Skip to main content
Loading video...

GenCon Recap: John Company as an RPG?

Transcript 28:46

hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Sal here and I just wanted to record a fun little follow-up conversation with non-breaking space uh about a game of John company that we played while at Gen Con so NB do you want to give everybody the rundown in case people weren't listening to the podcast or watching us tweet about this yeah sure so um a little while ago I was been working on this sort of RPG journaling RPG game um that was played on like on top of a standard game of John company and like it really just sort of focuses on looking and exploring what it meant for the families by giving them sort of a bit of agency to tell their story through the game um and giving players the opportunity to really reflect on what the Dynamics and mechanics of the game how they're sort of coming from the personalities that are in these families and so um it was a bit of a experimental go to see if it would all come together and um I must say that I was very pleased with the results yeah I admit I was very nervous before playing because I'm not a great John company player and it been a long time since I'd played uh so I you know I was like okay I don't know how to do this math I'm going to look like an idiot in front of CW and it turns this is a live place it's like a whole room of people but actually end up being a wonderful experience I think because of the RPG elements that got introduced into the game yeah like I think that it was it was fun sort of watching

Everybody approaching like this is like me as the designer facilitating and like just watching it's the joy of like an RPG experience as well because you get to see how everybody's just going to approach it and how the what level of immersion everybody goes into and so one of the most amazing thing watching was just like by everybody's like 15 20 minutes in like after writing that first everybody writes their first letter it's like all in you know it's like so everybody just sort of slowly um dipping into the madness that is their family and trying to like pull it all together and like just being able to watch that happen um really was just yeah it was it was it was fun to see yeah I felt like this was like a commit or go home kind of event and I'm really glad that we all chose like the commit so um for people who are curious about how this actually felt to play basically it was a normal game of John company but every member of the family introduced there was like a character sheet for their specific Cameo and you gave them a name and a birthday and you put them on a family tree in relationship to other family members and then you also um assigned them stats so they had braw so sort of like military Readiness like wi Charisma and what was the other one um finesse finesse there we go yeah I lacked it so that's why I wouldn't remember um but you know what's funny is that these these stats had nothing to do with actual gaml player die results they

did however I think make us embody our family members in different ways and I know that I made in-game choices that I thought were fitting for the family members that I had created yeah I think that's like one of the like it's funny like the stats at one point they're completely meaningless right they have absolutely no gameplay value at all but everybody leaned into to this is the St of this person and it and it just helped explain the actions that were happening to them in ways that you're just like oh yeah this is because of and I think like that's really one like just a subtle thing that was just beautiful to watch as well yeah I mean you're watching all of us so I assume that my behavior was actually probably typical for the other three people at the table as well yes yes yes everybody was on their own like everybody had their own character to it but everybody was it was a wonderful collective experience watching everybody just go deeper and deeper Madness um like just like in the corner just like going down the rabbit hole just like scribbling scribbling scri scribbling scribbling it was amazing you know um I think there was that one moment where I'm like so the way that I sort of facilitated it was that like Liz said there's character sheets and there's family trees and then I play the archist that's sort of just like keeping track of the dates and also I can prompt any of the players by handing them a piece of paper and telling them one of their characters is

going to write a letter and so um what I was going to refer to is like the one of the most amazing things was like me walking over with a piece of paper to hand a letter to Cole and he's like oh no no no I've already gotta I'm already working on this letter right now and so it's just like that just like cap like captured the whole experience altoe of just like everybody sort of really going at it and what it add into the game play I think was just amazing yeah so from the player perspective for those of you who want to know what this felt like basically there'd be a key moment in the game and andb would walk up to you and be like okay I want you to write a letter from ex-member of your family so we had all the names to either a number member of your family or to a member of somebody else's family and I want you to discuss X thing that just happened and so it could be something like you know I sent a bunch of my Military Officers to an area where the governor did then did not use them and so just complained about that for uh for a good while um or actually honestly I think my favorite was the unintentional Perfect story syncup of my like reluctant non-military inclined officer who somehow became governor and then had some horrible Governor roles and so he had to like make his excuses um it basically just brought so much life to things that were just strategically annoying before if that makes sense mhm mhm like yeah in terms of um stepping away from the math of it all and really into

like the the The Narrative of it all it's just yeah it's funny because I think when we were talking about it on the podcast I sort of alluded to it I'm like you know sometimes you just play something and you say that was cool and never do that again you know and that was not the like I was PR like I was prepared very much for this to be one of those experiences like okay that was all right just but I think it just really um it it affirmed in a way that I wasn't sure it was going to be possible because like the potential for fiddlin is there right it's like on the top it's just like this is like the most fiddly thing on a game that people don't necessarily think is the most streamlined of possible though it is pretty smooth of a game John company um adding something like this on top of it just being adding just like too fidly right um and that was the risk like that was the big thing that I was just testing the SE like I know what I wanted to be able to do but is it just too hard to do it I think Liz actually you've tested something for me before um you tested worker placement I did yeah and did you test it with a pencil yes right I think I did yeah yes I'm pretty sure you did so that was little GD yes so that's a another perfect example different type of game different scale Al together but just like testing the limits of it of like okay can I can I get to can I get players to actually do this with a pencil and immediately after that round of testing the pencil was gone it's never come back right like that's just

sort of like a that was cool it's never never gonna do that again and so this but I was open I was open to it yeah you know what was really funny is like there were moments where I was really stress but it was like I didn't know like what to name people or I didn't know what reasonable birthdays and ages might be honestly I think the one thing that would have made that game easier would be literally a cheat sheet that was like oh if you want to be this age pick a date in this range if want to be this age pick a date in this range and here are some typical men's and women's names at the time yeah I was going to do I wanted to do a random name generator just like it was just the time crunch got got to me but I think that's like one of the things that as I'm thinking about it and like okay I've got to do something else with this you know I've gotta like or not even that I have to do something else with it but more in terms of like okay I've gotta actually refine it and make it actually um repeatable right yes oh is things like that like name generator and like date like being able to manage the dates on your own and stuff like that because um yeah I think it just it's a it's a beautiful addition to playing John company and I think a lot of players that like the game like if you have a group that likes the game a lot I think it's just one of those experiences that um players are going to love like really enjoy having at least once that's like that's what it like I feel like that's you got to try at least once if you enjoy the game it's one of those things like oh man I want you to be able to try this at least once um yeah I gotta say I would absolutely do

that again I would do that over Discord well one thing that really made me laugh was that I don't know like there's the part I think that when you play games right like you're it's not that you want to impress your friends but you definitely don't want to embarrass yourself in front of your friends do you know what I mean but like it was like it gave me a different layer where I could be playing with people who are masterfully good at the game but still feel like I made a contribution by like writing a letter that made everybody laugh that was just like spot on to the situation do you know what I mean and like I remember really feeling the same way about other people's letters like I don't remember who wrote it and I don't think this is a quote that'll violate anybody's privacy and like the you know sanctity of the game but they were like talking about gossiping um gossip at a wedding yes and it was like oh yes the food was serviceable the dance appalling yeah yeah yeah and it was so great like it was it absolutely I felt like captured like that period piece Vibe and it was so funny and I just really enjoyed getting to appreciate other players at the table for that if that makes sense I think the thing that was even like like it was that added layer and then there were also like everybody was getting like everybody got the memo to get the hook in there that really like gave that attached the character to the actions that were happening in the game um and so it really like serves as a way of of like providing motivation right and like really being able to see the motivation not just like oh my di roll was this but

like oh we tried this because and it turned out you know like like this and like that that like was it was really just fun to see that on lay it on top of all of these like table talk you know it was basically like being able to put your own table talk on the record um throughout the game yeah it was also really funny because you could actually see little alliances forming in like the tones of the letters yes uh and what was very funny is that by breaking down the family different characters like I think carder and Drew both noted this is they had some members of their family who were friends and other members of their families who were not so it was like they were being two different like factions within their own side as a result of the role play yeah and it I think like the it's funny because we only did two turns but the level of intricate intricacies in the connections between the families and within the families in just those two turns was just like amazing you just like wow okay yeah I feel like um everybody understood the assignment yeah it was very good so the other aspect of this play though that I was actually not expecting at the time that I had agreed to do it and I mean I would have agreed anyway cuz if you asked me to do something going to do it so like whatever but um I didn't realize it was going to be a live playh so how did that aspect of the event meet

up with your expectations and then if you're going to do it live again what would you change to either help the audience engage more or help the players like what what could what could we have done differently and what we want well well yeah I think it's it's it's interesting because I think it really went rather well there was a lot of commentary from the crowd itself people like correcting rules and everything like that it was the best I'm like oh my gosh this is amazing and um like people stuck it stuck through the whole thing and people were still engaged at the end so I feel like there wasn't a lack of Engagement everybody understood they were coming to observe and not necessarily as a participation thing I think the challenge of like trying to make it participatory is just managing the the random number of people that are there right like you don't want to open the door for like a small section of people and like have another section of the people that's just like on the outside um and so I think that aspect like we don't we were talking about it then like there was it's it's very much a game that can be played as a team game where there's like multiple teams and people are taking on these different roles but to some degree how that scales is just really hard like as a as a person running the game I could just see that scaling in a way that's really hard to manage because you have to deal with so many people's different like different things and so um but I do think that like it would like I think one of the things that would could be

interesting and I actually thought about this later but I didn't try and do it was to have the audience reading the letters instead of me reading the letters right and I think that in that way they're getting to have that sort of touch and interaction with it as well um and seeing yeah yeah but I think that's like I think it's it's the type of thing that's that it's that type of a touch it's not like a um fully participatory just because it's just it would be really hard to manage I think like I'm not trying to say that I was doing hard work or anything like that but just like it's still it's one of those where in order to pull it together um there's a lot of like coordination that you have to be able to see and the more people actually complicates one of the actually one of the things that said when I was planning it with Cole was like I'm not going to do more than four people I'm not sure that it is even though the game goes up to six I'm not sure how well it will work at six because it's just too many right and like even it's too many and sort of too hard to manage the back and forth between everybody to be able to say like to be able to ensure that everybody's having a good experience right like that was I was I think that in the role that I played then I think I was able to manage and understand where everybody was in their experience enough to be able to ensure that everybody was having a good experience which is what I think the role of the game master is and so the more that you expand that out the harder that becomes yeah and I'm not

sure that that's something that you want to do because it'll detract from what's actually happening on the on the on the board one thing that I was really relieved about is you know in the podcast so those of you who don't know MB and I talked about this in a podcast a couple weeks ago so I'll put a link to that in the show notes um but I was you know oh how are we going to handle the fact that we're being kind of horrible and you know how are we going to role play that one thing I actually really enjoyed about this is that we actually I think felt safe enough including with an audience um because nobody was recording it because it was just really meant as experimental thing everybody was like I think the correct level of unhinged where it was like proper to the time um but you know we also all were like clued into the game and understood what was going on so there was like a freedom to explore even though sometimes like you'd read somebody's letter back and they're like oh God we all went for yes yeah yeah and I mean I think that's the that's the the key thing about RPGs in general is that it sort of is meant to be that safe space to explore not necessarily how you feel but like understand the motivations right and where those motivations can lead and I think that's the the goal isn't necessarily to put on a hat and be this character the goal is to understand who these characters are and how they interacted and um I think that's what yeah that's the assignment and I think

that's what everybody sort of understood and grasp yeah but I was like a very free space to kind of go for it and I really appreciate that so you know I don't play RPGs as much as I should and one of the reasons that I don't actually is I find them extremely revealing mhm and I have a hard time being that open with people like I struggle I think that the best the best of yourself at a tabletop RPG is like your most vulnerable and open self that's just really going for it and I sometimes hesitate and have a hard time really going for it which is why I will typically fault to board games instead um I'm just not willing always to be that raw but I felt like this worked I wonder if that's because of the split of characters where you're not trying to put everything into one or because you can't like identify yourself as just one you can just sort of see yourself through all of or see little pieces through all of them and that sort of creates a safer space to even Explore them I think that that may be it because I never felt like I was any particular one of them I felt like I was like telling a story with them in a little bit more of a distant way and I think that actually did help quite a bit I think that's one of the other things that was really interested for me is just in terms of as a designer and designing things it was another like one like Wonder and question of like okay is this an experience that players can handle you know like you have to manage all your characters and put them on a family tree and say who's related to Who

as a part of a game is like a lot to ask of them and that's a part of like the fiddlin the fiddly nature of it is that you have to do you sort of need actually I should asked you like do you feel like there was any of it that was excessive or too much um of an experience or anything that was a barrier to actually getting into the experience I definitely got a little anxious about time and like whenever I put somebody new into the writer or officer box I'd be like a man I got to make a character sheet right now um and so I definitely like felt a bit of irritation there but I also felt like it was worth it if that makes sense if I had again like I mentioned like some cheat cheats for like birthdays and some streamlining or maybe even some like you know possible starting stats just something like if you want to create an idiot go with this if you want and tweak off of this um you know because I really enjoyed just going extreme like this person is no Brun and all wet how will this go um so I think that like just a little bit of cheat sheating would help but the thing is that all of it was worth it when you got to the end of the of the round and then we read the letters yeah because they were so fun and it was like it was it was almost like being like a kid in school again where you want the teacher to read your work does that make sense yeah and you actually want to see what everybody else did yeah um it was like the best kind of show in tell because I want to know what everybody was up to because like there were whole family events happening across the table that I had no idea about and then the letters kind of like gave me Insight yeah and it was just

really delightful actually that's awesome yeah so for you managing us as like the the GM um where did you find that you were having difficulty if at all and what would you change for your own experience um I think that I wasn't able to be there for the players on the character sheets and like I think that was like because I knew that there are things that like being able to do that is the tedious part of like being able to like oh I've got to come up with the character and so like I know that there's things that were like not that were missed on the character sheet or like there's things that there's information that's not there and I feel like that's um sort of on me just not being able to be there individually I kind of just had to be there high level to be able to come in come in and just sort of insert myself um and not support on like hey how are you doing and being able to do that like I was that I feel like there's a little bit of a disconnect there and um I think that's like the biggest challenge that's again why like you can't really even go you can't go much bigger because I know that I couldn't do that at that that for that level so there's no way that it could go even beyond that yeah and of course you were also balancing between keeping us kind of on track and then also being entertaining to people who were watching so you had to like and see the whole thing I was on my feet the whole time so yeah oh but but yeah I think like but it

did I did feel like it was something that could be managed with the AIDS and stuff like that like that would make it so that it was a little bit easier yeah um but yeah that was the I think that was the hardest part for me um and I need there's like a dating thing this was when like I wanted to make a date sheet and I was like okay I was going to do this date sheet but I just could not come up with a theory that made it feel like printing it out would be useful do you know what I'm trying to say yeah I would want to know things like what are the typical ages of new officers um you know what's the typical life expect like those are the kinds of things I'd want to know right so I could decide like how old is the old generation how young and Plucky is the new generation and how would that affect what they said yeah what are like the more middle-aged man positions you know yep yep yep no that's true yeah that's what I was trying to kind of gauge I just made it up because like who cares maybe maybe's like either late bloomers or early ones you know but I think that's what I needed to see to figure out what those AIDS need to be or how those AIDS need to be I think that's sort of what it is is that like I didn't have a sense of how to position that information to make it helpful because I didn't see how players would need them and that's I think I got a sense of that a little bit better yeah one thing I also did enjoy is that you know the cameos and John company are both male and female images and we just like went with it we just went ahead and like had a female president like even if symbolically maybe her husband was the president but she was the one running

everything yeah I sort of enjoyed the fact that like men and women were writing to each other behind the scenes about business this way yes yes yes and I think that's again I think that's a part cuz I don't think that it's a far stretch that these letters would be the letters that would be in the archives or like that would be have been kept from these families at that time not NE you know like not verbatim and everything like that but the letters between this family to that family would be kind of about these things and along these sort of lines and so like where it's the fiction and think that that's where it's really trying to give that voice of realism of like oh this is where this could have happened and how the the motivations that you're coming up with there could have been real motivations one thing that I don't know if you could feasibly add this but it would be very interesting if you could decide that members of your family were married in from other families where you know again jonko is already pretty sem Cooperative but it' be very interesting to like have it where you know you have developed an attachment to a character who joins another family yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah I think that would be like I would love to figure out a point where somebody on your family tree ends up on somebody else's family tree yes yeah that would be fascinating because then even if like JN Co is still proceeding as a normal game yeah how would that affect player behavior and would they do things to help or Ally with or protect yeah characters that they had developed even more of an attachment to like I felt attached to my characters after two rounds of an experimental game yeah yeah

yeah yeah yeah I think yeah that there's a lot of interesting things that can happen I mean like the the the mega game variant of this where you play all the like the whole long scenario of John company with it which just have such like incredible like stories that just get weaved over this long period that you would just like oh there's something about that like I think that's sort of like what the next that I have to see I think that there's definitely like a standard to sort of like play this and experience it but the next that I have to see is like okay what's that long that long tail Arc look like oh my goodness yes well I'm in uh if we're if we're ever doing that but um so speaking of you know I've already you know when we tweeted about this people wanted to see what we were doing there were people who asked for Access what I figured like we should just answer that question here what are your plans for making this kind of module I guess for junko available if any um and yeah how how are we going to work that if all so I I'm not sure how I'm going to make it available yet um I think that's a discussion that I have to have also with Cole and stuff like that but I do think that I have to finish the rules and get everything tight so that it can be shared and so that's sort of the head space that I'm at right now of just like how do I finish the rules and get them to a place where they can be shared just because I've just gota it's got to get done because I can't keep it in my head for too much longer right um in terms of like sharing of the experience itself I have the artifacts

of it and I have like to go through them and there's a way that I'll collect them it's not going to be like the play-by-play a recording of it but I think that there's a way that I'll share some of that after I share it with with everybody that played to make sure that everybody's cool with it um just to sort of as the artifact from the game playay I think that there should be an artifact from that game and um it'll be good to share that around yeah that makes that makes a lot of sense yeah so I won't keep you much longer but I do want to say I am so glad that I played this version of John company I feel like it actually gave me a deeper appreciation of the game itself um I think that it kind of reawakened in me like an interest in gaming in ways that are more kind of like boundary breaking if that makes sense it was just one of the very it was one of the cooler gaming experience I've ever had like a once in a lifetime kind of fun thing to do so I'm very very glad it was nice nice thank you I'm glad to hear that yeah I think yeah it was an experience and that's sort of what I wanted to get out of it was just like to give everybody this experience and so I'm glad that all of the players were able to feel that as well as all the people that were in the room because the feedback there was that it was the experience that I wanted them to have as well yeah I I think it's like a very good reminder that sometimes when you game you really are doing it like I wouldn't say for the ls right but like for the experience like just let's just try it and see what happens I feel like we expect very polished experiences now and we want to see finished things and I

just really felt like this was a a a different thing and a reminder that we should be doing something different yeah y exactly exactly any last thoughts um yeah just like enjoy gaming like this is It's I think this is I think this confirmed for me as well like this is an amazing time for games because like who to th it right and so just like I encourage everybody to go out and have those amazing game experiences because like wow what a Time yes go out there and game to the max that's what I would say yes for sure all right everybody thank you so much for watching uh and yeah please like subscribe comment I'll let MB know if there are any good questions and most of all happy gaming oh

Progress saved