Skip to main content
Loading video...

Nucleum Roundtable Review - Friendly Ties Podcast

Transcript 1:05:26

hello there and welcome back to Friendly ties today we are going to be talking about nucleum guys yeah nucleum so here we are we're going to talk about this wonderfully heavy-ish new Euro release the problem with me introducing this episode is that I there's so much going on in this game and I cannot seem to capture it succinctly someone asked me to describe it the other day and it took me like 10 minutes so uh one of you oh and I'm a little bit sick so one of you needs to uh kind of give our listeners the overview of the game all right I'm gonna pick up that ball actually I'm gonna start this off with a disclaimer I that's Jonathan Cox made a sponsored video for this one so I'm going to be giving lots of opinions in this episode but just know I was paid by the people who made this game to make a video but I was not paid to make this so with that out of the way I've really enjoyed this game and it is I guess about a alternate history Europe in the 1800s where nuclear reactors were developed you know 100 years earlier or whatever and realistically this is a game about constructing buildings uh connecting power plants making mines for Uranium shooting energy all over the place just powering up a grid essentially and it's

uh the backbone of the game is action selection with a hand building type thing with little dominoes and a hundred other things but that's like the general idea is um is you know activating these options you have in your hand and and I guess one of the core mechanical things is when you put a domino down you can either use it in the future or you could permanently lose it as track that's like the first thing that really jumped out to me yeah the designers I I think said that it was sort of a marriage between brass and barrage or at least those were like a big part of their influence in the design of the game and you can certainly see that lineage there it looks like a network game but actually in a lot of ways I think it's more of like a heavy Euro with the the Domino tiles and the the actions that they're doing on them and like managing essentially your like cycle of taking those actions collecting them back up because it's got the like the Concordia thing right the Tribune is Anastasia calls it yeah forever yep any game where you pull your towels back stodfest and then you know there's that yeah yeah right points if you know what game I'm talking about in the comments so I we we've played this a decent chunk of times in a short period of time it's not a short game it really we've played the first round of it and John was like yeah I think it'll get better when we like know the rules a little bit and then Anastasia and I jammed a bunch of two-player games and we came back and we played another three-player game and it did not get

shorter once we all understood so for context I've played it three players all the way through twice and both those games were about three hours um and yeah the first time I played it with Nick and Anastasia I taught it to them uh which took I'll be honest about an hour I probably could have done it quicker but there's a lot going on in this game uh and then we proceeded to play it for about two plus hours and we just ran out of time it was just like we're gonna get back to this we never did we ended up playing the game a bunch more times but uh we never actually finished that first play because it went so long and uh that is definitely need something to consider right the two-player game Anastasia and I just played last night came in at right around two hours but that was like your fifth game right Anastasia so it's like you know much of a decrease in play time now no and when you know the when you were talking Nick was saying we jammed a couple two-player games I think we played like three in a row over like the course of a week and one of them I know we we had to like split up multiple times because we kept kind of running out of time and by the third one I was like well this is gonna definitely be 90 no it was the longest of all of them so I just this is not a game I think that gets shorter maybe with you know a ton of time but there is so much to think about in this game and that that is such a big piece of it um but before we kind of dive into all of that I want to go back to something real quick so we talked about the designers of this game it's um David turkey and Simon Luciano

and both of those known for a variety of games um one of which I think it's important that I know is Grand Austria Hotel less than 10 minutes and we have the first Grand Austria Hotel reference that reference out of the way here um because there is almost nothing that this game reminds me of for Grand National Hotel so I really had to just like hedge that in there except for except for how Innovative it felt to me after my first play and that really is the only lineage that that I see from those games but it is something that I took away after that that first half a game I was like oh there's a lot of these really cool interesting mechanics that feel both very familiar but also done very differently combined differently here in a way for me that was just like really exciting and really addictive and I was just like oh this is really cool I want to keep playing this you know it's very rare for me to read a rule book because I have John in my life and I was like I want to go read the rules just because I don't have the opportunity to play tonight and I want to I just want to feel that the game around me so so it is definitely one of those games it's just interesting unique you want to explore it and you want to get deeper into it and I'm sure we're going to talk a lot about why it was like a brain worm for you it was yeah it really worked it like invaded my space and thankfully Nick helped me work that out a number of times well it was it was a two-way street

right because I my favorite part about this game is is the exploration of it understanding how the different systems worked I was like okay cool like let's let's peel on this like let's see how this can work the first game that we played that we didn't even finish Anastasia and I were talking about I was like I'm pretty sure if we ended the game right now I would win but if the game continued like it's supposed to I would be very very far behind and I want to like tease out why that's the case because it's not an engine building game like in fact the game does a really nice job I mean this is something I respect about a lot of more modern designs of of challenging you to do something of value early on you do get a little bit better at things as you kind of like establish more turbines and uranium but for the most part like what you are doing is very similar from beginning to end you might be able to do more of it later on but uh not there's not a big scope change as the the course of the the game goes on which means that even from the beginning what you're doing really matters in fact actually I would I would argue that what you're doing right at the beginning matters most because that's when the game is tightest yeah that makes sense I mean it's it's a a big map with a bunch of cities and possible rail connections between them and much like brass which was mentioned earlier the very first time you put something on the board you can go anywhere the second time you put something on the board you are restricted by where you went the first

time you put something on the board and that's not always the case there is a lot of intricacies to that part of the game but yeah within reason I think it's a huge asterisk on that right anywhere at a high level like that first decision like on probably your first second or maybe third turn really matters like what part of the board am I going to be interacting with a lot in the early stages of this game yeah but there is something really interesting you said there Nick because at a very high level it's a phrase that John Lewis to use I can't laugh guys there's no laughter for the rest of this podcast no laughter at a very high level you've got a map that you're playing on you are building things what are like the five actions we can just give people like a sense of like what you're kind of doing here so you've got you've got to pick a build action you've got what is that actually called so you have you have urbanized yeah I read that rule book but you know none of it stuck so the five central actions uh is uh urbanize which is putting down buildings that are not energized and you energize them by flipping and that gives you points in a variety of ways uh there's urbanize which lets you construct turbines and uranium mines which help you energize the aforementioned buildings there's developer no no you said urbanized twice dude urbanized is is wrong on my video too turbines and mines which makes you better at the next action which is energizing energizing yes there we go

easy to flip the buildings over okay okay hold on let's just do it my way okay you can build like building things right you can build mines and uh turbines which is a completely separate action also known as industrialize then you can energize the buildings that you build and in order to energize you use the aforementioned mines and turbines right right that's the kind of the primary Loop yes and then the two other things hang out sort of by themselves there's contracts right and we basically report the contracts yep one nice thing is you can take contracts put them down they give you a little benefit when you put them down so that's a little bit of a resource generation and then of course you know you complete those and then yeah get new tiles and then your action tiles those are The Dominoes that John was referring to earlier they are double not double-sided double topped and bottom they have a top and a bottom two actions per tile different colors on the top and bottom and the way that they work and this is probably what the thing when I was talking about Innovative the thing that was coolest to me because I actually don't really I'm always a little hesitant with games where you have like multi-use cards multi Styles there's games that do it super great and there's games where it's just too much thinking for me yeah and I actually think this does it does it pretty well because it's when and how you want to play some as interesting so you can either place them at top on the top of your board or you use the tiles as railings which means you essentially get rid of them and never get them back yeah and if you place the tiles on top

of your board the colors don't matter you get to do both actions and then you also get to complete contracts and then that top of your board is also your income track so you want to place tiles up there but then you have this choice right you can play them out on the board it's that's it you don't get to use them anymore they go away but then that's where the colors do matter and that and that's essentially every turn is you know is play a tile on the map or in front of you and then do those actions that we just listed out yeah yeah and the color matching on the map is is uh it's a moment of interaction too because other people can put their tracks next to your tracks and if they color match the track that you put down already that's the moment you get to do the action but then they also get to do an action but maybe they put a clashing tile down so that neither of you get a bonus action there's like potentially some interactions there and now that we've described the entire game I can't remember for the life of me what we were talking about before I interjected with that high level overview well that's okay because I actually want to talk since we just brought it up about the action dominoes it's my favorite part of the game I don't know if it's an innovation or if State I mean I'll call it Innovation sure it's it's my favorite part of the game I think that it's a it's a very clever way of doing actions in a game so it's you know like we said there's these kind of five core actions but these Domino tiles they might have a mix and match of those five core actions those five core actions might have a discount or a perk associated with them or these Domino tiles might have a little benefit on them a one-time

resource bonus or an income boost which makes for roughly a gazillion different types of action and Domino tiles and so while everybody's playing the same core actions your choices of What two actions or action and benefit um that you get on your turn are different for every player different throughout the course of the game and when you're deciding to do that linking thing which is essential for creating networks and for teleporting to places where you want to be able to play things you are essentially sacrificing I will not be able to do this action again after my next Tribune right after my next pickup because I've lost this piece permanently and the push and pull between those decisions are is very juicy it's easily my favorite part of the game I'm most impressed by the the very very wide decision space that is made with you know frankly two sides of a tile that are doing at its core five different actions yeah and it also is the thing that leads to the absolute most element of AP in this game yeah when to sacrifice them when to play them where to play them how to play them um the colors obviously matter if you're playing on the map if you want if you're playing them in front of you or you're going to have the right tile to play on the mat you know like it's just everything that Nick said is a hundred percent true I couldn't agree more I I I sign off on that and agree with it all

day long and you can spend a ridiculous amount of time sitting there trying to think that through I mean we played one of our two player games we had to like break it up I don't remember why and I like remember opening the game and I just like I stared at my town this is the end and I stared at my tiles for an hour I swear just like working out which way I wanted to play them and if he could screw me up and how I would like play them out was the most I mean this game at its core it's not an engine builder it is a a efficiency uh maximizing efficiency what's like what's the term for that I don't know totally yeah no efficiency it's an efficiency system I agree with you yeah yeah it's also like a slow rolling combo game it was like unlike a lot of modern Euros where you take a turn and you do this into this into this into this into this that can't happen very occasionally in this game usually it's more like this into that and then you're done it's this is more like lots of little turns like I do this so the next one yeah so the next turn I can do that so the next one I can do that yep don't get me wrong that hour was like one of the funnest hours I had like I was just like I was like loving it because there was nobody yeah you're just like this yeah it was it was like literally what I thought I was like this is like doing a crossword puzzle like it's just like sitting there I don't even like crossword puzzles but it's because this this is what I would rather do than a crossword puzzle like I was just like it was so much fun but it just shows you how much you can think and that's actually one of the critiques

I think all of us have about this game is that you know when you're playing with others obviously you're not going to do that but you you can get kind of caught up in how and when to play your tiles and that that isn't necessarily it doesn't happen at the same time for everyone so there's there can be a bit of this fits and starts where you know it's pretty easy for you like I'm gonna do these couple of things I kind of see it but your opponent or opponents might be kind of like log jammed with kind of where they are and they're going to need some time to think and that can kind of create for a little bit of a lot of downtime in this in this game yeah uh Anastasia and I just played a two-player game last night there are definitely lots of moments where I felt that guilt creeping in again this is not a game about making humongous stacks of combos but occasionally the stars align and it was like I was doing my turn I'm like oh wait I also do this oh wait I also do that and then the last of those things involved taking a tile and putting it down onto the board as a track and I had not even been considering that so suddenly I was like I don't know where am I actually gonna put this and yeah I mean I don't think it actually annoyed Anastasia but I was feeling guilty about the the probably several minutes that that one particular turn did take and the whole time that was happening Anastasia already had her like next six turns plotted out so so like I finished and then she went and it was my turn like literally 15 seconds later well this game goes in lurches because you know a lot of things are little steps towards the big plan to me

actually the the biggest source of of AP in this game is that you're you're tight on everything you're tight on money you're tight on workers you're tight on energy uh and you need to make sure that you build the thing to set up the resources to then connect those resources to then flip your tile over and particularly in the early part of the game where you're a little bit poorer you can't screw up a step or you don't get to do the thing and so you know at its at its worst points you are playing where you have already figured out what those steps are and you are just executing the process because the process is is perfect there's no other way for you to do it and then the other players are at the stage of the game where they are trying to figure out what their next sequence of actions is where they won't end up screwing up everything and not being able to execute what they want to do so the game plays in lurches where it's like you're gonna have some turns where you're sitting there thinking for a while because I can't just build this right now because I decide where it goes how much like am I building a building with a lot of energy requirements low energy requirements like you can't just sort of Play It by feel like you have to know what the follow-up is going to be to what you're doing but then when you figure that out your follow-up is like bam bam bam yeah yeah and that's basically I mean you Nick had kind of

pointed out in our three player game that he had been in a position at some point where you had a bunch of tiles and you kind of knew exactly what you're doing and Nick I was in that position just described last night where I was like literally just organizing my tiles into the perfect like little sequence I was like and then I realized I was like oh this is six turns like John is still on one turn and this is literally six and he can take as long to think as he wants I'm not like that but it just it was that kind of realization and you know I want to kind of circle onto something you just said there Nick which is I almost want to say like a warning like I wanna I want like for those of you listening to this and you want to play this game I mean it is a great game and this is like nope spoilers for me like I really loved it it's probably my favorite game of the year and and yet I'm gonna also kind of put this kind of headline out there that this is a game where everybody really really needs to know what is going on you really need to know what is going on you really need to be aware of the little rules they're not a crazy amount of little rules but there are enough the tiles are small the values of the buildings are different the you we haven't even talked about this but you have your own board with its own technology tiles and they're just you know there are a lot of intricacies and you really need to understand that that the networks in this game the rulebook doesn't do the best job of explaining how they work they're rather confusing it can be very easy to think you're connected when you're not connected or you are connected for the purposes of energy but you're not connected for the purposes of scoring and all of these little elements that

are at play because we had a moment in our three-player game where we got to the end of game we've been playing for about three and a half hours or three hours and change it's at the end and I'm trying to kind of just move things along so I do one of my Technologies and I I think it's a level two I don't even think twice about it or whatever I just think it doesn't matter which one I do because I just kind of want to get to the next person's turn well what I've what I was doing was about to trigger an end game condition John and Nick both paid very close attention to what I was doing and they were like they planned their turns thinking that I couldn't trigger one of the end game because it's kind of like Scythe where you know it's like you have different you know there's a couple different ways you can end the game or beyond the sun where and then if you do enough of them you know the game ends and you only get one more round and I you know my whole plan hinged on me finishing those tiles and the guys you know didn't I had done it wrong right and so we come back to my turn and I'm like I'm gonna do this and they're like you can't and it's a really uncomfortable like table moment where I'm like like one of us is going to be unhappy at the end of this three and a half hour game like one of us is gonna tank our game right like and not necessarily hopefully you can come to a cord and you know I was hoping that was just and we worked it out and it and it was okay yeah but it still happened and then unfortunately last night John and I had a very similar experience that also worked itself out but John had misread

one of his tiles and he thought it was 10 energy and it was only eight and and you know they're really small and he planned his whole game around having exactly 28 Stars which matters where you land on the Milestones track and it's this whole thing and then he's like I built the wrong building right and I'm like I assumed it was legit and it exactly it didn't look closely enough because the other ones are tens and yeah and I asked you to change and we did but we did but I scored off of his building types which is a factor in this game and I was like well then I wouldn't have built that you know it's just I don't I'm taking a little bit of time to explain this out because I want to kind of just put that out there for people that there's like a little bit of an awareness to say that like these feelings can happen and if you're not like if that is the kind of thing like we're we are very experienced Gamers we have played hundreds and hundreds thousands of hours together like we are all very very good friends and we can take it but like there's still those moments where you can walk away from the table and be like I just played for three hours and like oh that felt so like bad you know or whatever yeah and it's not even a dynamic amongst us it's just a thing that can that that that has a possibility here and so I want to just kind of put that out there because I think that you got to kind of know that going in you got to be aware that maybe it's going to take you a couple plays I played it six times now and that stall is there and so I think it's just something that you're like cool be ready and willing to allow your first few games to kind of play out that way know that you need to keep things really

tight and and be very specific or also or just play and be like cool it doesn't matter what happens you know however but that is going to increase a lot of the AP for people because of that feeling and so yeah I'll just add that you know we're for those of you who are maybe first-time listeners or something like that we're pretty retcon heavy group we play a lot of new games um you know we've got a couple folks in our group that are a little bit on the AP side so in order to keep things moving along we say hey yeah like we make a mistake like let's roll it back right like we wanna we wanna make it so that like and also you know the last thing is like for having fun right like if you are playing in a group of people and you say no no precision's really important to us I think the takeaway from this conversation is like be prepared for someone to play this game and be like wow I died I died so badly yeah like I couldn't do my thing and this game's the victory Point conditions a lot of the victory Point conditions are in um steps and like what I mean by that is there can be a very big leap in what a certain Victory Point thing does uh based on like one condition and I'm talking like upwards of like 20 25 points in a you know 200 something point game um could be because this you were you were one worker shy or something like that because the the gap between executing exactly what you meant to and something just a little bit worse than that may literally be a huge huge portion of the game yeah I mean that was

my I think the third full play but I also recorded like like I said a sponsor tutorial video so like hypothetically I should really know this game and I think I do know it pretty well but yeah we were near the end of that that game and I had misunderstood my network I thought various things were going to be scoring and connecting and they weren't and I many games in and I think this is this kind of forks off of what we said before this is a incremental combo building game over the course of many turns and and yeah you build that combo that six turn combo and then you get to the fifth or sixth turn and you realize oh shoot I did something slightly wrong in the third step and like if you do all these steps in one turn that's fine but this game spreads them out and then yeah like one person's unhappy either you're super unhappy with yourself because you just misread a card or did a math by Wrong by one or also like in that three player game we just played um a couple nights ago Nick ended it he did the final like decision to trigger the end uh and he was going back and forth for like I don't know 60 seconds or so which is a long time and Nick analysis time but when Nick says there's AP heavy people in the group he is not referring to himself exactly but you should have seen John and I smiling while he was talking that was coded for uh yeah yeah it was very nicely said I wasn't gonna snitch but yeah they know but Nick was like do I end it do I want two turns or three turns I remember he was saying that two turn three two and he decided I'm gonna go with three turns and when the dust settled on this game I I actually came third I came last but I was only a

couple points behind Nick but we realized he got like 20 points out of going that third turn I got like almost 40 points by that extra turn and it's like oh wow in retrospect probably should have done two turns instead of three even though I mean I would have just lost by more but just like from a that shelf uh step perspective thing that you were saying Nick like my end score was about 200 and that one extra turn got me almost 40 points that's 20 of my score which I actually want to highlight on for a second because when we say these scores can be like 40 points or 30 points or like all of that like these differences when we first played this game we thought oh you know the score difference is I think John's first play that he had and our first play like we were like oh these gaps they're gonna be really big well last night doubling yeah you know the three-player game that we had like the our last two-player game that I played with Nick I think I lost by two points the game we played the three-player game I think I won by two points and last night John and I tied and it is a friendly tie it was amazing but it was but that just shows you like how a single point can matter and so it's a weird thing you know that was actually a pretty low scoring game we were in the only in the 180s but or 160s um but it was it it's still like it can feel like oh I can get these final turns it seems like you're getting like 40 points or 30 points or these things but they're actually they're not very clear on how they're coming they're coming in these little 3.6 point two point here and here and here so it you know we've spent a lot of time usually we don't finish the

game and be like well if I had done this different or I had done that different you know but this can be a hard game to unpack because of how kind of as Nick was saying like little things affect little things here and there and it all kind of spirals out and he's right that we we are a really big ret Connie group and you know I was just highlighting the retcons that actually affected other people I'm not even highlighting the individual ones that I think we we've taken you know doesn't yeah we've taken twice the like time yeah yeah I would have spent this worker instead of this coin yeah let's talk about the two and three player thing because yeah again for for listeners of our podcast you know that I'm not a two-player player and uh Anastasia and John but he does it all the time well I do it all the time but like it's almost always my preference yeah when we play two player I say okay well I want to see what it feels like at four we played this two and three we've not played it four I have almost no interest in playing it for and I prefer the game at two which for me feels like a very significant statement yeah crazy crazy yeah I mean one of the reasons why Anastasia and I played last night two players I mean partly because we were both really enjoying it but also I had not played it two player at all and you two had done it a bunch and so it's like well I want to be able to speak to this thing because while we were playing that three-player game a couple days ago YouTube kept saying like this is just not as good at three and I was like okay I want to see what that difference is and the map is completely different like one side of the board is a one to two player game the other side is a three to four player game so the map is is literally completely different on the

two player side and uh one thing that kind of jumped out to me as a comparison point is underwater cities uh which is a euro game that I love that is brilliant at two very good at three and I have never and will never play it at four and I think that nucleum is pretty darn similar and just like uh in in a similar way underwater cities has a two player side of the board and then you flip it over and then there's like a three and four player side and so I feel like you know with these two heavy Euros that the amount of enjoyment that you can get can be directly affixed to the the downtime that you have because of just the number of people around the table you have to wait for I think we hit yours is underwater cities and mine is Messina 1347 which is uh you know was one of my favorite games from last year and we had similar experiences with that where two player it's just this like lovely game and fun and thinky and all of these things just like this one and then three player it's just it is it is that downtime and it is the length right like I I don't want to spend three and a half hours playing nucleum I mean I could basically play two two-player games in the time I I keep dreaming but almost um play two two player games at the same time that it that it takes to play that and I think for everything that we've said I also don't want to do that in a game where you know little mistakes can happen and I know I'm gonna AP and I don't want to take forever and I can you know I can feel that with the people around me and but I think it's funny because I know this about Nick I know he's not a big two-player gamer and I

know he tends to prefer these games that larger player counts and so it's funny because when we played it two-player I remember you know we'd only played half a game at three player and I was like I was like so excited that the two-player game I was like almost like pitching it to him I was like oh look how interactive it is Nick and like look how the how the rails I was like trying to like kind of point out all these elements that I felt like the two-player game was like capturing from this idea that I had of the three player game and then when we went and played it three player I was like yeah it did do all that and I actually think it did all of that almost better like it was almost more interactive a two-player we we've gotten each other's way more and at three player you know we we kind of at least in the game we played you know when we finished we all three of us kind of stayed to separate parts of the map and the things I thought would be slightly more interesting the rail links and these elements they just didn't quite materialize in the way that I expected to of course we don't have a ton of data to go go on but I think this really is going to be a a two-player game for me yeah let's talk about the interaction a little bit because I think that's a part of like why the two versus three and you know again I think that like we've played it enough times to have a sense of it but like we might be like not playing it the same as you know your at-home group meta and what folks are gonna look like there but um I'll I'll say that the interaction in this game did not meet my expectations from looking at the board and that's not to say that it's bad not at all um but it did not meet what I thought

was gonna happen so because it's like I knew this was this like brass barrage thing the board looks very brassy oh yeah um but the game does not really interact in a brass-like way brass lake is like brass is like very you know overlapped uh between the players and the resources and the networking and the linking and this game they said look we don't want people to do anything with each other's resources your resources or your resources Anastasia can build their sand castle and the the networking component is more about do you have do you have tickets to the VIP Club of you know this city over here that's what the networking is more for over pretty much anything else and the primary points of contention between the players then wind up being where are networks overlap for our Mega buildings how quickly we're ending the game like in a kind of a classic Euro style the you know the race towards the end of the game who's grabbing what contracts there's a couple public contracts that we're all racing for so I thought that the interaction in this game was going to be very Network board based but in fact I find that the interaction in the game is more heavily on the Euro side where racing to like XYZ thing XYZ condition or end game scoring or something like that and that's where the the push and pull between the players seems to be primarily seated yeah I would agree with

you I mean I think the other main element of interaction just is blocking you know like it it's it's sort of like negative networks I guess I don't know what the term would be for this but it's like instead of wanting to connect to each other and like take resources or even like utilize things in sort of like a friendly way like oh you kind of helped me here it's a lot of like like last night like John just like cut me off from a city and I was like okay like you know so then I couldn't connect my things and and he kept saying which I actually believe but he was like you know I didn't even intend to do that but that was the that was the result the result of it and I think that there's definitely gonna be groups maybe even us that are gonna play that especially at two players or even three players we're gonna think a little bit like more aggressively for how you're controlling areas of the map or how you're preventing opponents from doing things with your Rail lines but what I don't see a lot is that there's Point income reward opportunity for being part of the two and three um you know connection lines if you will and honestly what I saw more than anything was like that was just like a point benefit to the person that was doing it it was like cool if you're gonna put that much effort into connecting a longer link you're getting points for that or you're getting Point income that you can potentially reap back from that we didn't have as many

opportunities as I expected to be like oh I want to join in on that with you it's like that's not part of my plan that's not really worth it unless I really need to be in that City I'm just not gonna go there yeah I mean I will say that there is certainly positive uh interaction when it comes to energizing and energizing is probably ultimately how you get like 75 of your points in this game maybe maybe more uh there were at least two times last night where I put down a rail track and Anastasia said oh thank you so much uh because like one time she was like oh you just connected my my building to Coal so thanks now I now on her turn she spent coal and into the thing uh another time and I was like I'll just put my road down here she's like by the way thanks for putting your road exactly there now I can send my uranium across your road which gave you energy which lets you energize and this game is all about energizing so I think I want to talk a little bit specifically about Milestones because that's kind of a central idea to this game and I know it's one of the elements that's kind of like barrage uh beyond the Thematic connection barrage is about has anybody actually played barrage because I wanna I wanna make sure we highlight this brass barrage connection okay once uh okay so you guys have played barrage okay yes we've all played brass okay yeah and every time you trim Tribune as we said every time you pull all your stuff back you do a reset turn you push it does have a name it does it does see uh recharging you you put you cash out

all of your uh achievement and you get achievement by energizing buildings and a few other things but mostly by flipping buildings and you put your little star on a track but there are areas where you could only go once per game and so that's essentially off limits to you in the future and this track has randomized scoring tiles that are put there at the beginning of the game and depending on where your stars are on this track compared to the randomized tiles and how high you are up on the track you get multipliers so like for example last night the top one um where I put my star down because I hit 28 because Anastasia let me retcon it gave me six points for every pair of Road tiles that I put on the board and I was trying to put rode like crazy in that game when we played with Nick the three player game none of the tiles had anything to do with roads at all so we had no incentive really to go crazy with roads in the previous game but in this game when we set it up we're like oh wow roads are the most most incentivized thing on this Milestone track that's a thing to keep in mind and in order to get that start your token onto that specific spot you need to hit this window of achievement which again you get by energizing and doing all these steps like in a lot of ways putting your little token down onto that Milestone track is the end of those like six action plans of all these turns together specifically to to nail that one spot and I I think that's interesting it's cool but it's also very prone to uh failed as we talked about earlier but I do think that from a positive perspective it feels to me like it's made the games feel different I really

like the Milestones I like what they do for the setup of the game I like what they do um for the the texture of the game so that there's along this Milestone track which goes from zero to 40. um there are four different end game rewards but six different multipliers and so you know the difference between getting for instance Two achievements versus anywhere between three and six achievements is you get either the times one or the times two multiplier for that bottom condition whatever it is be it roads or turbines or mines or whatever dozens of different things they have what's cool about this is you you see the game is going to reward you for doing these things this game right like you see in that last game you get six points for every pair of rail links and as long as you can get enough achievements to get to the top of the board but particularly in that middle area you might choose to play sort of like shorter or longer I keep calling them laps but like between essentially when you start playing after your previous Tribune or recharge and your next trip unit recharge you know you might choose to push a little harder or not based on like what kind of end game condition You're Building towards and that is I think a big part of the strategy of of the game versus like the tactics that I think are gonna drive up most of your decision making in this game throughout the course of that and I think it's really neat I I like that system I'm a little surprised I haven't seen it in more games because it's just

a it's a neat way of doing a variable setup but challenging the players to own you know how to how to get that how to make that happen how to like respond to that and you don't do all four things or you're likely not to do all four things um but you're gonna do most of them yeah Nick remind me because you've played barrage more than I this is very much from barrage right this like because in in that game don't you like make energy and then cash out your energy and yeah and and go to specific goals that are randomized at the start of the game yeah but in that one I think it's like based on every round so at the end of the round like you know what your energy level is right there and then I believe it's been a little while since I've played but I believe like if you're the best that round you get another perk or something like that um and then like the sort of minimum requirements change over the course of the game in barrage that structure feels a lot more like you're playing to catch up but in this one because there's no you know you have to there's the timing is controlled by you I think it feels a lot more satisfying in in nucleum than it doesn't brush I really like how the timing is controlled by you as well like last night when I played with Anastasia I I did a recharge one more than she did in the whole game I had an extra star there I kept doing a recharge after I had like three tiles down in front of me and you kept putting like eight or nine tiles and we just yeah it is it's nice that we weren't like affixed to the games clock we had our own clock and at a certain point the clock stops but yeah

but yeah we kind of do our own our own tempo for me what this actually reminded me of uh was Carnegie and the way that you have to sort of pick your own scoring goals in Carnegie and you have to donate to achieve them and I just it's this is definitely a different way of scoring a New York games I mean it's been in other games too but it is that idea of not only are the goals there but you have to you have to set them out you're not just going to score for all of these things at the end of the game and I do think that makes for a different very different way of playing in Euro games um when it came out in Carnegie actually didn't I didn't really like it and I I've gotten used to it because I think I do like a little simpler like here are your goals like just do them like and it's cool you know I don't like having to like at some point choose because you know like what if my plan doesn't work out and I like end up with a different one you know and so in this game you really do and this goes back to what Nick was saying like you have to find Value in your actions early on you can energize your buildings kind of whenever you want as long as you do it and so you have to time that to make sure you're in the right scoring goals when you need to and again you don't want to like over energize and be like oh I should have waited for the next cycle to stack all these together and the way that track works are some benefits to being the first one in an area and all of that it it creates I think just like to Nick's point just something really interesting and really Dynamic I'll I'll just add on that like like I said I like the Milestones but my complaint about the Milestones is that those end game goals

are not terribly inspiring in and of themselves like you for most of them like naturally through the course of playing the game are going to get a certain level there because this game really asks you to do more or less a little bit of everything and that's okay so essentially The Edge that you're trying to get is oh okay I'm leaning a little heavier on residential this game because I see at the top of the track they're rewarding residential buildings but it's unlikely that you're then just gonna ignore everything else in the game like you still have to do that stuff and in fact to me the most boring goal was the one we played I think in our first or second two player game that was like turbines and turbines are just I think they're they're like essential in this game um so as you're building them it's like oh okay well I'm getting rewarded for them great like that's perfect every single time you play this game you're just like oh they happen to be worth more in this game yeah before we go talk about uh the end is coming the end game here but let's talk about those turbines for a quick second yes I was wondering when we're gonna get to this yeah so you know I'm gonna let Nick Nick take this one the short version is that the level three turbine is op I haven't played this game enough to like be here and you know rage posting about how like I know better than the game designers who I'm sure I've played tested the like crap out of this game but it it has it feels to me like the

turbine that gives you two free energy on every recharge is essential towards playing the game I'm sure that someone smarter is going to get in the comments and tell me how I'm wrong about that but every single game we've played we've done that and the ones where I haven't done that I felt like I've been playing catch-up all game long yeah and I just I don't like I don't like that because it's not that particular turbine it's not obvious that it should be that way um but now we've just kind of like slotted into like oh yeah you built this every time it could be our group link but but yeah it could be our group thing I I do acknowledge that last night we were playing the two-player game and I was a little like well dang it here I go building the level three turbine first like I almost wanted to not do it to like try and have a Counterpoint but it just was so good in that moment but you felt like you had to yeah because the thing is the map kind of makes it that way right like it was like all the mines are in a section that aren't connected anything else and so it was going to take a while to get nucleum online and so you you don't want to build mines and the level that turbine gives you two free energy which is essentially free like it lets you build all your low-level buildings depending on how much you're spending on coal you don't even need to be connected to the coal yeah exactly I think part of the reason that it actually sticks is is what you said Anastasia is that building a mine early functionally doesn't work you have to do too much work work to connect the mind to the rest of your

network to make it do a thing whereas the turbines sit directly on the places where you want to be building where you can even like put Urban buildings pretty much like right on those spaces so you know the game kind of pushes you in that direction but it feels like you should be able to do something with Minds at the beginning or even it feels like you should be able to run stuff with just coal at the beginning but you're so choked on cash that it's pretty hard to do that like you can flip something really poultry but it's it's just it's just it just seems so hard it's too shiny and since since we're in the um the strategy portion of the podcast I apologize if you haven't played nucleum you know this this little section you could skip over and come back to you when you played it five times but I want to ask you guys something which is has to do with this so the level four turbine there's there's basically multiple ways on your board that unlock these Technologies so look I'm going to talk about the technology real quick don't skip yet so we each have there's four different unique factions or people or boards whatever system whatever thingies that you play on and you know they each have their own technology track and each of those Technologies level one two and three and we could get into those and they all do different things one of them is your individual end game scoring which you do need to turn online that is one of two level threes that you have and then your other level three is a is just a really cool power that is again unique to you and then the level ones and level twos have

we've kind of gone through them and we we have opinions on what's strong a lot of things that are easily forgotten but are also super important yeah yeah have lots of benefits and you know actually really add into the variability of this game in the way that you play because that is where you create your I'm gonna call it an engine Nick don't roll your eyes but um you know you have elements where like you know maybe you have things that benefit you when you play rail tiles so you know you get both of those online and then you're getting stars and money for rail tiles and then this is happening and like you've got a turbine that rewards you and so you're starting you find ways to get your resource generation to come from your board based on kind of like how you utilize this technology but the ways in which you activate this technology come from a couple of places but primarily they come from contracts that you complete and from the Milestone track that we were talking about for the level three technology and then the turbine you know the fourth level turbine for the level three technology and the other way is from uh the science buildings there's one of those three building types so there's a lot of ways which is good for you to do the same thing but one of the things that I've run into and I'm curious what you guys think about this is that I start to feel like as you get to the end game you start to like you've already activated maybe all the technology that you want to activate or you start to get to a point where you're like okay I just worked really hard to activate this level three technology but wait I've already activated a level three technology from these two other places like I don't even need this reward anymore so you get to the point

where like the rewards almost become inconsequential to the cost that it is and I understand that this is a timing game but I found myself at multiple points being like I don't need another level two Tech or I don't need another or I've done them all or I don't care or whatever and I I just had to pay a bunch of money or do a bunch of stuff and it's this this reward just feels like now and and I I don't normally feel that with rewards and games so I thought it was an interesting kind of takeaway I'm with you I suspect that this is a reflection of maybe me being bad really just not not experienced enough but like yeah I agree that the journey to get to the Technologies puts you so far into the game you're like oh I'm gonna I'm gonna unlock this level three one or even just this level two one and then I'm gonna make my game plan off of that but by the time I've executed that we're like two-thirds of the way into the game like I'm getting just a couple benefits from this at this point but it's not it's not shaping my game plan in the way that I've been like trained by many other Euros to like be like ah I get this technology tile and then I'm gonna press that button over and over and over again that's not really the vibe I've gotten from this game I am very curious from people who are more experienced or if they just had this with like certain play testers who like jammed them so quickly that it like kind of broke the game so they had to like slow them down a little bit uh because yeah I I definitely feel the same I see where you're coming from uh I generally in my

very tiny data set have gotten the the benefits that I need out of these things you know last night I completed 11 contracts which is awesome and I uh I hit the you know I finished all my technologies that was one of the end game triggers uh and I I don't think I wasted any technology gains that I would have had yeah I guess that's true they do drop down see and then if you complete them all you get an endgame trigger and you get points so I guess there is some rollback on that yeah and I think that's part of what's digging into the game like I've very quickly realized as we've played that I'm like oh these star ones are like super powerful because I don't I basically just make free stars and like how convenient is that like if I can just get that going and so like some of them are deceptively good we used to say that there was one that you know just kind of gives you an extra turbine and last night I sure needed that turbine and I really wish that I had activated that Tech and so you know there there are these elements and I really don't want to disparage the text because I think they're one of the things that make the game you know they're my second favorite thing after the actual like Domino tiles the actual you know kind of action selection of the game and I do think they create for interest seen ways to play based on like what you bring online and what you don't but I guess this kind of brings us to the one thing that we all kind of felt in our last two games this is the the end of the game comes speeding in here which is this idea of like you're you're playing a two-hour game or a three hour game and you're doing all of these things you're getting your technology online you're building your buildings you're doing all this stuff and then the end game shows up and you feel like Suddenly It's like oh I

have two more turns oh yeah it's over and you're just like what and that's not been the case in every play um some plays I felt like I got to accomplish everything I wanted to do but it has been an interesting dynamic in our last two games that we all felt like hey I I didn't even feel like I kind of got myself online even though we've been playing for two hours or three hours um uh you know and now the game is basically over and I'm gonna spit we're gonna spend the last 30 minutes of the game basically panic game that someone is going to end it and it's going to be over and you know getting your guys's hot takes on that yeah it does come at you so first of all this game can't be longer so the fact that it comes at you fast is essential yeah I think I I've thought about this because it's like how can a game take three and a half hours to play and then have me be like oh my God the end of the game is coming yeah I think I think the reason that it has that feeling to it is because the game asks you to do so much to accomplish the things that you accomplish you have to A to B to C like you have to like set up the urban things put the links have the minds that's got to be connected you need to make sure you have the resources I think there is so much asked of you to accomplish a thing which is I think part of the puzzle part of the satisfaction part of the fun but because there is so much there you only get to do that Loop a couple of times before the game is over because the game could not be longer it does it does really feel like you just

you kind of get there and it this game is very much like the journey is more the point than the actual like system as it were I think that in general that's a pretty good from a game design perspective you don't want a game to overstay its welcome but it this game does distinctly have a hi I'm here we're done with the end so while it is a noticeable feeling I wouldn't want the game to be more that makes sense I think part of the reason it's it's a surprising at least the first couple times you play is because the game end is triggered once two of the triggers there's like five triggers to go with um have happened in the three in the two player game it's actually three out of the five and you're like that's a lot of triggers like a lot of end game Euro games are like this one thing will cause the end of the game and you're like no no it's yeah two or three but the game I think has been balanced pretty well so smash all these at the same exact time it seems like generally they're all approaching at about the same time I mean last night Anastasia triggered the end of the game I think technically on accident like you didn't know you I didn't want to yeah like yeah I was like can I do anything to not trigger that I'm gonna go out of my way to try and not trigger that I had hit one of the three triggers and I was gonna hit the second trigger on my next turn but we still needed the third trigger and it looked like we were gonna be a few rounds away but Anastasia had more points than me in fact technically to get into minutia she had 67 points and actually hit the other trigger which

gives three points every time you hit a trigger and what are the triggers is getting 70 points if she had one less point the game would have actually probably gone on like maybe even two more rounds because I wasn't exactly like necessarily ready but it was just like she did this and I'm like oh wait that gets you three points oh wait that that ends it

deciding to go with it um and uh and we tied so I mean who knows if that was a good decision or not I'm not actually sure I don't know but either way I think it just rushes up to you because they do coalesce like that and things do get kind of more explosive and whatnot so I really like this game yeah like we've talked a lot I don't know if we've been overly negative um like we all have kind of different Vibes on this game I mean I made this my my game of the month a month ago on John gets games like I that was after one play and now I played it uh two and a half more times I I really enjoy the experience of it I really I loved our two player game last night the three-player game was a lot of fun as well although I'll admit I like the two hours more than the three hours uh from a general length perspective and I like that it issues a lot of the modern Euro comboiness or at least I like how it spreads it out even though that can lend the game towards some errors and whatnot like we've belabored I do think I I kind of prefer like the little turns kind of stacking things up and occasionally having something explosive as opposed to explosions happen all the time I do think that I wish the networking had been figured out better I think I joked at one point that like the network rules are the the paragraph that launched a thousand Board Game Geek posts you know like every day it feels like there's a new BGG but how networking works and I think that's uh you know kind of a emblematic of of a

lot of the game like there's a lot of really cool ideas I really enjoy a lot of this in fact I enjoy the game in general a lot but there's just a lot of sharp edges that you can get caught up on from a rules understanding perspective from just a remembering perspective and I don't know I I think I'm not sure where I land like this is not a 10 out of 10 game for me it's probably an eight or a nine it's probably an eight it might shift up to a nine I don't know I kind of got to play it a little bit more but I do personally want to play this one more specifically at two players um because I think that did seem like kind of The Shining spot for me and I'm really glad I got to introduce it to you too because I was talking about it for like a week because I was building the video and stuff I was like you guys this is this a pretty cool game that I'm working on you guys we should play this so I I'm I'm happy that I kind of invested all that time to teach it to you and actually get all these plays in yeah I mean Anastasia I think straight up said it was one of her favorite games of the year if not her favorite new game of the year yeah for me I'm I'm probably the lowest on the three of us about it like I I really liked pulling it apart but I'm not chomping at the bit what I liked was learning it what I liked was figuring out like how these things interact with each other I think that the game system is very satisfying like I said earlier in this podcast like the Domino tile action thing the Milestone achievements are designs that I really like I think they're super elegant super clever all of it together is has just like enough enough like whiffs for me that uh that make it so

that I'm not going to be playing this game a whole ton but I have loved playing it I'm not sure that I'd want to teach it to someone else but I would happily play with the two of you yeah yeah like well while we're here I guess yeah yeah is that because you don't actually want to teach it or because you don't want to go through the experience of someone new like learning it and having to kind of like make the mistakes that are going to be inherent with those first few plays it's more the it's more the latter it's the fact that like when I I feel like if I'm gonna sit down and play this with someone I feel like in order for them to have a good time I I would have to like hold their hand like when I think back to that first three player game that we played I like wish that that John had held my hand more you know like and so that that's it just makes so that it's like okay well so not only is it the teach but really the whole first game essentially is is kind of this like experience so that's why I'm not I'm not a lot of my friends are like not at the like level of heavy Gamers that the three of us are so I don't it's it's like unlikely that they would be willing to like be like go through that whole process and then be like cool let's play it a second time so that we can play it for our first time for real yeah yeah I think you know I I could John

I'm kind of waiting this year for a game to come out and and and excite me in the way that this game did you know it's like I always forget you know that that in the fall uh new games come out and and take me over you know I'll kind of go and be like oh you know I haven't played anything like really fun new in a while and then like here we go right and like I wasn't M like still I was very excited to play this I was like chomping on the bit all week I was like can we can we find a time can we do this can we play it more like I just want to explore I just want to go through it and I think that like I'm like so glad that I did like because it it has just been such a joy and it's been so fun I think that this game though is gonna you know if you listen to our Carnegie podcast I think I feel very similarly about it and that's probably the last time that I played a game as much I could play that game more because it was on BGA but yeah you know that I kind of did that similarly which is kind of like addicted um to kind of exploring the game and I think it falls in a similar place for me which is like if you've got a game group and you all get this game and you learn it together and you play it together and you played a bunch together you're gonna have a great time you're gonna have a great time going through it you're gonna have a great time learning it but if one of you knows it really well it is gonna create sort of a different vibe because you're not going to want to take away that exploration from you know the new players because part of it is figuring out the game but then it's also hard to be the player that knows it because like not dissimilar to Carnegie you know it it kind of creates like a different vibe when you know the game really well you're gonna play it differently you

know and that's a different situation because of the way that game is played but it's still a similar element here at play just in terms of mostly that retconing we're talking about the mistakes that are going to get made the little places that are going to happen and how difficult it will be if you're in a situation you don't have the right resources and you don't have the right things and like how is that all gonna work out but I I just want to say that if you're going to take a game like I think anything this complex that takes this big of a swing and I like I really want to complement the designers for how big of a swing I feel like they took here they've created what I know is like rated like a 3.86 or something on BGG right now but like it doesn't actually feel that heavy to me this game reminds me so much of how I felt about Arc Nova the first time which is like once you learn it it just makes a lot of sense like it just kind of like gels this is a similar game there's a lot of elements that are both familiar but are not common to the way we normally play Euro games like here are your goals and here it's like it's not like that it's like here are goal options that you can choose that have multipliers and this happens and here are your tiles it's just it's a lot to think about but it has a lot of I'm gonna go back to that word Innovative interesting Innovative elements and I think anytime someone does that and puts a bold game out like this it's gonna have certain elements that you're gonna like and you're not gonna like and you're gonna you know are gonna be this and they're gonna be that and I think that you know it's been a while since a game generated this much discussion in our Discord and like all kinds of stuff like that and it doesn't

matter if there's like little negative points or little that like this is a game you should explore if it sounds like your kind of game like play it love it hate it whatever I think it's fun and interesting and you're gonna have a great time with it even if it you know only lasts five games for you like it did for Nick and you're like cool like that's great that's got that can be plenty of of life for a game really well said yeah I think that the exploration has been fun right even though I'm the lowest on it I don't play a game five times that takes two to four hours to play yeah you could have decided you were done several games put prior yeah right yeah yeah yeah you know I do want to just as a last point just mention that like do you think the brass and barrage element is a little bit a little bit of a marketing grab there I haven't played barrage it's really not like brass it's just not and in fact for me it's better than brass I'm not gonna play Brass at two players I don't like brass of two players like I'd rather play this so you know if that's an element for you like this is a much better two-player game than brass I don't like the people take my stuff in brass nobody takes my stuff in this game so you know those are elements brass is a great game but it's a different game this game feels more like Concordia to me and it's not like that at all it's just it feels new and different and fresh it has lots of little elements and so I just kind of wanted to add that in as a as a it but you know it's a great game so check it out well I think that's going to wrap up everything we have to say today about nucleum it'll be curious to see you know where this one lives uh for us in a

couple of months and if it comes back or you know if we if we have to do a revision podcast in a year because we played it so much we'll see but it has been very fun to explore with you guys and if you guys check it out we would really love to hear any comments feedback are you excited about it have you played it what do you think you know tell us that because we've really enjoyed discussing this one amongst us and we would be happy and love to discuss it more with you guys so please go to the YouTube version of this podcast on the John gets games YouTube channel there will be a link in the description leave us a comment let us know what you think or just tell us you love us I like reading those too um and uh we'll be back I don't know when but there's lots of games coming from us and John is going to Essen so he's gonna bring back lots of games hopefully we'll get some of those played and you'll hear from us a bit more before the end of the year yeah exciting stuff thanks guys bye

Progress saved