Wayfarers of the South Tigris - Board Game Review - Don't Make Me Choose!
Transcript
thank you hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences we'll get on with the show in just a minute but first a quick word for my sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kiander.co.uk kiander stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on audra's over 30 pound further discounts on bulk purchases and even five percent of your spending refunded bacteria's points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get five percent discount on your first order over 60 pounds so let's make gaps in your collection a thing of the past get down to kinder and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so today I'm talking about Wayfarers of the South Tigris man if we'd be waiting a long time for this one ah the joys of Kickstarter deliveries the UK is always one of the last ones to get anything these days and so whilst other people have been getting Wayfarers and playing with it I've had to wait impatiently for the postman to bring it to my place okay yes I've played it a few times on tabletop simulator already but you want the physical copy don't you that's what you want but finally it's here I've given it more plays including the solo mode which I'll do in a separate little video but now I can finally give my full thoughts on it so as a little background yeah I've talked a lot about Garfield games in the past okay I love Raiders and all C it's in my top 100 I love
Architects otherwise Kingdom it's probably my favorite game they've done it's in my top 100 obviously I also love VI counts of the West Kingdom again top 100 pretty much neck and neck with Architects I love their games granted I burned out a bit on paladins hence I've mentioned it on a couple of recent top tens I've not played ship rights but frankly I don't think I hear anybody talk greatly at that one but also explorers I've never played however as a little treat hello I have it now I decided to like I got sick and tired of everybody telling me to play Explorer so it's like fine I had some credit and find Sticky under I've managed to get myself a copy of explorers in the North Sea so at some point maybe nearer to Christmas or in the New Year I'll be able to get this played and give some thoughts on that but yes I'm intrigued to play it just as much as I'm sure you are of hearing me talk about it so we had North Sea we had West Kingdom so continuing around the campus we've got South Tigris I think that's how you pronounce it it's not Tigris and if we're going to go by the previous pedigree from the last series Architects was my favorite of those free so could this one be my favorite of this three well we'll have to find out because it's gonna be a while before we see the other the other two but you know this one I was definitely excited to get this is definitely a much more card based one compared to a lot of the others because a lot of this game revolves around getting cards with tags on them so I think what we had from art Nova terraforming Mars you know getting the icons on the cards and using them to power other things but essentially what you have is you have a display board with a ton of cards surrounding it this is the journal Track event essentially and there's a couple of bolt-ons to the
end as well but what you're doing mainly during the game is acquiring cards which are set around the edge of this board and moving your Journal marker along this journal track here in order to get various bonuses but also to trigger the end of the game which is the first person to reach the end of the journal track the cards come in various different guises and these aren't all sleet because I've only just had my new sleeves arrived today but you've got for example C cards so you've got C like harbors and harbors and oceans in here which can get you immediate bonuses they can get you more dice placement actions but then you've also got the land card so if you don't want to go to Sea you can go on land instead a whole bunch of cards for those and these again will give you Dice placement spots but potentially some ongoing bonuses like every time you collect a certain card you get another bonus but then of course it wouldn't be a Garfield game if you didn't have townspokes so in the green category you've got townsfolk and these towns folk do what you thought they would do they boost actions that you already do you slide them underneath other cards and when you trigger the card you trigger the townsfolk I already love this from The Architects with The Artisans expansion and that I love it here as well but it's more townsfolk always gotta love those uh that's the solo mode we'll get onto those the inspiration cards which are a sort of me subset of cards these basically allow you to gain extra points for space cards if you fulfill the condition and the space cards well they go above all your other cards or your other land and Seed cards and they've got comets stars planets and various in-game scoring bonuses like one point for every Harbor one point for every black tile one point
for every Comet symbol you know that kind of thing there's another cards quite a few and what you're essentially doing is building a panorama on your board so you start off with a board like this and then on this side you're building the land cards on this side you build the C cards and then above those cards you build the space cards and above the space cards you build the inspiration cards it's a lot of cards I'm going to be saying that word a lot in this video but the idea your being that as you build up this display of cards you'll unlock more dice placement actions for you to do and you'll acquire more tags which enable you to get victory points in the end but also give you access to other cards or more stuff to move along the journal track your turn is essentially pretty straightforward you either place a die which is Dice that you roll a starter around and the value is not well the value is important sort of basically the dice placement spots require sometimes a symbol like a camel or a pigeon or a boat or so and you've got a little chart at the top here which tells you what symbols appear on the various dice but to begin with your dice don't do a lot what you do is that you acquire these upgrade tiles as part of your actions and you build your little Caravan like so and so that you give the dice other effects and other symbols sorry the light is glaring a little bit from there but hopefully the photos will do justice if nothing else and so you can build this up like a little mini polyamino game but you can also place a worker out place the worker around the cards and you know there's actions on each of these cards above them so it's like oh I don't want to trigger I don't want to get a car but I do want to trigger this particular action all right fine I'm
going to place a worker out on might I need the right color so blue in this case you put it on the card directly so for example let's say I don't know for argument's sake I need I need a towel smoke can I borrow a town so please so there's a Town's folk up here I want to do this action with a worker and there we go green worker you place it on the card meaning that if somebody else comes and takes the card they take the workers off it you start with a worker of blue and yellow but they become public currency once you've put them out in play that just sounds like slavery with extra steps someone's gonna get laid in college there's a lot in this game it's quite a mammoth for sure but that's a general overview you acquire these cards you place the workers you come you make loads of different combos Shenanigans with your dice but at the main part you are trying to journal along this track and until you get to the end at which point trigger the end game for everybody getting the last turn and of course total up all the points and the one with the most of course yeah that took a little bit to get through that uh that overview but that is you know credit to the game there's a lot going on this is definitely one of those games that gives you a lot of options there's a reasonable amount of rules overhead but not as much as you might think because a lot of the cards function very similarly I mean the C cards and the land cards function almost identical apart from just what sort of effects they might have the towns vote straightforward you shove them under a card and they boost the card that's under not much to teach on there apart from how you acquire them the space cards and the inspiration cards need a little bit more exploration
but again you know once you're used to one set of cards it doesn't take long to get used to the the others the idea of collecting symbols on cards is relatively intuitive as well and if you've played those games I mentioned Arc Nova and terraforming Mars this kind of thing is kind of you know second nature to you but also and credit where it's due Garfield game teams are very consistent with their iconography and their graphic design no change here if you're used to their other games you will pick this up very easily not like super easy but it will it will alleviate a lot of the burden if you're already used to the symbology they use because there definitely is some rinse repeat here as well as the new stuff but again because you know how their other games play you'll get into this one quite well now that being said I wouldn't recommend this to anybody who's not seen A Garfield game before you really might want to jump into something a little bit simpler like Architects or Raiders or as far as I've heard explorers is relatively simple you might want to check those out first jumping into this one first is um kind of like jumping into advanced mode this is definitely one of the heavier titles they've put out I don't know if it's quite as heavy in thinking as paladins the West Kingdom but it ain't far off it's getting to that point there's definitely more thinking you have to do in this one than Architects by far and I'd say more thinking in this one than my accounts even in that one wasn't exactly a lightweight shall we say so it's not necessarily that the rules are complicated but you have a lot of options you have like all these cards to go after but this is just part of the
board okay so these are player boards here's the other sides to it so you've got you know the side here which is guilt which has the guilds and the other actions on it and I forgot to mention guilds that basically you put the influence on them they allow you to do stuff and there's points at the end but they're pretty minor it's a minor addition but then you've also got the other side of the journal track here so this is the whole track right four cards four cards four cards four cards four cards on face up display that's not even including like drawing from the deck in certain instances wow um you have another choices oh yeah that was that was just the cards oh stupid of me I forgot about the four worker spaces for you know the coin this one doesn't have worker spaces you're right there but for worker spaces for worker spaces for worker spaces for worker spaces so you have got somewhere in the region of about 20 cards to pick from and about 16 worker spaces and that's not even including the like the dice placement actions I mean you can't just acquire a card of your choice you have to use an action to get the card but you're looking at all these cards deciding which one you might want but then you're also looking at the tiles that you might want which there's a bunch of those you're looking at all the dice actions you've got on your board and like oh how do I do these oh no I've gone cross-eyed the amount you've got to contend with in this game from a thinking level is pretty high however that's a good thing this game really does take a lot of boxes for me in terms of giving me all the options in the world but not making it stupidly complicated in order to decipher each one it's a case of look I know the song
the thing I'm after this is what I'm kind of focusing on and ideally you ought to focus in one area and not try to diversify too much but it's just one of those games where it's like each of the choices I have is not stupidly complicated it's just the case of wow all the choices what do I do which path do I go down what's a good tactical opportunity because you might be thinking well I need to aim for these particular cards but then you see another card come out and you're like oh that looks juicy I fancy a little bit of that what you think this geek don't ever do that again but with all this thinking comes at Hefty cost the cost being the length this box quotes 60 to 90 minutes on it I don't think so I really don't think so that is a bow face lie it's a massive lie two players you can get this done in about 90 minutes fine 60 to 90 minutes is doable but three players in 90 minutes that's touch and go four players in 90 minutes physically impossible never have I seen or played a four player game of this where it went to anywhere close to 90 minutes and I'm not even including the setup and teach setup takes a while because you've got all those different cards to shuffle and put out you've got all the different you know various tiles to lay out on various Stacks then you've got all your player pieces and that so setup's quite a bit of a tour already there's a fair amount to teach you know there's a decent amount of rules overhead in this and then you're expected to do this in 90
minutes before it is not gonna happen there is just way too much going on too much happening on turns too much thinking time I mean there's only so much you can plan ahead for because the card States will change quite frequently not to mention workers will come and go and all this sort of stuff so you can't plan five turns ahead like you could in certain other games so there will be a lot of analysis paralysis that this game can generate and certainly just the thinking time alone is going to extend This Way Beyond 90 minutes four player games of this where you've got new players can take this to two and a half to three hours it really does go that long now I'm having fun during that time but man that is long that is quite long I usually only want to play this at Max 3 players now because I know the length's gonna be crazy unless I trust implicitly that people I'm playing with certainly if I can play this two player hello great you know love it although the cards don't cycle as much in the two player as they would in the four player but then again you might think that four players a bit too chaotic so you know six of one half a dozen of the other but wow yeah um 60 to 90 minutes no I mean that is a 60 to 90 minutes bear in mind it's one to four players right so they are basically assuming that 60 is with one player 70 is with two eighties with three 90 is with four if you go relative linear progression through that time length it's trying to tell you that it's 10 minutes a player that's very unlikely now with the player scaling the two to three four players
other than the length works fairly similarly you have a certain amount of tiles depending on player account you always have the same amount of cards out it's just with less players the cards don't cycle as much because there's only two of you buying cars as opposed to four but even so in two players I've never found that the decks were that stagnant except for maybe the inspiration and the space cards those ones unlike this side of the board do tend to stagnate a bit but the land card the town folk and the C cards they tend to cycle relatively quickly because they're the ones that are getting bought more often than all the others so even a two player is not too bad but yes if you want the cards to cycle more you're gonna need more players or you could just house rule some effect that maybe after so many rounds or every time somebody rests um the card cycle a little bit I mean it's not in the rule book but you could easily house rule something like that in there but honestly yeah the game scales fairly well except for the length part as mentioned earlier the rule book itself as I mentioned there's a fair bit of overhead it but I actually found this rulebook to be better than some of the ones in the past the iconography is all on the back of the book so you know as much as I would have liked to reference a for each player it's nice that I've only got to turn to the back of the book to find all the important iconography and for the most part the iconography yes there's a lot but it's pretty intuitive I mean you know what what different cards are what well look at the color I mean if you're colorblind that's going to cause a bit of a problem but you know otherwise you've got the different upgrade tiles they've got pictures on it which is kind of weird actually the upgrade tiles have got pictures on to differentiate for color blindness but the cards don't it's kind
of odd but I digress and then everything else is mainly just the different tags which again you will get used to I didn't have a problem understanding the iconography in this but then I have played a lot of Garfield game stuff before but even the rules in here I found to be relatively easy to follow I didn't really have many if any FAQ moments where I'm like I have no idea how that works let me just have a look up here you know there may be one or two edge cases like they have been in the past where a particular scenario is a little bit harder to find than you would like but as I read through the book I managed to understand the rules for this reasonably well although it does teach you the game in slightly a weird angle here because it basically spends ages going through all the different things like journaling and influence in the water and land and space cards and inspiration cards and how you acquire cards and townspoken upgrade tiles and you're halfway through the book before you get to player turns um uh turn it around please yeah uh if I'm teaching this game you teach people player turns first you know like placing a die and placing a worker you know or resting you do those first then you go to the concepts and the various things like the types of cards and that it it sort of teaches you a little bit back to front but honestly if you just skip ahead to play our turns and then come back a bit you'll be fine but honestly yeah I didn't have many problems at all with the robot you do have to put up with a little bit of a luck aspect with this game as well though in the other games there have been occasional times where you draw crew that you don't want for your ship or you know the buildings
you draw aren't necessarily the ones you want Etc so there's always been a little bit of a luck factor in the Garfield game series here there's a bit more because you could be hunting for specific tags or specific things that you want on the cards and they just don't turn up you have a couple of ways in order to look through the top three cards and choose one but I've had times where I've tried to find a library symbol and I've looked three times in the top three cards of the deck and never found one it can just like fizzle out for you and that's pretty punishing because at some point you have to decide to skip it and go elsewhere but you might not be able to because that might be the last thing you need to journal across to the next section and if you can't find a symbol it kind of screws you up a bit and in a two and a half to three hour version of the game that's annoyingly punishing but you know on top of that though you've also got the lack of what inspiration cards could come out and when you know I might have been Gathering a ton of Harbor cards great I've got a bunch of Harbor cards I'm saving up those tanks for points and then I grab an inspiration card the last one I can fit and it's like I gotta work a little bit for it but it's doable we'll go for it and then the one that comes out afterwards requires five of the tags that I've already got five for and I can't replace the card oh great so again luck of the draw influences a little bit there and then of course dice yes you have some dice mitigation yes you can grab upgrade tiles that let you add one to the die roll you the yellow Guild allows you to manipulate dye value so there is some mitigation a decent amount of it but you could still roll three sixes never in my case but you
could still roll three sixes when you really wanted a bunch of low numbers and the dice don't wrap maybe the house rule should be that they do rap I don't know but you could roll dice like five dice you could end up by the end of the game and you could still just not roll the numbers that you want that's another thing that can hold you at times you're gonna have to get used to this with this game certainly more than I'd say a couple of the other games in the past there is definitely a bit of a luck factor with all the different decks of cards and the fact that you're a rolling dice so that's going to put you off you might want to hold back maybe try before you buy in a sense for me it's there and in a smaller player count I don't mind so much because I'm just enjoying all the smorgasborder options that I've got but it has affected me at times where the luck has just punched me out of the game when I didn't want it to and that is a little irritation I wish there was maybe just a bit less of it Wayfarers for me is another Smash Hit frankly I love the gameplay options in this I love the card play I love the different like past the victory I can take focus on the card diversify a little bit which type of card get more towels where get the space get the inspiration grab a bunch of upgrade tiles or maybe leave them B focus on the workers and uh go Journal as fast I can Journal a bit slower there's a lot of great things I love about the gameplay in this I like the fact that it wasn't too difficult to learn despite the overhead of rules although granted I might be slightly biased on that because I've played a lot of Garfield game stuff before I say if you're brand new to Garfield games then
this sort of series don't start with this one start with a different one like maybe Raiders in the North Sea but if you're familiar with the games you're gonna pick this up pretty well you've got a little bit of variety with a journal board but you've got so much variety with the cards you've actually got an insert to speak of even if it's not perfect it's still that's like better than it used to be and you've got a lot of options with the cards I mean if you're going to expand this just give me more cards that's all I care about I don't think it needs any more mechanics on top but the negatives are big negatives in some respects four player games and this are gonna take a while the setup is quite long and certainly you're gonna have to accept the fact that there is an element of luck with the card draw and the fact that you're rolling dice if this is a problem for you then you might want to stay away for me it is a problem but it's only enough to knock it down a point it's not enough to knock it down a full point and I really enjoyed this at two I really enjoyed as a free I still enjoy my time at four I still think it's too long at four at times but I'm still enjoying myself it's not like I'm sat there like wishing the game would hurry up and end I wish somebody would hurry up and take their turn and get back around to me but I'm still thinking about all my options and enjoying what I'm doing so that is a caveat it is a floor but it's not enough to knock the game to too much where do I rank this with the other Garfield games I don't think it's anywhere near quite as close as architects of West Kingdom I think that one Just Hits and ticks every box VI counts I think I prefer VI counts
to this one for the the rondelle and the card mechanic do I prefer this to Raiders though I I would probably say I do prefer this to Raiders of the North Sea so it's definitely fitting maybe as my third favorite of the Garfield game series at the moment maybe it can fight for second place I don't think it's ever going to be my favorite but hey you know these are four games that I put in my top 100 so uh if with your first second third or fourth you should be proud I think overall I'm giving Wayfarers to the South Tigris and nine out of ten it is an excellent game can't quite meet 10 out of 10 though for those flaws I've mentioned and certainly for some of you some of the flaws might actually be more of a burden so you do need to bear in mind the length the you know the overhead of rules and also the potential luck Factor that's in the game but for me you know they they are niggles and it does drop it down a point but it's not enough of a problem to drop it down past the distinction Mark I think this is still just another great fun game from them I think it's just very enjoyable very cool for someone like me that like say a kind of semi-strategy used to have a tactical feel for a Euro game with a smorgasbord of options to pick from it's the type of Bureau that works for me definitely heavier than the usual fare definitely more Binky and I would say out of the four that I've got yeah this is definitely the thinkiest out of those four that I mentioned of Raiders architects of icons and this one is definitely the thinkiest probably maybe not as much as paladins but it's not far off to be honest it's just a really solid game so that's it for me on this
episode of the broken meeple if you like what you see remember please thumb up the video here and thumb it up on Board Game Geek when you see it it'd be great if this could appear in hot reviews one day probably will never happen but hey I Can Dream but also I want to hear your comments down below rank the six Garfield games of the series The North series and the West Kingdom series and this one and that's seven games not six even you know what am I about to get in explorers do I have something to look forward to am I missing out on ship rights or was that really the sort of black sheep of the family in a sense and of course Phil stop telling me how wrong I am about paladins okay paladins is my weak link of the last Trilogy deal with it okay I still respect it all right I don't hate the game I just don't like it as much as Architects and by counts okay calm down man the amount of fact I was getting for that on the last couple of live streams but that being said I want to hear your comments down below about this game about the other Garfield games you're looking forward to Scholars let me know your thoughts so until next time you can check out more content on the channel including the recent beyond the base game videos I've done for Meadow Downstream and frantic themes for caverna one of them is a solid expansion the other one not so much have a guess which way around they go so until next time remember as always regardless of which way you're sailing north south east or west it's still only a game bye for now that just sounds like slavery with extra steps