Skip to main content
Loading video...

Root & The Riverfolk Expansion Review

Transcript 21:38

it's non-denominational holiday time and boy have we got a present for you never ever have we received as many requests to review a board game as we have done for root a game about cuty Critters slaughtering each other for Woodland Supremacy a game that has understandably whipped up board game enthusiasts into a frenzy so this holiday season we thought what better present could we give to our audience than a review of this Sensational game because in our household Christmas Means murder

all I want for Christmas is a board game one that's nice CU I land one to my mates and they left it in the state and now it smells like feed it's the cheese puffs now it smells like feet so all I want for Christmas is a board game something that's fun right out the box cuz all I ever get is the same thing but my friends cannot play with my socks they really shouldn't my friends cannot play with my

scks that was quite some murder yes it was the most murder in any board game review ever and in fact I'm expecting a visit from the Guinness people any second now do you want to do the review while we wait yes because the excitement might just slay me in route you will take on the role of one of the game's four factions the malicious Marquee deat the everpresent iy the bombastic Woodland Alliance of bunnies me and foxes and that raccoon known as the Vagabond your objective take control of the beautifully Illustrated Forest by claiming the most important prize of all be the first to 30 victory points one look at Roots cover and it's not hard to imagine why it's captured so many people's imagination here is a box that has ladles and ladles of charm delve deeper and Peak at the art on the cards and it reveals even more character and even a Sprinkle of Panache what exactly is pach I think it's some sort of detergent but let's not get distracted as much as the fight club via Beatrix Potter artwork from Kyle faren makes it stand out it's a Me candle to the Roaring forest fire that is this game's High concept root is a game of war where each faction has their own units that they Deploy on the map move them into territories and then fight fight fight but the way each faction does anything is completely different players Mary the

cat and you'll find yourself thrusted into the role of the forest usurper desperately Clinging On to retain control look that's a C on almost every clearing surely you are the king of the Woodland how can anything ever go wrong as the murder fluff balls you'll probably play a game that's most familiar building Sawmills that will fetch you wood recruiters that will make more cats and smithies that will let you craft artifacts that work as special abilities each building you build of the same type will fetch you progressively more points however it will cost you progressively more wood build a lot of Sawmills and you will never have a problem with wood but you will have no cats to protect it with however build a lot of recruiters and you will have a force to be reckoned with but you will be too slow to snag a win however leave the cats in checked and they will surely run away with Victory blink and you'll miss this tiny unimposing cluster of everyone's favorite M Birds whereas you once ruled the forest now you are but a mere Shadow of Your former glory but feather not because it won't take much to reclaim it all again as the iy you will play What's called a programming game but if that conjures images of computer Wizards coding software don't let that deter you because a it's nothing like that and B it's pretty

basic each turn you will be forced to play cards into the decree these cards form the Mandate that as the leader of the iy you are obligated to fulfill to translate that into human each part of the decree is an action such as moving battling or building roosts Etc put a fox card into battle and that means that you can battle an additional time in a fox clearing but it also means that you must battle an additional time in a fox clearing whereas the cats can perform mostly just three actions a turn your roster of action grows like an unwieldy Christmas tree that will start shoving presence into your arms whether you want them or not recruit move and battle turns into recruit recruit recruit which is incredibly hard to say move move battle battle build and if you fail to perform even a single one of these then your decree falls apart and you lose points playing the birds is the equivalent to frankensteining yourself on extra arms and legs until you have so many appendages that you can no longer function which is in fact an allegory if you think about it for how governments work but there's another catch unlike the cats you build roosts and roosts don't score you points when you build them but at the end of every turn which means turn after turn you'll score more and more points simply for doing things which means everyone will try and make you fail your decree but leave the birds unchecked and they will surely run away with Victory and if you think that is

explosive then wait till you walk a mile in the shoes of the Woodland Alliance if the C s start everywhere on this map and the birds have their own little corner then the Woodland Lions starts nowhere that's right you have no presence in this Forest instead you have support slowly but surely you will start spreading sympathy across the Woodland realm sympathy that can be squashed but each time someone does you will gather even more support gather enough support and you will literally be able to explode a sympathy token blowing everything up in a single clearing here is the kicker because you are the underdog you have half as much of a potential fighting force than any other faction and because you start with none it takes you a long time to build up a presence but every sympathy token you place will score you more and more victory points let me get yes if the Woodland Alliance goes unchecked then they'll run away with the victory I'm sensing a lot of checks here and who better to write those checks than the most B crazy faction of any war game ever the Vagabond imagine a faction in a game about having soldiers and sending them into battle you only have one soldier one piece traveling the world delving into dungeons completing quests

doing some casual murdering and generally having a grand time if the other actions are parasitic organisms spreading their systems across what can only be described as a biosphere of mechanisms then you are the Constant Gardener gently pruning the tendrils of corruption as the Vagabond you even have a system of alliances start killing cats for example and you'll get victory points that any additional cats you kill or you could help the birds out by giving them cards and if you give them enough cards suddenly you'll be able to lead the birds into battle but you have to be careful favor one faction too much and you'll tip the scales in their favor but leave the Vagabond unchecked they'll Run Away With Victory all right we get it this is why brute is so compelling because playing each faction is like playing an incomplete puzzle where the missing pieces are your opponents let's say as the iy you string together a perfect combination of cons it won't matter that each turn you will have to move out of two Fox clearings and one bunny clearing because you'll have prepared for that but let's say that I go in and decide to kill one of elain's cats leave my cats alone elain now has a grudge against me and she will leverage my strong position on the victory Point track to convince everyone else that I am the enemy and that's all it takes for someone to go from winner to Loser even

if there's a wh of success in the AA you you better have some air freshener to mask it this analogy has gone weird my point is as much as root is saying look I'm a game of cutesy animal War this really isn't a war game sure you have soldiers and you have combat but that's mostly just a tool to get in the way of other players what this game is is an exercise in puzzle solving and the ability to convince other players that your puzzle isn't the most aggressive and what this game really is is a myth it might sound like we're being negative but we're not we mean myth in all senses of the word something that's based on reality reality being the fact that this is a cardboard box with components that compose a board game that you can play but for a mystical veneer of gorgeous artwork and the promise of asymmetric player roles and the oratory culture of board game enthusiasts has taken on the perception of something more than it is I remember my first game of root very vividly we each picked a faction based on personal preference knowing full well that we won't be able to sink our teeth into the full depth that this game has to offer and I won't lie to you when I say that playing that first game wasn't as exciting as what came afterwards

the inevitable discussion of how the cats should have used their field Hospital ability more and how the birds suffered from the perception that they might be too powerful how the Vagabond should have focused more on questing and how Unstoppable the Woodland Alliance felt in the end we immediately gravitated towards picking this game apart and that could have only come from us being invested but it also came from a feeling that instead of ending on a bang or on a whimper this game sort of just ended and we didn't know what to do with ourselves but we wanted to believe that somewhere inside of this box there is a perfect game of root and that if we played it long enough we'd find it we wanted to believe that after X Games someone won't just blow the game out there'll be a really tight race a real Clash of the Titans and after a neck and neck battle whoever comes out on top it'll feel like they've earned it but that feeling never came even though we did have games that were incredibly close and I suspect that's something to do with how this game ends as soon as somebody reaches 30 victory points that's it the line is cut and they are declared the Victor imagine these pieces as victory points someone will tip the scales and then someone will tip them some more and then you will keep tipping

until someone slams it down and takes it away except in your head you're going right now wait on a minute EA that's not how scales work just because you dropped one kilo on one end what stops me from dropping two kilos on the other the 30 Point Victory marker feels arbitrary because arguably if I had another turn what stops me from just spewing out more points rout fans will undeniably Lynch us if at this point we don't mention the dominance cards in most plays especially if you're new then the dominance cards will just feel like cards but once in a blue moon someone will start feeling brave and might just play one for its dominance effect and at that point everyone will start going whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa if you play a dominance card you remove your Victory Point marker and Chuck it back in the Box you won't need it because you can no longer score victory points or win with them now you win if you control certain clearings at the end of the game for example three Fox clearings with a fox dominance card this is what is colloquially known as a ballsy move as everyone will immediately descend on you like vultures as soon as you do it playing a dominance card is like signing your own death certificate but wouldn't it be great if there were somewhere down the line that one game of rot and some of you might say look NPI you clearly want this game to be something that it

isn't except everything in rout leads you to believe that it's taking you to the promised land every faction has a carrot on a stick and that carrot is The Game's expansion what are you doing I don't know I just thought we could do like a smooth segue does this segue feel very smooth no ah yes the river folk expansion AKA all the extra stuff that was unlocked as part of roots Kickstarter and some of it really does feel extellent like why did they put five wooden blocks into my copy EA that's card holders oh yeah actually that's really nice and some of it really does feel extra like the mechanical Marquee which hands off the role of the cats to the AI so that you could play solo or Co-op or whatever other variants they dredged up that just don't work but the two actual extra factions that are included in this expansion the lizard cult and the riverfolk trading company well those are gravy because whatever that myth of root is whatever that carrot is they have extra of it we haven't talked much about the cards in rout because they work so differently for each faction but imagine them as a resource if a card has for example the mouse suit that means it's a resource that will function in a mouse

clearing and how it functions really depends on whom you're playing now imagine playing a faction in a war game whose entire engine is based on the premise of playing with an Open Hand of cards and trading those cards away to other players not only do you have to figure out what value your opponents are willing to pay for whatever it is you're selling but you also have to convince the them to buy things all together after all everyone could collectively decide to ignore you and then what do you do playing the Beavers is not only hard I'd argue they are deliberately more convoluted less efficient and less likely to win but within them lies that potential that one day you will play as the beavers and you will play your best game of rout and you will when one day which brings us to the recommendation part now everything that we have already said might lead you to believe that we are going to say that root is yet another overhyped Kickstarter over promiser except that it isn't my belief that the popularity of root lies in its accessibility and by that I don't mean that it's easy to learn this game comes with two Rule books that teach you the game pretty well but sometimes confuse and mislead and sometimes even cont contct each other and it's never enough just to

learn how your faction works you have to learn how all the factions work to feel like you have a leg on this table no what I mean is this is a war game that refers to no real war it isn't a battle that your family were involved in or that you might have lost friends to and so can't really stir up feelings of sadness or regret in The Human Condition it's pure fantasy plus it's really cute making you feel like you're just another part of it rather than you are on the wrong side it's much harder to hate a faction when they look like weird 30s clocks and it's a game that can bring people together with differing board game preferences don't enjoy having to negotiate to get anything done then play pretty much anything but the Beavers or the Vagabond if you enjoy programming and your friend enjoys Euros you can still play together choosing the factions that suit you and how you enjoy playing you can choose a faction that has a lot of interaction action or one where you're pretty much playing your own game which makes it very adaptable and if you're not sure which type of game will suit you you can try each one out and find the one that you like best you don't have to go out and get a new game in order to play a different game almost like a smoggers board but instead of meats and cheeses you get all the wood you could ever dream of root is still the right game for the right person someone who really likes board game mechanisms someone who likes to Tinker someone who likes to push things far and see how long till it breaks and

if that someone is you then you might just find joy reving in this myth at NPI we've come across so many games that dare to be different that experiment and often times we've just found them to be an awful waste of people's time and money from the arrogant and obnoxious 504 to the voluptuous feudum to the very well-meaning discover lands unknown all of these games have been flights Fancy from the designer or publishing houses that worked on them and in our experiences the best that they could offer anyone who bought these games was a cardboard box with wings glued on with candle wax R is an experiment but it's an experiment whose primary concern is to make sure that you have a good time and maybe you'll play it long enough to engineer that myth into a reality and for you the Tinker we undeniably recommend this game and for you the expansion is a must you just have to believe leave it hard enough and for us we can't wait to see what designer Co worly or publisher leader games is up to next the bad news is that if you decided you want to get this game well the main game and the expansion are both woefully out of print and you will have to wait till the kickstarter reprint or retail reprint however they decide to further distribute this to actually get your hands on it however if you decided that this wasn't quite for you or if you just can't wait and won a cool game here has some alternative recommendations Kim is

a classic and it's fantastic whilst technically not at all asymmetric each game Power tiles will let you engineer a strategy that feels entirely different and its two expansions significantly change the dynamic of the game if you're looking for that asymmetric faction feeling while it's not at all a war game we couldn't find a better recommendation than ciral Confluence a game of trading alien factions and those factions suitably feel alen and whilst both the artwork and the production are atter Pants the game play is so crisp we named it our game of the year for 2017 why can't I hear music oh

Progress saved