Skip to main content
Loading video...

Sierra West, Elysium, Jorvik Reviews - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 14:31

hey everybody today I'm taking a look at three board games those games being jorvik by Stephen Feld we have Sierra West by Johnny pack and finally we have Elysium by Brett Gilbert and Matthew Dunstan now I would consider these games as Euros but perhaps there could be an argument calling Elysium more of a card game than a Euro before I share my thoughts on these games I want to give a shout out to these shows sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in my show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order so let's start with my least favorite and then work our way up so we're going to start with Sierra West here this is a wonderful player game takes around 40 to 60 Minutes to play now this is a resource management style game as you are managing this hand of cards in each round you are going to slot three cards into your personal player board which will show certain icons on each of these tracks you have these two meeples which are going to be moving from left to right activating these different icons as you go and you can do that at any pacing you like now they're going to give you resources they're going to give you movement points to climb this mountain and collect new cards or better cards for your deck and they're going to let you move along this track here to increase your end game scoring multipliers in

relation to a separate track and so on it's all about the order in which you activate things to make sure you have the right resources at the right times now you can also collect these tiles which will increase your engine or your ability to do different things and I quite like this decision space of you are not able to activate these tiles unless you have somebody sat on them which means that you cannot actually use the you know the icons going from left to right so you can basically set them here and then commit them to the track but you can never go back on yourself so it's all about about that pacing and the order in which you are doing things now for me this game felt a little bit too forgiving um because it seems like no matter what you did you always had the right resources at the right time and I didn't really feel like I had to stress myself too much in order to optimize each of my turns because what you're doing is when you get to the end if you have the right resources you can cash them in and get quite a strong bonus you know such as getting climbing tracks um Etc now the game is modular and I'll be transparent I haven't tried them all the ones I have tried it kind of always harks back to that main mechanism which I like in theory I do really like that again that Tempo in which you're doing things but I just kind of didn't find the decision space too enticing or meaty enough to satisfy me so yeah I never really felt like I was making big choices and the game was almost playing me and the decisions were

fairly obvious despite being a cool mechanism it looks nice when it's on the table um some good table presents there with a big card mounting but yeah ultimately I thought the game was quite forgettable and I didn't really feel I wanted to play it anymore than what I did because I felt like I'd seen everything really and it again it just didn't utilize that cool mechanism as much as it could have because it's a really cool idea you know slotting those cards in I'm covering up some symbols to reveal other ones some of these symbols are punishing so you need to have resources at the right time or suffer you know a bit of a punishment yeah despite those cool things going on the game itself was just nothing I was kind of looking for and um yeah it didn't really do it for me so I can't really recommend this one that is Sierra West so let's move on to Elysium so Elysium is as you can see her brother beautiful looking game at this one accommodates two to four players and takes around an hour to play at least according to the Box the games I've played have been a bit quicker than that but this is a card drafting game and a bit of an engine builder as you acquiring these cars from different decks so this game is completely variable I think there's something like eight decks or something in the box and you only use five of them at each time so you've got some variability there some of the decks are a bit more aggressive than others some are a bit more kind of combo-rific this kind of stuff so you can really tailor the gameplay depending on your personal

tastes thoughts um it put some variability and some replayability now the drafting system in this game is actually quite cool as you have these colored pillars here and as long as you have them in front of you on your player board you can draft cards with those matching symbols on them so you can see here for this God of War card I would need to have the yellow pillar and the red pillar or my sheets here and if I had that I would be eligible to take it into my basically into my display but as soon as I take a card I have to relinquish one of these and basically take them off meaning that I now have few options to draft and those pillars don't even have to match the ones that I've just used to draft so you can see like if you've got a ton of cards with say the yellow symbol on them then you might want to hold on to that one for the longest but not only is there an urgency to get to the best cards there's also a really important factor when it comes to drafting these initiative tiles which will break turn order but also determine how many cards you can transfer from your engine to your Elysium which is essentially your scoring pile so this game is a bit of a a plate spinning exercise between utilizing the abilities of these cards for as long as possible with the tension of trying to transfer it into your Elysium to make it eligible for scoring because again if you're using those Powers they are not going to score you anything and as soon as you transfer them then the powers are going to be basically nullified but they are now secured for scoring and what you're trying to do is you are trying to create

sets of the same number in all the different suits and you're also trying to collect um a number one two and three card in each of the different suits so you have kind of two different ways to score points there and there's some bonuses as well for doing things quicker by getting these bonus tiles so if you are juggling quite a few things here um so I do like the way that works I think it's generally a cool mechanism and this game puts you under a lot of pressure to transfer it from your again from your um display into your Elysium because the rounds go apply go by pretty rapidly uh in this game and if you're always well if you're neglecting the um correct initiative tiles that you want then you can find yourself quickly running out of options to transfer the card so you might have great Powers here but you just haven't got enough time in order to transfer them and they're of course tons of things that these cards do such as generating new points giving you bonus points letting you transfer more cards I'm giving you points based on the different sets um so all the kind of things you'd expect when it comes to synergizing cards so I generally liked everything about this game um the only thing maybe I wasn't so sure on was that all the different suits or the different decks feel relatively similar yes there are a few twists on them yeah as I said some are a bit more confrontational some are a bit more interactive uh that kind of thing but the game generally felt similar each time I did like that rating to get to the different sets of the bonus points I

like the pressure the artwork is amazing and the little twist on the drafting is really solid and yeah generally this is a very well-rounded game now what I generally found as well is that because most of the cards are are pretty good anyway you'd find yourself just going for the actual cards you need rather than the abilities um so for example if you're collecting threes and you're missing the black three you're just going to drop the black three regardless of what the color was and hopefully the power will suit you as well that's what I personally found again maybe I'm not playing optimally but um but yeah that's just the direction I took and what my opponents took as well and it seemed to serve us quite well but all in all I think this is a very solid game um again I love that idea of having how long do I want to utilize these Powers uh before I give up on them and secure them as banked points now I've seen that used in quite a few games before the games such as tyrants of the undark of the valley of Kings uh those are more kind of Deck Builder games but I've also seen it in Coco Pele which is a steppenfeld game where again you want to utilize his powers as much as possible before securing those points and to be honest I think I slightly prefer Coco Pele to this one because I think it's a little bit smoother and I find the actual Powers a little bit more interesting now I don't want that to sound like a slight on this one because I can certainly see why if you like your kind of combotastic games a bit of engine

builder with some cool card play then I'm pretty sure you would like this one you know you've got ongoing Powers you've got powers that you can tap each round you've got one one kind of use per game Powers all these different things and it's all about trying to trigger them at the right time and I love the way that the timing really does come into play with this one so this is I would say it's a near Miss for me um I think objectively I can praise it and think that a lot of people would enjoy it but I can't really see myself coming back to it much more and if I wanted to play a game like this again I'd probably slightly lean towards Kokopelli and the final game I'm talking about today is by far my favorite this is jorvik by Stefan Feld now this is a two to five player game that takes probably 60 to 90 minutes to play depending on how many people you are playing with now this is actually a bidding Style game as you are okay building an engine of cards but the way you acquire these cars in this game for me is so fascinating and I love the bidding mechanism in this game as you are basically putting out a whole new display of cards each round and these cards do a ton of different things which we'll touch on shortly but basically the better the cards are the more expensive they're going to be by default because what you're going to do on your turn is you're going to place your meeples in a queuing system next to the cards that you want and the longer the queue you have to pay an equal amount of currency equal to the number of people in that queue but you refuse that card from the start of the queue to

the back of the queue so if there's say five people in the queue and your first online you can pay five coins to get that card but then if you don't want to pay that much you can pass it'll fall to the next person in the queue and they can pay four coins and then three coins and then two coins so it has this kind of a pusher like chicken mechanism which has so many wrinkles to the gameplay in terms of strategy in terms of tactical maneuvering because if you know that your opponent really wants a card um you can kind of start stacking your people behind them just running up the price and you might need not even have an intention to buy that card yourself but it might be so cheap that you might be forced to buy it and utilize it now there's a ton of different strategies you can go for here like a lot of stuff and fell games this game works against you by these kind of um these barbarians attacking and you can build up a Defense Force and if you have the best then you get some more points you have this kind of contract fulfillment system where you're collecting colored resource cubes to allocate them to these contracts that you're collecting um you have kind of conversion cards you have Straight Up victory points cards and all these different strategies are perfectly viable and it's all about trying to find a good card at a good price and there's even like this other auction mechanism that's going on at the same time through this reserving system where if you claim a card it will go into this another queue here and again the best cards will go to the front of the queue because people are going to reserve them but depending on the amount of other reserved cards it's going to cost an extra coin so this game is one of the

tightest games I've played in terms of money management you get very few coins income at each round so you need to be making sure that you are awaiting your bids exactly right and not open spending because um you know if you don't end up acquiring cars you're going to follow behind of course but if you're spending too much money then you're going to be left with the dregs and just not have enough kind of cash in the bank to uh to get what you want um the game does maybe go on a little bit longer than I would like but to be fair I have most recently played five players works perfectly fine at that but be prepared for it to maybe drag on maybe a little bit beyond that 90 minute Mark but three to four players this one works like a dream it scales well from that you know I don't want to um not recommend it at five because it does work really well at five but again it does take a little bit longer again tons of strategies to go down uh that queuing system is amazing and there really isn't much I dislike about this game at all so you know I have a lot of auction and bidding games in my collection and only one game I've seen before using that queuing system like kind of a chicken mechanism before and that game is sperium which happens to be another game I love so both times I've seen that mechanism I've seen it used to a very high standard and um yeah I absolutely love it I think it's so so cool and it does feel extremely tense um you know shall I shall I gamble I hope that my opponent won't pay that coin so that I can get it for one cheaper um but of course they're gonna get a first refusal to do it so this one is

not considered one of the best Stephen fell games but I actually think it's a very strong one and that's saying a lot for me because I generally like all the all of his games it feels slightly different but it definitely does have that stepping build flare to it um and yeah I'm completely in love with jorvig so this one's definitely going to get a accommodation from me and I highly recommend it so there we go that concludes the video hopefully you have enjoyed it um you know three different opinions here Sierra West I'd give a hard pass Elysium soft recommendation to the right person and jorvik a straight up recommendation but if you have found the video useful then please do hit like And subscribe to my channel and for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman or the board bye-bye

Progress saved