Batman Everybody Lies Board Game Review (spoiler-free)
Transcript
this episode of brains on games is about solving mysteries in gotham city welcome to brains on games i'm dr brian mcdonald in this episode we are going to talk about a gotham city detective game where you don't actually get to play as batman but batman might show up in the shadows as you're hunting for clues to solve some mysteries it's a game that's based on the detective system and it's published by portal it's a game called you might hear the pieces rattling around everybody lies so this is a batman themed game you can see batman on the cover but the players will not play as batman it's a game for kids age 14 and up you can play with two to four players i mean you could play it solo because it is a cooperative problem-solving mystery game but it's gonna be more fun to play it with more than one person and i'll tell you why that is very soon it's a game that plays in a couple of hours to three hours depending on the mystery you're trying to solve let's take a deeper look at batman everybody lies batman everybody lies is a mystery solving game and i'm not going to spoil any of the details here you're going to see some of the top of the title cards from these different decks i'm not going to show you any of the cards inside i won't even show you the other locations that go here although you might be able to guess some of them
so i'm not going to spoil anything but it is a game that's not too complicated to play but the mysteries can be quite complicated so i'd say light to medium in terms of its complexity and it does kind of take place in the a darker version of gotham city so it's not the light funny gotham city that you might remember from the 60s tv show or some of the super friends comics it is more dark and gritty and that's the reason why this one is aimed more at the teenagers than it is at the younger kids what you're going to be doing in this game is running around the city gathering clues trying to solve that mystery you're going to be playing as one of four characters in gotham city you do not get to play as batman or robin so the main heroes from the comics are not too much involved in this game although batman might be lurking in the shadows somewhere because it is a game that is set in gotham you get to choose to play there's a couple of reporters you could be vicki vale who you might remember from the first tim burton batman movie you can play as warren spacey you can play as harvey bullock who was in the gotham tv show or you can play as catwoman and we all know who catwoman is these are the choices of your characters now if you have fewer than four players then whatever characters are left over that aren't chosen those ones are going to be placed in the middle of the table and they'll just be informants there's two
sides to these cards so the informant side just shows the ability that that this character will allow you to use but an informant isn't going to have a personal goal or anything like that that they're chasing down you are playing as those characters to solve some mystery there's four different mysteries in the box there's a prologue which is an easier one and three more complex scenarios and each scenario is going to have a different goal and each of your characters that you're playing as might have a personal goal a secret goal that they're trying to accomplish as well i will mention that the game came with this big uh poster size map well a small poster i guess but a big map here of gotham city that we didn't really use in the games that we played very much but it is a nice visualization of gotham that you can refer to if you'd like to do that really you're going to be playing on this board and you start the game by opening an envelope you don't destroy the cards in this game but you will be opening these envelopes that's the the amount of the destruction that you're going to do as you play but of course once you've solved the mystery um you you wouldn't necessarily go back and play that same mystery again unless you were just specifically looking at trying out the different personal goals that the individual characters might have in the game as you play through it those envelopes will have a sheet inside and you're going to read some text i won't flip this over so you can see all
the text because i'm not spoiling anything here but you'll have this little poster and there's a lot of this is a full page here of text for you to read that sets the scene you that that text might allow you to access some files on a web browser this is an app assisted game and once you've decided that you've solved the mystery you're going to go onto a website and it's going to ask you some questions that will represent your report about this whatever the scenario is that you've tried to solve it'll ask you multiple choice questions about the general scenario and any personal goals that may have been involved along the way you've got to answer those questions that that's going to determine your score for the game but that website also has some clues that you might need to look at most of the time it's things like newspaper articles or transcripts of telephone calls or something like that in in some ways it's a bit of a wasted opportunity there weren't that many multimedia kinds of things that we experienced in the clues that we looked at so far in the game in fact there was a recording but instead of hearing the recording when we went to the website which would have been a cool thing to do there was no audio it was just a transcript of that recording so most of the time it's text and it comes spinning out at you so it has some nice graphics really that could probably for most of the clues at least have been just a separate deck of cards but the multiple choice questions that you have to answer is is something
that's that's unique to these detective system games so that story that introduces the scenario is going to give you some information about what's going on is going to tell you what your overall mission is for the game and it's going to give you some leads and those you follow leads by moving you just there's no turns you just decide um amongst the the players which location which lead you want to follow first and that lead is going to involve taking a card either from the main scenario deck this one says prologue but there are three other cases beneath that or from the personal goal deck sometimes you get to draw a card from the scene deck now i'm not going to show you these cards but these are fantastic because these give you like comic book panels that kind of immerse you more in the story so you you are going to be doing a lot of reading there's a lot of text on these cards for you to read it's sort of like a choose your own adventure kind of a book if you want to go to the gotham city police department take this card and read what's on that card and then you'll get whatever those clues are and it goes it goes sort of like that but having the comic book panels makes it more like a comic book than a novel that you're reading and those kind of get laid out as you go through the scenario you you can still access all of the cards all of the files you've seen on the web browser everything is there for you you don't have to have it memorized although it is a good idea to take notes as you go to help you figure
out what this mystery is all about as i said to follow a lead you're going to be moving your little zeppelin well if i lost track of it you're going to be moving your little zeppelin around the map once you've visited a location you'll flip it over and that might introduce a cost or increase the cost to visit that location really the only one of the base locations that has a cost is the gotham city police department when you flip this one over it says that you need to turn over a little triangular token that has a police badge on it this is what it looks like it's harvey bullock who can earn those badges you do that by turning in a couple of these investigation tokens then you get the police badge that's going to allow you to pay to visit the police department because harvey bullock has connections there once you've paid that cost it flips back over again so really you only have to pay the cost every second time for the gotham because one side is free now the other locations i won't tell you about but there are varying costs to go visit those in different tokens that you might have to use to go to those places you've got a batman symbol and a joker symbol as well and each of the characters can earn those by earn those tokens by turning in these investigation tokens now how do you get these investigation tokens well you get them by following leads so when you do go to a location if i decided i was going to go from the gotham city gazette and i wanted to investigate something at the police station then whenever you follow a lead you move this little counter along what this counter does is it just tells you how efficient
you're being you're going to get more points for getting the right answer on your mystery in these early yellow or green squares so if you've only done if you've only gathered nine clues and you get the answer right you're going to get more points then if you keep going all the way down past 14. now you can continue past 14 you can get a whole pile of clues if you wanted to but you're going to get more points on that website when you do your final report if you've been more efficient after you follow a lead very often it will say you know take an investigation token that shows that you've got some clue and that's going to allow you to spend the token to go somewhere else but you do move this forward each time you follow a lead and then you turn in two investigation tokens at a time to get one of those other tokens that will allow you to visit the police station or those other secret locations that i'm not going to tell you about and that's really the game there's a few spaces here on the board just to remind you to discuss with the other players what you've learned so far about the mystery in an effort to kind of remind you that there's a goal here that you're trying to work towards to answer some kind of a question and then you're finally eventually you're going to decide to go to that web browser to that website and answer the questions to show that you've figured it all out like i said it's not a game that requires you to destroy anything so once i'm done here if i've decided you know i've figured out everything i want to figure out about this mystery i'm not as interested in the personal gold deck i can loan this game to a friend because all the pieces are going to be intact as
long as the cards are in the right order in these different decks it's no problem to share this game around and that is something i like about these kinds of games is the idea that if they're not destroyed then you can trade them with your friends you know if they have another detective system game you can trade it with them and then they can play the batman one and you can play a different theme if you really enjoy these games and that is a question that i have for you this episode uh if you are a player of these kinds of mystery detective style games or of escape room style games the most the the most similar thing i can think of to this kind of game was the star wars unlock game that i talked about way way back i think when the mandalorian first came out so a long time ago i talked about that one but if you like escape room games if you like these detective games i'd love to hear what your favorite ones are what are the themes that you like there are so many of those unlock and and escape room style games that you know i wouldn't even know where to begin if i was going to choose one of those so i'd love to hear your recommendations about that what skills are you're working on when you play a game of everybody lies well there is like i said earlier there's a lot of reading in this game so you will get to practice your reading skills uh all of these cards in the the clue deck and the personal goals deck are double-sided cards with a ton of text on them so there is some reading there to be done and then you've got to remember what you've just read and put multiple cards together because there's information from one lead that's that really fits in
with the information from another so you're reading you need to remember what you've read note taking is i think a really important skill to use when you're playing a game like this when my son and i were playing we would get to that recap stage he was taking notes on his ipad and that made it easy for him to highlight things and draw arrows back and forth between certain you know whatever he wanted to to make sure that he remembered but we would get to that point where it says recap on the board and it would be well okay we just heard this person's name that person's name came up when we were at the newspaper and maybe there's a link there between those two things and what about this other location and that kind of fits with this thing so so there's a lot of memory but note-taking can reduce that load a little bit and note-taking is definitely i think a good skill for kids to practice i didn't take any notes i allowed my son to do all of that and and he's a university student so he's he's well-versed in note-taking but the most important skill i mean really the goal of this game is to deduce the the solution to a mystery so deductive reasoning is something you're doing here too you're looking at clues and putting things together and from from all of that information that you've gathered you're trying to find the answer to a question and i think deductive reasoning is also a good skill to practice and it's definitely something that you know i like doing this when i was a kid i used to read those locked door mystery stories where you'd have all of the clues were in the story and then you turned to the back of the book and you'd see what the answer was but you'd be
trying to figure out the answer before you looked at it before you looked at that solution i used to like those choose your own adventure books when i was in elementary school maybe intermediate school junior high where it was you know if you choose to do this then you go to this page and if you do that you go to this other page and that's very much what this game is like except you're looking at numbered cards rather than pages in a book so you're doing some reading you're doing some long-term memory making those connections using note-taking and then you're you're practicing those deductive reasoning skills that will allow you to solve that mystery at the end of the day now and speaking of at the end of the day let's talk about what are the final thoughts what did i think about this game overall well it is that choose your own adventure style mystery and it's these are the kinds of stories that i liked when i was a kid and i i've always liked batman and i still do the new batman movie was fantastic in my opinion so uh it's it's got the gotham theme it's too bad you don't really get to play as batman but it makes sense that you wouldn't play as batman for these kinds of stories because you're the people that you're talking to the leads that you're following they're not they wouldn't really fit for batman to be doing the things that that we did as we were solving these mysteries uh and of course if batman were in the game then i i know that my kids will be fighting over who gets to be batman of course so uh in a way i'm glad that
batman wasn't i loved batman but i'm glad that he he wasn't a playable character in the game uh i would have picked catwoman except the very first time that we played uh i i chose vicki vale because vicki vale was necessary for the story my son wanted to be the other reporter so we were both reporters who were teamed up in that first story so um i do like that choose your own adventure style and i i like the gotham theme and i like that you're you're working together it's completely cooperative you do have those hidden goals and that makes it interesting that keeps it interesting and maybe allows you to use this game more than once but you know for the most part it is a cooperative collective experience and it's fun to work together it was fun for me to work together with my kids to solve this problem to solve whatever uh the mystery was so i did quite enjoy that but it is because it's a mystery that you're trying to solve once you've answered the questions apart from the personal goal it is kind of a single use for the most part game i because you're not destroying things though you can trade these detective games back and forth with your friends if they're also into that style of gaming if there's a downside well there are a couple of downsides i would say to this one is that you get to go to that browser to do the multiple choice questions and i think that's great but you also go to the browser to get all of those clues and it does that nice spinny animation sometimes like you would see on a tv show in a newspaper pops out but
for the most part what you're looking at are static images and it would have been more fun i think to have more multimedia as those clues you know to to he overhear a phone call or a conversation or to see you know some security camera footage or something like that so there's an opportunity there where you know you didn't see anything other than static images pop up very often so i think that would have been a a nice addition i think to the game also for some players the amount of reading in this game this game could practically have been a book like a choose your own adventure book like i said but there is a lot of reading in the game and you know some kids are comfortable with doing that reading and some players are less comfortable uh with that so there will be some who will say wow there's it's just there's so much to read here i'm not as interested in playing this as as i would be a i don't know a strategy game or something like that um but overall i think we're talking about that that uh it's a fun idea to to work together to solve a mystery you've got the gotham city theme which i like i really like the addition of the scene deck because the comic book panels pull you into the gotham city story and the artwork is good on those i i mean even just the card here on the top of the deck with that great picture of batman with the long shadow of his cape um you know i like that batman theme and i like batman and i like solving mysteries so there you go so there are a lot of positives here maybe some wasted
opportunities in terms of the browser-assisted assisted option you know i mentioned i think i mentioned the star wars unlock game a while ago now the app for star wars there are all kinds of things you were doing in that app you had to search around a snow field to see things sometimes you had to wipe off the screen so that you could find something underneath there are all kinds of ways that they use that you know things that you couldn't do with the deck of cards or just static text and i i'm i'm hoping that as i play through some of these other scenarios that there's more multimedia to take advantage of the fact that you're using a browser as as a part of this game and that in a nutshell is a spoiler-free description of batman everybody lies if you have any questions if you want to share with me your recommendations for other escape room or mystery style games you can leave them in the comments section below or you can email me at brian brainsongames.ca brainzonegames.ca is the website that's where future episodes will go and the previous ones are up there already brains on games is the twitter handle and the facebook page and the instagram feed so we're all over the place and if you enjoyed this video and you want to be notified of future ones you can head on over to youtube and click that subscribe button thanks for joining me and hopefully i'll see you next time