Skip to main content
Loading video...

Carnegie Board Game Review

Transcript 10:34

hello welcome back to the channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews play for his unboxings we generally like to talk a lot of buttocks that tabletop gaming in general and in this video we're going to be talking about a work placement game we're going to be talking about Carnegie and in this game you will be placing your workers out onto your departments you'll be sending them on missions in the hope that you can get victory points that will allow you to win the game so in this video we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules we'll be telling you what we do like what don't like then we'll come back we'll tell you whether or not Carnegie it's worth your time and bother today and in the future so remember if you're new here then please consider subscribing to this channel hit the like button and all that YouTube [ __ ] we'll see you after this bollocks Carnegie as you play this guy so Carnegie is a action selection worker placement game right that Lucy follows the Endeavors of the philanthropist and union busting bastard Andrew Carnegie everyone will get a player board you'll see there's some pre-printed departments on your player board and everyone will be able to choose a department from the supply of 16 to put in their personal Supply and this is going to be the first apartment that you'll be able to build so the way that you select actions in this game is that you'll be choosing one of the tokens that correspond to the four actions you've got the HR action you've got the management action you've got the research and development action and you've got the construction action what you do you choose which action you want to activate then you'll move it to the next space on the right and then

this is the area on the map that you will activate for income you look at the missions area on that region on the map and then if you've got a meeple on that area you'll be able to take them off the board and put them in your lobby laid down and then you'll take income that corresponds to the position that you are on that track right you'll also be able to take any income that has been revealed on any of the sliders that are on the right hand side of your board right so once you've done this you'll be able to take that action depending on what action is chosen the first player will look at their player Board and they'll find all of the Departments that correspond to the following action so if you take the HR action we'll look for the HR symbol and you'll activate that action HR is basically a move action you'll be able to move your meeples around your departments dependent on how many movement points the department says you've got so the pre-printed one is going to give you at least three movement right whenever you move a maple will bring a meeple back into your lobby it's going to be laid down and you have to pay to activate it at the end of your turn right so next action you could take is the management action this is how you're going to get cubes and money if you look at the pre-printed ones it tells you that in order to activate some of them you've got to send them people on a mission right this doesn't mean you're going to send them out trying to get a load of dope right you're going to take the meeple off of your player board and you're going to place it on the mission region and this will allow you to take actions so for instance you might have to place a maple on a mission and then you'll get a free Maple or maybe you just want to move your workers around your department for spaces right so next action you can take is the construction action this is where you'll be taking discs off of your sliders and you'll be putting them onto different

connections on the board so for instance one of the actions that you could take is you have to send a meeple on a mission you'll pay one or two cubes to take a disc off of one of the sliders you'll choose a city and you'll place it on a corresponding symbol so you took a disc off of the housing slider then you'll have to place it in the region where you placed your meeple and on a housing symbol in that region right so the final action you could take is the research and development action you'll see that most of these departments will give you a certain number of study points yeah and you can use these in a number of ways you can bump up your disk on an income track as many points as you want and then that will increase your income and if you get it to the end you'll get a reward and you're the only person that's allowed to do that by the way or you can use study points to pull your sliders out of your board right cost is listed on each one if you're using housing and four if you're bumping up to the pink one at the top right you pull the slider out and then you place a disc on the spot that you've just revealed you know so you'll see on the main action selection Port there is also a space that tells you you can make donations the first player will get first dibs and you will be able to choose a donation spot plus a disc on it the first one you're going to do is going to cost you five dollars then ten dollars and so on and so forth right but there are departments that allow you to put these down cheaper so once you've used all of the Departments that you want to use then you'll be able to pay the cost listed only playable to Stan people's upright these then become active and you'll be able to use them at Cinema missions uh you'll keep doing this and then you'll do a big massive bunch of final score and the main one being that you get points for different links that you've connected on major

cities right there you get points for discs you got in cities and you get points for loads of other [ __ ] that I can't be bothered to talk about and then apply it with the most points at the end of the game will be the winner of Carnegie so the first thing that we really like about this game is that the rewards in terms of income can be split into two right there's an interesting choice here right do you pull off all your workers and get your income once but then you'll have a bigger Port of workers in your lobby to spread on your departments right or do you leave your workers on the mission spaces and then pull them off when it's next activated to get double income if you pull both workers off you're going to get double the income that's actually on the track on the board but you're only going to be able to activate the sliders and come once yeah leaving the workers out on the board means you can have less workers in your department to do the dirty work for you right and you've also got to be mindful of the fact that maybe the income isn't going to be activated until right near the end of the game right because there's 20 turns in this game so it's a nice choice in terms of income and if you bugger it up it's on you because there's not really that much randomization in this game you know second thing we really a lot about this game is that all of the actions will be available throughout the game right whenever I've played this a lot of the first timers do say well if the action marker gets to the end then I can't take that action you yes you can what happens is when the marker gets the end of the board you're going to activate the event space on the track below it right and if that's at the end then you're going to go up to the top so this means you've got to be very mindful about when you activate different actions because they directly relate to when income is taken

and when donations can be made right if you're just thinking about what action you want to take so you want to take the construction action because you're desperate to get that final link it's going to give you a lot of points you might have a bunch of workers in the East that you don't want to trigger yet you've got to decide which is more important right there's loads of media decisions like that in this game right and if you like Euro guys that's what you want in it so the final thing that we really like about Carnegie is that the end game scoring the final thing that we really like about Carnegie is that the end game scoring provides a really really tense finale there are victory points that are going to be available but these are few and far between so most of the scoring comes at the end of the game it's very difficult to see who is in the lead and this means that you're not going to be able to have a king maker nobody is going to be able to gang up on anyone else nobody is going to be sat there going I've lost there's nothing I can do anymore and some of these donations are really really powerful so if you've managed to bag a few of them then you're always thinking have I done enough to win yeah the fact that most of the scoring takes place once again is done means that you're going to be on your gsc's breaking it as to whether or not you've won the game so don't rely about a Carnegie so first thing that we don't like about Carnegie is whilst the artwork on it is sort of suitable for the female lack of theme really the color scheme really does look like a bucket sick it's got like this horrible sort of like diarrhea colored yellow with whites and blues just looks like that pavement Pizza that you get outside a pub on a Sunday morning but this one's covered with a Sheen of mold you know whenever I see this game out on a table it does sort of make me feel a little bit ill so second thing we don't like about this game is

those sliders has got to be one of the most insane design decisions that we've seen in a very long time right when I was setting this game up I've got a five by three and a half foot table right and I just couldn't fit the [ __ ] thing on a board we had to get some tissue boxes and stick a couple of player boards on them so there was enough room to move these bloody sliders yeah and they don't really serve any purpose at all really you could just have had like what Eclipse does and add a bunch of tracks with discs on and just take the discs off when you build it but no they decided to go for some dumb stupid gimmick with some sliders that look like massive dicks so I don't know if the Publishers have got some sort of Dick fish or something but I [ __ ] hate these sliders there are pain in the ass so the next thing that we don't like about Carnegie is that sometimes you literally can't do anything if somebody takes an action and you haven't got any of your workers on departments that can be activated then that's it there's nothing you can do and because there's four different actions it's very difficult to plan ahead for every single eventuality more often than not you're going to be forced to concentrate on one or two things and then somebody chooses that action you unplanned for and that's it you are screwed so even though all the actions are going to be available during the game multiple times there's going to be occasions where you can't take that action so the final thing that we don't like about Carnegie is that the main board is by and large a wasted space what you got on there you just gotta cut the tracks anyway some places to stick your meeples and then like a ticket to ride tribute ax so this ties in with the fact that we couldn't fit the game on a table right if you Shrunk the main board a little bit maybe reduce the amount of wasted space in the

western region and maybe just got rid of the scoring track because it's not really used throughout the game you could quite easily do what Carcassonne does and have a score on track to the side of the board you're only going to use at the end or maybe God forbid a scoring pad right yeah it just seems like they put a main board in here for the sake of it because a box standard Euro going has to have a main board right so it just seems like a complete waste of time and it just adds to that sense of frustration with this one so it's Carnegie worth your time bother today and in the future so we're going to say maybe maybe not Carnegie is a solid Euro worker placement game that has the usual broad mix of options that link really really well together the sliders are one of the dumbest gimmicks I've seen in ages and some actions on your turn are completely wasted because you just don't get the option to do everything that you want to do but insofar as Euro games go this could be a decent albeit largely uninspiring addition to your collection of dry ugly Euro games there you go that is Carnegie remember if you know it and please consider subscribing to this channel hit the like button and all that YouTube [ __ ] see you next time

Progress saved