Is The Hobbit: There & Back Again another Knizia classic? TCbH Review
Transcript
The last and only remaining gift I have for my birth mother is an illustrated copy of The Hobbit. Though the story itself was introduced to me in the 1977 animated film by my uncle and it served as my entry point into the world of fantasy, which became a lifelong obsession. And while I love the whole Legendarium, maybe because of this personal connection, The Hobbit remains my favorite Middleear book. personal anecdote out of the way. The point is that over the last couple of years, Asthma and specifically Office Dog, but Asthma as a whole, has released some really great Middleear games from Duel for Middle Earth to Fate of the Fellowship and the Fellowship of the Ring Trick Taken game. But needless to say, when I heard that my man Dr.
Reinaria was working on a game that is based off of The Hobbit itself. While my interest was more peaked than a young hobbit catching a whiff of Farmer Maggots's crops, there and back again is simply put an episodic rolling right. Each session is played on one of several maps in a gorgeously produced book depicting notable exploits of Thor and Company. From fleeing goblins to greeting dwarves to riddles in the dark to riddles with a dragon, the lead player rolls five dice and in turn players draft one at a time, gaining the depicted resources or map notations. Then marking said paths on the board according to the unique rules and objectives of the chosen scenario. When all dice are gone, the next player in line rolls all five again. repeat until the scenario's conclusion is met, and the player with the most points based on the unique objectives at hand wins. And that's the thing about this game. Even though the core that each scenario wraps itself around is exceptionally simple, the amount of interesting and thematic variables that can be toolled around with is a testament to Kitia's legendary design efficiency. Take the first scenario.
You're trying to mark pathways for dwarves to make it to Bag End. Though Bilbo is a good host, so players score substantially more if they pick up food icons on the board or through drafting dice in advance of dwarves making it to dinner. However, bread on its own does nothing and getting everyone to dinner ends the game. In a completely different scenario, the food represents cra, which becomes like a ticking clock that you can extend and give yourself the ability to make camp in the game and score some extra points as part of it. completely different mechanical approaches, but same thematic concept of how food is important to whatever section of the story it is. Simple variables, but interesting pressures. And this continues with food, pathways, swords, and even Gandalf's hat, which can be collected and utilized for a variety of awards contextsensitive to the specific scenario that you're playing within. and they just continue to be these variables that allow for interesting dynamism on the part of the mechanics, but also tons of cute illusions to the story itself.
Something that shouldn't be undervalued is just how freeing this riff on the andright genre is. Where most grid-based games have you outlining to traumos, here you mark the spaces in between, free to retrace and crisscross steps to make certain pathways work. It's disorienting at first, and I had to double check that I drew the right shape more than I'd like to admit, but ultimately this linear focus proved liberating, but that's about it. There and back again has been fun with every new session, though a big part of that academic. seeing how this or that story beat is adapted. And as a diehard Tolken guy, it's great seeing such a lively, vibrant take on this world I've spent the better part of four decades imagining, not the least bit derivative of other iconic interpretations. But beyond being a nice rolling right with beautiful production, there's not much else going on. And that in itself can feel at odds with this game type usually applauded for its simplicity, portability, and minimalism. Whereas the lavish production almost demands a more dynamic game. As a case study, an efficient and flexible design with all sorts of contextsensitive variables to take a simple structure and be able to represent episodic content with remarkable clarity. This is a pretty fascinating design. And for the dieards of the genre who look for a richer
though not necessarily complex role in Wright, this bound to offer some worthy twists. But as someone who holds the source material in such high esteem, I can't help but wish that the property and production had been taken in a different direction. I mean, come on, Kenitia. The Lord of the Rings cooperative game design is there on the table. Just readapt it for The Hobbit. That would be so cool. For now, I'm still planning on making it through the entirety of the scenarios within, you know, see it there and back again. But once I'm done, that's likely to be enough for me. And that's our review. But let me know, what is your favorite Middleear book? And what's your dream team of designer and publisher to make a game based off of that very novel? Put it in the comments. And then as always, do the like, subscribe, but bottom line, thanks for watching. Thanks for being an awesome community.