Union Stockyard: Westward Expansion Kickstarter Preview
Transcript
The new expansion to Union Stockyards adds some meat to the bones, if you know what I mean. Dwayne Wolf, the designer of Union Stockyards, reached out to me to see if I wanted to play and talk about Westward Expansion on my channel, the first expansion to the base game of Union Stockyards to show it off for its Kickstarting campaign, which is scheduled to launch in October this year. I had reviewed unit stockyards a few months ago and really enjoyed the game. So, I welcome the opportunity to share with you what this expansion is all about. In this video, I'll talk about the mechanisms and additions this expansion makes to Union Stockyards and feature some gameplay in the background to highlight some of those additions. Please note that what you see from the expansion is from a pre-production copy, so rules and art are subject to change by the time the Kickstarter campaign is fulfilled. And at the end of the video, I won't do my usual rating and final thoughts since I kind of already did that with the base game. I typically highlight mechanisms, do game comparisons, and do a peer review of what other people say about the game in my typical review videos. And so, while I'll leave out my personal thoughts about the expansion, I will leave some thoughts from my friends that played the game with me to serve as a sort of peer review for this expansion.
So, let's get into it. Now, I count a few additions to the game uh with some changes that, you know, make make a different experience. Uh the game, first of all, is lengthened for up to two new years, year seven and eight. Depending on the player count, you'll add one of four random year cards in each year to make these extra rounds occur with various outcomes and twists that are historically based and similar to the other six years in the base game. You have a new action space board called the exchange building. Three new actions are available to choose from, including reduce wages. If you have fewer than four low morale tokens, you get five bucks. You gain one low morale token, and you do raise the Union Spirit marker up once closer to the strike area. So, this space is a great way to inject a lot of money to use earlier on in the game, but at a price to you and everyone else with additional low morale tokens and the threat of a strike.
Next is the futures space. Place a futures token on an animal price tracker right underneath it. Wherever that respective black token is at the moment. Now, the next time you make a slaughter or cell action, you may choose to take the difference between your colored marker for that particular animal and the difference between that and your futures token and gain the money difference as opposed to wherever that token black token might be in the future. So, it opens up the opportunity to make a lot of money when you do take this slaughter action, and it potentially also makes it better than anyone else's slaughter action for that particular animal. Later on in the game where that future token stays and uh doesn't move that price until you make that purchase. When you do make it, you do retrieve it back and you can take the action again to place the futures token elsewhere. But you will have that opportunity for perhaps a bigger um uh investment and uh you know injection of money to your game.
Then finally, the last action space is the rent building. You choose a building that someone else has built uh their building card. pay half of that money for whatever that building costs to the bank and then place a rent token on top of that. You gain the immediate benefits of that building, you know, moving up the different tracks, various tracks that are depicted in these buildings, but you also acquire the specialist icons that are uh that are uh depicted on the cards on. So, on the other hand, while the owner of the building does get two points for having that building rented out to you, you do have access to those icons and potentially a step closer to acquiring specialist cards.
And finally, next are the city boards. This is probably the biggest addition to the game and as the name implies for the expansion includes a number of cities west of Chicago historically important in the evolution of meat processing in the United States. You start the game with the same number of B and C boards as there are players mixed into the building deck are expansion cards too which are generic for both B and C portions of the deck. So, when you see this card in the queue and when you take the build action, you can choose to take the expansion card place and place one of your new six spot building uh wooden tokens onto a city board. Note that you can also place your land cards onto these spaces, making this build action free. Each board offers an ongoing or immediate bonus such as extra workers, extra actions uh like extra action opportunities like uh for an extra slaughter action for example and for especially for the sea buildings you have opportunities for extra points at the end of the game.
Now there is a two-player variant of the game listed in the rules. I won't get into too much of the details, but you essentially are able to play uh at working. There is a two-player variant of the game listed in the rules where two players play as two companies each and use their combined forces and play a simulated four-player match with, you know, just two players. I won't get into the nitty-gritty of the rules, but you essentially alternate taking turns amongst these four companies of which you control two of. Then finally included are cards and rules for solo play. As depicted in the background play of this video, you play against up to three bots. Uh one to three bots are included in the expansion. bought standing for business from out of town.
And these represent real packers and businessmen that existed outside of Chicago at the time. Each bot follows an algorithm on their cards that dictate what changes happen on the board, where they place their workers, what they could potentially block you out out of, with the goal of creating an opponent that's easy to manage but challenging too, and offers a competitive score to try to battle against. And you can alter the difficulty of the bots where they start off with their points as well as where they start off with their animal uh tracking tokens as well on the board. And essentially you there are some actions that they don't take. Once again, I'm not going to get into a lot of the rules, but you do use the uh their savings or their victory points as cash to spend for building and other actions. And so you they're going usually going up and down the track as they are gaining and spending uh this currency to uh block you and be competitive for buildings and and so on and so forth. One major difference as well is that you do not when they build a building from the queue, they do not place that wooden token building in packing town. they will uh as they represent outside sources of meat packing outside of Chicago, they thematically are building those buildings elsewhere. And so the entirety
of packing town is up to you up to you to build with if you are playing solo. Uh and also, you know, it's up to whoever whatever player count you are playing as if you do include the bots. Now that you know what this game is all about, here are some observations from those I played with about the impacts this expansion makes to Union Stockyard. So, consider this a version of the peer review section that I do in my review videos. Overall, the additions were mechanically sound, but also thematically appropriate, which is fantastic. And just as it was in the base game, the overall impression that I got was that Union Stockyards should be played with this expansion and no one would return to just the base game.
First, the addition of the city boards is great and offer some flexibility where with where you can build. Before Union stockyards could feel cramped and deterministic, but now options open up with different sorts of avenues of point scoring and ways to manipulate the board's state. uh some of those endgame, you know, buildings that you're trying to achieve with the sea buildings in particular offer a different route or a different strategy to pursue if other players, especially at higher player accounts, are swiping up the normal uh additions of of buildings that are offered in the game. It's interesting to note that during our plays with both with and without the expansion, we still were able to build out the regular buildings in our four-player game um experiences, for example, and go through the entire deck.
I uh playing this solo as a three-player game, I was not able to get through all of them, but got quite close. And so, uh, so it's still very interesting that despite the additional expansion buildings added to the deck, you know, you're still able to get through pretty much the entire deck of buildings, obviously offered in a different order every time. But but yeah, it was pretty pretty interesting there. There was an observation in our game that was interesting as well that is in regards to the building queue with the expansion buildings. If you don't build something, that card stays in the queue until someone takes it. If we understand the rules correctly, we had two B expansion building cards in the queue in one particular game, and no one was incentivized to take them, and they stayed there until the end of the game, essentially bringing our rotating available building cards to two instead of four. So, I suppose this can happen with any building card that no one wants to get in any particular game, whether it's the expansion or base game. But for some reason, the expansion buildings offered in our game, didn't quite fit the strategies of many of the players at the time they were offered. And by the time it had gotten later in the game, the, you know, the other two buildings had been taken and replenished and uh sea buildings came out and were more uh viable options, I suppose. And so it'd be interesting to try out a variant
of that where uh like the rightmost building is shuffled out or um swiped out at the end of the round or you know incentives like money are placed on buildings that aren't taken from round to round, things like that. Maybe to uh try to cycle through those buildings a little quicker uh when it does seem to be or feel like it's a little clogged. But uh you know once again maybe we didn't understand a particular rule or uh didn't play as efficiently as possible and so you know that that may be a fluke on our end. One person in our group really liked the future marker token because it was able to incentivize participation in the market in addition to the benefit of gaining a lot of money. uh the manipulation uh if you do have like a futures token near the bottom, you do tend to want to push to sell or slaughter that particular animal to raise its price. Uh if it is the least amount if if it's the uh lowest amount of you know animal uh compared to the other two at the end of the round, then the price will increase. And so that will decentivize other players from slaughtering that particular animal, but it will offer you an opportunity to, you know, use your future token and get a lot more money than otherwise would. And so it it it was a really cool way to uh try to get a bigger payoff and interact with that uh market of animals.
It felt like for some players that the game also introduced more low morale. Uh, I think some of the additional year cards that were available in the game, uh, as well as like the reduced wages action, which was really popular early in the game when money was tight, really did inject a lot of low morale into our game. And for our our uh games personally, we felt like there were uh we were on strike a lot more often than we were before when playing the base game. And so you really had to think about getting rid of low morale tokens more often, which which I didn't do. I totally forgot and got penalized for it heavily. And so that is something to keep in mind of and an I guess an alternative or an additional uh sense of like kind of like a feed your workers type of experience in a worker placement game knowing that you have a sort of source of points in getting rid of low morale if a lot of other players have higher amounts of that particular token.
So that's something to keep in mind. The renting action was okay. It offered some incentive to watch out for uh like other players buildings for specialist uh specialist set collections. Uh you know, if if someone was eyeing a particular building, uh you would have to keep track of what other players might do like and think, hey, they also share a an icon with me. Uh they could come in and rent it and then grab the specialist card before I do. And so a little bit of a cat and mouse, a little bit of a race to get the specialist cards. Uh the the specialist cards in general, uh even from the base game weren't as big of a hit uh thematically as well as mechanically for some of the folks in my play group. And so, uh, so, you know, it it might depend on your opinion from the base game whether you enjoy the race for getting those specialist cards and those additional points and bonuses, but uh, renting did affect that more so than like the actual bonuses did. And so, uh, I think that was the most interesting strategic element for renting as told by other players. Another impact the expansion had was simply it it made the game longer. Uh, one of the praises I had about this base game was that it was crunchy. Uh, and it was a, you know, a solid worker placement game. It, you know, teaches you a lesson about history, but offers really solid gameplay in about an hour, maybe an hour
and a half with four to five players. But with the additional one to two years, depending on your player count, the game length did go up by like a half hour or so. uh where the usual player count uh was before. And so do keep that in mind. It it does become more of a like a a single game that you would play in a game night uh a feature game if you will rather than say like something that you could fit in uh like two like another game or two in the same night. On the other hand, with the additional city boards, the worker placement spots, new ways to interact with the market, the expansion offered some additional flexibility uh to pivot or to zig while others zagged at higher player counts. So ultimately, in conclusion, uh it was determined by my group that it was worth the extra time spent uh during the game.
It didn't feel longer even though it did add it technically did add some time to the game. Ultimately, it was still an engaging puzzle that was uh that had an appropriate amount of variation and new additions that made this game feel fresh again. And and so everyone really liked the expansion that I played with. And so if you, you know, like what you see, you like what I've, what I've heard, what we've experienced, that sounds like it's up your alley, then you can go ahead and check out the campaign for Westward expansion uh the first expansion for Union Stockyards. Once again, available uh October this year. And uh so yeah, be on the lookout for that. And uh all the best to uh Dr. for Wolf and and for uh the his his expansion and campaign. So, I'd like to thank him for this opportunity to to do this video. And let me know uh if you are excited about this campaign in the comments down below, if you like the base game or if you think this might will or will not change your mind um about uh you know, grabbing the expansion. So, let me know. Thank you very much. Have a great day. I'll catch you next time.