12 Rivers - Board Game Review - Rivers Might Not Be Included
Transcript
I must get my hands on those healthy purple berries. B. Hi everyone, I'm Luke Hector and this is the Broken Mele, a show where I rave and rant about board games. But there's usually more ranting if we're truly honest. This is a game from Good Games Publishing. Thanks for the review copy. And it is 12 Rivers. This one is apparently a second edition of the original 12 Rivers that came out a few years ago. I had nothing to do with it. I didn't know it existed. So, this is my first time jumping into this one with this new edition. So, there won't be comparisons between the two. Suffice to say, this one is meant to improve on the first one. But, this is meant to be a game using marbles. And we've had games like Potion Explosion and Gizmos and that quite a while ago. They were good fun. They used marbles. I mean, hell, there was even a Simone UI game. Golem.
Yeah, Golem down in my collection. Yeah, a game by Simone UI that is in my collection. I mean, go figure. But I like that Euro game. And that one uses marbles to dictate actions that you do. It's not to say that I'm addicted to marbles. I used to play them in school, you know, flick them around and stuff, but you know, it's just the fact that they don't get used as a game component these days. And this one is apparently meant to really utilize them. It takes its theme of 12 rivers, has you rolling marbles down, you collect the marbles and use them to fill up villagers and get victory points. Sounds pretty simple. It's meant to be a very easy game, family weight. So, uh, is it just a little bit of a gimmick just to make you go, "Oh, that's cool." And then you move on, or is there actually some weight behind this? The premise of 12 Rivers is very straightforward. You have a board set up here on a slope incline.
There are marbles set up on top of each of the 12 rivers held in by a little guard like that. The idea is is that players will have these action markers on a turn track down the bottom of the board here. And these are laid out specifically at the start and then they will jiggle around as the game goes on. And the way it works is that players will take it in turns each round to take from the top if it's a first turn marker and they will place it in one of the notches on the rivers. The rivers come with several notches in different locations and they cost cards as a currency. So if I want to place one here, for example, I need to pay two cards. Players will basically have a hand of cards that they will micromanage as the game goes on. And this is effectively a resource. You can play them in pairs to trigger their special abilities, but otherwise you're basically saying, "Well, I want to put my marker as high up as this one here.
That means I'm going to need to get rid of two cards in my hand. Those two are gone." Fair enough. If you go lower down the rivers, you get less choice of the marbles, but you get to draw cards potentially rather than pay them. But also, you need to think about the villagers. We'll get on to that a little bit later. As you place your markers on here, and you'll take it in turns to do so, you know, spending cards as necessary. But if you go to certain locations, like this one here, you can pick up fairy tokens. These are basically little special abilities that you can trigger during the game. But the idea is is that over the course of a round, these markers are going to populate the board. So, some of them will be used to collect marbles and others will be used to take villagers at the end of a round. The villagers are essentially point scoring opportunities where when you put certain color marbles on based on their criteria, you'll score victory points at the end of the game.
marbles that you collect during a round will store on your alpaca which is kind of a temporary storage facility until at the end of the round you can transfer them to your villagers. But these cards, they let you do things like take additional marbles or muck around with the markers and you know standard Eurogame fair abilities. But once everybody has placed all their markers out, and this isn't every single marker, I'm just showcasing a few. You will do what everybody looks forward to and release the marbles out. So out they come and they basically roll down the rivers as such, catching on the markers that players have put out, eventually dropping into a lake in the middle of the village down here, which is kind of if you go down there, you can take any or all that's left. You have no idea what will turn up down there, at least not fully, but you're kind of thinking, well, I just need a bunch of marbles rather than specific colors. I'll go down there. But the idea is is now they have caught on these markers. So now starting from the top left and going across in this fashion, you players will take it in turns to take a marble from the collection that is done there. So red can now take this blue marble, stick it on an alpaca and take the marker off.
This goes to the bottom of the turn track. So the f the earlier you go in the round, the later you're going to go in the next round and then so cool. So green here could take a blue or green. Well, the marbles are different victory points. So certain marbles are worth more than others, but then the villagers you have might be crying out for specific colors. So, I need pink and green on this one specifically. So, even though blue is worth an extra point, I need green. So, green's going to take this one. There you go. And then you take the marker off, and the marble continues on its way down to another marker, which coincidentally happens to be also green. Yellow decides they want to take a blue marker. So, blue, they take that one off, that goes down. Green's now got two to pick from. And this carries on with players taking the markers off until eventually a bunch of them are going to collect down in the middle. And if they get stuck, you can just basically release them. There's no rule for leaving them stuck there. And you know, the person going last can take a bunch of marbles here. The ones who go in the villager spaces can take villagers from a display of these, which are refreshed every round. And that's kind of the premise of the whole game really. Not much else to say. You play through five rounds in that fashion. The turn order will keep jumping. New marbles will refresh. You use your mar you use your cards as a currency to get the marbles you need. Populate your villagers. And at the end of the game, the one with the most points
B.
Yeah, pretty simplistic. And this game is definitely on that simpler weight level. I mean, I would say is kind of family weight. Yeah, there's not a lot of rules to learn in this game. The concept of putting your markers out and collecting marbles is pretty simple to anybody really. The most complicated aspect of this game is probably the cards themselves in terms of their abilities. And even then, the abilities are not that crazy hard. I mean, when collecting a pearl, get an additional pearl. Okay, straightforward. After placing the tribe token, one of these things basically, you get to move one of your other tribe tokens to the top of the turn track. Again, not rocket science. Um, after placing the tribe token, move one of your other tribe tokens from one place to another without paying any extra cost. Easy. You know, these are not complicated abilities and there's only five of them in the deck, but you know, you get a lot of them because you are playing them in pairs.
The villagers get loads, you know, blue marbles are worth more points, get this particular color combination, fill up this tile to get six more points. Again, not, you know, not difficult. The, you know, in I suppose maybe the slightly more fiddly thing is the fairy tokens cuz there's five of them and they got different abilities. But they do give you a reference aid. Thank god somebody understands about reference aids which tell you very easily what they all do. So there's no difficulty [clears throat] there. Although why did they only print two? Don't be tight. You're already printing out all this. Print one per player. Don't give me none of this share between two players nonsense. But the only thing I do have a problem with the fairy tokens is that the iconography for the breeze and cloud fairies is too similar. It shows the exact same mountaintop. And the only real difference is that is the direction of the arrow and a couple of little dots.
We've had times where we've got those mixed up. And so I would have liked it if the iconography was just a bit more different with those two just to make them stand out more. You get used to it after a couple of games, but new players do trip over that quite often. I'm just saying. But that's kind of really the only difficulty. I mean, it's not a particularly big rule book. Most of it is pictorial examples. There's probably more text in the book than is necessary for the game. It does kind of repeat itself a little bit. You know, like we've already explained this concept to me. You don't need to explain it to me a second time. So, I reckon you could have probably trimmed this rule book a bit sizewise, but the rules are not complicated. And if you've played games before, a lot of this is going to be familiar ground to you. And if you want to teach the game, it's all on the back of the book. And normally I do like to have reference aids for everybody in terms of rules, but this is a simple enough game that the back of the rule book is fine. It will suffice for, you know, a rules explanation because each round will play the same. You set up the marbles. You place the tribe tokens. You release them and then you take your marker off and take the marble and then you get a villager at the end of the turn and then you transfer all these marbles from your alpaca to your villagers. The only bit on the side is that you've got a gold card if you can get lots of the same color of marble on your alpaca. That's it. is a tiny little side thing which you know is an interesting way to get some more points.
But yeah, everybody can understand the concept of get color marbles, put them on the right colors on your villagers. So, it's a nice simple game. Is it fun to play? Yeah, it's generally quite a nice fun cozy game. This is not one that's going to burn your brain out in terms of weight and depth. You know, it's meant to be quite a simple affair and it does look the part. I mean, you got this on the table at a slope and it certainly does draw the eye. The artworks fairly sort of standard and basic. Although the purple and pink does create a nice again cozy atmosphere with everything and the marbles are cool and people look at this and watch them go down and it draws their head. I mean, you know, I've been talking about, you know, certain games like I and stuff lately where it's like people just wander on past. People don't wander on past with this. They stop and take a look at it. It may be a little bit of a gimmick, but it's a gimmick that works.
People are sometimes worried about the foam core thing that is basically made out of foam core like folded space inserts and that. Trust me, it's not an issue. I mean, I've been playing this game a bunch of times for a review, and most of these nodules feel still pretty tight. You know, you sometimes you actually have to work to get the thing in. Not crazy amount, but you know, it's snug. There's a couple that came a little bit loose, and obviously as you play more games, they may get a tiny bit more loose cuz obviously you'll scuff like a little bit of the corners and that, but it's not like the marker falls out or anything like that. You know, there's a couple down here where if I put the marker in, yes, I could move it back and forth a little bit easier than it being snug, but it's not like it would fall out. You don't tip this upside down or anything.
Earthquake test.
He's good.
I think people may be overplaying the fact that it's foam core a little bit too much. Trust me, it's fine. And it does enable this game to be a little bit more cost effective. It's still not the cheapest game around by any means, but can you imagine if they tried to do this with a wood insert or big like lump of plastic or something like that? You'd probably think it would cost even more. And I feel like this just works nice. You know, it feels good. The artwork can be seen nicely on it. Probably better than if it was plastic. Cuz let's face it, if they did use a plastic tray, it would just be a plastic tray with nothing else on it. At least here you can have nice artwork, you know, pretty artwork over it. So, it does the job fine. Bart,
the marbles feel like distinct colors to me. However, I'm not color blind. Uh, we did have one player struggle a little bit with the pinks. They thought the pinks and another one were a little bit too similar, and there's no way to differentiate the different marbles, unfortunately. You know, I mean, it would have cost too much to put little designs on them and that. It's just the nature of the beast with this type of game. If you are color blind, you might want to take a look at these colors and see if you're comfortable. You've got effectively white/ig effectively purple, pink, uh, light blue, and green. If those colors cause you concern, this game might not be for you. But by all means, take a look and see how easily you can distinguish the colors cuz you're going to kind of need to in this game. It's somewhat important. Um, otherwise, the game is just nice and smooth and free flowing. It doesn't it doesn't jerk at any point. It doesn't grind to it halt or, you know, grind its gears or anything. It's just smooth every round. You just put the stuff on, release it. Everybody loves it when the marbles release and they go down. It's a gimmick, yes, but it looks cool and it takes the theme of the 12 rivers, you know, seriously with it. And then you just take your marbles, put them on your board, take some villagers, and then pop them on. And then rinse and repeat for the other round with some funky little abilities while you're at it. That's really all there is. You know, it's a very simplistic game, but it's cozy.
It's family weight. I would dare say I would even call this close to gateway level. Actually, I don't think there's a lot of rules in this game that take it out of gateway level, except maybe when you combine these tokens with these cards. Maybe you might be jumping out of gateway level because as soon as you start putting cards with abilities and tokens with abilities, you start taking it out of that scene, but you know, some people will get it. And even if it's not gateway, it's definitely light. Like this will be your next step game after you've played a gateway game or two. So, it's definitely a family weight affair. A lot of people will be able to jump into this nice and easily. The player scaling is one of its problems. Uh, it can be played two, three, or four players. There's no solo mode. I don't know why you would want this as a solo mode anyway, but I feel like this game is really one that you're going to want to play with four only. I don't think it works as well at two and three. And the reason is is because you cut out some of the rivers with less players. So, it's called 12 rivers. You only use 12 rivers if there's four of you. If you use three players, there's only nine. If you use two of you, there's only six. You only use six rivers with two players. That just doesn't feel that cool when you're rolling marbles down this little tiny segment and that entire bit is ignored.
And three players using nine again, it three players I can live with, but still it it feels a lot better to have four. And it means that the turn order is much more important with four of you because you know you might have several you might have like five or six people taking turn well five or six separate turns by multiple people before you next get a turn. That means a lot in a four-player game. Whereas in a two-player game, you're just using the same markers back and forth and it doesn't feel like turn order is that big a deal anymore. So, you know, that does cause a bit of a problem. I feel like, you know, I mean, given that this is a family weight game, it's probably something you're going to be playing with four people anyway. You know, you got mom, dad, and two kids. That's a typical family. So, you know, you're probably going to play it in that context. I can't see many people picking this up with the intention of, "Yeah, I'm just going to play it with the two of us." There's cheaper and smaller games. I mean, bear in mind, this box is bigger than your average size box. This is not ticket to ride sized box. Um, you know, any of these other ones. This is bigger because it's got to accommodate this board. So, this is going to take up a little bit more storage space on your shelf and not quite line up with some of the games you've got and be a little bit more expensive than something you would want to buy as a two-player affair. So, player scaling is a problem, but honestly, just keep playing this with four. It's a fine little game. It's cozy. It's charming. It does what it sets out to do. It's not trying to be super serious. It's not trying to be a big massive euro with a ton of rules.
It's just trying to keep things simple. Could have maybe trimmed a little bit of the rule book, but it's not like the rule book's hard to understand. It's just they rinse repeat themselves a little bit. Maybe they could have had a little bit less text, but it's nice. It does the job. It's cozy. It's charming. People smile when they play it. It's good for family weight. Good for a game cafe. I think game cafes could use this. You know, it's not too difficult to learn out of the box. Somebody working at the cafe could easily teach this in about 10 minutes flat, you know, if that. And you know, people will have fun and it will be a good showcase. You know, it's a centerpiece for you. You have this set out on the board. People will look at it. You know, this at Essen had the similar thing. People were constantly looking at this table when they were wandering past the boat for Essen because, well, why wouldn't you? It looks cool with all the marbles and stuff. It's a gimmick for sure, but it's a gimmick that works with the game. It doesn't feel like it was just tacked on for the sake of it because I don't know how else you would do it other than this. It would look very boring or it'd be kind of weird. So, yeah, it's nothing amazing. You know, the replay value is not, you know, a great deal of it because the villagers are kind of similar and the premise of the game doesn't really change. There's no, you know, variation with the abilities and that and the player scaling is a problem. I do feel that this is really a game you're only going to play with four, but I would still give this one a a decent seven out of 10. It's a good game. one that I can recommend for families, one for cafes. It's charming.
It's cozy. It's not going to blow your mind. It's not really bringing anything massively new to the table. The replay value is not going to be like loads. And certainly, I don't think this works with two or three anywhere near as well as it does with four. So, you are kind of restricted in that fashion. But yeah, it's a charming, cozy, family weight game with a funky little gimmick that's fun, but you know, not like tacked on or anything. It just does the job nicely. B. So that's it for me on this episode of the Broken Melee. If you like what you see, then please thumb it up on YouTube and thumbs up on board game when it goes live on the page. Check out the rest of my Essen content. There is plenty already out and plenty to come. Still got a lot of games to play. Oh, it's going to be a long December and probably into January, I think. You know, this is definitely going to overlap to some extent, but don't worry, I'm getting to them as quick as I can.
Let me know your comments down below. Did you play the first edition? Can you compare the two? That would be great to have as useful information. And failing that, do you agree or disagree with any of the stuff I've said about this game? By all means, let me know your thoughts down below. Everybody else would like to read them as well. So, take care and remember, regardless of where your marbles are going to flow down a river, it's still only a game. So, bye for now.
Bart.