Skip to main content
Loading video...

Is this expansion a must have? - SETI: Space Agencies Review

Transcript 16:59

Hello everyone. This is Johannes

and this is Donovan

and you are watching Board Gaming Ramblings

and today we are taking a look at Space Agency the expansion for STI.

Yes, we are. This is a review copy. So, thank you so much to CG for providing us with this

city last year.

Really good game.

Yes,

one of the good games. Great games from last year.

One of the best.

Yes, we really enjoyed our plays of City and now we have an expansion as always. We use the expansion as an excuse to be able to play the game again. Uh what this review is going to be, we're going to go through the new elements. I'm already going to say we're going to show the alien boards, but we're not going to go deeply into the mechanisms or show the cards because I know for me a lot of the fun of steady, especially the first time you play and also whenever you play, you don't know the aliens that coming out. So exploring the new aliens is like fun part of the game. So you will see them. We will kind of detail on kind of the thing they do but we will not go into detail. I said we were detail not go into detail but we will not go into like great depth about that.

Many people felt like there was some problems with SEI.

We you will see later in the review if we felt that or not because we're doing our three three player ranking

must get should get or skip it all together. Yeah. MS get is basically fixing a game that needed to fix should get if likes more variety and if the expansion is good and skip is obvious you should skip away from it never look at it again. Okay, let's talk about this game. Um, SEI, if you don't know it, it's a action selection game. And if you don't know SEI, I don't know why you're watching a review for an expansion for the game, but it's an action selection game where you are trying to find uh like proof that there's aliens out there, and you will find proof because or else the game would be

spoiler alert

and you will interact with space, sending out probes, landing on different planets, trying to be the best space agency, basically. Yeah. So, first I'm just going to briefly talk about the few things that are new in this game that doesn't change anything.

Yes.

First off, there's cars. There's 42.

Mhm.

I like that.

Yeah.

42. Yes. The answer. Uh new cards. And these you're just shuffling. And this is one of those where of course when you if you get too many of the cards, you can kind of dilute it. But if the kind of abilities I'm guessing that the amount of different kind of abilities is still kind of the same, like the what is it called again? the proportions, the ratio. That was the thing I was looking for. And

I can't really say anything about like, oh, these new cars are fantastic. Because when you play the game, they're just there.

A couple of times I played the game, I was like, oh, that's from the expansion. Because there's a little symbol. I'm guessing you never saw that. N. So, it's it's a thing you can just add. So, whenever whether you don't like the other things in the expansion, you can just add this. The other thing you can just add is the aliens

because they will change the game but not in a way where the other things like the other aliens also changes things.

So those are the two things like there is the last thing is the space agencies and the quick start which we're going to probably use the most time to talk about in this video. Uh and also scanning but these are like the things you can just add. So we're going to briefly talk about how we feel about the aliens.

I like all the aliens. They feel different from the ones in the main game and I like the aspects of all of them. Uh the first one here is very timing sensitive and has interaction in it. The other one here has some set collection and also interaction as well. And last one maybe the one that we're least keen on of the tree is more has run more randomness [clears throat] in it. But of course as you're okay with that with interacting with that alien it's no problem. It's like you you get some random stuff basically. All of the random stuff is good.

Yes.

But it might be, oh, it's exactly the random stuff I needed. Or it might be this is not the thing I needed. But again, if you go for it in a way where like I hope I get what I need. Oh, I didn't get what I needed. Then you basically chose that yourself. So I will I feel like this fits right in. Like even if you don't like the rest of the expansion, you can just get the cards and the aliens, mix them in, and you have basically more variety. There was five aliens in the base game and now there's three more. So, it's a big uh addition to the variability of the expansions. So,

let's talk about the the thing that is the most thing about the expansion. The most

the most thing which is the space agencies and the quick start. Many people had a problem with SEI where they felt like the beginning of the game was too slow,

especially round one, maybe round two depending on how fast you got to the alien. Some people felt like the alien part of the game was where the game was interesting uh and they wanted that to happen faster.

First of all, did you ever have a problem with that part of the game?

No, I did not. No.

Uh I agree that the beginning of SEI is slow, but I don't mind it being very scarce on resources and very very hard to get anything done. I've seen that in other games. I'm kind of used to it, I feel like. So, I didn't have a problem with it, but I can absolutely see that that's not the favorite part of the game for many people.

I really understand because I remember the first round of SETI. The first round of SETI is I feel like I'm getting to do two things. And after I done those two things,

I I can't do anything else. Yep. And

for me, that kind of felt like a setup round. Yeah.

And now there is a setup round. So, instead of playing the first round, you're going to get four of these quick start cards, and you're going to choose two of them. And all of them basically do most of them do one of two things with a couple of exceptions. Uh, so there is a couple that give you a trace that you will place and the other ones are giving you uh able to place a orbiter in a specific planet or placing scanning basically uh in different sectors while getting some bonuses. you don't get the specific bonus for doing that action. So, it's not like, oh, I going to go to this planet to get that bonus, but you get So, for all the scannings, you're going to get two data. So, it's kind of like doing the scanning action. Uh, but for the uh the uh orbiting, you're not going to get that.

So, it is setting you up, setting setting you up. I'm the first person who ever did that joke. Oh, some of them actually just give you nothing and just give you better points. and and it's a kind of like a you're choosing some points as well. So you you are simulating that you play the first round. And when you're playing with one or two players, you can also draw four of them which will add uh things to the board to simulate like a third player doing something in the first round and then doing nothing again. Well, I like that though because with two players, well, basically things in SETI is generally expensive when you have like zero resources at all times. So, having a few um um markers uh in the place where you can scan already gives you more opportunity to go for that and also having some orbittors out makes it cheaper to land on the planets. So, I I felt that was a very easy thing to add to the game and I I I think it was a positive thing.

Let's just briefly talk about scanning before we go further because scanning uh people had a problem with scanning in two players. I never thought it was a problem. I just thought it was different. Yeah. Like the last game we just played, uh, I went pretty heavy on scanning in a two-player game and it worked out really well because scanning, some people said scanning is a bad action and I can't really understand it because when you scan, if you manage to win, of course, then you will get to trace uh, one of the purple or the the red traces. Purple traces. What color is trace? Pink. It was none of them. It was pink. Yes. Pink. Pink trace. Pink trace. and and you get to mark that and whether you win or not when you scan you get data which you use for the blue traces.

So you basically get double bonus for doing it. So I feel like it's a pretty powerful action because the one action gives you the possibility to do two of the three main things in the game.

Absolutely. And I I feel like I enjoyed the setup because it's just like it makes something a bit more available in the beginning so you can again so you can get going faster which is kind of the the thing of this game. I felt like these were a great addition. Um for me I again it's not like I had to play that first round.

Yeah.

So I can do this like it's it's not for me but it's not fixing anything. It's just like a different way of starting the game for me. I think people uh some people will say that it's fixing 100%.

I I will not.

So, let's talk a bit when we're talking about scanning. Let's talk about these scanning tokens that you can get

randomly from cards because it's that it's not like, oh, you're going to get these in the expansion. You might get them or you might not get them. What they do is that you can use up to two of them in a scan action to discard more cards from the card row to to scan more basically. So, it enhances again the scanning action. um which is fun.

You get to do more which feels good because doing things is always good. And now the main course of this expansion I would say are these 11 different agencies. They have oh that's flying out there. They have a couple of very specific things or interesting things. They have your starting resources so you don't start with the same resources anymore. They have how many of your four cards you start with with your that you tuck so that you get some more income that you choose yourself. Some of them have zero. Actually, I think there's only one that has zero and the others have from one to three of the cards depending on what the card is going for. So, talk to me about like of course like how do you feel about these player powers?

I like them. I feel like they push you in a direction of the game. So, if you don't like that, you might not want to play with these, but they felt

um they felt interesting and cool. I like the ones that I've played it with. Some of them feel more complicated to master than [clears throat] others, which could give you a real challenge, and some were really straightforward, uh generally good, don't push you in any particular direction at all. I think it's Yeah, it's like some of them are very specific, some are more general. I feel like some of them feels and it's hard for me. We haven't played a game thousands of times, so I'm not going to go and say something about balance because people make a lot of time to make their game balanced. So, but for example, there is one where you launch a probe, you will mark a signal.

Mhm.

Which is decent, but you're not going to The last time I played that would be pretty good.

Yeah.

Because I launched I think maybe eight or 10. Yeah.

So, you can do that instead of kind of a scanning action or helping you to finish that. So, it's good. But you also have this other one which is whenever you play a card as a main action, you can also do a a mark a space.

Mhm.

So, you can scan with with three different colors and then once a turn you can get a card and take them away so you can do it again.

Which is feels like kind of the same thing just better.

Yeah. I I don't know because I haven't we haven't had played with any of these actually and I don't feel like this one getting a card and getting the free action is so much better than just getting a card. So it is it those were I looked through them and I was like this one looks like kind of the same but just in a worse way. So

you see it has better income probably.

Yeah, maybe. But it's it's very

it doesn't Yeah, a little bit but not a lot. I feel like it's and all of them are going to be fun. Some of them I feel like this one and this one is the one that we have always chosen to not do. Yeah.

Because I can't understand how I'm going to play this. It's basically the only thing you can do is that you you have a little marker and on my turn as a free action I can place that marker on the scoring track and I can place a card down on the table and if that card has a cost of two for example I place a scoring marker 25 points ahead and then when I get 25 points or more I can play that card for free.

It's I feel like the timing in this game is very important. like I always have like a specific and I'm going to be like, "Oh, I place down this four cost card and then I get this like I don't need to play that anymore or it's I will always need to play a four cost card, but like a smaller card." So, and also you can like move it forward to get more cards. I I felt like this one felt very weird.

Yeah,

I I don't think I personally would ever choose it

because I if not for like let's see what happens.

Yes, I need to do that one time because it feels wonky. Yes. But but that's one that I feel like is really challenging. But um it might look like a lot of points and you will never get to play that card, but points uh like chasing points feels very important in SETI in general.

In most games where points are good.

Yes. So actually could work out pretty well and I guess when they have designed it and played it and did it, they must have had tons of fun with us.

Okay, a couple of things. Uh the game is not shorter.

No.

Uh because you get to do just more stuff in the last rounds. So that's our feeling so far is that we it's not like it's a quick start. It's more like a quick start. You get into the action faster, but it's not going to make the game quicker

because I feel like round four and five is just going to be a little bit longer, which then takes away the time that you use in round one, which isn't a long round anyway. Uh also, uh you will get to the aliens faster. Mhm.

You can absolutely get to the aliens in round two, which is now round one.

Yep.

And for some people that was like the main part of the game, what they wanted for the game. So, I feel like that is a good thing. Again, if this is not, this expansion doesn't fix anything for me. But, you know, when you watch this and you read about it and you saw it, if this changes the things, I've spoken to people, friends of mine like, I hope this expansion fixes the things I didn't like in SEI. I loved SEI.

Yeah. I love almost everything and single thing about SEI. It is very tight. There is some randomness to it. That randomness is not gone. But other than that, I I really like SEI and I feel like this expansion is good. Should we do some final thoughts? Yes.

Yes. Do you want to begin? Yeah.

I was almost into mine, but you can start.

I uh Oh, thank you. Uh

because I like this new expansion. I I think I will choose to play with it every single time we play. I wasn't troubled by the first round, but then again, that wasn't my favorite part of the game either. So, I would be happy to explore more of these um space agencies and also to have the setup round because it feels satisfying. I have to say though that the second round

still feels pretty slow.

Yes. And tight.

Yeah. So, just so you know, you won't get a tons of things done in the second round either. Maybe a little more. Um, but in general I would say for me this is a should get and I think as you touched on Johannes, you will know if this is a must get for you because what from what I understand uh this should be a must get for a lot of people who had uh bigger problems with the slowness of STI in the first place.

I agree with basically everything you said. I feel like this is another expansion which I will also just want to include. I feel like you're gonna get two of these. So, if you don't like one of them, you're probably gonna like the other one. I think if I get like two things I don't like, I'm just going to choose one of them and have fun. Si like we talk about it now. I just want to go and play it because SEI is so good. And the expansion does it make it better for me? No, it doesn't make it better, but it makes it the same fun and kind of different fun like it it makes it so I have to focus in a different way. as we said some people will feel like it makes it a lot better but for me it's just like the same great game just with some more stuff and for me that is a should get absolutely recommend it if you are into city and of course if you think that the things that many people felt like were problems with SEI think you will like this a lot and that's going to be the end if you are still here you can

subscribe

yes do it and we'll see you soon thank you so much for watching I'm Johannes I'm cinema

and you've been watching board gaming ramblings and bye-bye

Progress saved