Skip to main content
Loading video...

Catan Starfarers - Boardgame 4K Review - Still Worth It?

Transcript 13:40

hello welcome back to the ball games the 4k YouTube channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews playthroughs unboxings and we generally talk aligned Ebonics about so top gaming in general and in this video we're gonna be talking to you about a reprint of a 1999 so-called classic game we're gonna be talking about Catan star fair as all the staff errors of Catan and this is a game where you will be collecting resources that will enable you to explore the galaxy touch bases with alien worlds that will give you victory points that will allow you to win the day and in this video we're gonna be giving you a very brief overview of the rules would be telling you what we do like what we don't like and then we'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not katare star fair is it's still worth playing 20 years after its initial release so remember if you are new here then please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below give us a thumbs up and we will see you after this board games for K some Catan staff errors and to play this game so Kitaen star Faris takes place over three vices and you've got the production face you've got the age-old trade bill face and then you've got the flight face right so to start with you'll do the same thing that you do in original Catan you will be placing your

colonies onto the board in set spices you'll choose where you want to put them and then you'll get a certain number of random resources for in the resource pot right again where you've got these colonies you'll put them a choice into planets and those planets will yield resources when you rolled into dice yeah so the first thing you'll do on your turn you roll two dice and you'll look for all the numbers that correspond to those dice and those players with colonies on those colonies places that are adjacent to these two planets will gain those resources and then as an added bonus spending on how many vegetables you got then you will draw two extra cards and if you've got more feature points you'll draw one and if you've got more in more veg points then you won't draw any right so our next thing you can do is you can trade and build you can trade and build as much as you want and players can come back with counteroffers as well some of the things that you can build you can't build a colony ship and what you'll do your take a colony and a ship put it together and then you'll place it in a space born a spaceport is the equivalent of a city that contains a colony with a spaceport thing like rings that's put over the top of it right and you could only spawn ships from space ports right so you gotta be careful where you put your spice balls here spice ports are worth 2 points colonies are worth 1 point source like settlements and cities in vanilla Catan right so let me say you could build colony ships that will allow you to shoot off into the galaxy and establish colonies you can build trade ships that will allow you to shoot off into the galaxy and trade with a variety of different alien races right so will you do trade in the relevant resources you've got fuel carbon or and food and you've also got good spice but you got remember as well you could trade 3 for 1 anytime but Goods you can try to for us

that's really really handy right so there's other things you can do you'll notice that you have got this huge phallic type of rocket thing in front of filled with bolts bye unreal so you could trade into carbon to put a cannon on top of your ship right and what that does that allows you to fight the spice parts to give you extra feature points and they also help you with the encounters that you will come across during a game beer you can also add fight pots so you'll trade in two or your sticker froak pod on your ship this will help you out when you're trying to establish tri colonies where it's all bad and you can also get boost this your trade-in to fuel and this will mean that your ship will be able to fly farther and faster in the flight phase so once you are done trading and building you will move on to the flight phase and if you've got any ships on the board then you will be able to fly them into the galaxy if you haven't got any ships then you can't do this this step right the first thing you'll do is you'll calculate your speed and you'll shake your ship and then you look at the two little balls that are hanging for the bottom you'll ship then you will look at a little chart I don't tell you how far your ship can move and you add any boosters that you got to that and you'll move your ship certain amount of intersections until you are a planet or you'll hit one of these like docking station trade installation type things yeah if you have a black ball then you will take an encounter card and you will move three plus two boosters and you also allow to sort of turn back into you move into spaces you've already gone into so if you land at a planet if you even fly past the planet you can flip over anything this hidden like you can flip if you plan a certain variant you can flip over the actual planetary system tall we can flip over the number tiles to reveal and you've got to remember if there's a nice planet or any

pirates say you cannot build colonies adjacent to those things until I've been destroyed the way you destroyed them is you have to have more throw pots or more cannons than the number depicted on that toy and if you've got that and you get a victory point if there's nothing there then you can actually detach your ship from your colony and dump it all in the air and that will give you extra resources depending on their number in the production phase so if you wanted to touch your trade ship you would have to move it to one of the four alien galaxies docking stations you have to make sure that you've got more freight pods on your ship then the number of trading posts that are already in their system right this is so like the longest road or the largest army type thing in vanilla Catan and if you manage to go in there and you've got majority trading stations in there then you be able to take the alien standee which will give you too points yeah so there's a bit of a sort of a to-and-fro air with feature points so like we said if you've all read our you'll be able to take an encounter you'll plow on your left will read it's here generally gives you a certain number of choices you know you might have to choose a number away yes or no question and this is meant to add a little bit of flavor a little bit themed to the game right so you got remember that you can't blockade anyone spy sport spaces that rejection to a spiced pork or calling spaces or anything like if you blare neg or move out that you you might be able to get some extra VG point medals you can put together and I see these once things that don't know she fits give her very well by you can get them to I give you added victory points and you'll keep doing this round after round off the round and the first player to get 15 feature points will be the winner of Catan star varus so what do we like about Catan star Ferrars so the first thing that we really like about staff areas of Catan or guitar

staffers is that it takes Catan to a new level both in Fame and in mechanics barber dance or fur farming of dusty old Ireland you know I mean a medieval on it you out in the universe you'll explore it you're gathering resources you're building us it takes it to a new level entirely and the space beam really does fit this really really well but it also keeps the feel that the flavor of original Catana keeps what was great about that in this game and that's really good it's only second thing we really like about Catan staff versus there's more stuff to buy there's loads of stuff to buy but in the original game all you had to buy those roads see settlements and maybe your development card being this you've got colonies you've got space ports you've got trading ships you've got colony ships you've got all these different things that you can add to your rocket and there's an absolute wealth of things to do you never really stop for something to do with your cards that you've got in your hand so the third thing that we really like about staffers of Catan is the robber mechanism has essentially been not removed but been modified so when you rolled a seven there's no longer any kind of movement of this this pawn around a board that's gone so what you do is is no planets produce resources and the player that robbed the seven will be able to Nick a card from anybody wants and then everybody else will get a random card draw to sort of me okay the randomness owner and we think that's a better way of doing things I can't we don't mind the robber in the original Khattab they transplanted the original robber and so they said probably won't Werner well for reasons that we will talk about a bit so the first thing that we really like about the Star Ferry of

Catan is the way that when you are in the production phase and you're rolling and dice in original games sometimes you didn't actually get anything you were just sat there thinking like you think'll nothing ain't got nothing ain't got nothing in this you actually get signed it works really well in the sense that the low amount of extra points you've got the more cards you're going to get and the more stuff you can do it's like a nice little catch up mechanism and a nice little way of being rewarded even though you haven't rolled the right dice right so what don't we like about star ferris of Catan so d first thing is that is too long it takes about three hours to play if you're playing your first game you're gonna take about half hour to teach this cuz there's a little bit some of the rules of a little binge okay you're not mean that you're gonna have to sit down read the rulebook try and separate your mind from what you know about Catan and try and think about this is more or less a new guy so even when you've done that you're gonna be looking about three hours and there's certain portions towards the end where you're sat there thinking this is maybe a little bit too long for me so if you're gonna go into this you've got to know this one and in games it's gonna take you about 3 hours to play nightmares OD second thing that we don't like about guitar stagg Farris is it adds an extra couple of layers of randomness to a game that was already essentially a little bit random right so in the original Catan you've just rolled the dice and that was the more or less the amount most amount of random stuff is gonna happen ok that the development cars have came out round and draw this game you've not only got the round die rolls but you've got the random ship shakes for when you move and also you've

got the random encounter cards so that's maybe too many layers of randomness into what was already a game that was criticized for being a little bit too random anyways I think that we don't like about star fairies of Catan this follows on from our previous point about the randomness is we don't like the in camera cause we would prefer to work Polly what now or maybe if there was a way of reducing the amount of risk that you had again it and not only do you not get to choose whether you have an encounter when you shut your ship and you get blackballed but the draw is completely random as well go over to this what it is is that a lot of the encounters at the same you'll be drawing the same thing and it was when we played this elf a date as a law grounds oh wow not that one again oh oh that's exactly the same as the last one so if somebody has an encounter you can sort of second guess what it's going to be and you know what the rewards gonna be some of these encounter costs can be absolutely devastating and some can be absolutely fantastic for instance some of them mean you have to give up loads of resources if you go wrong or you check your ship wrong in others if you're successful means you can do a space jump and fly over to the other side of the galaxy and start building in a place that would have taken you about four or five turns to get see so they're wildly unbalanced in opinion it's even the artwork on it it's a load of rubbish you know I mean you got these weird wacky aliens look something I've ever had a Forbidden Planet no it's no so good well they should have done I should have done it so you could offer buy one or maybe choose to have one or something if there's some sort of choice involved that you could sort of changed I just me okay that randomness again I know we

keep banging on about it but the counter cause they done waiting so the final thing that we don't like about star ferris of Catan is that there's too many of those brick wall moments you know you saw finger in a flow you figure your cruise into a victory and then suddenly bang you can't do nothing so for example a game we played the other day are so far behind us thinking on at least encounter cars they've destroyed me I'm never gonna come back and I've got my guitar started flow us thinking I'm gonna win this one win it I was one point away and then I realized I couldn't build anything so I already built all my colonies couldn't get any extra resources and mainly all of the docking stations all the docking spaces were full up and I would've at sir have built all these trade ships have flown them halfway across the galaxy and if there was just no way of doing it so one of the main problems to this is that if there's probably a set way or a best path through this building process because you've got an added flight phase you've gotta add that into the mix you know I mean all your planning goes out the window so you know so the fact that there's too many of them frustrating I can't do any fat moments is a bit of a nightmare so to summarise is staff errors of catan still worth playing 20 years after it was first released so we are going to say yes we are going to say that this is an excellent variation on Catan if you if you're a big fan Catan this isn't like buying that way so it adds an extra layer of def bar sadly it that there of death is snuffed out entirely by an extra couple of layers of randomness you've got the randomness of the encounter cause you've got a randomness of the initial resource power-ups you've got the randomness of those ships are you gonna be shaken that

stops this game from being better than the original Catan for us had mr. Klaus Tauber halt to boat toy bar included a shorter variant that would have improved this game and it's a little bit sloppy in the Almanac when you gone on about the variable setup it's just seems as though he has tried to include all these weird and wonderful variations in how you play the game bear century it's just you play with this face-up where you play with that face up or you the play with nothing face up at all so it's a little bit sloppy it does seem as though some of the mechanisms are afterthoughts I get they've done a bit of play testing they've gone oh that's not gonna work how come we saw so we just changed will have breath that will have its own if if you do move into a colony space then you've got to move out of it next time you know I'll do that's what it feels like to us but we're still going to give this for our 5 we love Catan this is a decent alternative that is that suffers from a being too long and B being too rounded but if you can get over that then the component quality is absolutely fantastic they've improved on this reprint from the original by tenfold and it's still a wonderful game is still hooked up to date and yeah that circuit air Starfarer so remember if you are new here please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in their section down below give us a thumbs up and we'll see you next time

Progress saved