Skip to main content
Loading video...

Castle Builder – A Solid Foundation with Some Crumbling Towers

Transcript 13:00

today I'm going to show you the two to four player tile placing game from Fricks games Castle Builder now if you look at the profile for this game this is a pretty simple and not very interactive game focused on mechanics so with profiles like this what makes these games awesome is when they have a really cool or unique mechanic which happens to be what brought this game to my attention I will show you how to play in just a second and I'm going to talk about what I like about the game and what's not to like about the game but fortunately this game is something that I haven't seen before which always gets me excited so let's take a look Castle Builder is really a rather simple game every player has their own player board and a rack of tiles and players are going to take turns doing one of two things either they're going to draw two tiles from the face down Supply to add to their Rack or they're going to choose one tile from their rack to play onto their board now for placement there are a few rules the first rule is that you can't place any tiles in such a way that air would be directly on top of stone or um stone is on top of air like that that would never be allowed but the major restriction in tile placement and the driver of gam playay is that every tile must be placed

so that it equals the sum of the two tiles beneath it so 7 is equal to 3 + 4 6 isal to 4 + 2 so on my turn if I wanted to place here I would need to have 13 and I don't have a 13 as you can see but there is another rule which is you can discard a tile from your rack like I might discard this six in order to add or subtract one from the sum so 7 + 6 + 1 is 14 and I could place that there now for scoring in this game you're going to be scoring one point for every floor that the the place tile is on so in this case because it's on the third floor I would get three points and you can even get a bonus for the Little Gems so five points total you don't score any tiles that are on the bottom row even if they have a gem on them so that would not be scored speaking of the bottom row you can place any tile on the bottom so for example on a later turn I could place a three right here and that would set me up to place a six right there and that would be that six would be worth two points eventually I'm going to need to draw up so on a later turn I might draw two more tiles and that really sets me up for one last example which is to explain exp these check marks check marks are nice

because they can be placed anywhere regardless of the sum underneath them so that princess could go right there no problem it's worth showing you what the end of the game could look like because the restrictions aren't just sums you'll see that as I've built up I end up with these tiles that create air that I can't build above so right now if you look at my rack nothing I have here could be placed in a in a space like that because I wouldn't be allowed to do that so it's a lot tighter than just getting tiles that add together you also need to get tiles with the right shape so that would be a legal placement but as you can kind of imagine you're going to get to the point where it gets very very difficult to play and that's happens to also be about the time where the game sort of comes to its own end it's worth showing you how scoring is handled because it's not just marking a number of points but rather advancement on a track so if I was the yellow player and I played a castle on the third or a tile on the third story I would move up three points to land here and then because I've landed on a gem I get an extra movement and I can go there and eventually I'll pass this coin Once I pass the coin I can take any of these face up coins and each coin is going to give a different benefit like this one is the thief lets

you steal a tile off of somebody else's rack blindly this one is the Monk and the monk is going to award the person with the fewest coins and this is the tow the Tower or it's a competition for Tower because whoever has the most Towers immediately gets to draw two tiles so these benefits are going to benefit any person who satisfies the requirement whether or not it's the person who took the coin so I could pass and get to here and maybe I'll take this coin from the board but somebody else gets the benefit of the two tiles we're going to talk about this as we go over the review of the game um if you land on one of these tiles you get to take something from the market so there are a few tiles that are publicly available but this is the only way to get those tiles otherwise you're always drawing from a supply of face down tiles there is one more element to advancing on this track and that is if a player is to land on a space occupied by opponent then that player immediately moves up one space ahead I absolutely love the core mechanic of this game I love the placing of tiles based on building a scaffolding of values that will that will give you sums so that you're building on top of sums I think that's really great not only because it's something I haven't seen before but because when I'm playing this game with my kids it reinforces and builds numeracy my kids are constantly adding

as they play this game and as trivial or as easy as adding might seem the fact that you play this game and you take for granted that you're just going to be constantly adding I think is awesome I enjoy the core mechanic of Castle Builder but I do have some criticisms and to understand my criticism I want to make a comparison think of the game carcassone which has been around for over 20 years now kazone has a great core mechanic so much so that several expansions came out to give variance on how carason is played now this game Castle Builder doesn't focus enough on the mechanic that I love so much it feels like a variant of some other game that I I don't know about or does not exist I wish the game was more Castle building and less other stuff so what are the other things that I don't like there's a few things first the track movement is a real distraction for me the the way that you advance on the track if you land on an opponent's piece you get a free movement to Jump Ahead that means you could watch that board and try to get exactly the right amount of points so you can jump on an opponent and get free movement space but I I don't want to do that I don't care about the track I want to focus my game on building my my castle I want to focus on objectives making my castle have more windows or making it taller or giving it more individual spires there are so many cool objectives that could drive

gameplay and instead you're just focusing on getting these coins which I don't really like not only am I distracted by it but I have these tokens that are aggressive in ways that do not make the game better for me I don't like the fact that you can steal from another player because there's already too much luck in the rack management of this game which I'll get to in a minute uh but the one that bugs me the most are these these coins that say that when you take them uh the player who has the most Towers or the most windows or something they get an award even if that person isn't you because when you take a coin you get to choose which coin you take you don't have to take a coin that benefit somebody else but eventually as they come out we played a game once where every single tile was exactly the same tile and the player had to take it but why would I play a game where I'm not incentivized to take the trophy to take to take the winning marks like I want every coin to be good for me I I see what they're doing I see that they want people to be like oh look there's there's an award if I have the most Towers I want to go for that but you can't control that because you don't control what you draw you can do rack management but if you don't draw any tiles then the game the benefit just gets forced to some opponent not because they played well but because they just had stuff on their rack that you didn't have that's not cool let's talk about rack management for a second so on your

turn you can play one tile or you can draw two tiles the most interesting way to play this game is with a full rack is just having seven tiles to choose from if you have seven tiles to choose from then it feels that's where the game is I don't want to make a decision with five tiles I want all seven so the problem with the game is I can't get seven unless I spend multiple turns taking two tiles at a time have you already played the game that way then we would just spend multiple I take two I take two I take two two two two two two oh does everyone have seven now great now let's play like why how come you don't just make it that on your turn play tiles and then refill your board to seven why not just always have seven for free doesn't cost you anything that would be cool it would offset luck it should be done that way to me doesn't make sense doesn't make sense why you're using a turn to draw two tiles when really everyone should want seven that's what I think about that lastly I think I want to talk a little bit about luck because I understand that the game requires luck like you couldn't just play this game by just taking any tile you wanted the fun of the game is rack management and finding tiles that add together well so drawing things and having to deal with that is fine but there is a a optional rule in the in the rule book that says that if you don't have an exact match even differing by one you can discard any number of tiles

from your rack in order to make the sum work out that should be a decision that players can make I don't think it should even be an optional rule it should just be this is a rule um I like that there are tiles like there's a few other things in there that like offset the luck oh here's another one uh an option is you can start every game with a princess tile or a prince or and a prince tile princess tiles look like this they have a check mark on the bottom and a low number like a four on the top I think the prince has a six on the top starting the game with this is a great idea because you know what isn't fun when you start the game off and immediately the tiles on your board are like these kind this kind of thing where it's like a nine and it and it cuts off and makes a tower no one wants to start a a castle that way I think there should be like at least for the first turn of the game everyone should be given some tiles that you would want to place the three the four the low valued stuff everyone should start the game with that I understand the need for the luck but do you do you have to like start with a blind draw in the beginning I don't know it's thing like these that make the game feel great but flawed so I don't know how much I'm going to play the game honestly I really like the mechanic I can't stand the flaws what it makes me want to do is just house rule the stuff I don't like just throw out the track everyone draws up to seven at the end of your turn but then like what

am I reviewing you know am I reviewing a board game that was made or am I just reviewing how I play with stuff that I find or like I'm just making it up at that point anyway so that's Castle Builder thank you for watching this review and and oh man I feel like I was too hard on it but yeah yeah it is it's a game that's that's it let me know what you think in the comments okay appreciate that see you next time byebye

Progress saved