Skip to main content
Loading video...

TCbH Podcast - Luck in Board Games

Transcript 1:17:31

hello and welcome to the cardboard Herald podcast I am Eric and I'm Jack did we time it right this time yeah I think you got it right we're we're getting slowly slowly but surely better at uh introducing ourselves on this podcast I like it um well thank you for listening to our listeners out there thank you for coming back um Jack how are you doing this evening I'm doing pretty good at this bladed hour where I am on the precipice of one of the final missions of frost Haven in like two years of playing Frost Haven and it's it's a lot to have all come together like I think we are on like 90 log plays at this point so um we have decided even though that there's some other content uh we're going to try to finish up this C pain we've unlocked all the characters we've done most of the story side stuff and we are now just finishing out the uh remaining story like Mainline quests and I think we're on like the penultimate one so um excited uh uh a little bit uh skeptical as to Our Success because the uh finale missions have been progressively uh

harder uh but otherwise uh doing good how you doing Eric I'm doing pretty well I've had a uh uh overall pretty lovely day um and I'm excited to chat with you I've gotten some gaming in over the last week uh I am I I I don't know what came over me but I am like full sinned on board game arena plays right now yeah you're you're leaning in I'm cracking I'm just like cracking him out whenever I get the chance so I played Ark Nova for the first time and uh when everything's automated boy does that game Go real real fast I cred a game out in like 35 minutes it was two player so that definitely eases it up but it was like this is this is going you're zoom in uh now that you have a little bit of distance on Ark NOA how feeling about it like it it made a huge Splash when it came out like of course to me the biggest thing that brought it to my attention was when uh Tom vassel uh was like oh this is my new favorite game it's displaced my long running favorite game of all time and this is now my favorite game I was like whoa that is a statement and a half yeah um and I still really like it it gets a lot of play in the home um how are you feeling about it I really like like it like I just it's so once you get your head around the concepts everything just works exactly

how you think it's going to everything just like makes sense for the for the most part there are some times when the theme I think doesn't match perfectly like when the animals are I have a jaguar and that lets me add I'm going to hunt four which means I look at four cards from the deck and take one into my hand it just feels like that one she just be like I don't know get some points or something it kills an animal let me throw this at you yeah reskin as a Pokemon game where you're building your Pokemon Safari and now they are abilities of the Pokemon and it's not that they're hunting one another it's you know that they're recruiting or attracting one another or even battling yeah yeah I think that's first of all Nintendo would never let a a good board game exist they would they would they would put that in the stop that an tracks immediately uh I think that's actually a really great reskin I you've sent me that before I haven't ever actually gotten around to it um but that's the reskin makes a lot more sense where it's like oh yeah this is my Pokemon's ability I get to do this thing I I can see it working a lot better in terms of how it how it thematically meshes with what we're doing here in terms of Pokemon reskins I actually heard recently in the discussion around fin span which is the

recently announced continuation of the span Cinematic Universe um that uh Jamie STM actually has stated um and I don't have citations on this so I hope this isn't just me regurgitating something I saw on the internet and therefore assumed it was true uh but he actually did look into approaching uh Nintendo for the purposes of doing a span Pokemon game uh to have the license and the that just wasn't going to fly uh but then instead of worm span and you know fin span as sequels we could add like a pokey span like a Articuno span a span type game I span typee oh man we're getting into strand types um yeah I would love that uh I I think that also makes sense in terms of theme where it's like again I think that anytime there's like this animal has an ability and it has to affect the game so we have to work within the constructs of the game I don't know why uh a Carolina chick gets to to cash a wheat on the card I it it eats wheat sure that's where I mean at at a certain point you have to just kind of accept that for some games the theme isn't going to translate uh so it's more of an abstraction I mean all games are

abstractions yeah I think that yeah one particular example of this is a game that I played and I I wanted to make sure to mention was fromage which is a game that have you played fromage yet uh I went through the tutorial on board game arena I was going to say you should check it out on BGA if uh you haven't played it it's very idiosyncratic it's a worker placement with a a time element uh in that when you're placing workers they're on this Lazy Susan that rotates around and depending on which direction that they're facing On Any Given round is when you can retrieve them back ultimately that's just you know time ticking by for a a three-time placement a two-time placement or a onetime placement but it is a game that very much wants to live in the universe of its toe um it really wants to sit in that cheese Universe with its parochial illustrations and uh pastoral uh elements but at the same time it is just so divorced from any sense of cheese making uh to to just kind of be like a a point chasing idiosyncratic game it really reminds me in a lot of ways both visually and mechanically uh

something like Grand Austria Hotel you know like a Euro game that would have come out uh in the late a that would have been the darling the the Euro dour uh but now doesn't quite hit the Thematic elements uh that a lot of other games would it's cool um kind of reminds me of like Zuli or something but uh maybe a little brain burny and a little too abstract for the level of brain burning that uh I'm looking for uh in a game uh I was kind of expecting it to be something that really captured my heart because I love cheese and I love farming and games but I didn't really get the cheese element I didn't really get the farming element and instead I just got brain burning timable element so that that's my Fage story girls with veritude yeah we need to live in the veritude at the moment um now as far as uh uh BGA or you know have you only been playing on BGA or have you gotten any other games in um I haven't gotten any other games in I I've had a busy uh work week my my work schedule right now is just like it's a lot of nights uh and so I have time off during the day but everybody has jobs during the day it's crazy yeah yeah it's weird um so not not a ton uh not a

ton hitting the actual table but uh I did I've gotten another few plays of harmonies in it it it is just so easy to get to the table like that's the the thing especially with like it it's me and my wife playing and it's just like we both know the rules we can crank out a game in in such a short amount of time but it still like has all of the impact I feel like it it always has had where you're I mean we're definitely getting a lot more now that we know the rules were getting a little bit more gamey so I'm I'm hoping that in the future there is a expansion that just changes things up enough cuz right now we're just in a loop of and we we still are are loving the game uh I will tcbh will get a review out at some point or another but it's definitely like a game that my wife and I have both absolutely fallen for in terms of like yeah it is just so up our alley in terms of we want a game that we want to play in the next 15 minutes while we wait for a flight we're I it's in my backpack I I have everything let's just we're going to crank it out cool it's done and we haven't needed to change Gates so we're just gonna go on again do you have like a short list of killer combos at this point like have you played it so much that you know that inherently the Ducks work good with the

frogs or you know like some element like that where if they are on the table and you have the opportunity you're going to definitely get both these because it's tooo good not to whenever it comes up I think that there are some where we have taken note of it but it with the spirit animals you have the way the landscape scores changes enough where there are definitely still some combos where it's like okay I know that with the be I need a tall tree and three Fields okay so I'm going to have three Fields together I can probably chain that together I'm forgetting what animal it is but I know there's like an animal where it's two Fields together and then a uh uh Mountain on one side I think it's it's either the llamas or the Mir cats and I'm forgetting which one exactly but it's like if you know that you're going to need to build trees for your spirit animal that's a really easy oh well I'm going to grab that that but also at the same time because you could only grab one animal at a time uh my wife and I are both very much aware now of oh I'm not letting you get that I'm going to take that animal out of spite and that just is how we play frequently I'm going to give the audience a peek behind the curtain here and say that I'm looking at a Google doc

here and it says games Eric Challengers so I want to know what what is Challengers I don't even know what this is so like I have baited breath I had not heard of the like I don't I must have missed it completely it came out two years ago so it is a do you know what super Auto Battle Pets is it's it's I don't that's not the exact title I forget off the top of my head because I haven't actually played it but it's it's an auto battler yes you set everything up beforehand and then it just runs and you hope that it works out um right it promises to be that it's more of a game of war that you're playing uh where the cards have effects but it's a deck builder within War so you at the start of a round get to look at five cards you add one or two of them into your hand into your deck shuffle and then you just randomly play your cards hoping to beat whatever your opponent has the thing that I think is weird and interesting about it is every match is One V one but it's a a round robin within the game and so you are like if you're playing it in person I played it on BGA which definitely I feel like is the better way to play it

cuz you don't have to actually move you just it the the things move around for I'm moving a light around so that I so like if we're playing a four person game I might do a match that is against the person right next to me or the person who's directly across from me like the way that I test my deck is always against one other deck at a time is that what you're saying yeah exactly so you're always testing it against one other deck at a time so if you have four players there are two uh Fields I think is is the called but the they're just the playmats you have two playmats uh you have your deck to one side your opponent's deck to the other uh whoever goes first which is determined not fully randomly but there's there's a lot of Randomness to it but whoever goes first flips a card they Capture the Flag it's a capture of the flag game the your opponent flips over cards until they beat whatever card is on top like number one wise and then you take your person move them to the bench they consolidate and you just have to beat who whatever of their cards is on top and it's just a game of war where you keep flipping until you beat your opponent you go until either somebody's deck runs out and whoever has the flag at that point wins or a person's six slot bench gets full uh one or the other whoever wins

the match gets a trophy which is worth a random number points and you play until you play seven rounds I think it is it's either six or seven rounds and then whoever is the top two in terms of points plays one more round just against each other and it doesn't matter points don't matter at all at that point it's whoever wins that last round is the winner um I found it very interesting because it is in this kind of gets into what I think our theme is going to be but it is all luck but at the same time I felt like I had so much control over it uh in a way that I felt is rewarding and I think that that is a thing that we're going to talk about our the topic for the day is luck in board games uh which is why I thought this game was a really interesting one for me to play today randomly uh before we film this which uh I think this is like such a divisive topic or it can be at least where there's a lot of opinions on how much luck should be in a game uh I'd like to hear just your very above board thoughts of what do you think about luck in board games yeah well of course I like games of all types and I tend to look for not

you know like some homogenized this is my zone of exactly what I like and how close games are to that I try to look at the individual strengths of a game so I can really enjoy a game with very little luck in it so long as it does very well within that and hits on some of the things I love most about games um but I can also really enjoy games with high amounts of luck uh personally my my own perspective on this is that um luck isn't itself the problem when people are talking about like oh I hate games with a lot of luck um it's a lack of control and ability to mitigate uh that luck uh and a feeling of uh disempowerment uh at the hands of luck you know like I for the most part when we're talking about modern Hobby Games we're talking about strategy games games where there is an element of skill where you are doing something that is either testing yourself against uh uh the game itself in a Cooperative game or you're testing yourself uh against an opponent and many of the games that we play especially Euro games are this kind of like multiplayer solitire where you're kind of just testing yourself against

yourself and then seeing in the end how you rank against other people but in those uh you know like I think that for the sake of the way we consume these games luck is a necessity luck is a a balancer it's an accessibility point it's something that brings people in and um without it I I don't think this hobby would be nearly the fun approachable inclusive thing that it currently is yeah I think my big thought on it is nobody wants to play a game where they feel like they never had a chance to win and I think that goes both ways where you have people who if there is no luck in the game then somebody who has played it more than you is just going to win every time no matter kind of what you do and I think the I mean I I I I kind of disagree with you there I I think the majority of people yes I I think that goes hand inand with a lot of adults don't like looking stupid and that's a lot of people's resistance against uh playing games is because they think that an inability with it is somehow a or or like losing at a game is somehow like a reflection of their intellect and we as

adults tend to be very insecure about that but at the same time you know like if I go play a game of basketball or soccer or something with someone who is very very good at the sport I know I'm going into that destined to lose I can still have fun doing it seeing how much resistance I can put up against them um I don't necessar need uh a lot of random elements that are going to give me a leg up on my opponent to gain something but I think something about uh tabletop games um has this inherent mistrust that uh they're going to somehow embarrass you uh so uh very heady games with a lack of luck can be something that you know like a lot of people bounce off against but chess is one of the most popular games in the world right and there's no RNG elements of Chess um and yet you know people will play against other people that they know are better than them and they know there's virtually no chance for me winning but I'm still getting something out of playing it yeah well I think my point is more that I think people

people at least enjoy feeling like they have a chance even I mean chess is definitely a great example where people are going to play to learn against a person who is much better than them and I think chess is actually probably the best example just in terms of it's a game there is no luck there's no hidden information there's no role the die that is as best of a zero luck game as we're going to get and I feel like it's always used as an example uh because of that but with chess it's people definitely feel I think more pressure to play chess and if chess was not like the the King's game in uh institution that it is I feel like if you're just a person described chess and they're like hey there's a person who is has played for like one year they are going to beat you right people not necessarily I think Trend towards that um and at the same time people definitely don't want to have it where the luck takes out of their hand their chances of winning and I don't think that there are a ton of games that do one or the other I think that there a lot of games fit somewhere in the middle but it always is going to be something that it's a tight rope that game developers have to walk of you want some form of in the game I think a lot of games that do it the best are either games where

the luck happens before you have to make any decisions like the luck is you've pulled tiles out of a bag your options are different now but you know what's going to happen when you take your turn like you know like if you play this card or take these tiles this is what's going to happen and I think a lot of of times when people are not happy with luck in games it tends to be where it's I think the term is output Randomness right input Randomness is fine where you the new information is going to change your decision but your decision is definitely like pretty solid of I know that I'm this is going to happen or I know that these are the odds of what's Happening like in sorry in arcs you know that when you take the attack action you're going to roll D Dice and you can choose which dice you're going to have you can't guarantee what they're going to do because you're rolling Dice and that is random but you know that those are the odds you're taking and that just kind of is I think inherent to the game where you are first of all also choosing the dice so you're choosing what odds you have um um but that's a game where there is a little bit of output Randomness but that is a little bit the point of the game or something like cubitos is probably another great

example where it's the point of the game is you're pushing your luck you have so much control over your luck and whenever you the luck doesn't favor you it feels like it's your fault and that you are in control you drove the car off the bridge and uh you're you're you busted and now you're not getting to move on this turn but that's I think what people want from games they don't want it to be a thing where I can roll the dice and I'm going to just randomly end up losing money and that's and that was my turn I didn't do anything right and I I think you know like everything this is a spectrum some people are going to like some some people are going to like others uh and what influences um what circumstances you're going to like luck or not is um is going to be dependent from person to person to person but you know like stepping back from all that subjectivity uh and just kind of getting into breaking this into smaller uh chunks here uh I've spent a lot of time thinking about this and I've actually asked a couple designers about this throughout interviews in the life of the cardboard Herald um and I find that one consistent thing that I've heard uh that I tend to agree with uh because I only retain the information I agree with or vehemently

disagree with um is that uh luck should be in some ways inversely proportional to the amount of investment that you're putting into a game um and where I predominantly hear that is time you know like you don't want to play like a big six-hour game where luck or randomize element is the sole determining factor for why you won or lost but in a game that's only like half an hour that may be exactly what you're looking for but I I've kind of like taken that different direction and it's more about the investment um in general you know the collateral that you're putting down Beyond just time time is one example of that but I think the the uh mental investment you know the game that is engaging uh and asking you to operate at a level of complexity um that uh is really crunchy and and intensive that's a game that you don't want the outcomes of things to be heavily luck based and I think arcs is a great example of something that does thread that needle a bit sure there's randomization in how the cards are dealt um though it's a predictable amount of randomization because you know what the entire contents of the decks are and by

gaining certain cards uh the numbers are balanced out such that um if you have higher numbers you have fewer actions if you have lower numbers you have more actions it's always trying to give some sort of balancing element that um is more about giving you that randomized input you know and in theory you should be able to make something work out of that and then you get to things like the dice rolls which are picking the dice so you can choose how much risk that you're investing but the number of dice that you have is based off of decisions that you made in the game and the dice slem s have far less range of outcomes than a typical D6 they are d6s but the faces are not spanning 1 through six as an output yeah so the amount of possible outputs is much more easy to account for and predict um while still not making guaranteed outcomes and I think that's really this the the sauce when it comes to strategy games um and and luck or randomize elements and and uh RNG which uh for those of you who are old people like me uh who didn't use RNG in your average vocabulary uh growing up

random number generation is you know like how you're um creating uh elements uh in computer games but that has kind of crossed over from uh computer games into tabletop games and other elements where these are seeds for for certain outcomes but really people are just talking about randomization dice cards that kind of stuff um but I did go sorry I was just does oh go ahead really add on to that quickly uh I think it extends even past like the amount of luck should be inversely proportional to investment I think that also extends past just the game in general and goes even to like each action within the game like I think that there are a lot of things where in arcs the randomization of the your dice rolls I feel like makes sense that it's that random because it's one of your Pips is the attack uhuh and you can throw in more Pips if you want to make sure the attack happens but it is like there's that there's also like you know if you're doing an action that has no Randomness and then there's a separate side action that you just get to do as a bonus that's like fully random I think nobody is going to really find many complaints about that well

let's let's take it to a scenario of something that you played recently uh with Ark Nova and one of the things that you're going to have to deal with in that game is that you may set yourself for the best best damn bird engine that's ever existed where you get so much based off the bird tags that are going to come up and you put in the effort for that to happen but because there is only one of each card in the entirety of the deck and that is a monstrously sized deck yeah the there's no way to control that there's an even distribution of specific cards in there you may run into a situation where you're just not drawing all the bird cards that you need and that can have a drastic effect on your game and it's something that you couldn't have necessarily anticipated and can absolutely tank you you know how how do you feel about that sort of investment when it comes to randomized cards that are coming up and how do you like to see that addressed in a game yeah well I think that that's that's a really solid example of sometimes you have put in a ton of effort into a very narrow outcome span where it's you have gotten all of the bird tag things there but be you in theory should know that

the deck is really massive and you should maybe diversify what you're doing and that is but that's like a thing that you're telling me I shouldn't invest all my stocks in one thing and one thing only I'm just saying if you invest your stocks in stores it might not work out good call put it out all right um but I think that there's there are things like that in games and arova is an example that I think is pretty solid with this where it's the guards are so there is so many guards that just don't affect you like especially if you're getting late game you're like I everything in on on the table right now is nonsense I cannot use any of it or it's get out of here guine Pig we don't want you I don't want it and I think that they I I haven't played it's it's on board game arena I have not played with the expansion that seems to fix a lot of those issues um so that's a thing that I'm excited to try cuz I also have the physical version but I haven't gotten Ark Nova to the table recently so I'm going to try it out out on BGA and then hopefully get it to the table after I feel a bit more comfortable with it but that's the thing that they introduce I think kind of for that reason where it's they know they have a lot of cards and they need to get get them through rotate the cards more frequently and I think that's it also introduces a search element which is I think the other thing

you know like there there are some built-in ways independent of the deck that if you really want to and you put the time and effort to get them before someone else gets them for that particular thing you can search for something that has a specific tag it might not be the best thing with that it might not be something that you for sure can do or create but if you really need to get a lizard to the table you can fish for a lizard yeah I think that there's games in theory should reward you for investing your actions and time into a certain path to an extent again I think that there are times when you should if you've played the game enough should know that the odds are not the best to have this happen for you where it's you know again in arcn NOA if you're trying to go for Birds because of how massive that back is there is a chance you just aren't going to see birds and that's unfortunate uh that is unlucky but you have chosen to go down that path right and it might really pan out but that's that's a thing that works do you think that luck um has a place in thematics like I I

guess what I'm trying to get at yes there that you can reflect a theme of luck by having luck elements but I mean does it enhance the theme of A game uh to have luck because luck is ever present in our world right um whether you believe in like some sort of mystical Karma type thing or that there's just an incalculable amount of probabilities in the world that you know that like there's no perfect way to navigate or account for all the things that might happen sometimes you just get lucky um or unlucky uh you know like if board games are supposed to be some sort of simulation that may be more or less thematic uh and more or less representative of uh a specific thing in some ways divorcing it entirely of of uh luck can be less realistic less thematic yeah well I think that there's a everything in life has some element of luck and I think it's it's just there's so much I I think you put it pretty eloquently incalculable probabilities going on in the world that you just you know things are going to happen drop a fork it's

just as bad but it's a thing that is going to happen because you held it in a weird way and I think that in games it's it can be very thematic um to have some sort of element that is just unknowable where it's I think that a game that does it really well is do an Imperium with the entry cards those are like so incredibly thematic of you don't know your the secret plans of all of the other houses around you and that's I think a really great way to obfuscate what the opponent can do in a way that fits really well with the theme of That World um at the same time I think that sometimes it's a little bit weird like I you know why is it that in terraforming Mars my only option is throwing asteroids at things or blowing up asteroids sure sure I you know I think that there's some luck there that it's just well these are the cards I'm dealt and I think terraforming Wars is another game where it's I have zero complaints about the amount of luck in that game I think that that game does a really great job of you are given options and presented the levers to interact with the game that

present the the uh luck elements and and you know like when I'm thinking about the thematics I'm thinking about like my favorite moments in games you know the games where I have jumped out out of my seat and just like been like yes you know like those have always been I I guess predicated on luck right you know um my I I was playing kelp recently with my son and we were both having a great time time and he knew that I his dad as a shark was just about to get him and he knew the only way for him to possibly win was to um draw into the food card that he needs at this time but he had a full hand of uh like all but one card and uh drawing a card is in action there was a safe way of playing if he just dumped some cards this turn so he'd have more room to draw to his final food card next turn or or the the next round when it came to him uh however he also knew that there was a really strong chance that I was going to win on my turn because I knew exactly where he was he had no escapes left and so with only one card draw

and knowing he'd have to shuffle his entire discard pile and he he's not at the age where he's calculating probabilities except on like an intrinsic level he knows there's going to be a big deck and only one card in it and I'm only drawing one card at this time he was like nah I got to do it and he shuffled up his deck and he shuffled up his deck and yeah as a dad I was like I don't know I'm kind of skeptical as what's going on there and I even was like you know what I'm going cut your deck for you and I did thinking all right finally I'm going toast this kid and then he drew his card and he just jumped up and screamed and was like yes yes yes and he played the card as his second action which you can take two actions on a card and or on a turn and one of the actions is to actually draw your hand so he he took a huge risk but was able to eek out this win and I don't feel like that's a situation where he won based off of the luck of the draw he won based off of assessing what are the possible outcomes here and then using the tools available to uh make for the only win that he thought was realistic because the chances of losing next turn were even greater than the uh than the chances of uh I'm getting my greaters

and less than all mixed up here the chances of him losing next term was going to be greater than the risk that in trying to take uh just the one card out of his deck it was a stupendous Victory to a game that was made only possible by having randomized elements where we knew the odds for both sides and just working into it and that's not the kind of thing that you get in a game that absolutely minimizes luck and it's also one of the elements that allows me a nearly 40-year-old man to play a game against a 10-year-old in which I'm pretty certain I'm going to win but he has the ability to maybe pull something out through cunning and also recognizing how much luck there is and what he can do to mitigate that yeah and I think that is the thing that luck brings to board games is it makes it so you cannot know the exact outcome and you can't calculate it out like that is that is why we have luck in board games is to help obfuscate what's going on around you I've now have used obfuscate twice in this podcast I think both times we're Justified but we can maybe do an

obfuscate counter in the corner uh that would does that but it's just like a thing that it you need to not be able to calculate out everything that happens in the game to have that sort of tension that can bring those highs and I think that that's like right that is really what we need like that is I think that's what you're talking about the tension right you know like the the tension is what gives the the unpredictability the person who is maybe uh of Greater skill or greater knowledge or depth or you know whatever it is experience with a game by allowing for a degree of luck you're still giving the satisfaction of having that sort of investment and feeling like you uh have put the time in you put the work in you understand the game but you don't have the certainty that what you're doing is a guarantee so there is always a risk uh on the other end of that and that gives you decision space if there's a guaranteed outcome then that removes a decision um and if you have a degree of risk then you're having to think about like do I want to hedge my bets do I really want to take a long shot is this safe is this not safe and then the same thing is true for uh the the underdog of the story is that they do have something that can help balance

things out and help them feel like okay well if I just do this I might be able to um which is I I think what we want you know and bringing it back to that thing that you were talking about at the beginning that no one wants to feel like they're playing a game that they can't win I think it's that for this play Space face with adults who are not doing Tournament level play and whatnot and you can have games with tons of luck in Tournament level play but but approachability you know something that people feel like they can learn like they don't have to invest 15 games in to understand uh that they're just going to go over to friend's house after dinner and play some games you want something that's going to help them feel like we aren't doing a a a highlevel cunning um you know fencing match with cardboard pieces they want to feel like uh you know you're having fun and unpredictability to a degree can be what generates fun and accessibility and that feeling that if I lost well maybe it's I just got unlucky yeah it also yeah I just think that there's luck can bring so much to a board game that needs it like it can

bring that especi Kelps an awesome example where it's that game has I feel like from not having played it yet actually uh but from the outside it seems like there is a ton of luck but it seems like it is all levers that you're pulling you know the risks of what you're doing and I think that there's because because of that the the tension is so high that it can have these like really high Elation moments whereas in a game like and it this is a game that we both love it was our number one on our list Harvest I feel like there's not going to be those super high Elation moments even though we both clearly think it is an awesome game right right the randomization in that is just what buildings are coming out and then what uh Sunrise token are available and that is all that is up up to chance everything else you know at least you know what the options are and some other players might take your options so you might feel happiness or stress once you know what options are available to you on your turn based on what other players do but that is a game that I think even though we think that is a stellar game I don't think it is going to hit those High High highs that kelp might have but at the same time and you I think are like obviously a great sport

about it there are going to be be people who are super upset as the shark to have lost that way in kelp and I don't think it's necessarily Justified because you especially like you should know like that was a risk they took but they did put themselves like they played and put themselves in a position where they had that chance right like that is part of the game is you play to that level of luck and I think that so this discussion uh paired with a listener question that I I want to get to here in just a little bit is what had me thinking about battl Star Galactica um which is one of the more Infamous games to have like a critical dice roll in it uh the only other one that I think of at quite that level is oath both of which have a dice roll that can trigger the end of the game or like come at a very critical moment and there one of my favorite ways of accounting for uh for luck especially when it comes to dice is modifiers you know Dungeons and Dragons has that all the time if you have a strength stat that gives you plus three and you roll a D20 and then you add three to it or you know whatever whatever you're rolling um that was really good for somebody who doesn't play D and D that was really spot on okay there you there there you go um and

so in Battle Star Galactica uh famously uh you have to make these jumps uh which you can either fill up a gauge to be able to do this uh predictably without any risk or you can do it early with greater and greater risk uh which can be offset um you you have to be able to meet a certain threshold but then at that point you're taking a risk if you do it um and sometimes you just got to take that risk and that may be the difference between Victory or defeat and you roll a d8 to determine if you you know succeeded in the outcome and a lot of people would say I hate that my game came down to a dice roll but I don't honestly believe that it came down to a dice roll that dice roll is just the culmination of all the decisions that led up to that and the risks that you chose to take right up until that point or or the decisions that um LED you to believe that it was safe or not safe to do the previous dice roll um oath has a game ending which might come as a result of a dice roll and as you go through later and later rounds that dice roll is more likely to end the game and I saw as soon as the rule book came out for that you know people were talking about like oh my

game can end because of a dice roll that's totally lame it's like no you understand the risk as long as people are aware of what the random elements can bring and there are ways to work around those elements then that is to me an acceptable level uh of uh randomization in a game and this made me think of Battle Star Galactica so much that just back here I bought unfathomable uh oh yeah because I was like oh well I've been meaning to play that game and I got John coming to town I'll just play the the new adaptation of BSG in you know a a public domain setting uh with him that'll be great um real quick all right dice or cards which do you prefer when it comes to random elements um cards I think they give you a higher level of customiz customization like I mean I think that's the uh Isaac GIS in his designer diary for gloom Haven was like cards just give you so many more things that you can pull where you know you can know the odds and you can change them in a way that you can't really do with dice in a lot of ways so settlers a Katan at one point you could buy a set of cards that was the 36 possible outcomes for the dice but that way it made sure that there was an Eva distribution of you know like because in

K that you have the Pips that tell you how frequently you're going to roll a three based off of two dice or whatever but because that's randomization like just because something happened in the past doesn't mean that you're guaranteed to have something happen in the future which is a a gross misunderstanding of how randomization and and luck works and why some people are like how can we have rolled three threes how can that be possible well that's that's because that's how statistics and randomization in the universe works when you are individually doing you know like a a a dice roll but oh yeah yeah the cops are coming for me the randomization cops are coming for me I'm about to bring a hot take after you after you you feel free to finish would the would you feel better about a set of 36 cards or would you rather the dice and K there I think the cards bring a much different element where you are trying to predict what's coming out and you can then make decisions based on it where it's like okay I know that we haven't really pulled many fours I was between building either on an eight which has been pulled a couple times in a four uh I think that changes the game uh pretty substantial amount I think that with Katan the the luck is the game in a way where it's the whole point is

you don't have a solid frame of mind of what is going to come next so you don't know that you're likely to get a sheep in the next few rounds so you won't trade for sheep and I feel like that changes the game entirely from a so social uh negotiation game to a uh much more of a probability based strategy game yeah um I yeah I I think that that takes away from what the uh what Katon is aiming to do like the whole point of Katon is that there is this Randomness that you can't control and that's a lot of games have that in a way that works and then some games have it in a way that does not work um that would probably benefit from that card okay continuing lightning round DND D guy over here role player would you prefer a game that has a D20 with a modifier system or would you rather a game that uses multiple d6s so that way you have a nice Bell curve of outcomes where you're much more likely to have a a median you know probability Center uh as opposed to having a D20 which is equal potential outcomes of all of those and then just

Supply a modifier uh I think that it depends on the role playing game you're playing with Dungeons and Dragons it makes so much more sense to have it be this random chaotic thing that you can control via your modifiers and Via other abilities that will let you roll things um I think that for games that have a lot more a lot less Randomness in terms of what's Happening uh especially with your average DND campaign uh I think having it be like you roll 3d6 so that you are much more likely to roll this number you have the chance of rolling 18 you have the chance of rolling just three but almost certainly you're rolling uh I think on average for that it would be 10 or like 9 and a half uh it would be 11 and a half um as far as my experience with balers Gate 3 I'm pretty sure that a singular dice has the potential of being cursed and just constantly effing me over whereas I'm much more trustful of the homogenized group of dice yeah well and I've played role playing games that do have the you're rolling mul Dice and it's just whatever ends up being is as much more likely to be a am amicable result and I think that can work I think it just depends on what game you're playing um I think we there are some games where it

just feeling more in control of the luck would make it a whole heck of a lot better um one example and we have it as a viewer question so I feel like this is a good time to transition into our viewer questions uh this is from Flippin 7 to1 uh luck mechanics in games are sometimes brought up as something negative especially in regards of older games like Monopoly uh as a way to distance yourself from normal people not being in the hobby so it's used as like a oh I hate Monopoly cuz it's all luck dependent and it feels very gatekeeping with that said what is your take on how the luck mechanic has evolved since the 880s in '90s uh they have a couple examples there my immediate thought is game designers have gotten a lot more aware that people prefer to have control they want luck to change things you want luck to change how the game state is at the moment but you want players to know what outcome will happen when they take an action or at least feel like they are they know the probability thing how things are going to happen uh I think Monopoly is a really good example of a game that could probably do with a little

less luck uh but that is also like I I mean that is the game again again that it that like that is the game yeah and you know like Monopoly gets a lot of crap but at the same time there are so many house rules that people have baked into Monopoly you know like a lot of people's perception of Monopoly is what they played as a kid where you know them and their siblings were making free park and give you a billion dollars and then it's just a complete horrifying nightmare after one person landed on free parking there are a lot of outcomes that are actually in the game that feel punitive based off of the the luck of the role but I do think that even for an early game Monopoly does a lot of things right yeah you know like you have two dice so you have that bell curve of potential outcome so you can kind of have a a predictability of how many spaces about you're going to move um the the card draws uh are not too um uh intrusive as far as you know when you're getting Rewards or slight punishments um probably the most punitive thing is going to jail or landing on someone else's property but landing on someone else's property is after they've taken the time to invest in what the best possible properties are I think a lot of people's distrust a monopoly if they are

past that you know house rule stage is you know like Monopoly is just a mean game it's the combination of luck and meanness like that that feels exceptionally bad to have both bad luck and for someone else to really be sticking it to you that's when you know like it feels like you want to over throw a table um but yeah I I like you said accountability um being able to mitigate luck there are so many more uh times in which uh you can have rolls or you know take alternate paths uh or you know add modifiers to things that are just baked into pretty much every game at this point um and I think the uh potential negatives of um a mandatory lucky thing are not as bad as they once were you know you don't have as many games with skip a turn uh because some bad thing happened like that just sucks like oh well guess we go now yeah I think or or if you roll bad you get some sort of Kickback now it's not like you know like a a good example is uh Kora is a game that I have that you have to roll dice and you want the dice to be as high as possible but at the same time you do get

a little bit of a kickback if you roll poorly and you get priority over other players and I think that's perfectly fine you know designers are just smartly approaching what are the things that people feel bad about as a consequence of luck and how do we soften that blow yeah I think with Monopoly just as an example uh I think there are things you could do to mitigate the luck in a way that would make it more similar to Modern board games but like Monopoly is such a stronghold in terms of this is such an approachable game you this is because it's very luck dependent it some people are going to be better at the negotiation part of it just based on Charisma but like a lot of people have chances to win this in a way that a lot of other games there are not uh I had a PowerPoint night a while ago where I was talking about how to fix Monopoly in like a silly way uh and the the end result was I suggested you have people uh all property is automatically started as bidding instead of it's does the person not buy it uh so that property values are more in the airor uh and instead of dice you have a deck of cards numbered one through six that's

like a whole bunch of them you have a hand of three and you play two of them and then you draw to you refill so your options are still limited but it's still a little random of like I have three sixes so I'm going 12 spaces uh but I think that that just crushes What Monopoly is meant to be right and that kind of brings it back to what I was talking about at the very beginning which is you know like you want to to judge a game on what it's aspiring to be and what it delivers and what its strengths are you know as as a game itself uh rather than um purely evaluating on like what is your own Sweet Spot um the the next uh question I I think kind of puts the the uh nail to the Head uh if that's even a metaphor um uh to uh what we were talking about this whole podcast you know I I want to say this is Virgil lighter Vil aliri Virgil aliri 7192 there there you go got come on viril aliri uh most people in the hobby don't like very luck filled games because they like to still feel as if they're making decisions if you could

only choose one would you rather play only no luck games or only medium luck games I think I know the answer for both of us which is medium luck games I am terrible at chess because I haven't invested the time to get good at it I don't want to play it like I I think and and even if I got really good at it I don't want to play those kinds of games because a lot of people don't want to you know like have that and even if I'm winning every single game more than that I want people to play with me in the games that I like to play so you know I want things that make people feel like they have a chance and like they're having fun and like epic moments are happening yeah no luck games have their place yeah I do like that but you need a dedicated person ideally who is about your skill level to continually invest in that it requires a level investment to really get the most out of those games and I that's just not the gaming I do yeah I agree I think that there's just so much of gaming that luck brings so much more positive than negative most of the time right not all of the time but most of the time luck is bringing something that either helps people play the games more helps replayability where it's like you trying

to set up a perfect engine with just whatever happens to be in your hands like I think that's why games like race for the Galaxy are so awesome it's you don't know what you're getting and you have to just this is what you have this is what you're starting with and that the randomness of that is so much of the fun of the game totally um so medium luck game all the way um and that that brings us to our last one why don't you go ahead and read Carl Robinson's here Carl Robinson says what are your thoughts on games that feature negative emotions for overall positive experiences what is the game that you experience the most negative emotions during playing but still love so this is this is the one that made me think about Battlestar Galactica as well because it it's a game I have a real hard time lying um it's something that gives me a lot of anxiety but at the same time it's kind of like a horror movie I love horror movies they give me a lot of anxiety I'm not one of those people who's like oh I love horror movies they don't scare me at all they freak me the F out but I like that feeling and the same thing is true in games uh with um that sort of social deduction element or trying to play a long con and you're just praying you don't get found out and nowhere is that more palpable than in something like uh

Battlestar Galactica and hopefully unfathomable which I picked up because I was like man I I want that feeling again and it's it gives me anxiety it gives me dread uh and also there's that paranoia element that the person that you're having to trust you are forced to make a decision am I going to trust the person next to me knowing full well you don't have perfect information that they for sure are the person and that trust can be broken and maybe other people don't feel that as palpably as I do but that that is a a really powerful feeling um and part of the Thematic Resonance of uh battl Star Galactica um the original design and I'm certain is is replicated here is that you are forced into these situations that uh bring about very negative feelings yeah well and I think that we touched on this earlier but stress is such a strong motivator for games stress is tension stress is trying to figure out the best possible solution but you just can't not be sure that is like the core feeling for a good

chunk of games that are awesome and I think that there's even if it's like not analysis paralysis type stress if it's more just like oh we have to do this thing really quickly like kitchen Rush is a is a stressful game yeah but that is totally so much fun because it's stressful um I think that there are other emotions that I don't necessarily think I would say I've ever felt the full brunt of like most of the times those things are just stress like I don't know if I've ever felt fear during a game like I felt like real tension of oh is this going to work out or not like but I don't know if I would necessarily say that's fear um yeah it this question also brought to mind um something that we don't really explore that much uh in games though certainly it has been touched upon um is uh like sensitive subject matter uh because gaming by default we tend to think especially board games because a lot of people have this notion uh associating them to Childhood and so they should be friendly and light and fun even if they're combative they should be somewhat fluffy um video games had this as well but I think video games have matured and kind of divorced itself from you know like

the need to stay away from sensitive subject matter um but like really sensitive game topics uh particularly in historical games um I'm thinking of Freedom the Underground Railroad for example uh incredibly weighty topic uh fully Cooperative game uh and I don't know that I've really felt anything quite as powerful in a board game uh in the same way the at like an emotional level as having to evaluate how much time I was going to put into um like trying to Rally politicians knowing that that is taking money away from direct intervention and watching the cubes accumulate at the top of the board as lost slaves you know recaptured slaves and recognizing that this money has to be spent on all sorts of things this money has to get the politicians to pass um you know like certain acts I have to do lobbying but that's also resources that could be allocated to other things and just seeing that in such a visceral level was like oh ho whoa um to be honest I have immense respect for that that game but it bummed me out to the point where I'm like I'm so glad that I

played that I don't need to own Freedom Underground Railroad um I think every student should play this game um I don't need to own this uh I think this war of mine uh the the board game adaptation of that uh touches on some very similar things and I think more and more historical games are starting to explore a space uh of where uh you're looking at uh oppressed people um you know like uh intersectionality between uh Fringe groups uh having uh the different uh oppressors uh I'm thinking of like block by block is another great example of this um Molly house uh with you know the kind of like uncelebrated and unrecognized and mainstream art uh America at least uh long-standing history of um uh of lgbtq uh uh peoples in uh in Britain in the Victorian age you know like that's touching on some real heavy subjects but also I think the best of those are trying to present it in some way that you can also kind of have fun with a degree of respect for it too so I don't know I really like seeing it in games when there's emotionally weighty stuff

but it is kind of guilty to be like sometimes I want those to be like maybe not too in my face cuz I like having my like popcorn you know Feelgood game yeah I mean I I guess for me and I actually have not played the board game adaptation of it but I love this war of mine even though it is such a sad game like that is such a sad topic where it's all of the decisions you make feel so much more weighty than I think most other games because there is so much emotion attached to it and I really love that video game so I'm sure I would also love the board game adaptation cuz I feel it's great reviews from everything I've seen um I you like it it sounds like um I'm I might have to uh try and find do a little peie yeah do a little pie see if you get a copy I hear it's great solo uh so you know there there there you go um well yeah so I think that's kind of my thoughts on you know negative emotions in games I think that there's a there's a place for it yeah I I think there's a place where I think mechanically uh evoking certain emotions through the the pressures the mechanics um can be really interesting and I think you really hit it with uh uh

like pressure tension um to feel pressure is to feel that adrenaline rush and a degree of anxiety um yeah everyone's going to react to that different but you want to feel uh some sort of pressure in almost any game that you're playing that's why people come to games but uh also thematically weighty topics uh I I think there's so much more room to uh explore um themes uh but also relationships of players to one another and what we evoke in one another and the types of interactions that we have so I don't know games are cool there's lots of games out there we should play them we should and I think that there's uh you know there's a space for negative emotions and there's also a space for luck and that I think is a great way to wrap up this podcast um well where can people uh contact us uh yeah if you have any questions about anything we're going to start trying to post V roughly what topic we're going to be talking about the day of so please find us on our YouTube channel uh the cardboard Herald if that is not where you're currently listening to us uh uh you can also email in questions at uh cardboard Herald gmail.com uh or shoot us a message on

any of the socials we're on are we on socials we're on some socials generally if you're on a social you can find us there we're pretty much sticking to like blue sky and Instagram right now is where we're posting the most of our stuff um but us there you can also just find the website cardboard herald.com and there's there's a contact us there too yeah uh let us know any questions you have we would love to answer them thank you so much for tuning in to this edition of the cardboard heral podcast I am Eric and I'm Jack thank you for being an awesome community and we hope you have a good rest of your day

Progress saved