Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Finest Fish: My Favorite Mechanism

Transcript 4:56

So, you would know that if you're watching this video for the first time, I'm Jamie from Stonemaier Games, but I am recording the 14th video from the games that I played at Geekway to the West 2026 right now. And this video is about The Finest Fish. This is the final game that I'm recording. I played 14 games over this convention. And I definitely didn't save the worst for last by any means. This is actually, I think, my favorite abstract animal-themed game that I played during the convention. And there were quite a few of them. It seemed to be a very popular genre at this convention. And I enjoyed the other ones, too. But I think The Finest Fish is my favorite. I think partially because, as abstract as these games often are, it is really satisfying to look down at the table at the end of the of the game and see something like this. See that I have built, designed, created a fish with that looks spectacular on the table. This is a dual-layered player mat where you're sliding these tokens into the mat during the game to form the scales on a fish, and then you're scoring them in a few different ways at the end of the game.

Um I really enjoyed how simple, and streamlined, and forgiving this game was in terms of one specific mechanism that I'll mention in a second. So, basically, on your turn in this game, you are choosing from one of the piles of scales. There should be three scales. I believe it was three scales per pile. You're choosing one of them. And generally, you are putting those scales on your fish adjacent to other tiles. Adjacent to other scales. The patterns that you form on them matter in a couple different ways. One is you have these goal cards that want You can kind of see Well, let's see if I can find one adjacent to here. Oh, there's another beautiful fish. Um yeah, here you can kind of see some of them. You want these specific colors of scales next to one another. Here they are. Uh once. You just want that pattern to appear once on your fish, and you're good.

Um that's one of the ways. Also, you were trying to create clumps of scales that are at least three of the same scale touching the other other scales of that type. And if so, you get to score one point for each of those groups of scales. Um so, there's these two goals that sometimes might conflict with each other, but sometimes might overlap if I have a certain pattern. So, I'm trying to accomplish these specific patterns on these goal cards, but I'm also that I'm claiming. These aren't common shared goals. These are private goals. But, I'm also just trying to create clumps that are at least three. The game could have chosen to say, "Okay, only look at your largest clump." But again, it's a very kind of generous forgiving game. It's saying as long as you reach three, um you get to score that entire clump. I like that. I also like the black scales count both for their group, but they also, wherever they are, even individually, they each count as one point each.

Last, the other forgiving {slash} generous mechanism in the game is this fish bowl up here. So, on your turn, you're placing these three scales or you're using these three scales. One of the uses of them is to get more goal cards. Generally, you're placing them, but you might use a few turns just to get goal cards. But, the other thing you can do is trade with the fish bowl. You can if there's a specific scale in the fish bowl that you want, you can get rid of a scale from your fish and place it in the fish bowl and claim another scale from the fish bowl. So, there's always this pool of resources essentially that you have at your disposal that increase the size of your temporary hand of scales, letting you do the things that you want to do. I'm kind of endlessly surprised by these abstract games that get in the way of doing the thing that you want to do, which is to generally, you know, build a clever and beautiful array of of cards or tokens or tiles, whatever it may be. And this game says, "No, we're not going to get in your way. We're going to give you some constraints.

Sure, there are there are limitations. You're only getting three of these scales. You have to spend one to get a goal tile. You have to You have to put them on on your fish or they're adjacent." So, there are constraints, but they make it very flexible, very open, very generous in terms of the scales that you have access to, uh the how the goal scoring can overlap with your groups um, and the black scales they can score wherever they are on your fish. I really liked the generosity of this game. It felt really good. It felt very freeing. It made the end game when I got to look at my completed fish, it made that feel extra good cuz not only did I complete something pretty, but uh, I I was the game gave me access to the resources I need needed to be able to accomplish that goal. So, yeah, the finest fish. I really enjoyed this game as uh, especially in the the abstract nature themed game genre and um, yeah, those are my favorite mechanisms from it. I'd love to hear your thoughts if you have played this game and you have a favorite mechanism or you can think of another game in this genre that was generous that is generous in what it gives you and the constraints don't limit you to the point of frustration but rather the game gives you all the resources you need with still some interesting constraints to make something beautiful and make something that scores a bunch of points hopefully at the end of the game as well. That's the finest fish.

Thanks.

Progress saved