Skip to main content
Loading video...

Wispwood - First Play Review

Transcript 11:44

Hey there, I'm Jonathan with Getting Games and this is my first play review for Whispwood. Now, what you're going to see was a segment that was recorded live as an exclusive with the Patreon supporters of the channel and now I'm bringing it out here so that you could watch it, too. I'll be describing how this game works and also talking about my feelings on it after my first and second plays of the game. Now, I do want to ask that if you want to support this channel as well as potentially join in with a live stream that you please go to getames.com/support. Also, if you enjoy this video, then please click the like and subscribe buttons down below. And lastly, if you have thoughts about this game, please leave a comment down below as well. All right, let's talk about the game. Okay, we have Whispwood. And this is arguably my favorite game of Board Game GeekCon. Uh this is a new release that came out from Czech Games Edition at uh Spiel and I thought it was kind of interesting.

Like I heard a little bit about it, but there wasn't much fanfare for this one. You know, last year SEI was their spiel release and that was everywhere. You heard about it. Um, it seemed like there was just a lot of hype for it. And in general, I feel like there's a decent hype for CGE's games, but Whisp came out and I kind of forgot about it until I was at Board Game GeekCon. So, I saw it on the shelf and I was like, "Oh, yeah, that looks neat." I got it off the shelf. I learned the rules very fast. Um, it's a very, uh, easy game to teach. And we sat down and we played it. We played a four-player game. I really liked it. and CGE had a booth at BGcon and they were selling it for 30 bucks with a promo um and like some promo cats and stuff. So, I went down and bought it and then I played it again. So, um let's talk a little bit about how it plays, but like just to open this thing up um I really enjoyed it so much that I bought it and uh again, arguably my my favorite game of the convention. So, this is a Polyomino style game with a very cool twist. And I enjoy Polyomino puzzles a lot. pretty much always like I'm having a hard time thinking of a polyomino game I did not like. Oh wait, Indian summer.

I did not like that one at all. Anyway, uh and the way that Whiswood works is you're going to be going through three rounds and in each round you're going to be building up a grid in front of you. In the first round you're going to build a 4x4. In the second round you'll do a 5x5 and in the third round you do a 6x6 and then whoever has the most points is going to win. Mechanically the way it works is on your turn you are going to do one of two things. The first option is we have a a board here in the middle of the table. You are going to take one of the tiles that is on that board. For example, um I could take this tile right here. There are four different color tiles that are going to show up here with different, you know, art for each of them. And when I take this tile, I'm then going to place it into my grid using one of the adjacent patterns. So four in a line or this three in a line with one, you know, kind of nub sticking out. And the way I do this is I'm going to take that tile and I'm going to put it down. And then I'm going to take other tiles face down from just a big stack and I'm going to assemble those into the correct polyomino and then insert it into my area. So for example, if I went for the three across and one up, I could just slot that in right here. I have to put it so that at least one edge is adjacent to one of my previously played tiles. And within that pattern, I could put the face up tile, that blue tile into into any of those different slots. So, you're building your polyomino out of these 1x on's every single turn as you're placing these things down. And then you're just deciding where these icons are going for scoring purposes. So, once anybody finishes a 4x4, then that's going to

trigger the end of the round. And then we're going to score. And these are upside down. Sorry about that. But um at the start of the game, you're going to deal out a random orange scoring card, random green, a random blue, and a random red. And this is how you're going to score each of those icons for the entire game. If I remember correctly, I think there's four of each of these options within the game. So, you randomly choose one of the four orange and then one of the four green, etc. And then you choose one of the I believe four tree ones because if you see the face down tiles all show trees on them. So, you also are going to score points based off of what your trees are like in your area. And this is the puzzle of the game. Every time you play, you have a different kind of variety of these things out here. Each of the icons behaves in like a similar way from one game to the next, but scores differently based off of the cards. So, after you have the 4x4, everybody scores it and they add their points to a little score pad. And then you're going to remove every single tree from your area, but leave all of these icons remaining. So, if you look over here, that is how my friend Dave had his area looking like this because it looks like we probably had just finished the third the second round because made a 5x5. All these different spots had trees in them. We scored all that stuff and then every tree was removed. So, going into the third round, he's going to build a 6x6, but you can't cover up spots that are already full. So, like only a one by one can go here. Uh only a one by one can go here. And I'll explain how you can do that very soon. Whereas for me, I have a little bit more flexibility. Uh maybe

we're just starting the next round. Yeah, I think we just started the next round and I put one new thing down and then Dave was about to take his turn when I took this photo. So, you have this thing with the Polyominos where you're puzzling them together like every polyomino game ever, but then you rip a lot of it out and then you have to deal with the problems that you've given yourself. like Dave scored a lot of points for this because um obviously it made sense for the hearts to be in a checkerboard pattern otherwise he would not have done that but it was really difficult for him to fill these gaps in because of what he did. So you're essentially dealing with your own problems while getting an escalating set of scoring as well because all of your previous icons stay behind. And I guess I should talk a little bit about what some of those are. Let's see. For example, uh the blue right over here.

This one is going to score you two points for every different uh icon that is within either the row or the column. You find the better one of those. So, for example, over here when I scored this blue, it's going to be 2 4 6 and then not two for this because there's already an orange there. So, I'd score six that way. Or I could go up and down, which currently is 2 46. So, obviously, I'm probably going to try to work the last icon into one of those two ways to score eight points for it. Uh, with the jacko'lanterns, they always want to be away from each other in various different ways. In one of the games I played, it was like Sudoku where you didn't want any jacko'lantern in the same row or column. In this one, they just needed to be a certain number of spaces away from the other ones in order to score. And um, the hearts generally seem to have to do with trees if I'm remembering correctly. And lastly, the witches are particularly interesting because they just score for the number of witches that you have. So, the scoring is very simple. However, the witches have special placement restrictions that are different every game depending on which one you choose.

So, for example, this one, it said the witches had had to be placed next to my cat. You could you could not place them anywhere else. Everybody begins the game with a cat just in the middle of the table. So, you put the witches down. You have to put them down there and you have that extra uh requirement that as you're trying to build everything else in. Now, you might be saying, "Wait a minute. There's witches that aren't next to your cat, John." And that is because at the end of each of the scorings, you're allowed to move your cat somewhere else in your area. And in particular, I think the cat was probably here before. I moved it down there so that I had more spaces to put the witches hats down. Uh oh, there's a whole rule I forgot. Uh on your turn, you do one of two things. Instead of taking one of these tiles, you can just take three trees and then put them down anywhere one by one into your area. And then you can refresh your cat. Uh the cat gives you a bonus action. you can flip the cat over and they kind of hide inside of a tree stump. Uh so that you can like flush the market or you can have some more flexibility with the polyominos that you're putting down. So if you do a cat action, which are very good, you're incentivized to do a tree action where you only put three trees down. But of course, when you just put trees down, you're not putting the scoring tiles down. And every scoring tile is permanent. It stays there for the rest of the game. So these things kind of compound. And that was an issue Dave had. He needed to put a lot of he needed to do several of the tree actions to fill in these checkerboards to get a lot of points for them, but he was putting less of these icons down, which means he could have scored more points. It was close. I think I beat Dave by a small margin. Um, but I because I had more of these things down, but we went for very different strategies in this game.

Honestly, the game that first uh came to mind for me was Cgraphers because uh in Ctographers, you have different scoring conditions that you're going to be putting down um in each game. Uh, that one is a um writing game. It's like a flip and right game if I remember correctly, but you're drawing polyominos into an area in front of you. In that game though, you score these things at different times. Like you're going to score this one and that one in the first round and then these two in the second round. Whereas in this game, you score every single one of those. So all of these are live essentially and you have to piece all these things together. Again, the reason this one really cast a spell on me is the trees and how you remove them and then how you deal with that later. When I first read the rules, I was like, "Okay, whatever. A 4x4, then a 5x5. Sure." But then as I was actually playing this game, specifically when I was like halfway through the second round, I was like, "Oh my gosh, I really wish I hadn't put this thing there cuz it's really in the way." Um, but at the same time, if I played something really well, I'm like, "Oh man, I'm so glad I put this here." Like maybe an eight-point blue, which I don't have yet, but maybe you get an eight-point blue in the very first round. It will score eight points in the first round and the second round and the third round because you never move these um non-tree tiles. So, you're essentially compounding your score as the the game goes on. Not necessarily because of other things that you could do based off of like the trees and whatnot. But for a lot of these, they just kind of compound. Like you have like three witches, you get 18 points or 12 points or something like that. In the next round, if you get a fourth witch, you get even more points and you you're scoring the witches once again. So, it seems like early tree actions are

probably particularly bad because that means that's like many of these scorings that you're going to be skipping out on things, but you still sometimes have to kind of work those things in. So, as I mentioned, I I played this one twice at BGcon. And uh the first game was four players and the second game was two players. And the two-player game was great. I mean, honestly, I' I've really enjoyed both of these plays. I'm super happy that I own it. I'm going to be playing this game a lot. But the two-player game in particular was was a great headto-head in the way that a lot of two-player games are. In particular, with hate drafting in the four-player game, I was trying to take the best thing for me essentially. I wasn't really paying attention to what Dave or Nick or Natalie were were doing. Um, if I took something that they wanted, then like cool, that makes me feel good. But in the two-player game, it's just me and it was my friend Owen. And I can look across and be like, "Oh man, he really wants that jacko'lantern.

Jacko'Lantern's pretty good for me. I'm gonna take the jack lantern to take that specific shape so I can fit that thing in and then I take it and then he gets pissed at me and we laugh. So I I think I strongly suspect well I mean I guess I played it at two and four and it also plays three. I don't see why three would be any different. I think it's really good at all of these player counts and in particular two player really feels like a duel when it comes to all these things trying to deny various uh symbols from your opponent. Um, playing it twice means I've seen different scoring objectives with these um, tiles. And like I said, the vibes are similar. Like the jack lanterns seem to always want to be away from each other. The blue ones seem to be always about the variety of various contiguous things. But it it does seem to like build different puzzles and the different options that you have in front of you. Maybe I'll play this 10 times and be like, actually, it just seems like it's the same thing over and over again. But also, maybe that's fine because I really enjoy that polyomin puzzle and fitting things in again. And then also the shifting nature of it. You start with a 4x4 and then you clear all those trees out and now you have a 5x5. But it could be like here or there or down there. And depending on how the trees clear out, you could have a lot of flexibility with where that next one is going to be. So there's a lot to think about. There's a lot to think about here. And I think it's a pretty brilliant idea to have a polyomino game with just square tiles where you build them yourself.

Progress saved