Skip to main content
Loading video...

Arkwright the Card Game - How is it compare with the board game?

Transcript 24:17

you make it so much simpler than what it is ark right the heavy euro economy game has the cardigan fashion what is it about what we think of it stay tuned

hi everyone it's taryn here and stella from meeple university thanks for joining us today for arc right the card game this is a 2021 release of arc right which is the retheme from arkwright the board game yes which we also have um so how we'll do this we'll be able to we have played both it's been quite a while since we've played the board game and the board game is the heaviest complexity game in our collection uh it is it is um per the bgg rankings last time i checked it was the heaviest standalone board game in our collection at 4.57 or something like that heavy we've actually got the um there's an expansion we've got that's heavier the alchemist golem expansion but yes so this is it's a well-known heavy economic europe and so the card game is as with most card game versions the streamlined and quicker and easier version but still heavy not that much easier it's still got it's still got a lot of the beef that arcride had which actually is is a good thing right it's kind of like you want to have the feel of the original board game usually when you play the card version the light version the roll and right version or whatever version that originated from the original board game yes so as you say we've played this not

that often and quite a while ago seller doesn't remember very much i remember a little bit more um so i'll be able to do a bit more comparison but otherwise we'll um we'll be mostly taking you through how the card game would i play without you taran what would i do without you you'd work it out okay so with the card game each player has a setup like this and a personal deck of cards which covers workers shipping factories all the various things in the game basically anything you want to do you're going to take from your hand of cards your collection or reserve of cards there's no competition for these the exception is there are some development cards which i'll talk about in a sec um so you'll have this set up here and then you've got this main board here which is long if i just um if i do a spaceballs here we just continue scrolling past it so we'll show you the bit that's important but this uh much like the board game there are four factory types in the game bread clothes cutlery and lamps and there is a common market for each uh represented by this black disk that represents the demand and then the appeal that you have for your your goods which is a combination of the price and quality will be based on

this cube and your position on this track versus the black disk is going to tell you how much you sell and other players will be on this as well i've just got it set up for one player so the game plays over three decades three rounds i think the board game was six and in each decade you're going to activate each type of factory once so there's going to be around and then activating bread factories around and then activating clothing factories and so on down the line again like the board game um on each turn or on each round you're going to have one action out of the five or seven in the game depending on whether you're playing the expert version so you do one action then you'll automatically get to adjust your price and appeal for the current type of goods and then you automatically get to do one development and you compare that with the board game you would uh you would do one action but you would have to pay for it so there was this whole mechanism where you had to hold money and pay an amount and the amount you paid it had to meet a minimum it couldn't go above a maximum based on your developments but how much you paid dictated how much you

could do so none of that you just get to take that one action and then in the board game you could either take a development or do a price adjustment depending on which action you chose now it's just you always get to do this round's price adjustment and you always do one development the developments are now simplified as well they're either one of these tracks so you can just move a cube up on one of these tracks or there'll be a handful of these cards depending on your player count available and these ones are first come first so you'll take this and you'll uh you'll gain the benefit from that that's the basic flow of each game the sorts of things you can do very much the same as the basic arc right you can build more factories so open a factory of another type it's not always good to have all your factories because if you've got unprofitable factories it may not be good for your share value because then you need to pay the cost of running it as well each time without producing it without you able to spend an action that very limiting action to buff it up indeed you can add workers to your factories so each factory has two worker cards that will go on here they'll add extra extra production capability but add extra wages costs fit your meatball yep adding new factories and adding new

uh workers will increase everyone's wages costs this is uh relatively similar to the board game so this will become quite expensive as the game goes on you can replace workers with machines as an action and this makes the wages cost substantially cheaper for you but the maximum number of machines you can build on around is based on this development track you can add appeal or add distribution and these are consistent with the board game so you can add these appeal cards uh to give you flexibility on price or appeal sorry what are these called quality cards or you can add distribution which gives you extra appeal but it declines as the game goes on so that's all very consistent and yeah that that's kind of how it works and then at the end of your turn you will choose your price and choose your appeal price at the top and appeal at the bottom yes and you've kind of got flexibility you've got a range of seven to start the game until you start putting in more quality more um quality cards and so here for example let's say i did it like that i would have chosen to have three appeal i would move my cube up to number three oops move it up to number three and then each of these icons that i cross

oops each of these icons that i cross will move the demand marker up or down in the same direction that i've moved and as everyone moves their markers on this um the disc is going to go up and down and that will set the size of the market yeah so like this if like this the difference is one two three that means you can sell three so the demand is three goods you can sell three goods up to three goods yes so this is one of the major simplifications versus the board game in the board game you would have the um the market would tell you the total demand players would produce their goods and then you would divvy up that demand among the players based on appeal and so if you had poor appeal you might end up not selling very much at all taking a huge loss on the round it's less directly interactive this time now each player the interaction is uh causing the movement of this disc and then each player independently looks at their cube versus this disc the difference here is two for example so that's the amount you can sell to the home market so probably good as a second play of the last player so you can observe what's going on before making your decision maybe yeah so this part simplifies and it's a lot less brittle um you can also still sell overseas the way you could in the base game so you've

got two ships that you can use if i use one i flip it over it can hold a certain amount of goods you get more money for selling overseas but the shareholders get nervous and so at the end of the game each time you ship it's progressively going to reduce your share price and that's basically how you win just how many stocks you have times the self value is your final score yes so your one remaining action is you can spend your money on purchasing stocks and you'll move your stock market up the track as you buy stocks as you sell goods locally each time you sell two goods locally you get a share value increase and whoever has the most appealing goods gets a share value increase if they sold it in that way and so that is that is really how you're building the game you've got to pick the right times to buy shares keep enough money on hand to handle any losses that your companies make because they will make losses especially at the start stuff start it's tough to it's tough to make ends meet oh yeah then at the end of the game you will buy a last set of shares uh you'll give back shares if you've taken loans you'll lose share value for your ships and then you'll add it all up you make it so much simpler than what it is yeah it's quite a it's quite an intricate set of things going on it's um it's tricky to it's tricky to visualize but it does

have all of the pretty much all of the core card game the core board game mechanics in a simpler and more predictable way i guess the flow of the game is not that hard you basically have you know there are three eras three decades and each decade has got four rounds and each round you just do one action one development and that's it on selling goods and that's it but then the actual strategic decision the the what you need to do whether you the calculation make sure you have enough money whether you make profitable business that's really really tricky yes tough so what do you think i actually as taran mentioned earlier i it's been a while since we play arc right last um but i still remember bits and pieces and taran explained it to me again and i feel like as with economic game i feel like it's missing that brutality i know it sounds bad but you know just say food chain magnate i i do not too bad at make that because i can like as bad as it sounds again i like that brutality where it affects other people's like i can like yeah just like just get everything so that you can't afford it and things like that i think that's amazing but it is um if i see it from okay i have not played let's say if i have not played the base game and i played this one it's good

it's more gentle it's probably might even be a good introduction before you play the heavier the board game full version because it it simplifies a lot of things it is more friendly to new gamers that just plays there's no brutality there um you can still have a little bit of interaction of you know you can see you know you think that oh that player does not have the factory that you want that's that's actually um maybe a good thing for you because then you can just monopolize the market you can you know exactly how the demand is going to act you can just influence the month without other people influence it but you know having a lot of factories means that with that limited action you can only do one thing per your turn and that's really tough me had three factories you had two factories and you can buff up both your factories better than me having to focus on different ones like on the turn where you know i don't have the factory that i uh in my tableau means that i can buff up one of my other factories while you can do it twice because you only have two factories on the tents that you don't have but that means that you know that means i on the factory that i have and you have means that you just have to be careful where the demanding supply is and that's where turn order might be kind of like yeah matters a little bit um it is very tricky i don't know how to do this game well this version um and whether you want to

sell overseas you want to sell it in the local market do you want to buy the the stock earlier there's you know options for engine building whether you want to have the helpful card more um in your hand you can have have up to four you know these things are it's really a rich and um yeah it's really really a rich sort of options that you can do um but yeah i do miss that that thing um of you know brutality does that make sense it does and and that um largely it largely matches my opinion actually as well i think i haven't actually discussed this previously which is like surprise i think yeah you're definitely right in saying this i think this works better as an introduction because arcride is a very heavy and very dense game and i think this probably does act better as an introduction to its mechanics um than it does as a way of playing a lighter we we're finally in tune darren yeah we often think differently maybe it's different at a different play account because maybe at two players these demands aren't going up and down as much um but yeah i think you know things were all a little bit more predictable i was able to concentrate on my personal game a bit more rather than having to think too hard about hedging

against what might happen in the market and that's a big part of the board game but i think also for people who doesn't really like that brutality then go this one definitely this one is i would totally recommend this one over the board game because you know i mean we that interaction that brutality some people like some people don't so you can just speak now you have that feeling again you have that you know that nice sort of engine built that you build up and whether you want it or not whether you want that brutality or not yeah it's your choice it's definitely an easier um it's easier to think through the fact that you know you've got an auto development and you can set your price yeah compared with having to make sure you did the correct base action to set your price at the right time um it definitely takes some of the the edge that that original heavy heart acrylic had off from that perspective and that's um it's definitely going to appeal to some people and i mean arkwright's a long game as well it's very hard to uh and it's got a lot of concepts and development types so it's hard to to get people into that this is a bit easier to entry level i mean if i have not played the board game i probably just you know if it's an independent opinion they'll be like oh yeah that's nice you know um that as entertainers say maybe for higher number of players say four players more people have similar factory as other players

then it will interact more in the track it will influence the demand a little bit more but yet um at the end of the day when you sell it's quite independent rather than a board game where it's it's brutal brutal i mean good thing is that we don't that's what we do as a couple we will play brutally and then after that yeah it's fine it's all just a game right tarot of course like i like beating you in fish and magnet one day i'll figure it out i won't shave my secret now you're probably just lucky no you don't you don't do that um you don't have that record in it from luck well i told you the secret right find a good place no then i didn't well it's probably similar with arc right as well where being the last player is probably good that's the that's the same food chain magnet that's true if there are certainly cases here where you can react to uh reacting what's going on and react is the other one i think but i didn't win this one and you you win it when what's the secret there um i managed to have one big profitable round out of my lamp factory than that that last time we played that was the biggest thing because i think we both spent a lot of money early that was one thing i there were definitely more losses here than when we played the board game

we just i'm just constantly running at a loss yeah we both we both bought as many shares as we could early on and we're then just trying to uh make ends meet it was like just marching small margin now that having been said um there's a full track here for taking nine loans yeah and it's entirely yeah we we haven't explored whether more aggressive engine building early pays off um in these loans later on yeah that's true um because we're both quite focused on staying above zero so because you know like you tend to take more risk when it comes to that i tend to be scared usually like we play a few games that oh you have to do this otherwise you out of the game things like that that kind of like scares me or you know this will give you negative points or oh fight counts um you get this debt and corruption no no i'm so scared but really if you manage to risk it's it's usually okay right it's there for that say for a reason it's often a it's it's a more philosophical thing like they they always tell you when you they always tell you when you play brass that you're gonna take you're gonna take two three four loans during the game yeah um but it's often burned into your mind that you would only ever take a loan if you were doing badly it's true because i'm sure in other games as well vidal said this game has got that as well that sort of mechanics where what is it called that mechanics where you you know take something a bit of a

risk but then as long as you can manage it well then it's it's fine like when sandra gets angry oh yeah you spend all your time pleasing sandra you won't um this is kanban yes yeah you're well done okay even even the um dinosaur island's another one oh yeah yeah yeah you are if you spend all your time getting zero visitors eaten um probably not you're probably not hedging the risk correctly yeah so yeah that's not a we haven't we haven't explored that here i haven't played it enough but maybe you have let us know um either an arc right the board game or archive the card art right the guard game let us know if you have played what do you think of it what other economic games that you like beside this one if you have played it or do you have a favorite economic games mine's probably witcher magnate is one what other economic games are there that we have played tarrant oh we've played a few um brick and mortar and lizard wizard were a couple of good ones with economic um on the lightest on the life side yeah power grid of course one of the classic economics yeah you won a dollar over somebody playing power grid it was looks like you want i won by one dollar after several uh massive rule and in-game trigger mistakes anyway we've got we've gone off the topic here a little bit um

also we're so with our crowd the car game there is a solo version that comes in here there is also as there was with the board game there's a beginner and an expert version um the expert version adds a couple of extra actions so you can do extra production or extra shipping which i know was actions that the board game had in the in the expert version as well um fixed setup versus variable setup things like that so despite what i say about that if i am to play again if i am to play this i think i'm quite happy with it it is not as brutal especially if i you know just started it's not as brutal it's good it is quite interactive it's quite simple it is a nice i think it's still a nice well-designed economy game yep and it's unmistakably accurate it has a lot it definitely it doesn't it doesn't scrimp on very many of the mechanics that came with the board game um it's still very much arc right it's still quite a heavy experience especially for a for a card game version of a board game yeah yeah it's still among the heaviest of them which makes sense because as a board game version it is also among the heaviest let's say compared to dinosaur island and dinosaur island right it is heavier than i thought as well the same with this one this is a little bit heavier than i thought because yeah i mean if the game needs to capture the actual

original board game needs to be need to have those elements that make the board game yeah anything else yeah it kept a lot more of them um kept a lot more of the board game elements than i initially thought it was going to based on the size of the box so frederick is still okay this is still still a decent game um but i think the board game scratches uh my itch for it more that's fair enough so what do you think again of that please let us know let us know in the comment sections below um and it would be very helpful if you can please help us by hitting the like button and subscribe to us if you haven't or done so we do reviews like this dan does a really good how to play and i'm definitely biased but yes tara does really clear what's the word concise and structured logical how to play i do my stellar shoulder suite we do live lecture on the weekend and so on i'm also on instagram so find me there as well i posted our adventures of bought games and um that's it i guess yes that's it from us i'll see you later bye

Progress saved