Obraje | Zenobia Finalists 2024
Transcript
hey Gamers this is Liz from Beyond Soler and I'm super happy to have on the show today uh Diego Javier Luis he is a Zenovia award finalist and designer of oah how you doing Diego I'm doing well thanks for having me Liz yeah super happy to meet you and hear about your game so for people who have not been following Zenobia uh what's the what's the story on oah so O is a game set in the 17th century in colonial Mexico the word means textile mill um and I chose that because the textile mills um in Mexico at this time were um the the most brutal sites of colonial labor and enslavement as well and the um point of the game is to try to achieve as much Social Mobility as possible um within this very restrictive environment and um I I'm I'm calling it a choices matter roleplaying historical simulation because the whole purpose of the game is uh is making a series of decisions so each turn a player draws a card that presents them with a kind of moral conundrum and depending on what they choose there's a coin toss basically a randomized result of that decision and that will determine either advancement stagnation or going backwards um on the
kind of multiple scales of social Mobility um throughout the simulation and I find this period so fascinating one as a as a historian of the period um but two because uh Mexico was was at the center of both the Atlantic and the Pacific Worlds at this time so it's a rapidly globalizing Society that's going through enormous social changes and so um I I just wanted to bring that a lot to life uh for players that's really interesting so how did you decide that you were interested in 17th century textile mills yeah I mean so I'm a historian by trade so uh so for for me that's that's kind of an easy one because I just find it fascinating um and you know I study the colonial period in Latin America I teach the colonial period in Latin America um really focused on Mexico um again because I'm I'm interested in the populations coming to the Americas across both the Atlantic and the Pacific um it's a society comprised of you know not only multiple um ethnolinguistic groups of indigenous people but also Western Europeans of course West and West Central Africans and Asians coming from across the Pacific too and um and many of these people are meeting and and interacting in spaces like the textile mill um and having to Think Through what
it means to inhabit uh such a space to live in this kind of very restricted constraining oftentimes violent uh colonial society and how to sort of make the most of these circumstances so um so kind of that's that's how I got drawn into the world of of the textile though oh that's awesome so also I should have introduced you it sounds like as Dr Lise oh right yeah so I I do have a PhD um in history but you know I'm not about all the titles but fair enough fair enough um but you could have expressed your interest in this period in a number of different ways because you know you are a fully trained historian I know you must write a lot I know you must read a lot about this history what made you feel that a game was the best way to express it to others uh so one uh I'm a gamer myself so i' I've gotten a lot out of games that Force players to make decisions where there's no clear right decision and there's no clear wrong decision you kind of it's it's it's so situationally contingent but makes you feel like your own sense of morality is being tested um as you go through the game so I'm thinking a lot here about The Telltale Games um which I've played a lot of big fan uh I'm also thinking about games
that have come out recently like frost Punk 2 for example where you have to balance like um making decisions that will like piss off one political group but sort of ingratiate you with another so um so I'm I'm all about um I'm all about have having choices in a game that feel morally significant and fraught for players and so like the decision to create a game about the the textile mills during the colonial period is um is to try to to make the um to make the kind of vivid or visceral lived reality of a space like that come to life but yeah I basically I I want um I want players to inhabit the subject position of someone in a textile mill for whom there is no right decision to try to either get out of the mill or to advance their position or to look out for themselves which may require um making morally fraught decisions and and that's because you know there there is no there is no right way there's no wrong way and there's so many sort of paradoxical moments that you get from reading the colonial Archive of these spaces people make decisions that from the 21st century subject position it it doesn't make sense right why someone would choose to intentionally commit blasphemy for example and and expose
themselves to inquisitorial punishment why would someone make such a decision why would somebody when commanded to uh to punish their fellow bondsmen or bondswoman within an OB choose to comply with such an order right but when you put yourself in that subject position and you think about what you stand to gain or what you stand to lose um then the whole landscape of decision making changes and I think that that allows for a greater sense of empathy with the um historical actors who were actually faced with many of the decisions that are present in no very interesting so when you were coming up with this game is this something that you are envisioning playing with students or is this something that's more for like a personal game night so I I Envision it in both settings um when I've done the play testing it's been mostly with students and with colleagues um I think that it has a kind of natural fit for a classroom environment and I'm hoping to also write um kind of an article length publication to accompany it that kind of explains the thought process why behind why I made many of the kind of design decisions uh that I made when designing it um but yeah I would love to see it a
kind of Standalone thing that exists beyond the classroom as well because I think it has a kind of broader applicability and and for people who enjoy choices matter um RPGs then then this would be in a historical setting especially then this would be an interesting addition to that genre so mechanically um how much has the game evolved since beginning the project until now mere days before you have to submit your final per time don't remind me Liz yeah we've got four days before the next admission but um so this is this is a game I've been thinking about kind of off and on for several years now um it started as an idea just tossing around with a few buddies like um thinking through some of the scenarios that a player might encounter and imagining how our students might re react to being faced with these scenarios that take you far out of you know the kind of Comforts of a 21st Century College classroom for example um but uh it's gone through a lot of evolution since then um since those early conversations and you know one of the the uh major um I guess benefits of going through the zobia process is is sort of being forced to uh to clarify many of
many of the mechanics that were hypothetical but you know I there were a lot of things that I I sort of added um to make the game more Dynamic more tense um you know players can denounce each other to the Inquisition now for example which does not always result in a full inquisitorial proceeding which is historically accurate for example a denunciation can also backfire so there's kind of risk management that's part of every um every decision a player might make you can um you can try to get married you can um I say try because again this does not may not always work out as you think it will work out if you try to pursue these Avenues um but you know also the the player Begins by choosing a cast category among the cast categories that were um uh that were present in Mexico during the 17th century each category comes with a kind of special ability that players can use throughout the game um they can choose an o or an A ending for their character meaning a um masculine gendered or feminine gendered character um which also comes with a particular kind of risk management as well um so there are a lot of ways that I I wanted to make make each player's experience unique as
they go throughout the game and so that by the end you know whether or not they end up quote unquote winning by reaching the highest stage of social Mobility which of course requires many things that um you know a player might ask themselves what what did I have to sacrifice to win the game um but whether or not you end up in that that highest level um you still have a biography of a person that's actually plausible um for someone who who lives during the 17th century and each one will be unique um during each playthrough so um that that was U I'd say the core elements of play that I wanted to clarify through the Zenobia process that's awesome so it sounds like though one of the things that would be challenging about this game is you're it sounds like you're asking players to make very difficult decisions morally Highly Questionable decisions from our cozy place here in this Century so how how far were you willing to go with that and what kinds of positions do you feel comfortable putting your players into yeah um so I'm for this simulation I I'm I want to go quite far with it I mean there are of course hard limitations to what that can um but uh but I want to represent many
of those kinds of paradoxical elements of colonial society that I um mentioned before and I'm really inspired by the historical work um that that folks like Pablo Sierra who's written a lot about the ores uh in colonial Mexico javia vlores who wrote about blasphemy which I mentioned previously and also the work of Daniel assas Williams who um who I often teach with um because she talks about a case in colonial halapa which is sort of on the Eastern side of Mexico uh in which you have a woman who's described as a mulata meaning that she's described as a mixed uh afrom Mexican woman and uh she ends up becoming she she's a descendant of enslaved people and she becomes an not only an enslaver self but also an enslaver of her family members her siblings specifically and so the one of the major questions that emerges from this um seeming Paradox is how did this end up happening why would someone choose to enslave their family members what are the kind of power dynamics that are at play how does this speak to the kind of marginal position that that women in general faced within colonial society um and so there are so many questions that
emerge from that and I think that um that there's a way to represent not that exact situation but similarly uh kind of morally fraught situations and ways that um that don't sort of relegate that to like oh I can't possibly imagine how how that could be possible but thinking through like what's actually the kind of moral or economic or political calculus behind um Behind These really really complicated social realities all right I selfishly just have to know but I'm going to turn into like a real question you mentioned the you mentioned blasphemy and Inquisition several times so how does religion play a role and then also I guess that kind of has a follow on of what aspects of society were you you not able to fit into this game that you maybe wanted to yeah those are great questions um so yeah religion as you know religion was important to colonial society uh not only Catholicism but also the religions that people brought from overseas too and also indigenous spiritual beliefs that were present there as well and so I try to represent all of these with in various ways in the simulation um one because you know non Catholic religious practice was an important way to build community within enslaved and free
societies and to kind of resist the the strictures of um of the Catholic Church um so so that's present uh but also you have many people who who were part of the kind of cast system um who were not Spanish not European who who were practitioners of Catholicism and for whom Catholicism was kind of a a spiritual Haven and a way of integrating with colonial society um but where blasphemy comes in is um you have situations where if someone in the O is being punished and they feel that their punishment is unjust um there are situations where people would would denounce God and the virgin Mary and the Saints um in order to this is this is an interesting part in order to um invoke the jurisdiction of the Inquisition so basically by denouncing God you're inviting inquisitorial inquiry so that you can then protest your unjust treatment before the inquisitors um and this is because a an enslaver or slave master was responsible for um for the the kind of consistent Catholic instruction of his or her enslaved people this was in
fact not only an obligation of a slave master or enslaver but actually what uh legitimized enslavement as an institution within the colonial world was this obligation and so if if an enslaver was found to have violated that obligation by unjustly punishing their enslaved it was possible and it did happen in some cases where um that enslaver would lose um would lose ownership over the enslaved person and the Inquisition would transfer that person to another enslaver um so it was you know it's it was a very risky strategy because the Inquisition might punish the enslaved person even more but in some cases it did have this um this outcome in which an enslaved person could actually achieve being transferred to another in slaver and potentially um potentially uh avoiding those kinds of unjust uh punishments in the future so um so these are the kind of tactics that people with no power really in colonial society were still able to to exercise and there are a wide range of these kinds of strategies that are also um to a degree replicated within the within the game um so things that I couldn't represent I I
mean there's so much that the actual I mean scenarios and possible resolutions to scenarios I mean I have pages and pages and pages of writing on this but um but yeah I mean there are limitations to the kind of Mobility um that people experienced in the colonial world because this is really focused on Central Mexico I mean you have many cases of people going to like Guatemala or to California or down to Peru across the ocean to Spain or maybe the Philippines and then back to Mexico and people were moving all over the place all the time and kind of limiting myself to Central Mexico means that those are those are sort of out of the frame um although you know there there are sort of references to people moving around but as a player you're kind of confined to um to Mexico City pbla also in central Mexico verac Cruz on the Atlantic coast and Acapulco on the Pacific coast so trying to get that kind of geographic coverage for Central Mexico and each of those spaces kind of have slightly different mechanics um depending on where you are but I was thinking you know maybe in the future there could be an expansion in in Peru you know um where you could actually go somewhere and then have unique scenarios there and then come back to Mexico for example but yeah oh that's super interesting all right so I have one more real question and then we'll go on to softy stuff so what
um how do I ask this what does Victory look like in your game if there is any Victory condition and then how do you get there and what are you incentivizing um by setting the victory condition the way that you do in a game like this I love that question that in many ways that question is at the center of what this is this is all about because the game tells you that um so okay let me back up and say that there are four rings of social mobility and I like the kind of metaphor of the Ring because sometimes it feels like you're just going in circles you know and um but there are four rings ring one is where you begin that's in the OB and then ring four is you know you're kind of member of the low lower Colonial Elite which is you know as high as as someone who's very lucky um and uh you know maybe plans this way um is is able to achieve so the game tells you that you know after a certain number of turns which represents an entire life the person who's in the highest ring with the most of the two of The Game's currencies which are capital cards representing material wealth and honor cards representing social Prestige if you have the most of those then you know you win the simulation but uh winning can also be a kind of hollow Victory because because you have this whole biography um and you can look back on
the decisions that you've made and you know think about if that's actually if that's actually winning you know if if if materially winning is the same as morally winning um and uh and I've kind of played with how to represent this in terms of the mechanics of the game uh because you know earlier iterations of the simulation I think were a little bit too easy in that if you simply you know complied and collaborated then you had a better chance um uh but you know as I thought more about it and as I kind of iterated and play tested I wanted um I wanted collaboration to all also be a risky Endeavor um and I'm borrowing too from the scholarship of of some of my mentors people like um Robert Douglas cope who's written that you know the higher someone who's non-european tried to climb in colonial society the more kind of restrictions um they encountered and you know there are con the concept of colonial mimicry by um you know homie Baba is also another uh iteration of that so I kind of I wanted to represent that there were risks to taking the kind of more compliant or collaborative route um and that if you go for a kind of more and and not every card is split between resistance and collaboration because I also want to explode that binary but if
you take more um decisions that are sort of explicitly you know against the grain of what you're being asked to do or what you're being presented with um that there are also chances to run away for example and um but it's obviously you know that's extremely risky as well and and so the player kind of has to constantly weigh um what the scenario entails and what are the risks and possibilities to any particular decision um so uh yeah so um so that's to say that there's there's no sort of one one route to quote unquote Victory and there are many kinds of ideological or political positions that a player can choose to adopt as they're um as they're being presented with these scenarios and they'll just have to find whichever one works best for them I like it all right so just a couple this sounds like really interesting I really got to play this now um but uh for now people who uh make games usually play them uh so what games have you been playing recently that you've enjoyed yeah so I mentioned um I mentioned The Telltale Games previously and frost Punk 2 which I recently beat um big fan of those kinds of games um I'm currently playing Elden ring uh which is very difficult but I mean I there's a kind of constant theme here
like extremely difficult like morally um morally fraud games like I I like games that challenge um and uh you know obviously you know there's there's tremendous value to all kinds of sort of emotional experiences that you can have with with different kinds of games but I I want um I want players to be to be uh to kind of feel like they've been affected uh and that they've actually learned something about themselves and how they themselves would react to to being in particular situations and so I'm kind of drawing inspiration from all these these games that that I'm I'm playing now fantastic and then uh do you maintain an online presence and if so where can you be found uh so I'm not super uh active on social media but I can say that my um my work is available um online and uh you know I had a book come out this year it's called the first Asians in the Americas and it does focus on the relationship between Colonial Mexico and the Philippines across the Pacific and the movement of people and the OB do show up uh in that in that work I also have um my own podcast coming out at the end of the month which is kind of about the personal story behind um the writing of the book and why historians make again decision-making why historians make the decisions they do uh when they
approach particular histories because historians are not objective um there's no one way to write history so uh the podcast is called the the historians table and it'll be uh exploring all those kinds of questions fantastic um all right so we got to draw to close but Diego Thank you so much for coming on talk to me about this this sounds really exciting congratulations for being a Zenobia finalist but also like no matter what happens I really really need to see this game thank you so much I really appreciate it all right everybody out there I can be found everywhere as Beyond solitire uh please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming