TEND levels up with the Hive expansion - TCbH Review
Transcript
If I had a nickel for every time that I've had to cover a game about space bees, I'd have two nickels, which isn't a lot, but it's weird that it's happened twice. If you've followed this channel for a while, you know that the our opinions of the output of relatively young publisher Ivy Studio has been mixed. But, one undisputed fact is that I love Tend. It's big, it's weird, and it subverts so much of what I think I dislike in tabletop gaming by just giving me a load of rich systems to explore and barely any time to explore it. And Ivy is now coming out with two new expansions for the game, one of which dramatically changes the scope of what Tend even is with some fever dream of a three-act multi-game structure ala Arcs. And then, the other, which is the subject of today's video, the Hive expansion, which adds space bees, tool upgrades, and just overall makes Tend even more Tend. Hive is lean in concept, but its execution is pretty dramatic. Within, you have new cards that add to the action decks, more markers to indicate luxury goods, which all of delicious space honey is considered, some new reference materials, two dice through which all global apiary growth is determined, and last but far from least, a new sheet used in addition to your prior farm,
featuring a new holding area that is more confined but offers up to three points for a designated item. Your apiaries, through which you generate honey, a buttload of new basic action upgrades to be explored and unlocked, and then a whole section dedicated to investment, through which you can commit resources to build up multipliers for each badge you unlock. The titular Hive comes through these two dice rolled during each setup step of a round. And during the round, players can freely write the number from the yellow dice onto an unlocked apiary, obeying its numerical restrictions like same or different numbers or total values under an amount. When you complete a row, and then every production phase from there on out, you earn that apiary's unique type of honey, instrumental in many of the new upgrades, but on the whole, exceptionally lucrative. And your beekeeping has upgrades, too, allowing you to also mark the white dice or modify outcomes. As you might expect, Tend is going to tend. Okay, so the first thing that I have to point out here is that Tend is already a table hog, and Hive stretches it to its limit, probably beyond it. And I, for this review, played Tend solo. I think it's perfectly suitable as a multiplayer game, especially with a simultaneous action play, but as a solo game, it loses virtually nothing. And even then, it was taking up vast swaths of tabular
real estate. I can't imagine the table that you would have to have to play this game with this expansion with four or more, five, six plus players. But then again, I guess that's to be expected out of an expansion to a game that already is as maximalist as can be. And therein lies my biggest criticisms. Hive accentuates both the best and worst aspects of Tend, and just presents them in dire relief. Did you hate the dizzying array of symbology out before you and the complete free-form opportunity to both synergize and stumble your way with whatever whims you fancy this given play?
Well, the Hive completely compounds that. On the other hand, if you're really into that kind of thing, if that's what attracted you to 10 and you're like, yes, I love this. Well, Hive sees you and just lays on so much more. To be clear, I love the new upgrade paths and opportunities with cool little additions like whenever you complete a corresponding core action, you get a bonus resource based on a dice roll or you get to pick up an animal or a crop. The possibilities are huge, but the outcomes, particularly late game, are so full of cascading effects that it's dizzying.
I dig it, but I could play 10 games back to back and not tell you if it's balanced in the least, whether there are some dominant strategies or optimum paths. Though I'd argue that even if there were, following them undermines the best part of the game, which is just picking a route and seeing what you can make out of it. As for the bees, well, they're awesome. Admittedly, I was disappointed at first that I didn't actually get a cool dice for them on my board like other animals, but the new functionality is perfectly fine and leads to a level of automation distinct from other systems in the game. Probably the only thing I didn't find interesting was the investment system, which just felt like a repository for surplus resources and cash you're going to end up with due to just getting a lot more stuff through upgrades and the the hives in this game with this expansion. The investment system isn't a detriment, it's just by far the least exciting addition here.
So yeah, Hive, it doesn't seem like that big of an expansion, but the impacts are exponential in space, in resource production, in possibility, in the complexity and also complication involved in action interactivity. Personally, it makes me love 10 even more and also I'm a big insect guy, so I love even conceptual abstract bees. So I'm always going to want to play with it, and I'm certainly always going to play it solo, but I am never going to teach a game with the Hive expansion included because my god, but as far as I'm concerned, Hive is kind of an in for a penny, in for a pound situation. If you're already [snorts] on board with Tend, then I think that this is going to feel right at home. If you got the table space, if you got the willing personnel to take the space farming spreadsheets to 11, then Hive is going to get you there. And that's our review. But, let me know, what is your favorite maximalist game, and was there an expansion that recognized that and even cranked it up some more? Put it in the comments. And as always, thanks for supporting. Thanks for being such a great audience. Thanks for watching and doing all the things that help us grow.
The likes, comments, subscribes, checking out our Patreon, and sharing these videos does a huge amount to just help this channel keep doing what it does. But above all else, just thanks for being such a great community. You know that I've been Jack for The Cardboard Herald.