TDG: High Treason: The Trial of Louis Riel
Transcript
Hello ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know earlier today I was looking for some fresh ice but all they had was that frozen stuff. Today we're going to go ahead and take a look at high treason the trial of Louis Rial from Victory Point Games. Heat. Heat.
high treason. The trial of Louis Rial attempts to recreate the infamous trial from the 19th century in which a Canadian supposedly led a rebellion against the Canadian government was brought to trial and was executed. They hung him. Now, in this game, players take on the roles of either the defense or the prosecution as they attempt to acquit or convict Louis Rial in this famous trial. Now, the game board contains places for some reference cards for every phase you're in. It's going to have kind of a a guilty track, which is which is what the prosecution wants this to go up on. You've also got a insanity track, which the defense argued insanity. They're trying to get it to go in the opposite direction. And then you have kind of the trait areas of the board, and more on that later. Now, at the beginning of the game, the first phase is jury selection. You're going to put out 12 cards that represent different jurors, and they have a lot.
Some of them have different numbers of spaces on them where they can be swayed eventually. But what you're doing here is you're putting out these cards and each one of the jurors is going to have three traits on them. The trait is either going to be religion, it's going to be occupation, or it's going to be language. Now, these traits are represented on the game board. As I say, with religion, they can either be Catholic or Protestant. For language, it can either be English or French. And for the occupation, they can either be a farmer, they can be a merchant, or they can be a government worker. So, at the beginning of the game during jury selection, you don't know which traits uh correspond to which on the tracks. Now, during jury selection, each player is going to get seven cards.
Now, two of these cards will not be used. You're going to place them under your uh plea token, and you can potentially use them at the end of the game for their summation values, their summation events. But what you're going to do is you look at the very specific part of the card that deals with jury selection. And it very the very first thing is the uh prosecution is going to go first. He's going to play all five of his cards and he's going to do whatever they tell him. And usually they're either going to allow him to reveal traits on certain jurors or they will allow him to peek at them. Now all of the traits are pointing upward. So if you peek at them, you can actually just point it toward you. So you can always look back and see what that is for the rest of the game. But after the prosecution is gone, then the defense attorney will go and he too can either reveal traits or he can see where they are. You know, he can peek at them and point them toward him. Now, once both attorneys have played all of those cards, you can now dismiss juries. Now, as I say again, you start with 12 jurors, but now you can just determine which jurors you don't want. Beginning with the prosecution, uh they can dismiss a juror and then the defense can dismiss a juror, and you keep dismissing jurors until you get down to six jurors.
And in that way, you kind of are gauging which jurors you think have the traits that you can best manipulate in the game. Next, you've got trial and chief part one. So, the trial begins. Now, during this game, uh you're playing your cards and you're alternating playing cards. Again, you get seven cards. You're going to play five of them. Two of them are going to go in your summation deck. Now as you are playing this what you are doing is you can play the cards for action points or you can uh play the card for its event. Now some events either side can play some are just for the prosecution some are just for the defense. So you have some options here. Now with the actions you can essentially try to manipulate the trait track. For one point you can actually move the trait one space toward you and you're going to put a sway marker on there. There are three sway markers on all the traits. Once a track has been manipulated three times this way, it can't move again. It's locked.
You can actually also spend three action points to move a track uh to move one of the trait markers two spaces toward you. Now, you can also spend an action point to place a sway marker on a juror. Now, if you can go ahead and get a juror locked, meaning you have all of your um all of the spaces are covered in your color, um that's going to be very important toward the summation and the jury deliberation. Now, if you if somebody has tokens on that and you don't want them to have that, you can actually play your actions to remove some of their tokens, but you can't have both prosecution and defense tokens on the same card at the same time. Now, as you're manipulating the trait tracks, essentially you're arguing, you're arguing your side of the case here, and you're trying to get those in certain locations. For instance, the prosecution wants high numbers. You want to move them toward the 10 on the track. They can't go higher than 10. And the defense wants them low, and they can't go lower than one on the track. Now, instead of playing your cards for the actions, you can play your cards for the events. As I say, there are different kinds of events on many of these cards, and you can go ahead and play them. And some of these things again will manipulate the trait track. Some of them will manipulate the jurors and and add sway markers. Some of them will allow you to move up on the guilt uh track. Some of them will allow you to move up on the uh insanity track.
Now, some cards do have a moment of insight. This is kind of a a lightning bolt, and that allows you to do some important things. You can actually trade out a card from your hand with one of the cards that's under your plea marker if you think that one will be helpful to you in that round. You can also force the opposition to reveal one of their plea cards so you can see what their summation ability will be for that card. Now, at the end of the first trial and chief phase, uh you're going to go ahead and again place two cards under your plea marker. Then you're going to repeat this in your uh trial and chief phase part two. It plays out just the same way as the first phase did. Now, in the first two phases, you can actually call for a mulligan. If you don't like any of your cards, you can set those aside and you can draw new cards, but you only get to do that once. You flip over your plea marker to show that you've actually done the mulligan. Now, finally, phase four, you have the summation. So, what you're doing is you're taking the six cards you have under your plea marker, and the prosecution will play three of his cards in a row. You'll be looking at the bottom summation side and again this will allow him to manipulate the uh traits. It will allow him to sway jurors or you know remove sway markers from his opponent. You play three of them. Then the defense will play all six of theirs and then the prosecution will play their final three. Now after summation you go to phase five. This is jury deliberation and their judgment. Now the very first thing you have to do is you have to look at the guilt the evidence of guilt track. That has to be at least on the two. If it is not at the two, the
defense immediately wins. The prosecution hasn't made their case. Now, if the prosecution is able to get that defense even higher to three or four, that will allow them to place more sway markers on the jurors. Now, if the evidence of insanity marker is at the two or higher, uh depending on where it is, it can move all of the trait markers a number of spaces toward them. Next, you're going to reveal all of the trait markers on all of the jurors. And then one by one, you're going to add up all of the traits on the board for each juror. Now, if the prosecution has locked a juror, you can double that number. If the defense has locked that juror, you can have that number. Now, you're going to go ahead and total up all of the numbers from all of the jurors. If that number is 100 or greater, then the prosecution has made their case and they win. However, if the number is 99 or lower, then the defense wins.
Hi, treason. The trial of Louis Rial. We'll get back to the review in just a moment. I want to take a minute to ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where we talk about history, books on history, military history. I even post some of my uh lectures for my classes on there. Please check that out. Please subscribe to that channel. And now, back to the review. All right, ladies and gentlemen. So, first of all, I knew nothing about this court case. Um, I'm a historian, but I don't know everything. Uh, no one does. And I I I didn't know anything about this. Now, I remember, you know, I guess what was it, 2015, 2016? I remember when Victory Point Games back in the day under Allen uh released this title, and I thought it sounded interesting, kind of a a card driven, almost a CDG in a courtroom. It is a CDG in a courtroom. I remember thinking that sounded really really cool, but I never um it was one I never played. And you know the original one it was a victory points game which were great games but the productions were always so so you had very small um you had paper maps and you know cardboard laser cut chits and stuff that had the soot on them. I always liked them. I always thought they had a charm but it wasn't it wasn't the greatest productions. Well, now Tabletop Tycoon with their Victory Games line, they've created this new and really beautiful version of the game. I think the the the board's beautiful, cards are beautiful, great artwork and and and representations here. I I think the game looks great
and I'm very intrigued about this idea of a trial of playing of abstracting a a capital case and playing it out. And it's very interesting. Now, I have to admit, the first time I I played it with Chris a few times, and the first time we played it, um, we got a few things wrong. There were a few things we were doing wrong. For instance, I didn't realize that the jurors, you couldn't have both sides on there. And, and it took us a while to figure that out. And there was one or two other little things. For instance, we were playing most of that first game thinking we we certain traits favored the prosecution, certain traits favored the defense, and we wanted them all high across the board. And so, we just were not playing very well. And then we just missed things. We're just in such an eager to to get a play, we didn't we didn't read it carefully enough. And it's no fault of the game because the rule book here is pretty good. I think this is a pretty strong rule book. It's not a very complicated game, but but the the the ideas and the concepts here lays out pretty good. We were just in a hurry to play it. So when we go back and we actually read through it more carefully and we played it and we played it right, the game is very challenging for both sides and it's one of those games where you feel like you're losing, you're losing, you're losing even when you have the upper hand.
um you're watching those those tracks go up and down as you make your arguments and it's very interesting to see those things. Um you know when you when you feel like you're really getting ahead and then somebody plays a card that just kind of undoes what you're doing both on the the argument tracks, the trait tracks and with the the swaying the jurors. You know, you're trying to get a juror to get locked on your side and then somebody can just play a card and usually once something's locked, they can't they can't take it. But there are some events that will allow you to still remove stuff and they're h you work really hard and you spend a lot of your time to get those things done and sometimes people can just screw you over. So there's a lot of take that in this game which is something I always really really enjoy and so I like that. I think this game does a great job of abstracting a courtroom case which is very very fun.
Never played a game quite that took this theme to this level. But really fundamentally the game is a tugofwar right. It's it's it's one side's trying to trying to get the jurors on their side and the traits to their side and the other side is doing the same thing. And so there's a lot of back and forth here. There's a lot of, you know, card play and and trying to undo what the your opponent just did. And what makes this game, I think, really stellar is this is a quick game. That first game we played probably took us where we're doing stuff wrong 40 45 minutes and then we played we played it again and we played it knowing the rules and understanding the game better and it was a half an hour if that. It's a super quick game. Where there where the where where time is an issue is with AP. It's not with the game but even AP isn't that bad. So, we're playing these games and yeah, it once you know the game, it plays in a half an hour. It is a super quick game and it's one of those games, too, that you know, if it if it were an hour and a half, I probably wouldn't like it that much. But where it's so quick, it's great. It reminds me a lot of Watergate, which is another fairly quick tug-of-war game where you're trying to get stuff done and kind of CDG for events or or or action points. Um, you know, it's these are great games. You know, you look at like Twilight Struggle, which is a much bigger and complicated game, but it's still got some of these same fundamental ideas of area control and, you know, the playing the cards for events or for points. I really liked High Treason. I
thought it was incredibly fun. It's one I'm I'm happy to have in my collection now and kicking myself I didn't play it earlier. So, the recommendation for The Discriminating Gamer for High Treason: The Trial of Louis Royale is I'm going to give it an eight out of 10 on the Cody scale. Really a lot of fun. Thank you once again for joining us today on The Discriminating Gamer. As always, we'd ask you to please leave a comment for us here on YouTube, on Board Gamegeeek, on our Facebook page, on Twitter. We'd ask you to like and subscribe to all of these. It's very important that you like and subscribe to this channel. That means a lot to us. And if you like what we do here, please check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where we talk about history, military history, books on history, even post some of my lectures on that channel, uh, please subscribe to that. It would mean the world to me. And if you do really like what we do on this channel, I would humbly ask you to click on the super thanks button and leave a tip. You know, my wife recently told me that she's going to leave me because I'm too old-fashioned, but I'll bet she just wants to have scone with a chap who's a real scoundrel.
Help me on my feet again. And I don't know where I'm going. And I don't know where I've been. Please somebody.
Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go