Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 17: Robert Domaingue on State Department Gaming

Transcript 46:37

hey gamers this is liz davidson from beyond solitaire and i'm once again taking you beyond the board this time with special guest robert domain whose job description is conflict game designer at the office of asian and pacific affairs at the u.s department of state so how you doing today robert i'm doing really well with thank you so much for coming on so you were a conflict game designer what exactly does that entail like your actual job is designing games well i should start out with um i'm actually a foreign service officer in the state department and i should mention uh the usual caveat that everything i'm saying is just my own opinion and doesn't represent the government or the state department or anyone else but uh yes so i started as a foreign service officer and uh primarily uh working overseas at our various embassies around the world and this is a special assignment that i'm in now where i am working with others to try and bring uh gaming tools uh for use in the state department some of those could be like tabletop exercises or matrix games or other approaches as well so that's that's the general focus of it so just for clarification what is a matrix game what kinds of games do you design and play yes so i i divide games up for for dealing with uh kind of real world problems into two broad categories one would be seminar games and those are argument based games and things like

tabletop exercises or matrix games and the others are systems games which are more rules bound and those would be like traditional war games and or board games so the rules are very structured in those formats whereas in the argument based games or seminar games uh it's it's much more flexible and loose so a matrix game is just a a sub category if you will usually involving six to eight people experts in some area and the structure is you make an argument about something and why it would be successful and then you go around the room and others make counter arguments uh either why it would not work or they could do it in support of that and we go around and listen to everyone's arguments and then people kind of step out of their character and they may be representing a country or an organization or whatever you're you're trying to figure out and game out so they step outside of their uh their role and then they give an honest appraisal about how likely it is to succeed the action and then uh you can have people hold up like index cards with numbers on them like ranging from 10 all the way up to 90 chance of success and then the facilitator will quickly scan the crowd and say okay it looks like everyone thinks that this is like a 60 chance of success and then a person would just roll a ten sided die

and if it gets one through six it's successful you know if it was seven or higher it was not successful so if it's a successful action then that becomes a new established fact in the game and then you go to the next person then they make then they propose their action that they're going to perform and so it works that way but it's a very flexible format that you can use for almost any kind of problem that you want to to explore if you can make arguments about it then you could use that format that's interesting do you feel comfortable telling us some sample problems that you have gamed out in this way i probably wouldn't talk about uh the particular games because there were other countries or other issues but um but the general format is to uh yep to present those arguments and then the counter arguments so one what you're really trying to get at is maybe assumptions that you may have held that you haven't examined or surprises something that causes you to think huh you know i didn't really think about that i better look into that more so it's often used to not as an endpoint so much as more of a starting okay we're exploring this topic we want to see where it goes and hopefully find some areas that we hadn't really thought about and now we're going to do some more research on it so when it comes to research how much research goes into sort of the pre-game for a

seminar game like this i mean what do you need to know before you're even able to really play and assess those probabilities or facilitate a game of this nature yeah i think it really depends on who your audience is if you've got a lot of experts who know a great deal about a country or an issue then you don't need to provide as much background material if you've got people coming with different backgrounds then you're going to want to get everyone up to a certain minimal level of understanding so that they're kind of all on the same page and then they'll bring their expertise in and people will respond and and interact with each other so so it really varies on their experience but i should mention that um tom moat is kind of like the pied piper of matrix gaming he's in the uk and works with the uk department of defense and uses these a great deal and has a website that he has posted a lot of matrix games that he's designed and other people have designed and has an online guide to uh to using these but tom in a party will say you know we're gonna we're gonna have a matrix game okay we're in a western town and you people are the bank robbers and you people are the uh the townspeople and here's a rough map here's where the bank's located go and so people will then kind of okay i'm the bank robber this is what i would do and they'll just run with a game like that so you've got the whole spectrum

from okay i need to do a lot of research and background that i'm going to present to people beforehand to uh you know what tom does in a party format where you're using people kind of spontaneously dealing with the issue so it's it's that flexible where you can use it from anywhere in between those those extremes that's so interesting so it sounds like seminar games are meant to be very exploratory very discussion based so how do systems games play into your work what kinds of rule sets um are we looking at in this sort of professional context yes so i think the the quintessential example of that is probably the department of defense war games and uh mitch uh was one of the earlier programs talks a lot about those and those are can be really large events where you've got a huge staff that might work on preparing a game for a year and then have high level officers come in and play that game for a week so in that environment uh very very structured in terms of what are all the rules going to be for engagements and how are we going to adjudicate you know there's a whole cell that's just figuring out okay i did this to that unit or something and this happened was it effective and what what damage did it cause or what impact did it have so people will try to work all of that out at least the rules for engagement and how the impact is going to be way ahead of time and so i think

matrix games were almost designed as a reaction against being having this heavy rule-bound kind of system and were a reaction to having these strict rules in place and wanting a freer looser kind of structure where you could take it in maybe directions you didn't anticipate so i think those would be the two main differences between the two kind of the systems gains games as being very rule-bound and having to work out all the details of the rules and seminar games being much looser freer being able to go in other directions now you also can have in a tabletop exercise adjudication and a group of experts kind of deciding okay well those actions won't work based on this or that and you can even use more sophisticated models but they tend to be a little bit more um flexible in that regard so as a conflict game designer yourself do you have a game style of choice or or do both types of games play into the work that you do i would say it's right now we're dominated by the seminar games now there there are interesting uses of board games for analysis and we we're not doing that so much now but i have seen other people do it and it's fascinating you know games on that have been produced on water crisis in the middle east and you get to play the roles of different countries and having to make all these difficult decisions about

allocation of water and you know if the farmers or the cities aren't getting enough social unrest but then you've got to deal with neighbors and so all these complex issues you're dealing with can really help you well one empathize with decision makers who have to go through all that but also make you aware of all the complex interactions so uh again i i've we've seen some very good examples of that we haven't been producing them ourselves it's a little far a little more complicated but uh i i think it's something in the future we would like to produce and as far as the large war games we're probably not not there yet we might try something at a smaller scale there's some other people in the department of state who are very interested in kind of developing their capacity to do more about uh wargaming out pandemics and the impacts of those uh so you know we're developing our capabilities but we we don't have the same culture and focus on war games that the department of defense does and they also use a number of seminar games as well but you know they've people are used to coming in and maybe doing this at the kind of the lowest levels and working throughout their career and being exposed to this we don't we don't quite have the same approach in the state department but i should say uh we we do have uh other traditions for example role playing is is used a great deal in the state department in fact in order to become a foreign service

officer you have to pass a a written exam and then you pass an oral exam and part of that oral exam is they are putting you in a in several roles and seeing how you will respond in one you could be trying to help out an american citizen who is in this third country and is in trouble and so you've got to provide assistance and in another scenario you might be delivering a difficult message to the host government who is not going to be happy with the message you're delivering and so they're wanting to see how you react and then you know there's a group exercise as well where you're playing a role of trying to figure out which projects uh the embassy may support so again they're they're putting you in roles and looking at your judgment and how well you adapt and work with others so uh role playing begins at the very beginning and then throughout your training it's used in in almost uh or in many of the training programs that people will take or in language training it'll be used so uh in certain aspect uh role playing is is widely used in the department so i'm assuming that you were assigned to the job of conflict game designer because you yourself have an interest in history with games if is that correct and if so what is your history with gaming well i i should mention it started before the state department actually growing up i did the more traditional games but i wasn't uh heavy into into war games and things

growing up but uh in graduate school i well i got my graduate degrees in adult education and was focusing on experiential learning so was very keen on how do you find experiences to help people learn out in the community or in the work environment that teaches them to learn from their experience so games are such a natural for that so that i was i guess you could say that i was primed to to be interested in the use of games and uh was able to attend uh some seminar games and some more games and just got excited about their potential and decided you know i really i really want to be doing this more of this so i had actually proposed for this special assignment that i delve deeper into this and try to develop materials and and capabilities and and just develop it further and the leadership uh in my bureau agreed with that and and so hence i was able to to do this so for gaming now uh i find the people who are very creative in the approach to developing seminar games or war games uh do have a background with board games and get inspired by that i mean mitch reed is a great example working with the air force

he is one of the more creative people in the work he does in his professional ward game design but he's also heavily heavily involved in board games and i think he's in uh mechanics that he's seen in board games end up uh influencing his thinking about how to design his his professional war games so i have uh you know taken inspiration from that and i've been trying to expose myself to just a larger range of games so that i could learn and get inspired by by them so just to clarify you have this job because you propose your own special project job and so it's not something that is a normal career path to become a conflict game designer this is something that is part your enthusiasm and part maybe a change in state department culture to embrace this more yes that's correct uh i'm a foreign service officer which means i have an assignment like every two years or so two or three years so i would go on to another assignment and then another and another in in the state department uh civil service people will be hired for one job and kind of stay with that one job and but foreign service will keep changing and moving their positions so in the future there could be a possibility and i think you know some people realize the value and importance of this of possibly creating some civil service

positions that will be there to help others develop tabletop exercises and matrix games and and use gaming for their own analytic goals or strategic thinking or just analyzing assumptions about some plan you want to run so my hope is that yes in the future there actually will be positions that uh where you could be hired into doing that and that you would be a resource to help other people develop games around a wide range of issues so you mentioned before and i'd actually been intending to ask so i'm glad you did that your higher degrees are in education and specifically in adult education what led you to that and was gaming always a part of it or was that an insight that you had as you were researching how people learn yes i actually started as an undergraduate in anthropology and studying cultural anthropology and went off to to grad school at washington state university originally in anthropology but a friend of mine from indonesia who was also an anthropology department but was taking courses in the adult education tournament told me all about it and i was just curious so i went over and talked with them and realized wow i didn't realize that one that this was even a field that you could study and uh or that the university even had a department in it so after investigating i realized

i really want to spend more time here so i ended up switching uh from my masters in anthropology or over to adult education and then my wife and i went off to to fiji as peace corps volunteers and i was very interested and still am interested in appropriate technology and renewable energy so i was working on this little smokeless stove project with villagers and i was trying to show them how to how to make the stove in a way that i was taught how to do it basically making cement and you kind of put it together and and people can use it and it saves firewood and it gets smoke out of the kitchens and has a lot of benefits and once people figured out what i was trying to do and you know they they made improvements they made it easier to build and they made improvements to the design and i just thought wow you know it's far more interesting to help people be more creative in solving their own problems than just provide the solutions to those problems and at the same time i was on on leave and went to a used bookstore and saw a book on creativity and said ah this is it this is what i want to study how do you help people be more creative in solving their problems so that's when i went to um to work on my doctorate at the university of wisconsin in adult education but a focus on how do you help people be more creative and and then brought in the experiential learning

part of that in helping people learn in the environment that they find themselves in and enhancing their creativity to learn from their experience and and come up with novel ways of solving their problems so that's kind of the the genesis of of my interest and i it still remains i'm keenly interested now as i think about games how can we use them in new ways uh to solve problems out in the community and so i'm i'm keen to promote matrix gaming for people who are out there to to look into it and encourage them to say hey you know i'm working in my neighborhood food bank maybe we could use matrix gaming to think about how we can improve services or problems that we may be facing or new ways of doing things or you know whatever whatever community group or organization you're part of bring this in and start with a few people get experience with it and then learn from that experience and share your share your experience with others so that we can learn from the great innovations that you do so this is really interesting basically what you're talking about is something that's role playing but for real life situations but as an educator you also know how do you get people to buy in to what you're doing and really commit

to a game or to a role-playing experience yeah it's it's a it's a it's a problem and even in the professional environment there are people that just see games as as you know trivial things and uh you know beneath me so those are the people you don't really want to invite uh but i think when you bring people together and you're focused on an issue that they care about and they want to see can i learn something from this that most people will approach it with an open mind and if you craft the experience uh so that you can kind of immerse them in it like you create a scenario that sounds compelling to them and they want to explore this and you provide you know the inputs okay well this has now happened or that action caused this unanticipated action to occur now what are you going to do and so you know people get in that role especially if they're in a problem-solving role and if they're working with others as part of a team i find people will get into it and and often will get pretty emotionally involved as well in the in the fate of their their fictional scenario so i i think it's how it's crafted and selecting the right people so do you think that that level of commitment helps people learn more information and learn it more deeply than just learning something the traditional way with some books and some citations and writing a research paper

i do um and and i'd really like to test this so you know if if possible i would like to have like a say a week-long traditional training course that's you know typical um lecture format say a topic on leadership development for example and have people go through that and then ask them you know what they learned and then maybe come back a little bit later and find out how they applied the material have that and then at the same time have a different approach and have like a game within game kind of thing where you're put in the role of needing to use these concepts in some environment and when you need it in the game you can then in a just in learning format call up say a mini little lecture that that provides information or insights on that skill you're trying to use so you call it up when you need it and then you apply it in the game and you get feedback from the game and i would this is just my speculation that i think if you had a a large extended game that allowed people to do this over a week and you compared these two groups that i believe the game group would have probably learned the material deeper better and a little bit later you would probably find that they could apply it in real life better than than the traditional class so this is just my speculation but i

really would like to test this out um and and i really think uh we would find that that people could potentially learn deeper through these techniques so essentially what you're imagining is almost a solo gaming module sort of thing where people are incentivized to want to learn the information that you want them to learn because you're putting them in a situation where they're immediately going to need it which is going to force a different kind of focus then like oh yeah okay let me sit through the training maybe i'll need this some time yes yes exactly putting that role of oh i need to do this and if you're really struggling and then you know involved in the scenario then you want you want that information you want it right now so i i think so and you mentioned solo games and i think i've become fascinated with the power i think that solo games can provide because i think you could create a solo game before a training and then people can do it on their own schedule and they can do it repeatedly and so it kind of primes them and then you have your your training activity and then maybe you have a separate or different solo game afterwards where they they use the materials in different ways or new ways and i think that combination could also be extremely powerful in learning but uh i'm yeah i'm excited about the potential for solo games and wanting to to just learn more and more about them well you've come to the right place so so here's my question though just as a

teacher too um how do you give feedback in a game like that that's how do you make a game that's so flexible because they're gonna have to use information how do you make it responsive you know how do you balance between having the game need to be free enough for the person that needs to learn information and apply it in a unique way but also rigid enough that you can spit out like a set you did this right you did this wrong this went well this didn't how deep can something like that go yeah it's a really good question and i've only seen bits and pieces here and there that kind of hint at it um one example would be people have different learning styles uh some can can dive into deep text and really get a lot of information out of that so i would want to be able to provide uh information in that text format but i'd also want to be able to provide it maybe in a in a lecture format an audio format people could hear it and absorb that information i'd also be able to want to provide it maybe in a in a simulation or something a visual representation of it so ideally i would try to provide information in various ways and let the the learner kind of navigate through what he or she finds that they use best but also encourage okay you primarily like to learn in one way but let's try and reinforce the material

by looking at it or or examining it in another way as well so use some of your other approaches to learning that that you may not normally use but by using different approaches you're going to learn that material much better there was a a i recently attended a the connections war gaming conference which was held online this year and there was a presentation on a dilemmas game it was a computer-based game but it was on covet 19 and you were put in the role of being a leader of a country and you had to make all kinds of decisions about um you know do we lock down are we opening things up and you had so they provided you with a series of questions are you going to do this or are you going to do that and you had a series of advisors to choose from and there were there were medical experts and then there were um political experts and then there were people from the community and then there were special interest groups and so you you could hear from all these people and then you had to make a decision and then the game would bring you to another another problem and then another one in another one and so it slowly developed but at the end of that you were then given a readout of because it could track all the decisions you were making who did you consult uh who who did you weigh more you know their opinions more on your advisors that we were using and what were your actual decisions so

in the end you know it gave you this whole plot of all your decisions kind of spread out in front of you so that seemed like okay there you could get a whole lot of detail about the decisions you were making and how you were responding to the challenges that were presented in front of you so these games are partially about learning in a sort of research and actually gathering information sense but they also teach you something about yourself the kinds of decisions you make maybe give you insights into the way that you would perform in real life weak spots to watch out for is that what i'm understanding from this yes i i think so one of the things that i hadn't thought about but when i went through this program at the end it said i was like i think 84 focused on uh protecting the health of population and hadn't given that any thought but when i went back and looked at the decisions and stuff and said yeah that's where definitely i was leaning in the whole series of of choices that were presented to me and there was a lot of difficult trade-offs there were economic issues and there were social unrest issues so uh in that whole mix of things i tended to have this fairly consistent approach and that was something that i hadn't thought about or even considered much and so the game allowed uh some peering inside of my own thinking that i wasn't aware that i was doing that is so interesting so out of

curiosity you know games you play them you explore and they also kind of present ways of being to you and make some actions more successful than others is there also a way in which the games are training foreign service officers to respond in certain ways or giving them positive feedback for certain types of problem solving i i think at this point not quite except in the area of language we we teach many many languages at the foreign service institute and there are a number of games to help you try to you know immerse yourself in the culture and use the language as you're you know going to a market or something like that and so for those i think they they really do help you learn the language in a context you know you're not just remembering vocabulary words you're you're trying to learn in a context and i believe probably when you are in that country trying to use the language you probably will learn it better because of that but in terms of right now helping you deal with really complex problems not well i should say that's what some of the seminar games or the table topics are trying to do they're trying to alert you to something you might not have thought about and so therefore you're going to okay here's here's a gap in our plan that we hadn't considered so now we're going to go back

and and do that better but uh you know when you're at the post and you've got all these different challenges coming up ahead um you know i don't know that we have games that will help you be more strategic although i think uh long-term board gamers will say there's you know playing different kinds of board games helps your strategic thinking and helps you think about okay allocation of resources and and having to make difficult choices between things so you know if you're used to that maybe you won't be paralyzed by all the choices in front of you and maybe maybe you could um so i think in the future we could probably make games that are a little tighter uh directed towards that environment but in the meantime there's probably a number of good board games out there that will in an entertaining way help you think about how you deal with complexity so you talked a lot about people being able to learn more in environments or in situations that they found compelling how much effort is put in state department seminar games into making the situation interesting or compelling as opposed to just educational yes i think again it usually you're dealing with a number of experts on the subject so they're approaching this problem and so it could be very narrow

it could be um something that people outside of that expertise wouldn't even really be what wouldn't even be focusing on that as a problem and in that case uh you don't you provide a general scenario okay you know this is this is the environment we're operating in this is the nature of the problem you know these are the resources that you have available or here's problems we've had when we're facing this issue now what are you going to do about it and so i think people quickly flip over into that problem-solving mode so you don't have to uh invest as much into that elaborate um background scenario interesting so we talked about games as a way to kind of open your mind to a problem a way to maybe look at yourself in your decision making processes how much attention is given kind of to the post game where you look over what happened and analyze the sort of session report yes that's absolutely critical uh there's uh so the naval war college is you know have been doing probably wargaming longer than almost anyone else they have a huge huge staff and they have an entire team that's focused just on data collection and analysis of the game

material so from the beginning when they do a really large game that could involve 400 people and they're taking a year to prepare they've got an entire team thinking about how are we going to collect the data and and they could have entire you know network computer systems that that are collecting data and note takers listening to what people are doing in the room a whole range of ways of collecting the data but that's critical because that's where you're going to gain insights and understanding and with these really really big games so much is going on that it's it's impossible for anyone to even know what's happening in all the different subunits and sections and different rooms so that's where all the data collection occurs now state department much much smaller scale with a tabletop exercise or or a matrix game a matrix game we might have like eight people around a table but we would still want to have a number of note-takers around the corner maybe one assigned to each team because if they if they break off and go into a separate room to talk well you want a note taker kind of scurrying after them to collect notes about what they're considering and what they what they thought they were going to do what they rejected and they didn't do some useful insights can come from uh people just considering well we could do this we could do that and then they don't even do it in the

game but if you didn't have a note taker collecting that that would have been lost but there might have been really useful insights from that like ooh we didn't really think about that as a course of action so having note takers around is probably the the simplest way of collecting the data and depending on how the how the game is structured you could use other ways as well again we're thinking about how can we do games in a distributed environment where people are at a distance and so now we're collecting you know email traffic or chats that are going between different groups so all of that's to be considered as you design the game but but definitely that that's the big goal and is the big difference between doing a game for fun which you can just enjoy the process versus using a professional game because there's a purpose for it you are looking at some kind of problem and you want to capture any insights that you can into that problem so this is so interesting because i've kind of been thinking about it on a personal level because i mean i play games for personal entertainment so i was thinking oh i could reflect on my game and see what kind of person i am but this is a whole new level where it's it's not only that the game is informative for the people playing it but it serves possibly a much larger purpose for anybody who wants to look over what happened when considering those issues is that how this is used yes sure uh what made you success

successful in your strategy that you you did as a team uh versus another team and why they weren't not as successful so teasing that out or or i think another really important thing is just teasing out assumptions okay you didn't do this why you know it seemed like a clear possibility and then you tease out the assumptions behind their thinking and realize okay they didn't even consider this this and this because of um some way they were thinking about the problem and so yes look there's a there's a very rich environment there and so a lot of thought has to go into not wanting to miss any any critical insights and and not losing anything when when you're uh when you're playing these huh so you mentioned playing at a distance how has distance play and the use of zoom how has that affected or maybe even evolved the way that these sorts of simulations play out yeah there's uh actually in adult education there's a whole subfield of distance education and there's certain parallels between distance education and trying to think about designing a game and playing it at a distance and you can think in terms of physical distance

but people are on at the same time so you know having a zoom chat and you're both on at the same time but you can be physically far separated from each other versus distance in time or asynchronously so i get on at one point and do a move or something and then someone in the other side of the world gets on and does it at another time so in that case we're both physically separated but we're also separated in a asynchronous or in a time separation so distance education has dealt with a lot of these issues in terms of how do you help learners learn at a distance and a lot of research has been done on using various tools and techniques and usually a new tool comes out and and some of the first research comes out that compares it with traditional face-to-face learning and and almost all the research shows that a well-designed distance program shows no difference in learning outcomes with with the in-person one if it's well-designed there can be really poorly designed ones where people have a hard time learning in that environment but but uh so taking insights from that i think and people are kind of rediscovering these elements on their own anyway when they're thinking about how do i do a game at a distance and how do i

figure out all those other support mechanisms i would maybe normally have in a face-to-face which i won't have so working around that and working around what's available with the technology are all the challenges one example that i kind of got excited about i was listening to a professor from alaska talk about his experience in a format that people have kind of referred to as play by mail which was maybe used more often in the 1970s but the idea of you would have a group at a distance and give them a scenario and they would think about what they were going to do and they would write out their actions and send it to you and you could have another party uh say an opposing force respond think about what they would do in that situation and send you their response so you collect them all and then you think about it and say okay uh based on this scenario and based on what this blue team did and based on what this red team did here's what i think would happen and so then you rewrite the scenario okay this is what occurred and then basically send it back to them and then they have like another week or so to think about what their next action is going to be and so in this way you can evolve this game over several months and one of the advantages of this is that

people can stick keep doing their normal work and do this on the side uh and come in and also have time to think about it you know it's they they don't have to be thinking about decisions right then and there with a huge time pressure now some games you might want that you might want to pressure people to under uh difficult time situations to come up with decisions but in other situations where you want them to reflect and think about it this kind of format seems like it's very flexible and doesn't require a lot of high-tech equipment you know you're using email and maybe powerpoint or or something like that uh to run it so i'm excited about this potential that is fantastic so i don't want to take up too much your time i'm going to ask you one more question before wrapping this up which is what are you playing right now for fun are you currently a hobbyist gamer as well i i am and i'm trying to to learn from them and i have to thank you for uh recommending the wars of marcus aurelius uh you know i i was interested in stoic philosophy but the combination of being able to to read basically his journal and maybe read a biography about him and then play him in wars just it brings it to a whole new level so as well as learning you know the mechanics of how to do a good solo game so thank you for that recommendation i'm i'm really enjoying it i'm so glad you enjoyed it and also it sounds like you're a gamer after my heart i love to do the full experience of like play the

game read the book think about the primary sources yes i'm glad i'm not the only one yeah it just it just it's more the immersive experience and it just you know just helps develop a lot of empathy as well uh um difficult decision being an emperor at war and having all kinds of other problems going on that's awesome and if you're interested in more stuff of that nature i've actually got a review copy of stiliko right now and it's looking pretty good stay oh tuned i'm i'm very excited i i'm so impressed with the designer i just had you know some some questions i didn't understand about some of the uses of the cards and just put a question on on board game geek and he just responded immediately and clarified uh what i was doing wrong and so i just i just appreciate him so much and so i am looking forward to his next game awesome any other game recommendations from you before i let you go well there's this one i was playing by family it's steam punk rally and it's a it's a game where you are playing an inventor and you're you're creating this vehicle and you've gotta you've gotta you know trade-offs between heat and water and electricity and you're basically building your engine as you're going in the race but your engine's falling apart and it's failing and things are going wrong and you're having to rebuild it and it's just your it's just ongoing engine building thing where you're allocating

dice to these different functions and it's just a mind stretcher but just a lot of fun as well and so i'm also trying to think okay what kind of things can i learn from those mechanics so i just appreciate um i i you know i i probably do like getting them uh attached by the theme at first uh another one is fields of green where uh very different you're you're building your own farm uh and you're you're trying to your fields of crops and your orchards and you've got your animals and you're trying to figure out how to allocate water but again you've got this little tableau of cards of your farm as you see it being developed and that's very satisfying but also those trade-offs and um as you're trying to optimize your farm and take care of all these needs is also very compelling that is awesome so robert thank you so much for coming on to this podcast and spending this time with me everyone else just so you know robert is an international man of mystery no there is no place to just find him on the internet although do you feel comfortable giving your bgg handle uh you know i don't even remember what it is well this is embarrassing not at all okay so our state department contact disappears into the mist but you can find me anywhere as beyond solitaire so feel free to reach out with any questions robert domain thank you so much for coming on thanks liz it's been really fun happy gaming everybody

you

Progress saved