D&D Lite: My Favorite Mechanism
Transcript
Hey, I'm Jamie from Stonemaier Games, and today I'm going to talk about my favorite mechanism in Dungeons and Dragons, a lighter version. Uh I have never actually played a a game of Dungeons and Dragons. As a kid, when I was around like 13 or 14, I played a few games of a Star Wars role-playing game. Um but beyond that, I really have no role-playing game experience. And so, a few weekends ago, a friend put together a very big game of Dungeons and Dragons, but a lighter version, a distilled version, with a little bit of um I don't want to quite say a LARPing, but I'll explain what I mean in a minute. There there is there's actual physical movement in the game in this one-shot D&D light scenario. But I did because I've now had a little bit a little taste of it, I thought I'd share my favorite mechanism from this experience.
Um here, I'll put this on the screen. This shows kind of the vibe of this game. So, we uh we we're going through a one-shot campaign that was mostly driven towards uh uh fighting a series of monsters. Um so, unlike I think typ- typical role-playing games in Dungeons and Dragons, we didn't have a lot of options. We were a little bit railroaded, but that's okay. We only had like 3 hours to play this game, so that was the point of it. I think I would enjoy greater freedom of choice to uh to do, you know, a greater range of choices um in a full D&D game. But I did enjoy this. We also weren't really creating our We didn't create our characters in advance. We created them as we went. The flow of this game is that we'd stop by the uh we we we'd go on a little adventure, like like a 10-to-15-minute 10-to-15-minute adventure.
And then, we would physically walk to a different room after that part part of it to go to a tavern where a friend was uh let's see if I can find it here. A friend was um No, I don't I don't have it here. There's a photo of a of a friend who is running the tavern serving drinks to the adventurers based on the monsters that they killed little mixed drinks in little vials. It was really cool and letting us buy new equipment and leveling up based on what we had done. So we this is why it was a light version of the game. It it was very distilled and much faster. I think than a normal game of D&D. However, we did still experience some of the core mechanisms of D&D in terms of the dice resolution system and I was new to this and I was very dubious about it because it uh it it's you know, rolling a die rolling a D20 of all dice where you have a huge spread of odds seemed like not the I I was very hesitant about this game mechanism. So I was like, okay, I'm going to say that I want to do something. I'm going to roll a D20 to decide if I actually do that thing or not. That was my perception of it.
Um just didn't seem didn't seem to give me much agency as a player. However, I've walked away from it realizing how much fun this actually is this system. I I wouldn't want it in every game, but I do really like the way it works in um in at least this flavor of D&D that I experienced. So the the system was very simple and here's what was a bit of a surprise to me. How much agency I I actually had over it in a couple different ways. And also that combined with how much fun it is to see you or one of your friends roll an incredibly high number or an incredibly roll low number. It creates memorable moments in the game. So we certainly in a even just in our three three-hour game five-player three-hour game we had multiple players roll ones.
Uh and that that indicated the kind of an instant failure like the worst case scenario they rolled a one. And we also had players roll 20s at key moments in the game. They unlike maybe other games that didn't completely feel earned, but that didn't stop it from feeling good when you did that, especially since you were doing this for at for the team. You rolled the die, you got a 20 for the whole team. You you did something important for the whole team. And that was that's like a critical hit. You've done something really powerful at that moment when you when you rolled a 20. However, my perception was that it that it was more of a pass fail system, and I was wrong in that uh there's actually different variances of uh of success when you roll a die, depending on which monster you were interacting with or what what whatever you're encountering. You know, in our scenario, we were always just fighting. Um that meant that if it was a weaker monster, uh if we rolled a 10 or a higher, we were doing well. We were we were dealing damage to the monster. For harder monsters, we needed to roll 15 or higher.
Um and so I really like that. So, it actually was more of a coin flip for certain monsters rather than a a 5% chance at at at doing well. Um and it did get a little I like that you have different scales based on the difficulty of the the monster or the scenario, things like that. I also really like the advantage disadvantage system. Uh there was a certain point in the campaign where we earned a second die. So, we leveled up, we got a second die, and that introduced advantage and disadvantage. What this meant is uh if we had the advantage due to other factors over a certain um monster, then we well, we we got to roll two dice and pick the better of those two dice. If you had the disadvantage, you had to roll two dice and pick the lesser of the two dice. And sometimes we were still just rolling one die. See, that's a really clever system as well. Again, it doesn't involve a choice, but it does uh break up the odds and improves the odds a little bit or makes the odds worse if you have disadvantage.
Also, we were earning cards and abilities. Now, in D&D, I don't think there are cards, but I think there are different abilities that characters earn and have different skills and traits. Maybe this happens when you're building your character, but it maybe also happens throughout the campaign as you gain new items. And these cards often have to deal with dice mitigation. Like some of them said that just every time you roll a die, you add plus one to it, or you get to reroll a die based on certain circumstances. Or my favorite thing, I liked embracing the role that I was a support character. I got to make other characters, other players stronger. That felt really good to me. I really, really like those moments where someone needed my help, um and I was able to give them a little boost after they did after they had a really bad dice roll. Um so there there were a surprising surprisingly high number of ways to mitigate the dice rolls and have agency over it despite it being a D20.
And because it was a D20, it led to big, memorable moments in the game either through failure or through success. And so, I had a really good time. I I I know it was just a 3-hour one-shot. I know I'm barely touching upon the mechanisms of Dungeons and Dragons. But I actually think that's okay. Like this was my my experience. I liked that it was lighter. I liked that there weren't a web of complex rules that we needed to navigate through. I like that we could just jump in and start playing and that they leveled on these systems as we played. It was really, really well constructed by the the friends who put on this D&D light one-shot event. I'd love to hear your thoughts, especially if you know Dungeons and Dragons or or other similar role-playing systems much better than I do. I'd love to hear what your favorite mechanism is and how you think um D&D, anything that I missed in terms of dice mitigation um while also allowing the dice to lead to memorable moments. Let me know your thoughts about that in the comments below.
Thanks.