on the total value of the animals then the game is going to end immediately for example in a two-player game i think it ends as soon as there is a combined value of seven so here it would be a commando one two three four five six but let's say it was up to there it would be a combined value of seven meaning that um the game would be ended now the the thing i really like about this as well is at the end of the game you know every every animal you've collected is going to be costed on on or going to be giving you points depending on how high that animal is up on this track so you know if if you really invest in a certain type of animal and try to push it right to the top then you're gonna you know it's gonna pay off but at the same time you're not gonna get the rewards in terms of having the complete sets of five because again you're gonna get ten points for each set that you have so there is that kind of push and pull there those kind of contrasting mechanisms that pull you in different directions which i like and alternatively if somebody is really going for a certain type of animal you can try and take those animals away from them to try and stop them from capitalizing so much but that's yeah some really interesting decisions here not only for the low engine you're building but through your prioritization of the animals that you want to collect you know what you're gonna invest in and what you're gonna you know improve the stocking and i really like that i love the the way that the powers interact with each other i said there's loads of different cards here

loads of different powers you can't have two identical powers on your board but that you know that would really be an option anyway because of the pure variety of cards here and and so on so i really do like the simple mechanisms and that the way that little engine works without being paralyzing because you know you can only ever have three things at once and you know what generally you want to start shifting your engine anyway because you start achieving things quicker and you want to branch into new new areas and maybe get bonuses based on different colors and different animals so yeah it's pretty simple mechanically as you can see just just drawing your cards allocating to the spots there revealing them putting them in their relevant spaces and taking the actions um and you know that works really really well and balance wise as well you know as i said you can you can choose to go one way in terms of collecting a certain type of animal or really you know trying to branch out and get one of each animal you start with a pretty big um you know a big benefactor in terms of having a large tile which counts as two animals so you know that that starts as counting as two moths for example meaning that you know it might give you a good kind of starting point in terms of building up the um the points that the most are going to be acquiring at the end of the game time investment i mean the game takes probably about 45 minutes to play which i think is about right i mean maybe towards the end longer side of things i would like it to be um maybe half an hour would have been better but you know it's still fun throughout and that you you are engaged because of the um because of the engine that you're

building so no real complaint there and in terms of the up time you know up time most of it you can play um simultaneously you know allocating your cards you can play together allocating your power you can play together and even collecting your resources the only phase that might that you have to play in player order is the um turn c when you are actually putting your workers onto the board um because you know you want to get there before other players do and right yeah the rest of it can be played simultaneously so that's really good and there's no real downtime or anything like that replayability it's a pretty simple set collection game but of course there's variability in terms of the setup with the tiles being in different orders but the game is not going to really affect the gameplay to be honest you're always going to be going through the same motions but as i said for a fairly light game with some decent decisions in um i think it does hold up quite well in terms of replayability um interaction there is a moderate amount of interaction i mean not only for stealing the places or taking certain animals because the board is going to get tighter and tighter in terms of what animals are left and um you know you're going to be start fighting for the same animals and additionally you know boosting other animals or certain types of animals is sometimes going to play into your opponent's hands when you might not want it to aesthetically i think it looks okay i would have liked the uh the cards to be a bit clearer at least in terms of the

um the little player aids here they're a bit small and a bit you know the print is very small and hard to concentrate on but in terms of the components um i i'm not overly happy with it these little player boards aren't great they're very flimsy they're just a fold a bit of paper basically the the adventurer little plastic tokens they're fine i mean they didn't really have to go to the effort of making little adventurers but it works absolutely fine this scoreboard is terrible it's literally just again another bit of paper um barely or barely more than paper but you know the cubes are absolutely fine just your standard euro cubes and the cards you know i i i think this is again that more than warrants having smaller cards um because i think having it full full-size cards will be a bit of an overkill so yeah two minds about the um two minds about the components it looks okay but um the quality isn't great to be honest and uh the setup and teardown time not too bad again just snap the balls together and put all the tokens on the different symbols and you're pretty much good to go maybe a bit of shuffling in terms of the deck and because there are so many cards it's not the easiest thing to shuffle but again no no real issue um sense of progression i think it has a great sense of moving forward not only because the animals become more valuable based on the you know based on the current point value of them but because for such a simple game you do have a decent element of engine building where you constantly have to weigh up

what you want to keep and what you want to get rid of and that kind of cost analysis is really interesting especially for a game this lights to have this decent element of energy building is fantastic and the scalability i think all player counts it works fine i think you're probably better at a three player account um that's four four again three or four saves best two maybe a little bit too open but again the the complete or the get the end game trigger is going to vary based on the player count again it's no real issue there and um comparison wise there are quite obviously quite a few set collection games but i love the fact that this one you know the set the the values change throughout and it reminds me of a bumantu which was a game that came out last year in 2019 or two years ago now i suppose where you know the values of the animals are modified throughout the game and i like that i think that's an extra wrinkle of a set collection game that i that i personally enjoy so overall um i think that this is actually one of my favorite failed games that fall into that lighter category i would put it higher than say um this might be controversial but like castles of tuscany or maybe notre dame rialto that kind of thing i i think i preferred this one a little bit more because it you know it doesn't pretend to be something that's not it it is a simple set question again but that extra player board just for me is so compelling and i just love that

hard decision i love all these powers but which one am i forced to cover up and i really do like that and you know that for me is what i take away from this game it's just a really nice introductory game and a great game to start maybe feeding their engine building element into a gamer's repertoire so yeah i can't complain there at all so a real enjoyable for me and a hit for me as well and certainly one that's going to be sticking around and i think i can have a lot of fun and get a lot more plays out of la isla it gets my my seal of quality sneaking in at about a um a seven out of ten so give this one a try if you've written it off i really think it holds up well i hope you enjoyed the review if you have please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos and for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved