Skip to main content
Loading video...

KeyForge | Dark Tidings SET REVIEW

Transcript 55:50

hey fellow key foragers i'm carlo from all you can board and today i'm going to be doing a set deep dive and review on dark tidings which is the fifth and newest set from key forge so we're going to be talking about um the evil twin decks um the new mechanics that come into this uh with the tide and how chains kind of come back in um there's also a new house the unfathomable so we're gonna talk about that we're gonna do a deep dive on some of the unfathomable cards i've come across um in my playing over the past few weeks and then we're also gonna look at some of the cards from all the other houses and then i'm gonna end by giving you kind of my overall thoughts on the set how i think it ranks and uh kind of matches up against the other sets and how it is just for the the game of key forge overall so stick around we're going to do this all in depth one at a time starting with evil twin decks so previously when they you know announced this kind of this is this is the big kind of you know every set kind of has these like chase cards or something that you know incentivizes you to go buy more packs thinking you're going to hopefully get these really cool cards or something unique you know there's been anomaly cards in previous sets uh and all kinds of stuff like that so in here we've got evil twin decks uh previously i thought these were a lot more rare i bought i think i bought three decks at first with dark tidings didn't get any and then i bought a couple more recently and i was lucky enough to get an evil twin deck actually so um basically the idea is that you know this is a unique card game you're supposed to have a unique deck but every once in a while there's going to be in dark tidings these evil twin decks where there's basically uh the same deck list but some of the cards in there will be will have an evil twin version which is

basically it'll have a card of the same name and usually some of the same stats or effects but something will be twisted a little bit um usually it's like it has some really good thing but something offsets it or it's just changing the mechanics a little bit um my evil twin deck that i got only had five uh evil twin cards in it um some of them we're going to get a look at as i go through the set um the set or the cards for each of the houses a bit later on so we will look at them overall i found that from what i've read online just looking through like the key forge subreddit and some of the other community resources out there and just from the decks that i myself have bought as well as a couple friends of mine we it seems to be kind of somewhere in the 1 in 10 1 and 20 kind of range maybe um again between a friend of mine and myself we've had the one deck out of maybe 10 or 12 we've opened and i've seen other people online say they bought a box of 12 and they got two or three evil twin decks some people need to you know sometimes open 20 25 before they get to one so that's what the range we're looking at not quite as rare as i thought i also thought they were going to be i thought they were going to be maybe i thought there's going to be more evil twin cards in them or that there would be more i don't want to downplay them too much i mean i don't want to say that i was expecting more excitement but yeah for for something that sounded so different like they were kind of going back not going back on the unique aspect because it is still a unique deck but an aspect of like almost a matching deck like a deck's counterpart out there that was the first time i think we've seen this in the game in terms of the algorithm creating a deck that you're kind of like you can be looking for something that kind of is the counterpart to your deck so uh

it's it's a really cool idea i don't you know i think they overall played it fairly safe but in a way that is still you know i'm still really happy to have the deck and as we'll see later the evil twin cards are very very cool so now let's talk about the main new thing in dark tidings and this is the tide so every dark tidings deck is going to come with one of these cards that has basically a high tide and a low tide half on it the way this works is as long as one of the two players has a dark tidings deck so we can either both have a dark titan's deck or one player can have one and one player can be playing from another set either way this tied mechanic will be in play as long as there's one dark tidings deck present and the way it works is at the start of the game the tide is neutral and some of these dark tidings cards have abilities that will say like raise the tide or lower the tide or you know if the tide is high this happens and the idea is you know again you can play these cards either raise or lower the tide but as an alternate option for yourself and also for your opponent who might not have a dark tidings deck at any point you're during your turn you can just raise the tide and gain three chains so for those who might not be familiar chains are basically um you know a handicap that you get that slows you down you know at the end of your turn if you have a chain you draw one less card so you're basically getting through your deck uh slower with this tied mechanic so by bringing this into the game um and i'm going to get a bit more in depth with my thoughts on it at the end when i when i give my overall thoughts on the set but uh it definitely slows down the game um sort of in the same way that we saw

with worlds collide with the saurians being introduced and a lot of the kind of exalt mechanics and you know trying to figure you know warding and all kinds of stuff like that so with this tied mechanic there's this aspect of you know there's this extra element to almost every turn at least when the tide cards start coming into play where you and your opponent have to sometimes think if you don't have a way a card in play that can raise the tide and swing it in your favor sometimes at the end of your turn that last decision is do i want to raise the tide and gain those three chains and sometimes you don't really know if it's worth it because you can't always like parse the information for that decision on the board if there's no cards on the board that have you know the the tied element in play then you don't know if it makes sense to raise it now because you don't know what your opponent is holding the other thing that i feel the tied mechanic does is it feels like it's it skews a bit more towards the competitive side of the game so for anyone who's seen you know we haven't done a ton of these key forged videos on the channel but i have been doing them recently and if anyone's watched you probably know by now i play keyforge more casually than than competitively um i haven't really gone to any tournament so i'm not really looking to like you know compete and try to make the world tour or anything like that i just like playing with my friends having a good time with the game and i found that the tide i think is going to create an even more of an imbalance if you're playing an experienced player against a new player so you already know in key forge that the better you know your deck the better you know you know your opponent's deck the better you know the cards in the set the better you're gonna do whether you're going into a sealed deck format or not if you can

spot cards and know kind of how strong they are or what they can do in the deck it's going to help you out and so with this tied mechanic let's say i'm able to look at my opponent's deck list and i already know just from looking oh i recognize that card okay they need the tide to be high from that i can kind of have an idea going in just from looking at someone's deck list you know how how important it's going to be for me to keep the tide in my favor and keep it low for my opponent whereas someone who's new to the game who doesn't know you know they don't recognize the cards in their deck they haven't played their deck a lot kind of thing they might not really know and if they see on the board that there's nothing that immediately affects them they might just think oh whatever it's not worth it i don't need to raise the tide not knowing that you might have a card in your hand that's like you know take really takes advantage of having the high tide so i feel like not only are you at a disadvantage if you don't know your deck as well but also just if you're newer to the game so you know that was already the case but i just feel like it widens that gap a little more so for the competitive scene um i think it's going to be really good for casual players it can be cool to kind of experiment a little bit and try it out but i think ultimately if you're a casual player and you only have like a couple decks here and there i don't think you're always going to want to play with the tide mechanic i do like that it brings chains kind of back to the forefront a little bit we saw more stuff with chains i think can call the archons at the start and some of the sets after that were a little light on stuff that would gain you chains um as a consequence for your actions and in here i i do like that dynamic it is an interesting

you know again if you're if you're okay with it slowing down the game a bit it is cool sometimes to look at the board and try and figure out like it's rewarding when you make that decision to gain the three chains and raise the tide and you see it pay off because you know it's a gamble and i've had a game with a friend the other day where we just kept stubbornly paying or gaining three chains to raise the tide gain three chains to raise the tide but looking back on it we were kind of you know looking back on the game afterwards and realized we kind of had to do that because it kept putting the pressure on the other person based on the cards that were out there and as you're going to see when we go through some of these cards sometimes the cards on the board really make it important that you have to do that but it is something that it makes the game almost all about the tide like maybe not from the very first turn until those cards are in play but once the tide is in play either with creatures or an artifact it tends to be every single turn of the game you've got this aspect of the tide lurking in the background so uh i think it's a good addition to the game i think it was a cool thing to kind of switch things up give this um set a different style of play and a different mechanism that we i mean here's the other thing we don't really know if this is going to stick around i mean unfathomable obviously isn't here just for this set i don't know if they're going to keep the tide in future sets and if so if it'll just be tight unfathomable because there are other houses that still use it so um yeah that's about it for the tide mechanic now we'll go we'll touch on that again at the very end but uh next up we are gonna look at unfathomable as a house so unfathomable has replaced this um i'll just quickly touch the three houses that are now missing from the

from dark tidings are dis mars and brobnar so uh unfathomable comes into play as a kind of a control house as a replacement to dis so they have a very kind of like slow play style they're there to kind of get in their opponent's way slow them down by exhausting their creatures or saying that their creatures don't ready they stay exhausted and there's all kinds of things where you're you know returning things to your opponent's hand making them discard things it's there's kind of elements that you see from like diss and shadows uh from previous sets um they've got their own you know obviously the whole thematic thing is they're these underwater creatures um and again they bring with them the tide they're the ones who use this tide mechanic the most so um i'm gonna go through a bunch of the unfathomable cards that i've been fortunate enough to see again just because of the pandemic and stuff i've been limited in who i can play with and how much i can play so my experience with the set is limited to the cards i've seen myself as well as played online with a friend of mine so we're gonna go through a bunch of these unfathomable cards before moving on to looking at cards from the other houses so first off um and i'm gonna focus a lot on the commons here because these are the ones that obviously come up the most often and these are the ones that are gonna kind of dictate a lot of these games and the cards that you're gonna see a lot of in this set um but i've snuck a couple rares in here every once in a while and some uncommons that i just think are really really cool cards as well so uh first up we've got uh seabringer kokoa seven power taunt and when destroyed raise the tide not much to talk about here but it's just a big body creature um again for a comment have seven power and taunt and have that ability is is really solid and you're

gonna see there's a lot of these pesky uh little creatures not only in unfathomable but in other houses so having a big uh body taunt creature next to it can be super useful uh we've got hook master four power one armor fight if the tide is high your opponent loses two um that's a great flavor text be careful what you fish for um so this is another going back to what i said about slowing your opponent down right if the tide is high your opponent loses two so you're just you know chipping away at their their amber supply getting them to uh take longer to forge keys obviously uh we've got recusal's chant next up so it's about the amber bonus icon in the corner uh play is exhaust a creature if the tide is high exhaust each creature instead so you can see the power already even if they're even if it was a first-round car there's no creatures in play you're getting the amber on its own bonuses exhaust the creature you're almost always going to be able to do this to one of your opponent's creatures and if the tide is high you know so you can play around with this too and it says you know exhaust each creature instead you could fight with some of your creatures so that you you know knock off as many of your opponent's creatures as you can and then once yours are already you know exhausted you can play this to exhaust the rest of your opponent's creatures so cool stuff for a comment i really like it next up we've got bubbles five power uh when it comes to play put an enemy creature on top of its owner's deck these are obviously just super annoying to play against i i did this to an opponent the other day and especially when they have those cards that like when they come into play they have a dis a bad effect like coming to play lose couple amber but then they have a really good destroy effect like there's that troubaroo uh for dis or whatever but again bubbles

is just another thing slowing down right a creature back on your you know enemies or opponent's deck that they have to then take another turn to get out they might not even have picked that same house so really slowing down their deck next up we've got brain drain which is an awesome common i love it this feels like you don't even i don't even understand why it needs the bonus amber icon it's already so good but you get bonus amber and when you play it look at your opponent's hand choose a card from it and put it on top of their deck amazing any card that lets you look at your opponent's hand even if you don't do anything with any of the cards after just looking at your opponent's hand is an amazing effect and when you also get to do something like this and put a card on top of their deck even better um again we're talking about the fact that you might be gaining chains along the way to raise the tide so you know your opponent might already have a five card hand then you might be doing something like this putting another card on top of their deck so people might be starting their turn with like three four cards in their hand based on stuff like brain drain i mean i guess bubbles might be giving them an extra card but uh next up we've got storm surge which is a great action card in the new set uh your opponent cannot ready cards during the ready card step of their next turn this is what i mentioned you're going to see more of these as we go along more of these cards that exhaust your opponent's cards so this is just awesome awesome awesome frigerific rod this is a staple artifact you're going to see it's probably the most common artifact in the set for unfathomable at least it's got the bonus amber and the action is exhaust the creature or artifact the ore artifact part is awesome because you can even use that like if someone's got you know gourma bomb out there that can destroy an artifact or they've got something

like lash or broken dreams that you know can stop you from being able to forge next turn you can you know take unfathomable to exhaust that to counteract whatever they're going to do on their next turn uh it also helps for just exhausting really powerful creatures so great card great card next up is omnipus this is uh one of the i would say this is one of the chase cards that people were talking about i was lucky enough to get this and it did come actually in my evil twin deck uh so omnipost is a rare eight power cannot fight when it comes to play you discard the top eight cards of your deck play each tentacled from your discard pile one at a time and the reap effect is gain one amber for each friendly tentacled so my deck i don't know if they always come with a number of them but my deck came with five of these tentacles which are just a three power skirmish and taunt and it cannot reap so once if you can get this omnipotent early and like with this type of deck if you have an omnipotence and you don't draw it in the starting hand i mean it depends on the deck i don't want to say you always want to mulligan and i'm going to do a mullet went to mulligan video at some point in the future but if you don't have omnipotent starting hand and you mulligan and get it imagine the potential of playing this and maybe even if you just get one or two of these um tentacles out that you can put them right next to the octopus now it has taunt on it and then suddenly next if you can even get one turn out of that reap effect and you've got this eight power creature uh just thematically it's really cool it's a really fun thing to play around because you're kind of always watching for it in your deck because so many of the cards come into play with it um and there's just a bit of again thinking to do with when are you gonna play this when are you gonna have you know when do

you think out of those top eight cards you're going to actually have some tentacleds in there based on what you've already gone through in your deck very cool really like this card next up we've got kaup uh you might have seen me speak about this one and are getting into key forge in 2021 video we did a little while ago this is this might be my favorite or one of my favorite at least unfathomable cards so far it's an uncommon it's a creature with two power only but an amazing ability which is your opponent cannot play more than one card of each type each turn so this reminds me kind of of those like uh discards like restaurant gunthis and control the week where you're basically locking down your opponent and limiting what they can do on their next turn um again and because you can get this next to things like sebring or kokoa which has taunt or if you are lucky enough to get it in a deck with your tentacled uh other creatures with taunt even from other houses you can protect this thing and it really sometimes once you get this out your opponent is just stuck for the next few turns only being able to play one or two cards such a powerful card um really cool yeah i and you know what kay now we're into one of my evil twin cards which is evil twin cup which i didn't think you'd get any better than kaup and at first i wasn't sure what to think of this um because the okay so it's seven power it has a negative effect which is you cannot sorry you cannot play more than one card of each type each turn so it's kind of the opposite instead of limiting your opponent it limits you but obviously it has something good to offset that which is not the seventh power but a fight slash reap ability which is discard any number of cards from your hand and for each card discarded this way

deal two power or two damage pardon me to an enemy creature so this can be really strong once you have it on the board it might limit you because again you you're limited in what cards you can play but it kind of creates this dynamic where you can reap with calp or fight and you can discard certain cards like let's say you're holding four creatures and you know that because of this evil twin cop you can only play one creature per turn you can use this reap ability and let's say discard three of those four so that you're ridding yourself with some of the creatures in your hand and then do a bunch of damage with it you know board wipe a bunch of your your enemy's stuff and then maybe next run you have a bigger variety of cards in your hands so it has crazy potential but i and i like that these evil twin cards often have like a downside or a drawback to them like this i've had games where i put this into play and then it's kind of tough or or i then want to just fight with it so it gets off the board because it's limiting me and playing cards too much and unfortunately i will say right now the other thing is i got this in the same deck as my omnipotence which once you have cope if you play omnipus that play effect where it says play any of the ten tentacles you get from the top of your deck because you only play one creature as soon as you play that omnipot that's your creature for the turn and all those tentacles will just go into your discard pile so i've got a bit of anti-synergy unfortunately with my omnipotence and evil twin cop which it's unfortunate to get the anti-synergy when you get an awesome chase card and you get an evil twin deck like that but just because of how fun they are to play i don't even care the deck doesn't have a particularly high sas score but still just a lot of fun to play with so all right so now we're gonna go through each of the houses and we're gonna look

at about probably five to ten cards for each house just to give uh give you guys a little bit of a taste of what's out there some of these i'm gonna try not to spend too much time on um but let's start with shadows so there's this common walk the plank uh it's an action if your opponent has no amber deal four damage to creature otherwise steal one pretty solid you know you know we obviously know that stealing is a very common mechanic in shadows and this is just a way that if you're not going to steal you can maybe deal some damage to a creature so not much else to say there jack guitar i really like this one and involves the tide mechanic which is cool so two power elusive that right there is already you know and it's an elephant a thief so it's very very shadows you know the low power elusive creature uh and the reap ability is deal one damage to a creature if the tide is high deal six damage to a creature instead so this is one of those ones that puts the pressure on your opponent to feel like they have to have the tide in their favor i mean especially i was playing against a friend who had a saurian deck and having this card out was just amazing because like how many of those big saurian creatures you know have like five six power and as soon as i would raise the tide i was just either picking them off or you know leaving that one or two health and so uh my opponent was just like forced to feel like he had to always keep the tide low uh for me or just get rid of jackie tar this is a common so this you're going to see a lot of this a very pesky creature uh and one that i think fits in really well for the house and just very well in the set in general for kind of adding that kind of high priority um to to raising the tide and having it in your favor next up we've got francis the economist um three power skirmish and the fight ability is each player

gains one so the first time i saw this i just thought i'm cool enough i guess like three power skirmish was good which player gains one whatever but then i realized a lot of these cards you know the one thing that sometimes stops you with shadows is when you want to steal amber and someone either just forged a key and they're at zero or you know it's early in the game and they don't have anything to steal yet so getting your francis economist to fight and gain you know you're gaining one you're gaining one for then your opponent gains one and then if you have a card that steals one you're gonna get it right back so it's just a good way to kind of set up for that and also even if you're not gonna steal it you're just putting more pressure on your opponent by getting you yourself uh by getting closer to forging a key so uh cement shoes uh it's an action gain an amber just for playing the bonus and then the ability is deal to damage the creature if this damage destroys that creature raise the tide so just another interesting thing to kind of work around here it's you know just trying to give you guys some glimpses to it like how the other houses uh cards play into the tide monte bank this is an uncommon i really like this car it doesn't have anything to do with the tide but i think it's really cool one power only and it doesn't have elusive so it's a lot easier to get rid of when it comes to play you may exalt monty bank up to two times and the action is steal one amber for each amber on monty bank so there's a bit of a risk reward you're trying to assess okay what are the odds that i'm actually going to be able to use that action on a future turn to steal these because if you come in you know if you play this card you exalt twice and those sit there and then on you know you can't use that action the same turns then your opponent

goes and if they just kill monty bank they just gain that two amber but if you can get away with that amber for even one turn and then steal two on your next turn that's a four amber swing if you can do that imagine doing it twice even if you just exalt once and then this stays out it's something that your opponent has to maybe waste a card or waste an enemy you know instead of reaping a song they might have to fight just to get rid of monty banks so it kind of sticks with that theme of having those pesky little creatures that you just need to get rid of when you're playing against shadows next up we're going to look at a really cool artifact this is a rare archons revenge it is a ship and the action is exhaust up to two friendly shadows creatures and for each creature exhausted this way steal one it can be really really powerful at first i kind of on you know i underestimated this a little bit until i actually played with it and even the first time i played with it i wasn't able to keep you know often when i went shadows those creatures already been eliminated off the board or let's say i had jack guitar and i wanted to use the reap ability to do that six damage with the tide being high so you can't always use this but at the end of the game it's like when you have your second key especially and you're just putting pressure on your opponent to every turn and especially if it's a tight game sometimes you know sometimes the correct move in key forge is you know you know you're kind of behind in terms of board presence but you just need to make that final push to like put yourself you know you you and your opponent each have two amber or sorry two keys forged and you have four or five amber each and you're just trying to put them in check to force their hand on their turn and then sometimes they do something to stop you from forging and then they put you back in check and now you think well i could get back over six to forge

but i can't stop them and you have to make that choice between slowing your opponent down and this arkon's revenge really comes into play in those late game duels where it's just a really tight finish because you can just take your turn exhaust two creatures and just steal two and if that's enough to you know deny your opponent from uh forging and then putting them back in check then the next turn they go it comes back to you you can just do the same thing again next turn if they don't get rid of your shadows creatures so very cool card very happy to see it in the set and we've only got two left here and we're going to with sea urchin and then we're gonna look at the evil twin version so the regular sea urchin is just a one power creature that has poison and it has a play effect of capture one if the tide is high steal one instead sea urchin the evil or sorry the evil twin version of sea urchin has the same power does not have poison but the playability instead is capture two and if the tide is high steal two instead so they've just increased the capabilities like they basically powered up the play um ability but you know there's no poison on it so and the artwork's even very different on them they're very cool i again going back to the evil twin thing we talked about before it's it's subtle enough that it's not gonna you know make someone feel like if they're playing against an evil twin deck that the evil twin decks like a lot better necessarily or you're not gonna you know but it but it still adds enough unique flavor and enough sort of you know that that uniqueness the game that that kind of makes keyforge what it is right even just having this card is cool uh just to have a different form of a sea urchin to be able to play that's it for shadows we're going to

move on to saurian so sorian uh first off ostracized it's an action play is lose one if you do purge a creature so not a whole lot to cover here but i don't think soria normally has a whole lot of ways of purging creatures and it's again it's per a creature it's not enemy creature or or your own so even if you have let's say a certain creature that in your deck that has like an anti-synergy that doesn't work with something or you know you want to start purging creatures of a certain house to thin out that house that you don't draw it as much you can do it on your own cards as well so it's cool to have this option for saurian because they didn't really have a lot of this from what i remember next we've got medicus lackas uh five power while the tide is high you may spend amber on friendly creatures as if it were in your pool this is kind of similar we've seen a lot of other sorian cards that have cards you know that's the whole point to an extent of the exalt mechanic is getting amber on your creatures so that if they you know die off that amber goes to your opponent but if not you can you know if if you can use it to gain uh use that amber for one of your own abilities first um we've also got faust the great which has a kind of similar thing with amber but this one is your opponent's keys cost plus one amber for each friendly creature with amber on it and when you play it you may exalt a friendly creature so again more of that risk reward that we're used to seeing with saurian i love the artwork on this fellow great by the way and i could be wrong but this one might have even been in a previous set don't don't quote me on that decadence which is an action i really like this one too these these choose one are kind of coming into play a little more so the choose one is exalt ready and use a friendly creature or move one amber from a creature to

another creature so it just gives you some flexibility nice to see especially because the car doesn't gain you any amber just for playing it um this is a really cool comment i like crushing charge destroy each creature with power 4 or lower and gain a chain i'm not sure how much sorian really needed a board wipe like this and especially because this one specifically seems to avoid hitting most if not all their creatures i can't think of i mean yeah i mean i can't think of any soaring creatures off top my head that have less than four power but um i mean you gain a chain from it but imagine playing against like yeah shadows or you know that have those low power pesky creatures even star alliance has a lot of them that are below this power um even untamed has some so this can this is one of those ones that like sometimes it might do nothing you might just discard it or just destroy one creature with it and gain the chain but other times you might like wipe an entire board so it's always good to have commons that have that you know situational aspect of sometimes they're going to be amazing other times not next up we've got reach advantage gainesville amber just for playing it and the play effect is if the tide is high a friendly creature captures three otherwise raise the tide you're gonna see a lot more of these two in the set that say do this uh if the tide is high and if it isn't then just raise the tide instead so um yeah it's good to see here's one of the few we've seen so far for sorry where the tide effect is coming into play and then i've got a couple of rares i want to talk about for saurian um i believe one of these might have been in a previous set but i could be wrong the first one here is tertiate which is an action gainzy the amber bonus just for playing it destroy one third of all enemy creatures

and one third of all friendly creatures rounding up each time it's just something about like the artwork the theme of it and everything it's not again it's one of those it's not always going to be amazing or it's not always going to be bad but i really like these situational cards that make you kind of think differently and pick when's the right time to use them and that just give you decisions that you don't always see in key forge so i really like that and the next one i'm going to go over here is endless new mary another action also gets an amber for playing it and this one is take control of an enemy creature with amber on it while under your control it belongs to house saurian i've played with this deck a couple times and i have not had a chance to make this work yet i either took advantage of the enemy creature and then it died off beforehand or i played the card and my enemy didn't or my opponent didn't have any creatures in place so still hoping to try this one out but a very very cool card there isn't a whole lot of possession type stuff in this game uh i know mars had some of it in the i think it was an age of ascension um i can't remember who i think there was another house that had a possession like take take control of an opponent oh there was a was it harlan mine lock i think for for logos there's probably a couple others there that i'm forgetting but uh yeah so that's it for saurian um i like a lot of the cards that they've added in because again they're giving them some of that tied mechanic to play with but giving them some more flavor it's not as many of the kind of you know big power similar effect creatures i think they've given them the house a little more variety and i think they're also a little less powerful and less dominant than they were in worlds collide so i like that

next we're going to talk about sanctum which uh spoiler alert i guess if you haven't seen my house rankings video for key forge but um samsung is one of my least favorite houses in the game and i think part of that is because i've had a lot of decks with sanctum and they have a similar feel across a lot of the the sets and i just find them not as interesting as some of the other houses to play but you know the change in in dark titans is what prevented them from being probably my my bottom my 10th ranked house in that rankings video because some of these cards i think have brought them back in an interesting way um that has made me actually kind of happy to have sanctum in some of these new decks again so we're not going to look at too many sanctum cards but we'll go over a few here first being an action which is called strange ordination this is basically um virtuous works light if you remember virtuous works from call the archons super straightforward the car doesn't have an ability it's just an action that gains you three amber so strange ordination gains you three amber as well but it says play only if the tide is high so keep in mind even if you don't have tied cards you can just you know gain the three chains to to raise the tide and then play this so i think it was wise to bring back you know another easy way for for sanctum to get to gain amber because they are a fairly slow house and especially with how slow you know unfathomable are and you have shadows in this uh set as well and saurian can make for some slow games i'm glad that they didn't keep sanctum just being you know and not to say that they didn't have other amber game cards in the past they did have like cleansing wave and free markets and all these but i'm glad that they've kind of kept that aspect of you know you've got these quick little boosts that you can get with uh

with gaining amber as as uh sanctum uh next we'll look at a common called marshall ewer it's a creature you're going to see a lot of for power to armor and play slash fight raise the tide so this is just going to be one of those ones that's there mostly to power your other tide cards right i mean having the two armor makes it so that you can use that fight ability and probably you know raise the tide a few times especially if you pick smart targets and you're attacking elusive creatures and things that don't have a lot of power um so really really good card and i think it's good that it doesn't just it's not one of those kind of just self-explanatory sanctum cards you put it into play and it just kind of does its own thing and works for itself like this one i like that the commons in this set for sanctum are making you there's a bit more timing and and figuring out when's the best time to use this in the best situation use it or rather than just like hey i play this and automatically does a good thing for me i know that kind of goes against what i just mentioned about strange ordination away because it's just game three amber but you still do have to figure out how and when you want to get the tide raised before you do it uh hammergram pretty straightforward just an action card deal three damage to creature and stun it uh nice to have some more stun cards in there grand melee i like a lot actually this is an action card it's a common again and destroy each creature that does not share a house with at least one of its neighbors this is one of those ones though that and especially because it's a common you're gonna this is a card that you're almost gonna want to know you're gonna remember when you're playing like when you have this on your deck list or you're playing against someone and you see it on that their decklist you almost have to play the rest of the

game keeping that in mind like oh i you know because again if you're it's a the strange creature that does not share a house at least one of its neighbors so you want to be keeping creatures next to each other that share houses that's not gonna be possible things are gonna happen you're gonna sometimes kill off a creature as high priority because you just need that thing off the board and then suddenly you didn't take into account that you have a grand melee next turn that's gonna mess with that or your opponent's playing it against you so it's a card that makes both players kind of play their whole decks uh differently and because it's a common you're going to see a lot of it so expect to see a lot of grand melee when you're playing dark tidings and expect it to be a source of not only your frustration but hopefully for your sake uh source your opponent's frustration as well uh and then i got a couple artifacts i want to talk about here for sanctum the first being red hand registry which is an uncommon it gains you the amber just for playing it uh it's a law which i'm always a fan of those thematically like proclamation 346e is one of my favorite law artifacts from a prior set and this one is after amber is stolen from you your opponent skips the forge a key step during their next turn so this is obviously i wouldn't say targeted directly against shadows but um you know obviously shadows is the host that steals from you the most so yeah i'm feeling already a sense like some of the other cards we looked at here even that were targeting low power creatures it feels like each of the houses has these things that are maybe not again maybe not specifically targeting shadows but are you know familiar enough ways you're going to see the counteract some of the power that shadows can have uh last one we're looking at for sanctum is called dry the river love this card um okay so it's just an ongoing power

each creature gains while the tide is low this creature cannot reap so it does slow the game down in some ways because again if either player wants to reap they're going to have to raise the tide first but this is a cool one that once you get this into play and i think the last time i played it against a friend with this deck i played this on the first turn so the whole game and he didn't have any way of getting rid of artifacts so the entire game we were playing with this card so the whole game every turn was always uh do i want to pay to raise the tide we just had so many chains the game took a while but it was also it felt that back and forth it was a tight like kind of slugfest um so again these a lot of these cards with the tide there are gonna slow it down they can make for some interesting matchups but it's just you know sometimes it might slow it down more than you'd like but i just thought even thematically like the artwork um i just love this card that's it for sanctum we're gonna go right into untamed uh first off looking at a creature which of the dawn if you remember which of the eye from called the archons which was a three power creature that allowed you to reap and i think it was take any card back from your discard pile or was an action card i can't remember now um now you've got witch of the dawn which is play instead of reap return a creature from your discard pile to your hand so which of the eyes sometimes wouldn't trigger because it was a reap effect so you could put her into play and then by the next turn she might be gone whereas this one you know you're going to play it but you can only return a creature to your hand instead of just a card yeah i think which of the eye was any card and that explains why this one is a play effect instead next up we've got a key frog which is a two power creature

um and this is not uh that big of a surprise seeing this in untamed the destroyed effect is forge a key at current cost so untamed is used to having these key cheat cards um and they're not always things just like key charge or try to hazary where you play them on your turn and it's like an easy hey as long as you have the amber you just forge the key right away so this is cool because it's a timing thing it forces your opponent to not want to destroy the key frog on their turn um necessarily because it might forge you a key um but at the same time you can do some cool stuff where you can go above the required amber and then use you know key frog to fight someone or just use a card to destroy it to get that key forged so a little bit of trickery there which i like to see uh next up we've got chalonia which is a two power creature elusive after you play another creature if the tide is high gain one so i'm drawing a blank now on the previous uh untamed card from another set that had this sort of thing where you play a card and then that creatures like when you play other ones i wasn't hunting which i think um and this one the tide has to be high but chalonia's got elusive to balance that out so uh very cool i like this edition of the game for untamed next up we've got kangafante this is an uncommon creature five power each creature gains reap destroy this creature this one is interesting um it's another one of those ones that can slow the game down a lot because once this comes into play your opponent is if i play this my opponent immediately feels like that's the high priority thing they have to do is kill off this kanga fans before they can do anything else um you know if it's your own turn you can play a bunch of you know reap with

all your untamed creatures and then put this in play but then even you know that you have to deal with this later you know you can if you have the one if you're the one with the kangaskhan you can fight and potentially you know get them off the boards that then you can reap or whatnot but it's just something that causes both players to play differently again kind of like the tide um i have a deck with two of these that was kind of a little annoying but i don't know not maybe not my favorite card but it can make for some interesting games persistence hunting is next uh it's a common action gets the amber bonus and players choose a house exhaust each enemy creature of the chosen house very cool especially because we've seen some of that exhausting stuff i know we were talking about earlier how unfathomable they're kind of the specialist of that but there was also what was it cooperative hunting from the original set so this is persistent hunting which just is a bit of a different uh different target here deep water grew in um we had fuzzy gruen in a previous set so now we've got deep water grew in bonus just gains you two amber five power and it's gotta play slash reap if the tide is low your opponent gains one all right so now we're looking at star alliance starting with rocketeer trisca this is a common creature with four power while the tide is high rocketeer triscus neighbors interplay ready so just again we're talking about the tide being high this is just another thing that makes you consider that and obviously star alliance is uh is kind of known for having that re-readying creatures that have already been used kind of thing or being able to use creatures the turn they come into play so very cool card i think it's a great addition to star alliance for this set uh next up we've got an action card that i really like grand alliance council so it's a common

and the play effect is just choose a creature of each house destroy each creature not chosen um first off just look at the artwork you can see kind of one you've got a dinosaur you've got the uh the logo sky cam oh i can't remember what his name is now um whatever that robot was i can't remember now it doesn't matter it's kind of one person from every house you've got the the flavor text will form a committee to handle this and it just makes you again this is another card that just makes you think in a way that no other card really does like picking out which creature from each house you want to keep they form sort of a council thematically and you just wipe the board from everything else so i always like these kind of situational tricky board wipes where you have to kind of figure out how to use them best i love it uh next up is together this is a uncommon action and the effect is play you may play a non-star alliance card if the tide is high you may play another non-star alliance card um again love the artwork on this one too flavor text too what do you mean you're not water resistant uh it's just one of those ones again we're always talking about how the the non you know star lines lets you play non-star alliance cards it's kind of a supporty type house that is similar to logos where it lets you get through your stuff quicker and this just fits into that theme perfectly and has the you know again it lets you do one but if you raise the tide it lets you play another one so i really like that next up we've got an artifact static collection array uh gives you an amber bonus just for playing it um your keys cost minus one amber or one less amber while the tide is high and plus one amber while the tide is low so again something that is just forcing you to constantly be aware of the tide it says specifically your keys this does

not affect your opponent in any way so it's not something that your opponent has to sit there watching your artifact playing off of it this is just for you next we've got lieutenant valmart uh this seems like a very powerful comment three three power but it's got a play slash fight slash reap ability which is if the tide is high keys cost plus three amber during your opponent's turn excellent uh i mean just one of those ones because it's got the play fight and reap it's something you can use multiple times something's going to force your opponent to really want to keep that tide low for you next up we've got biome discovery amber bonus play if the tide is high you may look at the top two cards of your deck and discard one of them otherwise raise the tide so another one of these you know do this really good thing if the ties i otherwise just raised the tide so a lot of these are just like worst case scenario you're going to raise the tide which usually works in your favor if nothing else even if you don't have the cards they're gonna you know do something with the high tide you're putting the pressure on your opponent amber back very cool upgrade added into the set um that just makes this whole tide mechanic come through even more play raise the tide so that's when it comes to playing you attach to someone and then the creature gains the ability at the start of your turn if the tide is high capture two just a constant thing again love the artwork too but it's just the constant ability that your opponent has to watch for that's again putting that pressure to keep the tide low for you and we will go right to this rare that i like which is commander derksgaar uh four power creature if an upgrade is attached to commander dirksaur or one of its neighbors gain an amber so because this is and flavor text it's jerks guard it rhymes

with roon kirk kirk's which doesn't rhyme uh and the artwork's amazing too but this is another one where it's just causing uh you know like with all the upgrades in the set this this just feels like one of those high potential cards it's not always gonna be good you might put it out there nothing might happen it might just be a four power creature that gets killed off and yet you have the potential to gain so much amber from this love it very cool card now we're gonna move on to finally logos so first off we'll talk about submersive principle which is a common action play each player loses when amber if the tide is high each player loses half their amber instead rounding down the loss this kind of reminds me of i'm gonna blank on it now the card that i'm not gonna remember it now it's from called the archons one that makes players both lose half their amber and you lose a chain round it down right then you lose a chain i can't remember anyways it's a great card this is kind of their version of it in here with a bit more of that situational thing playing around the tide uh then we've got bilge warden a common creature with two power play slash reap if the tide is high your opponent raises the tide otherwise you raise the tide so this is one where you this is a timing issue and can actually you know be negative for you because it's it's something that's going to stay in play and you just reap to raise the tide but again when you play it or reap with it if it's already high um the tie is already high in your favor you're gonna make you're gonna swing it and it's gonna be low for you and high for your opponent so bill jordan's cool it's one of those situational ones again that you have to play around the timing

but if it can stay on the board it can be really powerful for you next up we've got armadrone which i really like um one power three armor and a fight ability steal one um i love this because first off not many hoses in the game even have creatures that have armor and you don't see a lot of it i mean the only one that comes to mind for logos now is that group think tank that has i think three or four armor there's some along the way that sometimes have like one here and there but three armor is huge and the fact that you can just keep using this armadrone uh to steal is just really cool and the artwork is just kind of flying in through the open window just gotta love that next up we've got think twice it's a uncommon action for logos and the play effect is play an action card from your discard pile then purge it very cool this is going to be one of those ones that is going to depend on the deck that you have and what other action cards are in there but this is one of those really thinky cards that is going to make you you know again it's it opens up a whole world of possibilities and this is one of the things i love about logos and what they do with this kind of stuff whether it's archiving playing cards off the top of your deck because this isn't it's not only for logos cards so depending on what other actions you have from other houses you might have a key cheat card in your discard pile or you might have something that allows you to like steal amber at the perfect time so you can pick a logos but then still you know maybe play in a shadows card for your discard pile to steal amber to help to stop someone from forging so think twice i love these types of cards this is one of my new favorite cards in the set for sure next up we've got information exchange so it's another common this is an action um play is

steal one amber if your opponent stole an amber from you on the previous turn steal two instead so not much to talk about but it's just nice to see logos has a bit more or still has some of those steel effects like they had with uh was it cutthroat research in in one of the previous sets next up we've got final analysis this is a very cool card so it's a common uh action and it's destroy each creature each player draws a card for each creature they control that was destroyed this way so this we don't see a lot of these cards in the game where you can draw a whole bunch of cards there was that martian generosity for mars in age of ascension and we see drawing blanks on some of the other ones right now but i really like these cards that have this effect of like there's a drawback you lose something but as a result you draw a whole bunch of cards because drawing a bunch of cards is you never know if it's going to be an immediately good or bad thing it depends how many cards you're going to draw you know what if you had already played a bunch of cards and you're down to one and then you drew a bunch of cards and they were for the house that you weren't going to play either you didn't pick that turn then you would have drawn those cards at the end of your turn anyways so sometimes the drawing a card effect literally does nothing for you but you could also play the start of your turn wipe the board you know you might draw five six seven cards or whatever maybe even more twelve cards and suddenly you've got a handful of cards to do stuff with so um i really like this and the fact that it applies to both players is just another one of those kind of thinky aspects that i really like about key forge it also comes in it also feeds into this next card and i was lucky enough to have these in the same deck the next one here is data forge this is a key cheat for logos it's an uncommon uh it's an action you

gain an american for playing it and the effect is you may forge a key at plus 10 amber uh the current cost reduced by one amber for each card in your hand so the ideal thing would be have a big board of creatures play your final analysis draw a huge hand of cards play your data forge to forge your key and then lay out your big hand of logos cards all in the same turn if you can do that i think that's going to be super powerful and just yeah i'm just loving again oh whatever spoiler alert logos was my number one rated house in our key forge video and i'm sure you can see why these cards are just amazing i haven't gone through all of them yet and there's tons of them that i haven't seen but i just love the play style and love what they've brought to logos in this in this set you know after a while you would have thought oh maybe they're running out of ideas with logos maybe the house is getting stale but that couldn't be further from the truth uh just very happy to see my favorite probably house still being preserved and and you know continued in a really interesting way so two cards left here i'm going to go through for logos first being pi sweven it's a creature with two power and it has a reap effect which is if the tide is high draw three cards again i just mentioned drawing cards isn't always going to be good necessarily but especially because this you play one turn if you actually get to use this effect you can use it at the start of one of your next turns when you start with your full hand of cards you can start right away by drawing those three cards just to give you more options and more information to kind of plan your turnout so awesome love to see that this is a common as well and the final one i'm going to go over here is a rare it is an artifact slrs australis

amber bonus just for playing it and the action is exhaust up to three friendly logos creatures for each creature exhausted this way play the top card of your deck one at a time so this is basically a wild wormhole in artifact form absolutely love this and there's a bit of again that thinky aspect of a lot of logos creatures that stay in play you'll know have good effects like we just went through even you know pi sweven has this reap effect um i can't remember yeah armadrone has the fight effect right you've got these creatures that you can use for other things but you can also take this risk of exhausting creatures to play the top card of your deck but again part of this is depending on the deck you have this in you might have cards that you know are just like a board wipe like destroy all creatures or destroy creatures of this power or you know do this and sometimes you might not want that card off the top of your deck effect but it gives you that kind of second guessing yourself i i always loved wild wormhole as a card and the fact that logos has that and i love the fact that you can do this and even get up to three cards sometimes you just play this and you might get two or three creatures from other houses played out for free and then next turn you don't go logos you go that other house and you have those two creatures that are already in play now so lots of cool stuff absolutely love it um yeah so that's it for logos and that's it for basically all of the houses that we've previewed here all right so now time to talk about my final thoughts of dark tidings as a set so first off we're just gonna say where do i where would i rank this among the other sets overall out of the five sets so far it's definitely not my favorite

but it's also i wouldn't say it's my least favorite either it's probably fourth i would probably have it just above age of ascension um but it's a little early to tell i might still you know my number one is definitely mass mutation and my two and three i'm not really sure what order i probably have called the archons and and worlds collide and then this would probably be next um before getting to age of ascension at the bottom but and i think part of the reason why it's not higher is well there's a few things the main thing i would say is that the tide mechanic while it's something that i like i like being able to try it out i like you know playing around that tied mechanic but the fact is that you know pretty much every game that you're playing with a dark tidings deck even if you're playing against a non-dark tidings deck suddenly the tide is in play and it's not something that i think you know if if key forge let's say when the game first came out just had the tide mechanic this was part of the game all the time that's not something i would want in the game i think it's good that they just brought it in for one set i don't know what plans they might have for continuing it onto future sets whether that's either just through the unfathomable house or other houses maybe it'll make a return you know down the line in one set but it's not going to be in the next few i honestly don't really know um by the way if anyone i know there's tons of you guys out there who are listening to podcasts all the time and all kinds of stuff if you have any info about this if you know about you know if the tide mechanics bound to reappear in the future please let me know um but yeah i like it so here here's where it is i think if you're someone who is only going to get a couple of decks or you don't play key forge that often

let's say like i don't think this set is necessarily tailored to a new player i think for new players this is one of the worst sets you can start with because not only are you gonna then you know again if you just buy like one or two dark titings decks and even if you have one or two from other uh sets if like half your decks or more than half your decks are from dark tidings you know that you're going to play a lot of games where that mechanic comes into play and not only that not only is it going to skew you to playing that those kind of tide based games way more often but also as a new player like i mentioned there's kind of an emphasis with with this set and with the title having to know your own deck better know your opponent's deck better know the dynamics of the cards have an idea of how many cards in the stack actually play off the tide what's the importance of me having the tide to be high when can i risk uh you know just letting it stay stay high for my opponent and not taking the change so i think for beginners and people who are just casually into the game and don't have a lot of decks you know maybe it's worth picking up one or two kind of thing to just have but uh for me personally it's not something where i want to always play with the tide um you know sometimes you just want to match up decks from other sets with with your friends or whatever so that's something definitely to keep in mind the other thing i'll say about the set um i mentioned about the evil twin decks they played it maybe just a little safe i think maybe it's because we're sort of coming off the high of mass mutation and mass mutation maybe not exceeded expectations because i think most people were very excited for it but i i didn't really expect before it

came out for it to end up being my favorite set and i think they absolutely crushed it with mass mutation and having like the the giant creatures and the enhancements was just such a cool addition of the game and so when dark titans was announced i was really excited the evil twin deck sounded really cool the tide mechanic sounded really interesting too and i think even though i do like the tide mechanic and what it brings and gives you some variety for for those of us who are playing a lot and have a lot of decks it's nice to kind of have that and play every once in a while um you know ultimately i still think that it didn't quite live up to being as exciting as i thought after a while the tide mechanic is cool but i'm like okay i kind of want to break i want a few games now where we're not playing with the tide i don't always have to make that decision about the tide and whether i want these chains um so yeah that's definitely something to keep in mind i think for sealed play it'll be very interesting because with seal deck you never know what you're up so both players are kind of on more even ground there isn't going to be that skewed thing i was talking about with like a more experienced and less experienced player i mean yeah if someone has played a bunch of dark tidings decks they're going to a sealed game against someone who's never played the game sure but for the most part i think sealed is going to be maybe the most fun way to play this and i might even do something like that whereas in the future i might just buy a box of dark titings decks and just have a sealed deck tournament so you can play out that mechanic and have it you know be fresh where you don't know how to play around your opponent's deck and know which cards are going to have that tied but yeah i think sealed will be a great a great format for it overall i would say it is a really good

set i think it was a good one also to have during the you know the pandemic um potentially brought new players in who are interested in this mechanic and the evil twin decks and stuff um the other thing i want to mention actually that i didn't really touch on is just what it does for the different houses in the game even aside from unfathomable because there have been issues we've talked about how you know worlds collide for example brobnar felt so weak you know almost all the decks with broadnar people don't like playing them they've got low sas scores they just feel really tough to win with they're kind of unsatisfying um age of ascension had some issues definitely with mars even though i absolutely love love mars but i have to admit there were just too many cards in there that didn't work or anti-synergies and just overall mass mutation i think did a really good job there weren't any houses that felt either way too strong or way too weak and so far in dark tidings i think they've done a really good job too there isn't any one house that stands out as being too strong or too weak um it feels like they've kind of kept you know i mentioned in my my house rankings video recently that i was hoping for some you know more interesting stuff with with shadows and i think they kind of they have shadows in a pretty good spot here i think they're still maybe due to cycle out in one of the next sets but i really like what they did with them as i mentioned they've made sanctum more interesting to me again really like the way they've kind of kept things going with logos star alliance i mentioned that i really like what they've done with saurian as well in terms of kind of preserving that identity of the big body creatures but giving them some other things to play around whether it's purging creatures or some really interesting artifacts to play with untamed is the one that i would be

slightly skeptical of they they have brought back some really interesting cards there's that key frog that allows you to you know for a cheat sheet when when it's destroyed um you've got stuff like witch of the dawn i went over some of those other cards but i just i don't know if it's either gonna be potentially weak or if not weak it might just be potentially maybe not as interesting or not as there might not be as much variety and untamed as some of the other houses or also even just comparing to untamed and previous sets so overall i would say they've done a great job with all the cards in the set and i like that um and so yeah that's pretty much all i've got for dark tidings as i said that'd probably be number four on my set rankings it is still fairly new there's still you know tons of cards i haven't seen or played with or against so my thoughts over time might change but that's pretty much all i've got i'm curious to hear from you guys what do you think where does dark tidings rank for you what do you like or dislike about the set do you like playing dark titans against dark titans decks or dark ties against non dark tidings decks and what are you hoping to see in the next set um yeah plea if you like these videos uh please consider you know subscribing to the channel if you haven't yet um stick around leave some comments you know let me know what you think and if you have any requests for future videos let me know as well otherwise thank you all so much for watching and i'll see you next time

Progress saved