Warpgate Review - The Broken Meeple
Transcript
hey guys new review today and this is an interesting one actually this is warpgate from wolf designer this is not a new game or at least not a brand new game I think this came out in 2018 and it took me a while before I actually got round to trying it you can get it on retail release but I just told never really came across it I knew one person in my club who had it he'd constantly been saying ah do you want to play this and I'd always brushed it aside to play something else cuz I had other stuff to review but eventually I got a copy at Essen and decided you know what I got to sit down and play this and give it a decent review if I can well what what gate is trying to do is this essentially trying to be a space 4x game which can be done in a fraction of the time of a typical space game like empires Lavoie to Twilight Imperium 4 Exodus Proxima Centauri's ayah all those epic space games that take hours and hours and hours this one tries to do it in something like 90 minutes it claims it claims it can basically do it in 20 minutes per player time ratio so maximum two hours if you're playing with the full count of six players it goes all the way up to six and like any other space for X Game you are building your ships sending them out to different planets and order to research new technologies to give you special abilities you take control of a faction with its own special power and you're doing collecting trade goods that give you an ability in fulfilling objectives that give you points thing feels very much like Twilight Imperium in that regard the twist with this is you have
these boards with 1x 2x 3x and 4x on it and they vary between some of the factions you know there are unique and you've got quite a lot in here as you can see but the idea is is that you have cards which you play down onto this board and they all have an effect like attacking moving and researching and so on but they usually have a modifier X and with the x value you essentially treat the space you put the card on as the value on the action so if you put on the first thing typically it will be 1x so it might say you get to move a ship 1 range but if you were to leave it until the last action you do in the round then it's forex so you end up being able to move something it range for or two ploy for ships instead of one or go attack with two groups instead of one you know it's it's done like that so essentially you have a hand of cards and you're deciding which order you want to play the cards in that round each of which has two actions on it to give you anywhere between like you know eight actions or draw actions in order to actually you know do in your turn and it's about planning what you're gonna do and when but you don't plan all four out this is not a programming game you essentially do one action and in the next player and an expert an expert gets background to you and then you do the second one and then it goes on the idea being and it's meant to be super fast turns we'll get onto that a bit later so does it meet the criteria of a decent space game and does it fulfill the objectives it sets out to do let's look at it in more detail so firstly let's get on to
the big one in that is the duration of the game this one claims 20 minutes per player and it really goes to town about this on the back of the box I mean I gotta be careful cuz it's got lots of pieces in it but on the back it's got a two-player game of warp gate which can be completed in 40 minutes next thing you know it's your turn again you'll remember all the rules by the end of round two no sitting in your own corner blah blah blah now it makes a lot of bold claims does it succeed not exactly although it's still good when compared to the other space games 20 minutes per player is kind of wishful thinking really I mean you've got four different actions you got doing a turn there's three different ways the game can end but you know they tick down at different rates so if they tick down at an even rate it's gonna take a bit longer you're gonna have a pea generated from players because of what am I gonna do with the card because you can only plan so much before it's your turn because of the tactical element 20 minutes per player is kind of stretching it and that's certainly not including setup and takedown time which can take a little bit of a while as well so you're gonna add that on to the 20 minutes thing there is nobody out there who is playing a two-player game of this we've set up and take down including maybe even a rules teach in 40 minutes that just does not happen the first time I played this with free new players and I was fairly new to the game myself but I'd read the rules took us about say four four players took us about 19 minutes plus the rules teach and that's still pretty good for a four player space game that do it in 90 minutes rather than six hours but it's a not entirely the same
as the bold claim they're making on the back of the box certainly I would say 30 minutes per player is a more realistic estimate of how long this game will take it will probably set you back more than two hours if you're playing it with five and six players particularly if you've got new players involved now I did play it with like players who had seen the game before and it did go quicker so I think you need some experience with the game in order to bring it down to that bold claim of the duration but it's gonna take a while for people to get to that level and even then you're not gonna play this with the same group all the time in the real world you're probably gonna have new players coming come and go and then you got to teach them again and then they're like okay so how does this action were you know it's gonna slow the game down that being said I didn't feel like there was a huge amount of downtime between turns other than with AP prone people who can slow down anything and I felt that the turns actually could come round pretty quickly if you had people who knew what they were doing or just like took their turn and stopped delaying the game so the game does actually succeed at being shorter and quicker than all the other space games out there but it's not exactly lightning fast if that makes any sense so the ease of play yep well it's actually not that difficult a game to learn I mean this is the rulebook which is pretty big but if I show that the back page is basically the solo mode more on that later you've got two pages to set it up with do you see pictorial representation of how to set up this hexagonal board and then you have got a total of six eight pages to learn but there's a lot of
pictorial representation in here this is actually a pretty solid rule book I'm not sure if um I think Paul Grogan said to me at one point that he'd helped a little bit with this you know he'd got peaked he had some input on the raid this was written if that's true then it shows but this actually is not a very difficult rule book to read I mean even if you're just playing this from the get-go from scratch it wouldn't take you too long to get used to this and certainly all I had to do was read for it once and I felt like I was confident enough to teach most of the game granted I got one or two rules one play but you know they were quickly sorted and they were little fiddly bits here and there it's not a perfect rulebook because there are one or two elements I found where it doesn't explain something unless you look in the example and then the example explains this key point you need to know it's like oh right why didn't it say that in the paragraph before you know there's one or two occasions like that but if you just take your time and read through it properly you will actually find that it's not that difficult to learn certainly not compared to the other space games are out there however for new players they are going to freeze up with a bit of analysis paralysis at times you've got four different actions to plan but you've got eight to choose from and that's assuming you don't draw more cards by various effects and around it's not an easy game for brand new players to gaming to get into and anyone who's not familiar with the whole action card planning system so moving on to tactics and strategy this is where warpgate really actually starts to come into its own the card management system is really cool I love the way that you know the later you leave an
action the more powerful it is but sometimes you want to do that action first but then you have to realize it won't be as powerful you won't be able to do as much with it but I really need to get that ship onto that planet and if I wait I can't do my awesome action later so I'm gonna have to do this first but then I'm using up this card where I might want the research action later terrible on you the bottom part of this card first and I've only got a hand size a4 I can't draw any more cards and I could take an action to draw cards but then hang on a minute that means I'm doing less in the round but it may be useful still it's not necessarily a bad thing to draw more cards there's a lot of cool turn angst with this game just from like deciding which cards you're gonna use and I love multi-use cards as you've seen me in other videos you know the idea that card has multiple uses I can put it facedown to draw cards which is not as common but still it's an action or I can use the top or the bottom action and it's like deciding which one of those top top or bottom actions I want to do really does come into its own and it's very much a it's Gobert strategy and tactics because you need to kind of think right well I've collected some objectives and they want me to score for these I can't do them all it's physically impossible to do too many of them but you're thinking bro well I need to focus on that type of planning probably get that color read technology and at least have a bunch of ships on other people's colonies for example yeah fine I'm gonna go for that that's my strategy but you gotta be tactical because people are taking over colonies left right and center establishing their own trade routes planets free up suddenly a technology comes off the deck and it's blue and it's like I need to go
to a blue planet in order to have a look at that bad be pretty sweet so you have to react to what's happening in the game and so this impacts a little bit on your ability to plan for the next turn but it's a cool dynamic flow of gameplay where you have to pay attention to what's going on you have to pay attention to the opponents there is interaction because they can attack you and you know blow up your ships and potentially blow up there isn't a suicidal charge you've got a very cinematic combat system with drawing cards from a separate tactics deck the tactics deck which you can actually upgrading the game as a different action so you can have unique cards that no one else has you even have a starting card that no one else has again a bit of replay value there and with these tactic cards you draw them and you have to decide which one you're gonna use and they have modifiers and decent effects the bigger the modifier the possibility that you're going to lose stuff like in camicazi charges but the lower the effect the more that you can do some cool effect on yourself or possibly even hinder the opponent slightly you know there's a lot of cool decisions that you have to make and for a game that supposedly a fraction of most space games it does a pretty good job of giving you plenty to think about despite being shorter and a lot more simpler and certainly less like up a behemoth as something like Twilight Imperium for now we get onto the aesthetics and the aesthetics are actually pretty decent as well I mean you've got some pretty solid artwork on these cards and there's quite a fair amount of them I mean you'll bag them up you'll get them in their sleeves and etc you've got a bunch of tokens for an expansion but you do get some pretty
nice sculpts for the various Sur ships and I mean you've got little basic tokens where yeah these essentially just like our markers and their standard tokens nothing major but you do get a few you know miniatures in there so you've got some fairly basic ships then nothing to sing home about and everybody's got the same skull which is a slight worry but you know they give you that pieces it's not just a token each player has a model for this research drone it goes out and gets technologies so there's a decent eye in the box even though it's not gonna win any awards for like component quality but you do get some pretty solid pieces for the board itself I mean these are the starting tiles so that you know they've got their big flashy color and starting planet but then when you get into the hexes themselves they're pretty decent as well I mean there's lots of different types that you can come across and they're pretty large they're you know you can easily see what's on there it's the board can get busy with a lot of pieces on it but it never feels like it's like I can't tell what's going on you know and the artwork on this is very good I mean each of these planets just pops off the board they've all got a unique style to them so even if you're color blind it's not the best game to play if you're color blind I will say but there are some graphic design things that they've put in to try and help with that some of the planets you know there's a volcano planet with lava it's breaking up you got the white one with rings but yeah if you're colorblind you're probably going to struggle with this but otherwise you'll get a lot of nice you know picturesque art work on these tiles with
the sector's clearly marked off in you know the big like that sort of weird blue segment that says this is in that sector it's pretty easy to see so then moving on to the immersion of theme this one takes a little bit of a hit but not much obviously with the giant 4x space games you know theme is a big deal you've got a lot of theme in something like Twilight Imperium 4 there is a turn the theme in empires of the void - and I really love it but this one has to abstract things a little bit in order to make it shorter and less like those games but there is still some formatting elements in there I mean you are still establishing a trade route and it has to go from separate planets and you can't you know if some of these in your way it's like a blockade the actions themselves you know you are going off in attacking other people you are setting up colonies on planets that other people can come and you know stay with you or you know take them off you you have got the tactics combat we just slightly cinematic in the way it plays out like if you play a high modifier it's because your ship crashed into the enemies so you have to lose it at the end there are formatic touches here and there the race is I can't just whatever there ages their player powers I mean some of them kind of fit what their abilities are that there's one that gets a more streamlined uniform like like modifier system for their cardboard like 2 X 3 X 3 X that kind of thing and they're a droid army so big kind of makes sense that they would have an ability like that there's one that looked like traveling merchants so they're pretty good with trade goods there are some like I say some formatic touches that work but yeah you're not quite getting
the same emergence something like empires and possibly not even ti4 though I would argue that ti4 is abstracted to some extent you know but that's the price you pay when you you take stuff and make it into a smaller game but I don't think what gate is like an abstract game it is certainly not a dry game I feel like I am my space faction going off and doing this stuff in space yes I'm not doing diplomacy with other races yes I'm not conquering planets for resources per se I'm just going there playing these cards and getting more objective cards but I'm getting technologies as well so it's there but there's a bit more piecemeal and you kind of have to like tie the loose ends together and join the dots as opposed to something like empires that would just like feed it to you in dripping glass ball falls a theme and then finally longevity longevity in this game should be pretty decent I mean you have got you know the the variable setup for the board so the map is gonna be different you've got up to 6 players who can play this and it works fine it all player counts I found that two-player work just fine so did 4 5 & 6 can take a bit long for my liking so I'm less keen on that but it does create a pretty like congested board with lots going on and if you've got people who are familiar with the game a 6 player game will actually feel pretty good and even at its most epic of links it won't be as long as ti4 or zyre or any of those ones so it's again still going to be shorter the cards themselves you're using the same deck as everyone else I wish there was a little bit more variety but then I
suppose that would mean quite a balancing feat to try and get right but these tactic cards that you use are pretty cool in the way that there's a huge amount of them that are like totally unique and one of them is unique to a particular faction you can decide for the whole game you know I'm not gonna upgrade my deck I'm just gonna basic tactics I'm just gonna have to deal with the fact that I'm pretty easy to kill in combat but maybe I'm like yeah you know what I'm gonna constantly promote promote promote promote my and I'm just gonna build this deck full of cool cards and now I'm gonna go off on a killing spree yeah you can take a different path to victory especially when the technologies and the objectives will come out at different times you'll have accesses and access to them at different times and they will like dictate a bit of how you're gonna do your game especially the technologies but the best thing that's gonna help are two things firstly the faction boards you've got quite a few of them in here I forget the exact number but I think the Kickstarter deluxe version had 16 different factions you could use this one I think has 12 but you know and each one has got an a in a b-side so you've got two different abilities that they can have two different variations yeah not crazy variations but you know a different ability is a different ability you do also have a solo mode in here which is actually pretty decent as well an AI deck that you flip a card over and much like your tom knows and things like stone Mario games will dictate what the enemy will do and they'll go around and make colonies and blob your ships and take a technology card off you in that so it simulates a human player but actually is a relatively good way to a learn the game and be just actually
enjoy a space game solo there aren't many of them out there when you think about it can you play zyre solo I'm not entirely sure but you know someone correct me on this I can't play in bars of the void solo i cant play TI for so long I can't play Exodus Proxima Centauri solo I don't think you know most of these space games involve other players so the thing you've got a solo mode here is already putting what gate in this niche gap that you know hasn't been filled by a lot any other space game that I'm aware of and yeah before you start getting on my casing oh but what about space core 2035 or whatever that rubbish poly garbage was seriously if you're gonna put that as a solo spacefaring game that abstracted mathematical point blowing up out of proportion nightmare luck fest as that for our luck fest as a suitable solo space game
how about no so my final word is that warpgate is an underrated space game that deserves more attention it offers similar concepts to other spacefaring games like technologies objectives space battles and colonizing planets but it does so in a fraction of the time and yet includes a decent amount of replay value and a solo mode and will likely hit the table a lot more often this does what I need it to do gives me a simple space game in a relatively short time granted it's not going to supplant something like empires on the boy - for me but it still is gonna stay my collection and I think I'll bring it out every now and again so this one I'm giving a 8 out of 10 and a decent seal of endorsement I think this is underrated on BoardGameGeek at the moment it's somewhere in a four thousands I don't think it's got a huge amount of distribution out there but you should be able to get a copy and honestly I think if space is your kind of theme and you want something that can be done in a shorter time or even solo give this one a look you might be genuinely surprised so that's it for me I'll see you on the next broken meatball video if you like what you see please subscribe ding the dance subscribe to the patreon and all that governs and for now regardless of whether you'll enjoy a space game that's 30 minutes two hours six hours or takes three days what does it matter it's still only a game so enjoy it regardless take care and I'll see you on the next review