Good Games - On Tour, Search for Planet X, Transcontinental, & Umbra Via!
Transcript
welcome to john gets games where today i'm bringing you a new good games vlog and this was actually recorded live on the youtube channel and then i edited it down to the video you're seeing today now i'll be discussing my initial impressions on four games that i enjoyed and played recently and i will be going through them in alphabetical order now i do want to mention that if you'd prefer to listen to this vlog instead of watch it then you can do so by searching for the jongit's games podcast wherever you normally listen to podcasts i also would like to ask that if you end up enjoying this video that you please click the like button for it down below as well as the subscribe button for the channel in addition to that if you'd like to directly support the channel in the creation of videos just like this one in the future then please go to johngetsgames.com support there you'll find a bunch of ways that you can really help things out and some of them come with perks like watching some of my videos early and advertisement free as well as voting on which of those videos are made alright let's now jump into the vlog the first game is going to be on tour uh now this is a game that came out uh well about two years ago it looks like and this is one i've heard about a little bit over the years it's a roll and write style game where you are thematically trying to book a tour for your band across america or europe uh now this game didn't really jump out to me because it came out in a time when there were a ton of rolling rights happening so i kind of saw it in passing and didn't really think much about it but then i played bytes from boardgametables.com the publisher and um they asked to send me a copy and they asked if i wanted on tour as well so i said yes and i'm glad i did because i have been
able to play this one so far and uh let's talk about how it plays uh now out here you can see we have um a board in front of us this is a roll and write game that actually uses dry erase markers instead of having a piece of paper and a pencil and we have only played it once and we played at the europe map there's an america map on the other side now mechanically the way this game works is very simple uh you have these two large d10 dice and every single uh round essentially both of those dice are going to be rolled then you will deal out three random cards and then every one around the table this plays up to eight people everyone around the table will simultaneously um do something and once everybody has taken their turn we discard the cards roll the dice again and then deal out three more cards so the what you do is is a really neat take for dice rolling games i haven't seen this mechanic before where you are going to write two numbers down onto your board and those both come from these two dice you have to bring those digits together so in this example we have a nine and a three so that means you have to write a 93 somewhere on your map and you have to write a 39 somewhere on your map so if you rolled a zero three then you would write a three and a thirty as well um now the way the tour actually works throughout the map of europe in this case is you start with the lowest number and you continue up onto equal or higher numbers until you stop you don't actually have to start with the absolute lowest number on your board you're just trying to score the best overall tour that you have and um right here we have an image of the game about halfway done
now on the map we have europe and there's a bunch of lines between all of the various cities and the rubric actually recommends that you start drawing lines between cities mapping out the potential tour that you're going to be doing this is a dry array style game so that means you can modify your tour as you go and in this case i have several little lines connecting various spots where i think it's unlikely i'll be able to better that specific part of the route because again these are just numbers and you are matching or exceeding so when you have a three and a five i think it's pretty unlikely i'll get the four to put it in between so i put the line between there to say this is probably what's going to happen on that leg of the tour if i end up using it so again you find the the best leg of the tour the best uh connected set of cities that ascend uh to give you the most points at the end of the game and that's the one you'll go with and the points are really simple in this game uh you are simply going to be getting one point for every single city that you go through and if the city is circled then you get an extra point and the cities become circled if you actually write into the city that matches on the cards so the cards have two big pieces of information they have a region an area like south west um north central that kind of thing and they also have a single uh country on them on the europe side or a state on the america side now if you write the number into that specific uh state or country then you get to circle that uh state or country and if you end up going through there on your tour you get plus one victory points one for just going through that city and plus one for the circle so what that means is this game does a
really good job of leading you astray because you know the mechanics are very simple you just roll the dice write two numbers down i did forget to mention that each of the two numbers has to match up with a single one of the cards so every single round each player is going to utilize two out of the three cards so that means you have these number of restrictions where you're trying to make this ascending tour that's going to be wrapping around the map and you also you know have to pick a specific card um and then it has that allure of saying well if you put the number on that specific city you get double points so what that means is it kind of pushes you uh to make mistakes or to i guess push the envelope to a certain extent because you want bonus points you want to circle these cities but uh very often when you actually decide okay i am going to go into montenegro um well what if that's a little bit of a stretch what if that's a couple cities away and what if there's only nine numbers between the previous city there and the next one that you want to connect these two up maybe you'll actually get no points for that instead of getting double points for going through there and i really liked the way it was um actually pushing you into these difficult decisions because if the cards did not have these uh state or country names on them it would be much more flexible you just place it into one of the very large uh regions that show up on those cards and you just have lots of flexibility to place things down now i'm not saying it's easy but i love that extra temptation that little uh you know devil or angel or you know figure on your shoulder tempting you to do the riskier thing uh now as this game goes on you're just going to keep playing until every single location has a number on it and then you score it as i mentioned
before and um as you can see uh there are pretty winding different uh routes you can take but crucially there is some randomness to this game like there is definitely great decisions you can make but in the example that i have here i got 31 points and i started over in turkey and i ended up in ukraine kind of rapping all the way around europe but the final number the very last number that i put down was germany which is right in the middle of this chain so this is a 31 point scoring tour but if i had not rolled a number between 50 and 64 on that very last dive roll of the game my score would have been halved i would have had to go either the northern tour uh i guess going from i believe denmark over to ukraine or i would have just done turkey over to oh man it's really hard to tell but you know somewhere in near poland switzerland i think i put marco right over the name sorry about that um so yeah there's there's a lot of intelligent thinking that you have to do when you're playing this game and you also need to play the odds to a certain extent as well like i thought i was being really creative with some of the potential routes i was doing in fact i have some uh routes that i was really hopeful about that ended up getting erased um in the tour this tour we went from germany up to denmark and then up to norway but i also had uh the possibility of going to sweden and lithuania um hoping to wrap around through poland i had the numbers that were really close they um almost matched up but by the time i uh actually had to fill in the numbers i had to put a one down into
poland which kind of broke all of that up and fortunately i was able to stay flexible um near the very end of the game i had germany and poland both open to try and connect these two parts of the tour together and it ended up working out for me um now i didn't win i actually played a four-player game of this and i came in third so um even though i got a little bit lucky with that very last die roll um it was still not enough to like catapult me up into the lead the winning score i think was 38 and i think a big reason why i didn't win this game is because i kind of ignored the entire western part of europe uh united kingdom uh france and spain um i essentially threw numbers that weren't working out very well everywhere else on the map down over there after it became relatively obvious that i would not be able to pull something through there i did hope to swing through the united kingdom near the end of the game but i actually had to put an x on that spot and you put x's down when you have no legal place to put the dice so uh that happens when you're pretty late on in the game uh now there are also stars out here and you can place those down they're wild numbers whenever doubles are rolled on the dice or when all three of the cards laid out are the same region so the stars are wonderful things to see like everyone is very happy to see those because they can really increase your flexibility i have a star down at the bottom that connected up a 30 up to a 32 i don't believe actually no i did end up rolling a 31 at some point later on in the game i remember saying man i wish i could have just put that 31 on the star and gone somewhere else but this is a dice game and you have to kind of keep that in mind now i've just played this game once we played it four players and again it plays up to eight because technically no one is the active
player you can have the same person rolling the dice every single round um this is one of those games you could play with a thousand people if everybody had a board in front of them and then you just try to see who did the best with the input randomness of the dice um and i i really enjoyed this one i i love that idea of the dice where um you just roll these two dice and then you have these uh two difficult decisions uh sometimes the numbers are really close like if you roll a 97 well you put a 79 and a 97 down which are relatively uh close to each other but you roll a 91 and now you have a 19 and a 91 you have to place which hypothetically you might want to put very far away from yourself but you can also wrap around uh at the end of the game like i said i went from turkey over to ukraine which are actually relatively close to each other i just went through a long path throughout europe on my tour to actually end up getting there uh so yeah i was impressed with the puzzle that this game brought um this one was played late in an evening uh and when i i went out to teach it for the very first time i said you know you know it's late in the evening this game has almost no rules i could probably teach this in about a minute um so like this seems like a good game for that time period and i'm not saying i was wrong but while the rules are very simple the decisions can be quite difficult especially when you get to the middle stage of the game early on in the game you have all sorts of opportunities all sorts of options when you get to the middle that's when you start to feel the uh walls closing in as you're like how am i actually going to piece all of these pieces these different parts of the tour together into one epic tour to give me the most points and then near the very end of the game it almost feels a little bit less strategic and more like you know a casino game
where you're just desperately hoping to see a certain dive result on the dice uh in the beginning of the game you don't really care what that i say in the middle of the game most die rolls are going to be good for you so there's this interesting arc about your relationship with the dice where early on they are just you know information that you use and late in the game you're just desperately wishing and praying these dice give you the numbers that you want um and if they do then you know that's obviously a big high moment i was so happy when that last eye roll let me put a 64 onto germany and i remember i thought like i might have just won the game you know by doing that like i was so lucky my score went from 15 up to 31 and then i found out i actually came in third place but it was still a really good moment uh so yeah i'm impressed with on tour i'm i'm looking forward to playing this one more i think everyone who played it enjoyed it um while it is a roll and right in a very crowded space i felt like the dye the dice mechanic where you roll those two d10s uh was quite fresh and this is also an interesting game in that there are essentially no rules for uh placing uh for the uh adjacency placement of the things out on the map i've played lots of um roll and right games where um even they have simple rules like oh two numbers can't be next to each other or something this is a game where it just says all of the decisions about where you go is just scoring like you could put any number anywhere as long as it matches up with a card which i guess is a rule but that's as close as you get to restrictions and i i was really i was really impressed with uh that and i'm looking forward to playing this one more especially uh the american map because it seemed like that one was a little less long in the paths like on the europe map you have uh greece all the way
over to portugal um portugal goes all the way up to ireland like some really big paths that can make your tour seem even more spread out uh whereas in america it doesn't seem like there's any of those gigantic paths like that all right let's now move on to the next game and this one is the search for planet x now this is a wonderful player game and uh we played a four-player game of this one actually right before we played uh on tour and this is a competitive deduction style game uh but by deduction i mean like like sudoku kind of deduction or um nanograms or you know that kind of logic puzzles where you have uh a limited amount of information and you're trying to make deductions about where you can go obviously those two are very numbered based and this one is more about information because in this game thematically you're all astronomers trying to find planet x uh which is a planet that people think probably exists way out beyond pluto um based off of how things move gravitationally it seems like there's a big object out there and it's called planet x and uh this game has a theme of trying to find it which is pretty cool i've actually watched some documentaries about planet x so that uh intrigued me even more about this one so i was able to play a four player game of this one and it was taught to me and uh let's just jump into talking about how this game plays uh now in the middle of the table you have a big board and it shows the night sky going through various seasons and every player has a little um uh observation uh laboratory uh token that's gonna kind of cruise around the map and on your turn you are going to take
an action which is going to take a certain amount of time uh the amount of time is different for the different actions that you can take uh you are going to be researching you're going to be surveying this guy and you're going to be doing some other things as well although those are the two primary things that you do now every time you you spend time you just move clockwise around and it's your turn when your token is farthest to the back which is a mechanic i've seen in many games and in general i really like to see now in the middle of the table you have the night sky as i said and it's split into 18 different regions this is actually the expert mode i believe the standard mode has 12 regions but we decided to just jump right off and do the expert version of the game right away now in each of these regions there's spots to put player tokens and effectively in every one of the 18 areas there is some type of celestial object in this game there are comets asteroids dwarf planets gas clouds planet x is out there as well just one of that and then truly empty sectors and every single one of the spots is one of those things there are exactly two gas clouds there are exactly four dwarf planets and then there are rules uh logical rules based off of how these different objects interact with each other for example comets only show up on specific sectors uh those sectors have little comet icons on them uh the asteroids have to be adjacent to at least one other asteroid so that means you will never have a single asteroid you might have two asteroids next to each other or you could have all four asteroids next to each other uh dwarf planets show up in specific bands of six with a uh six different uh options so
essentially the dwarf planets are always kind of close to each other gas clouds are always next to a truly empty spot and planet x is never next to a dwarf planet and is always going to appear empty and this is the tricky thing about this game because as you are going through the game taking actions you are going to be learning things like oh there are so many uh dwarf planets out there or so many gas clouds and you might be like oh there's nothing there it's empty space or it could be planet x you're never going to do a survey action and say hey planet x is there that would obviously make for a pretty boring game now mechanically the big thing that you're going to be doing is surveying and everybody has a player sheet in front of them behind a shield so that nobody can see the notes that they're taking and you actually write down what you've done on every one of your turns and you want to write down the actions of all of your opponents because you could definitely glean information based off of what you know they have tried and then their actions based off of after they've taken those specific previous actions um if somebody surveys an area that overlaps with an area that you surveyed and then they do a different type of survey which seems strange well you could probably read into that because odds are good your opponent is not playing randomly they know something that you don't and you want to try to infer what that is now specifically the way the surveys work is you are going to be uh looking at the night sky there's always half of the night sky that is available to you and you can survey up to all that or smaller chunks and the smaller band you survey the more time it takes because you have to really look in deep and let's say for instance uh you surveyed right here you surveyed from 15 all the way to
five and you surveyed four dwarf planets then what happens is you actually have to use an app this game does require the use of an app i use the iphone version other people used android i'm not sure if there's a browser-based version it wouldn't surprise me if there is and um you plug it in you actually say okay surveying 15 through five looking for dwarf planets and then the app will tell you how many dwarf planets are out there it doesn't tell you where they are it just tells you um how many there are in that band so obviously if you search for dwarf planets on half the night sky that's going to tell you a decent amount but if you search for just like three sectors that's going to tell you a lot more information specifically if you get a hit like oh there's one dwarf planet there or even there are no dwarf planets there can be enough to help you out with some of the other things that you're doing now by other things that you're doing i mostly mean research so every time you play this game there is going to be a set of research rules essentially that the app randomly makes and it's the same for everybody you use the same seed code to when you're using the app and it essentially generates the night sky based off of the base logic rules and these special rules that happen but you don't know what they are at the beginning of the game so on your turn you can spend one of your time to actually research one of these rules for example in our game i researched rule c and i knew before i even researched that it related to dwarf planets and asteroids so um i did that because i wanted to learn something about asteroids i remember i knew quite a bit about dwarf planets at this point so then what the app told me is that there are no dwarf planets adjacent
to asteroids so that is a new rule which is not going to be in the game every single time you play it just happened to be in our play and then i could use that based off of my information on the dwarf planets and on our sheet behind our shield we also have all of these options and you are just crossing things off as you learn things circling things as you become very confident about what those things are and a big part of this game involves putting out um research papers essentially studies on what you think is out there now this is a victory point game you win if you have the most points you do get a lot of points for finding planet x but it's possible that you could win without uh being the person to find planet x and i'll talk about fighting in just a second and that's because at certain times throughout the game players are going to be putting down these tokens onto the sectors you put them face down and on the back of each of these tokens it shows one of the objects like asteroids or dwarf planets or gas clouds although there's never one for empty space or planet x so everybody at certain points in the game will reveal how many they're doing but they're face down and you'll put them down onto the very outer parts of the board and every subsequent time when you do a publication you move these down you actually move them down immediately but then you keep scooting these down until these publications hit the inner ring and the moment that happens you flip them over so a decent amount of time has happened since you wrote that paper and now it'll be revealed and then you plug it into your app and you say okay you know in sector 2 is it a dwarf plant and the app will either say yes or no if it is a yes then you leave it there and you flip any others on that row and you get a bonus point for being the first person and you will get victory points at the
end of the game for getting that right um but if i had put i was purple in this game the the dwarf uh planet spot on sector two and the app said that it's not a dwarf planet it's something else then i would just remove this and i would actually lose one time i would go forward one time on the track to show i guess that my prestige is getting lessened or something in the academic community but anyway once the game is over you actually get victory points a varying amount of victory points for the correct papers that you wrote based off of the different things so every time you get a correct dwarf planet out there you get two victory points every time you get a correct gas cloud you get four victory points which is um you know obviously a lot more than the dwarf planets but there are only two gas clouds and there are four of the dwarf planets so maybe it will be a little bit harder to figure that out now um that is essentially the base loop of the game you are going to be surveying and you are going to be researching and there are other things that you can do the main one is actually trying to find planet x uh this is something that you do for your entire turn and on that turn you actually have to uh i think spend five time uh which is a lot actually this board say right here is right after planet x had been found the blue player shot right uh all the way up to the front uh and they got it they figured it out and the game is not about just finding planet x you have to know a lot about it and by that i mean you have to know where planet x is out of the 18 sectors and you have to know exactly what is to the left and to the right of planet x so you essentially have to know everything about those three sectors with the middle one being planet x and you actually put that into the app and it says if you're right or not if you're not then you just spent five
time which is bad you don't want to do that but um if you are correct then that puts the game into the endgame state where then everybody uh no longer takes turns everybody will simultaneously also try to figure out where planet x is everyone gets one shot and depending on where they are compared to the person who figured it out you get more victory points actually uh in this instance i was purple and i was one two three four five time behind the uh blue player and uh in that case if we look at our player sheet that is actually going to give you 10 victory points if you are five or more time behind the player who gets it so that means if i had gotten it right i would have had just as many victory points as the person who got it correct whereas other players who were maybe spending more time than i did would have gotten less points for being closer now in this instance uh no one else got it and it was really interesting because as i said you're writing these papers and putting these tokens out there and when they're correct you leave them there which means you are broadcasting real hard information to everyone around the table the moment this token was flipped over to say that sector two was a dwarf planet everybody knows that sector two is a dwarf planet you can mark that on your sheet and then you can absolutely have cascading effects going off of that and um over in the sector 13 area we had a really interesting situation where i knew for a fact that both of the gas clouds were when within sectors 13 through 15 but there's only two gas clouds and that's three spots so that means i if i put a paper down it was kind of a guess but you don't lose a lot by being wrong and those gas clouds are worth four victory
points at the end of the game which is almost half of what you get for finding planet x so i decided i had a you know a two and three shot uh placing it down i put the token into the 13th spot now as we were playing this game the person who won they actually did a lot of very similar things to me as i was playing the game and they knew that the gas clouds were also over here but they knew for sure for a fact that 15 was one of the gas clouds so they knew the other one was on 13 or 14 and they had seen that i put a publication out into 13 they knew that i had been searching for dwarf planets and gas clouds just like them so they figured that i knew for a fact that 13 was actually a gas cloud when i didn't it was you know i was pretty confident but i didn't know for sure so for them it was a coin flip between 13 and 14. for me i knew two of those three were and the person who won the person who figured out where planet x was based their entire theory on the idea that i am correct over here in 13. if i had been wrong if 13 had not been a gas cloud then the person who won their entire logical train would have crumbled and so they actually won because i guessed correctly about putting a cloud over here and they read into my yes if that makes sense because they don't know how confident i am about putting this here because again the penalty for being wrong is not devastating it's not great losing one time is definitely significant but it's not great and that was really fascinating now unfortunately for me i was about to take the next turn and on that turn i was going to uh do some research which would have really helped things out but having the planet xp found on that
turn left me largely in the dark um i i made my best guess and i missed and once the uh scores were over actually i came in second place which is pretty cool i mean the person who found planet x won by a pretty long shot i think my score was 13 and the winning score was 21. you get 10 victory points for finding planet x for being the first player and up to 10 for being the other players so you know that is the name of the game and i have to say that um this was a fun game it was a really taxing game in an interesting way because these are the kind of logic puzzles that i don't actually do very often uh my wife jessica who was playing this with us um she does and uh she definitely uh i think liked it even more than i did it definitely leaned into you know the kind of mental pathways that work out really well for her um but for me man i found myself feeling constantly like i was missing something like i have all of this information i have all of that information what can i glean from it in fact in this game um out there on the board uh everyone but myself figured out that the asteroids are two asteroids on nine and ten and uh one of the players figured it out based off of a action that i haven't really talked about that i don't really need to and the other players figured out based off of the first player's actions that those must be asteroids they place those down there and i totally missed that i'm actually kind of surprised i came in second place considering all of the victory points i missed for not seeing that and that had nothing to do with the turns that those players took that was entirely about them looking at the actions that somebody else took so these are all just complicated things
that you have to keep in mind and it is very satisfying but i will admit that at a four player game it took a little while and there was a decent amount of down time uh now it wasn't downtime like i'm sitting here bored it was downtime like everybody's sitting there with their wheels just spinning like crazy and then it's like oh crud it's my turn uh what the heck am i gonna do like it's almost like a hot potato thing where you don't want it to be your turn because you're you're just you feel always like you you have enough information to glean even more and you don't quite see it yet and uh you know that can be frustrating in a satisfying way i suppose i definitely felt like i learned a lot about how to play this game better over the course of this game even really simple things like the fact that if you know something on your player sheet for example uh in the sector 2 i knew that it was the dwarf planet and i circled it it took me like many turns to realize oh i can cross everything else off like that's a really simple thing like every sector can be only one thing but it took me a surprisingly long amount of time to say oh i could cross everything else off and the more things you cross the more you can learn about things because of the interactions of the different research rules that come in the game as well as the base rules so i was really impressed by the game i could definitely see myself playing this one again um it's definitely a quiet game as i said you're not really talking to anybody there are certainly times where somebody says i'm gonna survey you know you know two to uh 15 or whatever it is uh gas clouds and somebody else will say gas clouds didn't you just survey gas clouds and then everybody goes
what the heck are they doing they spent two turns in a row surveying gas clouds and then you look down and you see what they've done before and you see what you know and what you see what they hypothetically know and then you try to leverage that knowledge to your advantage so yeah this is a fascinating game uh there is a normal version as i said which i believe is 12 sectors and the rules for the logic for the empty sectors and the dwarf planets are different although i'm not exactly sure how um i might try that at some point but it wouldn't surprise me if i continued to play this version of the game um it was really cool to play a competitive logic game like that and i was happy to come in second place i will admit that there is there is certainly room for a bit of luck in this game uh on my very first turn i decided to survey for dwarf planets uh between um a couple of sectors i think one through nine and when i did that survey one through nine which is half of the night sky it told me that all four of the dwarf planets were there which is huge information like in this game when you know that everything is within your survey you can cross everything else out so for example i knew that i could instantly say okay half the map is not dwarf planets the other half is so within those nine spots there are four dwarf planets that's a tremendous amount of information for one turn whereas when uh jessica took her first turn um she did a survey for actually she researched and then she surveyed for asteroids and she got a partial hit i think she uh on her she she wrote like you know one or two or something like that so that was certainly good information
but it didn't allow her to exclude as much of the night sky as it did for me and on my first turn when i did that survey uh the person who won also did that exact same survey which is why we did so many similar things throughout the game because on our very first turn we got kind of lucky with this this golden nugget of the dwarf planets are absolutely in this half pay attention to that um and um so yeah i think that's that's definitely a factor in the game like there is i guess you would call it randomness um to a certain extent but you definitely try to leverage things as best you can and um i've rambled about this one for a while uh so let's uh see if anybody else has any comments about this one the dice matrix says you played a four player game and if you like puzzles it should be good for you not really your style you know that does not surprise me i think for some people they're not going to like how quiet it is and also if you're not into these kind of deduction things which i'm barely into them i think you could certainly bounce off of it this is a really good game but i don't think it's going to be a game for everybody so looking at some of the other comments it does look like somebody best at star trek said they thought the game would be more fun but it never comes to the table and i i really do think that while this design is brilliant it's not going to be it's not going to hit all the right notes for a lot of people i think um it is a board game absolutely but to a certain extent it feels a little bit other like it kind of tows the space between board games and like puzzle hunts and you know those puzzle books that you can get at a bookstore and that kind of thing which means you know some people aren't going to be locking into that as much as others and some people aren't going to be liking it as much as others trevor says
uh was it pretty quiet around the table given the mental crunching uh yes yes it absolutely was um i wasn't i'm not exactly sure how much time it took but i feel like it was probably around two hours and i think a big part of that is because half of us had never played it before none of us had played at four players so that's definitely things to be considering and uh yeah there was no discussion happening at this table everybody was was pretty much just nose down behind their screen thinking thinking thinking sighing sometimes going and then everybody looks over like oh man what did they just figure out i wish i could figure out something so that's definitely like a fun environment to be in for some people but you know this is not a raucous type of or even conversational game because you are spinning so many plates in your head you're thinking about so many things you don't even have room for conversation and it's also interesting like when i'm playing board games i like to talk about the game uh sometimes i complain more than i should about i don't think i'm going to win uh sometimes i just talk about like oh that was really interesting how this happened there and i kept finding myself biting my tongue when i was playing this game because i'd want to be like oh man such and such and such and i was like that's going to give away information like even just small talk friendly chat around the table is going to give away information about being happy about that or even saying something like man i just wasted that last turn everybody will say they wasted their last turn i wonder why like every utterance out of your mouth essentially is clues that your opponents can use which does lend the game to a quiet atmosphere
um trevor asked how long did the teach take i think it certainly was no longer than 30 minutes it was probably around the order of 30 minutes uh if i had to say i feel like the teach could um have been likely shorter uh with a little bit more experience because the game is you know it's somewhat novel i mean i didn't actually teach this game but i feel like the first time i teach it it would probably end up taking something on that order i think a big part of it is the actual core teach is probably more like 15 to 20 minutes but then it's gonna lend itself to a bunch of clarifying questions as people say wait so what about this and like what did you mean by this or like how do i do this like oh right that's right you do this uh but i found that the uh player aids that you have do a really good job of explaining a lot of how the game works uh and so that definitely helped out as well aj asked if i've played cryptid and if i have any comparisons to that um i haven't uh cryptid is a game that i've been interested in playing for a very long time uh that's my understanding is that's also a competitive deduction style game where you have a map in front of you a hex map i think and you're trying to find the cryptid on one specific spot uh i don't know much else beyond that i do think there's things like you know such and such terrain is always next to three away from that of the terrain like rules like that um i have heard that cryptid is a game that you could win on the very first turn like it's possible not always but it's hypothetically possible you could have enough information to figure out where the cryptid is which could potentially lend itself to even more analysis paralysis as your you think like maybe you could
find it whereas in the search for planet x you feel like you know nothing for a long time at the start of the game there's actually a difficulty slider you can go with i think i went with standard which meant i got four clues it was essentially four things i could cross out at the very beginning so you know a little bit of information but this is the kind of game where you know nothing you know nothing you're nothing and then suddenly you're like oh wait i think i know something and then it can cascade in fact when this game ended uh the player who took their turn who found planet x was just about to survey something else and then they they suddenly looked at their board and they remembered oh wait a second um the uh planet x can never be next to a dwarf planet and suddenly they actually said that like oh planet x can't be next to a dwarf planet they just forgot about that logic rule and then suddenly they're scribbling the scribbling and about a minute later they said i think i found it so they went from knowing nothing to oh not nothing but but feeling like they were still totally in the dark to remembering this one tiny logic thing that's in every game planet x is never next to the dwarf planet but they knew exactly where the dwarf planets were and that just cascaded into them cracking the the game and and winning it uh so that's definitely uh a thing to keep in mind um you're not going to be able to beat this game on the first many turns uh dustin mentioned that his problem is that he's way better at deduction stuff than his wife is and yeah i i think that this definitely is a game that could lend to some skill gaps but i mean no i say that but i beat jessica and she is so much better at this kind of deduction than i am but again i feel like a large part of that is because i got this gift of knowing what half of the
board all of the dwarf planets were on whereas she got less uh potent information as the game went on um also i think she undervalued just throwing out some papers when you're not entirely sure to get some victory points because this is a victory point game uh and that's just you know playing the game for the first time kind of feeling it out um so this is a situation i think where certain people could be very frustrated by being nowhere near on the same level as others but i do want to say that while i think i'm a pretty smart person i don't do these kind of deduction puzzles for fun like jessica does and uh and like many other people i i don't really do puzzle hunts i don't do this kind of stuff and i still did pretty darn good in this game so i don't think the stratification is going to be as extreme as it could be unless you're like a super logic puzzle type person but again even if you are you could survey the night sky and it could say hey there's two out of the four dwarf planets and half the night sky and you're like cool well that's definitely good to know but there's a big difference there's a massive gulf between knowing where two is and where four are uh when you do an initial survey like that neverglow said it feels like clue for gamers that's actually something that somebody said around the table they specifically said this feels like modern clue so i definitely agree with you there yeah supposedly it was released a month ago but it's been delayed uh the person that i played it actually got it for christmas so maybe it's that first printing uh went away i'm not really sure and yeah supposedly this game has a solo mode which i know nothing about so if you really enjoy this kind of stuff then and you like solo games then that could certainly be something to look into because it is quite the
intricate little puzzle that it makes honestly i'm super impressed with the app i didn't put any images of it up but this is a lot of information that it has to have correct with the variable rules that come into play there's even specific rules relating to planet x that gets revealed at certain times throughout the game and all these things have to match with all the standard rules i'm sure very smart coder people figured out ways to make this happen because obviously it works very well but i don't know for me it seemed very impressive so trevor mentioned uh that you really like logic puzzles but you really like a lively social atmosphere around the table especially in a game that can go two hours um that is something to consider i will say that the people who taught us this game they played at two players several times and they seemed to be very high on it they were very curious to try it at four so even at lower player counts which would probably have i don't know if they'd be quicker necessarily because there's less information out there but it would be your turn uh twice as often that could be a thing but i'm certainly not trying to convince anybody they absolutely have to try this because it it might not make the kind of uh environment around the table that you're looking for all right i think on that note let's move on to the next game this one is the transcontinental which i actually had not heard of before a couple weeks ago and a friend of ours on our discord channel that where we play games um they backed it on kickstarter they played it on tabletop simulator and they really wanted to play it again so uh we sat down and we played a four-player game of this and it was the first time that it was played at four for the our friend who taught it to us now this is a train themed game but it
is not cube rails i know i've talked about q rails games so much over the last many months but while this is a train game this is uh more of a work replacement type uh situation uh and according to board game geek it says it's a 75 to 150 minute game and i'll start right off at the beginning and say that that's essentially what it ended up being it was like two and a half hours uh maybe a little bit longer but we were playing it four players and before i even talk about the details of the game i do want to say that um in retrospect when i took a look at board game geek um it says the community thinks it's best at one to three players best well best at two to three players uh and specifically when i looked into this even more it was not super recommended at four and um keep that in mind as i'm talking about the game because i do think playing it at four was not the right way to go but let's talk about how this game actually works because it has some super cool mechanical ideas going on now in the middle of the table you have this track this uh uh strip of board where a train is going to go down and it's essentially um you know a one-dimensional uh track the train is going to be moving on and on either side of that track there are these action tiles and they are put down so that they are offset um so one set is above the track and the other set is below and essentially uh what that means is every single one of these action tiles is touching two of the track spots in the middle and they are staggered now mechanically the way this game works is you're going to be placing workers down or i guess technically they're called telegrams in this game onto the spots on the track and then once everybody has decided they're done
placing workers this train token is going to move down the track and it starts in the east and it heads to the west once it uh hits a token on the track it stops there's a little auction that i'll talk about in a second and then the train turns around and then you do more work replacement back on the track that's potentially been cleared and once the train makes it all the way back to the east the round is over and you move on to the next round now whenever the train reaches a spot that has your worker you are going to perform actions on up to both of the tiles that it is adjacent to because again there's a tile above and below the track and since they're staggered that means no specific work replacement spot is going to be identical to another one now the action spots the actions that show up on these tiles they differ many of the tiles actually every single one of the tiles has development options on them as well as an alternate action that you can perform the alternate actions do things like potentially getting extra resources potentially moving resources around that kind of thing but the big thing that you're doing on these tiles especially early on in the game is developing them and the way you do this is you put resource cubes down on top of them now this game has a super interesting resource mechanic where um in the game it's called the transcontinental there's just this one train that's going down and back and that train is represented at the top of the play space and every player has all of their own resources on this communal train so behind the train there are these carts that can hold different types of resources like coal as well as lumber and steel and that kind of thing as well as navis who i think are like engineers or something like that people
that help make things happen and when you get resources you put them as cubes down onto the train and if there's not enough room in that cart on the train you take a new cart from the supply and you put it into the rail yard and you put your tokens on top of it and later on when specific actions happen those carts can be added to the main train and then they'll stay there for the rest of the game so that means there is this communal uh resource requirement or threshold that starts out relatively small and as the game goes on and actions are taken the train itself is going to get longer and the overall communal train can hold more and more resources for each player when you have a cube on a specific cart that cube is what that is so it's a navi when it's there and it's a piece of wood when it's on a different cart and you actually place these down onto the development spots on the board and then once all of the spots are full you flip that over and then every player who was either first or second most cubes in the development can then put their own little houses on top and then in the future when you go to that action place spot only the players who have a house on that location can do specific actions while everyone else can always do the basic action that was there so that means the overall board evolves as the game goes on also when you flip these tokens over as well as when you add new carts to the communal train you get victory points so this is a game where you're trying to get victory points as much as you can and you can get it from a lot of different ways in fact in this game i took a huge lead in the mid game because i was just going crazy on expanding the communal train it just seemed to work out that i got a lot of coal which is how you do it i'm not going to go into the details because
that's actually one of the more complicated mechanical parts of the game but i kept doing this i kept adding carts on and when i did that i essentially enabled other people's resources to then become viable and usable but i also got victory points for their resources which was a really neat piggyback now there are technically ways to pull resources from the yard over onto the board but i'm not going to try to go into all of the nitty gritty details so again the main loop of this game is you place workers out then the train slowly moves all the way to the end and once it reaches the end there is this blind auction where uh players are going to decide how many of specific resources they want to spend it's a one-shot auction you reveal and then you figure out what the overall buying power of that auction is and then with that in mind you look at the tiles that are blocking the track and you see how many tiles the train is actually going to dig into essentially and then in order from the person who bid the most players can take these tiles which will give potential immediate one-shot actions as well as victory points and now the overall track of the transcontinental got longer so that means as the game goes on the train goes there and back but every time it goes there the track gets a little bit longer so the game goes on there's longer and uh a longer distance the train can go there's more worker placement spots the spots never get blocked so that means the game gets actually more loose to a certain extent from a worker placement perspective as the game goes on and this unlocks new locations that can be developed to then be flipped over to get victory points and have new action spots to go on to to get resources and stuff that you need in
order to win the game so that is the general idea you're going to keep going until you reach a certain spot on this track and it's an indeterminate number of rounds and there are so many cool things mechanically and uh to think about while you're playing this game uh specifically with the work replacement the fact that you do both of these actions is really interesting but also there is a sequential nature to the game where the train is going to start in the east to go to the west so you want to make sure you have the resources that you need at the right time in order to maybe later on actually put those down and develop a tile to then potentially flip it over but there are actions that let you actually put cubes down resource cubes down onto spots even farther ahead from you so these can actually be sniped you might say okay i'm set up i'll have the resources to finish this one spot off and then somebody else does a special action down over here that you forgot to think about and then they actually complete that thing before you even got there but now you can always still do the other action on that spot if it potentially works out for you so you have this sequential work placement but then again it is too um phased so you have a first phase where you go there then there's an auction and then the train comes back and before the train comes back you can place more workers but you have a set number of workers in the round so that means in the beginning you might not put all of your workers out you might put like two of them wait for the train to go all the way there and then before the train comes back you place more workers out until all of them are out there's also a bonus worker you can gain which i won't go into the details of but obviously that means when the train gets to a spot that worker is removed so that means if somebody went onto the spot that you really want to go on to well maybe you can place onto it when the train comes back which is a super interesting idea i also
love this resource mechanic where you have all of these cubes communally on the same train but going back to how you actually add these tiles down again i'm not going to talk about the details of it but i will say this was the hardest mechanical part of the game um one of my friends who actually ended up winning the game um who wins a lot of games very smart board gamer continued to not understand this part of the game just like they had to be explained it like four times and it's not because they're dumb it's because it is a strange thing that can actually kind of force you into a situation where you don't like where you might have to spend your coal resources to place carts out that might give you a couple points but might actually help your opponents more so from a mechanical perspective this area while i love the idea of a communal train i kind of wish the act of adding the trains on was a little bit simpler a little bit easier to grok now there is one part of the game that i've glossed over entirely so far and that's because it's a part that i don't actually like very much and that are ally cards now there are these stacks of cards that have allies on them and you can get them through a variety of ways action spots as well as at the start of the game and these cards have a variety of different uh one-shot actions on them and they really vary uh and i just did not like the hidden information of it and i didn't like the randomness of it um this is a euro style game it's a resource acquisition and uh uh usage type of game and you could set up this round place your workers down in specific spots you have this great plan nobody's going to snipe that and then somebody plays a card that says just kidding i get all this stuff and i place all this stuff they flip the tile
over and now your placements are kind of bunk and that's because of something that you could not plan for because they had a card you didn't know existed and these cards are so varied that you can't even necessarily lean on knowledge of what people might have i mean if you play this game a bunch then perhaps that comes into it but i i have to admit i really wish that the game had not been designed with the ally cards like this like i'm okay with a variety of the actions that these bring in but for me personally i would drastically prefer if you uh at the during setup perhaps shuffle these cards up and put one out and every time you did an ally action you just did the action that's printed on the card so that you know that that really powerful development action could be activated by somebody or maybe even every round you put three new ones out so if you want that extra variety you get that in each of the rounds although that might cause too much analysis process now this is way beyond even a house rule like you cannot play the game in the way that i just said and have it be even remotely balanced that's more just me complaining about wishing the game did something a little bit differently uh it's not enough for me to hate the game but it definitely rubbed me a little bit wrong the other thing that maybe it's just a one thing too many is the fact that when the game is over you're actually going to be scoring some hidden objective cards that you have in front of you that want you to have houses on specific icons there's all these little icons on the development spots around the board as well as other locations and if you have certain sets of these you can get a bunch of end game victory points and i really struggled to try and make those happen i think it's just because there's so many other things happening so perhaps you know after playing this one more it would be easier to piece these
together but that along with the ally cards just felt like things that didn't necessarily need to exist for this game to still not to still be quite interesting it seemed like the game leaned into a little bit more randomness and a little bit more heaviness than i would necessarily prefer but again those aren't necessarily damning things realistically the biggest issue that i had with this game was the downtime uh it was long and i totally understand why on board game geek it says some people have voted that it's not recommended at four players um there's really no balance uh setup changes for the player accounts so what that means is you're gonna be spending that much more time when you add another person onto the table i kind of wish there were less workers like in a four-player game sure you'd get less stuff done but maybe the rounds would elapse a little bit quicker and maybe the token starts a little bit closer like this didn't again i'm okay with playing a two and a half hour game that's really thinky and you get to enjoy a lot of the decisions but i spent a lot of time waiting for somebody to take their turn when i knew exactly what i wanted to do or even potentially worse while this work replacement mechanic is super cool it can lend to large amounts of downtime because let's say to do the plan that you really want to do maybe get resources before the blind bid you place all of your workers then you're going to do nothing when the train comes back you've used all of your workers so there's a significant amount of time the train gets there you do the blind bid you did all your actions and now you're waiting for the train to slowly make its way back bouncing on other players workers and they're maybe getting their bonus worker to them place out and they're thinking about how all these
things interact with their hand of special power cards that they have from these allies and there were definitely times where i just i was in um tabletop simulator where i just all tabbed out and started surfing reddit i i hate to be that person who like wasn't actively paying attention but there were just significant parts of the game where i there was nothing to be done for paying attention i was just waiting and you know when people were crunching through all these options it just got a little bit long so this is one i would not mind playing again at three but i don't think i would ever play this one at four uh and while i do wish that um some of the mechanical parts of the game were modified i don't think it necessarily makes the game bad it just makes the game not ideal for me like as the game stands it's probably like you know a seven out of ten but i feel like if the allies had been done in a way that was not so surprise random and if the the game had been simplified just a little bit like ten percent uh this game could have jumped to a an eight or even a nine as far as my overall uh uh enjoyment of the game um i am really big into different mechanics that come into games like i'm a a sucker for a cute different ideas and this game has a ton of those which is a big part of the reason why i think i would play this game again at lower player counts because i think the the work replacement spot with the stagger different locations is cool i think the communal uh resource uh limit uh whole situation is really interesting and i think understanding how those trains get put onto the back of the train will be much easier on a second play there's so many really cool ideas to this game that i don't think the ideas that i dislike destroy the whole thing it just
again leaves me in a situation where i don't like it anywhere near as much as i potentially could uh so i see some people asking about the transcontinental uh being on kickstarter and yes it was uh a while ago many many months ago i'm not sure when it's actually going to be uh being delivered uh i will say that the tabletop simulator mod for the transcontinental is the most advanced mod i've ever played and i've played the crew mod which is also incredibly advanced this mod does so much uh it's amazing like you put the tokens down and a bunch of things change uh when you actually put the resources down in spots like things automatically flip over it automatically scores things for you um it's really impressive overall like a lot of coding was put into the mod for this one well i don't think i see any other specific questions about the transcontinental uh so let's go ahead and move on to the last game we'll be talking about today which is umbravia now this one came out recently uh and uh i'm actually not sure how widely distributed it is at this point i was sent a press copy of this one it's a two to four player game uh supposedly plays best at three according to board game geek and i played this game once and it was four players um i can tell you right now that i'm not gonna be complaining about the four player game like i did with the transcontinental it was totally fine at four players so let's jump into how this game plays because i talked before about enjoying uh kooky mechanics and really fresh ideas and this game has some really interesting fresh ideas now mechanically you have a board in the middle of the table which
is a square grid and you have these square tiles that fit onto it that have various paths on them and then each player has a bag in front of them that has these little flower tokens essentially for the most part you have the regular color but you have some pale pastel ones in there as well which i'll talk about in a second now the way each round works is players are going to be first of all revealing four of these tiles onto a communal board and the rotation is important because it's actually randomized at the start of the game when you make that deck and you place these out and they will not be rotated again then every player is going to dig into their bag and pull three tokens out which could again be your standard uh energy tokens i think they're called or the pale ones which i think are called soul tokens something like that they're more powerful for the bidding and then behind your player screen you're going to be placing these three tokens down and it's always three now you're going to put them onto the one two three or four spot you can consolidate them or spread them out and then everybody reveals their screens and places the tokens they allocated onto the specific tiles on the spots one two three or four after that you put your shield back and you draw three more tokens and you do this again to then reveal the shield and then place these out so there are two rounds of uh hidden bidding essentially and this is really important because that first round will show you some intentions of the players like if this was just one round you reveal and be like oh wow that's you know crazy i don't think you do that and then you move on i love the um agency that this game gives you and also the paranoia that it gives you by doing this double stage thing
where you reveal and you put some out and then you have to bid again and you're looking to see what the other people did and what are they potentially going to do based off of what they've done already and based off of what other people have done now once you've done these two rounds of bidding you will then look at these boards and the board that has the least number of tokens will get the one token placed next to it which means it'll get placed first then the second lease will get the two then the three and then the four so essentially the more tokens on that tile the later on in the round it'll be placed then the player who has a majority control of that specific tile who has the most of their tokens on there is going to be able to place that tile in particular the kind of pastel soul tokens count as two whereas the regular ones count as one now this is important because that two count will potentially put you in control of placing that tile down but then you remove all of those soul tokens from that tile from the game they're permanently gone so that means they help you with trying to win the bids but they will never make it onto the main board then the player who had the most control over that tile or most points on that tile effectively will place it onto an empty spot on the board and again they cannot rotate it they just have to place it with this specific orientation and if by placing that they have completed one of these growing roads on the board then you immediately score the road doing some area control now the road is completed when there are no uh empty edges facing to a spot that you could place another tile down so uh that means uh a tile with a corner could be placed onto a spot where it immediately completes itself and it's a size one whereas you could place something else out to have a gigantic scoring uh with tons
and tons of tiles now when these tiles score you're going to count up the number of tokens that the players have on the entire path and this is really where the game gets interesting uh well i take it back the bidding is also quite interesting but this is where mechanically it gets pretty kooky honestly because there are these tokens on the tiles when you place them but then when they get added to these paths those previous tokens kind of group up with all of the other ones you were just doing majority scoring for the entire path but the majority the area that's being scored is going to be ebbing and flowing it's going to be well i guess not ebbing it's just going to be growing as the game goes on until it gets scored now when this scores the player who has the most tokens will then get uh one soul token from their scoring pile equal to the number of tiles in that overall scoring area so that means if you score a one tile and you have the most control of it you get essentially one soul token and if it's a five uh tile long scoring and you have the most you will pull five of those tokens off of your little board off to the side and that's important because this is a race game i know i've said points and stuff like that but realistically you just want to be the player to get all of your soul tokens in play now when you gain these they actually go into your bag and remember when you pull them out of your bag and bid with them they then are removed from the game after you actually place them out so they have a one-way journey from the score pile into the removed from the game pile um and your bag is going to be kind of changing as the game goes on so this means if you have a really big scoring and you get like five of these things and you dump them in your bag the next time you do bidding you are much more likely to pull these soul tokens out which means you are
going to be in a stronger position to win and place these tiles out but remember you don't actually put the soul tokens down they are removed so the soul tokens are a double-edged sword um they're not bad but they're also not good uh they just help you in certain circumstances and don't help you in others you could place them down into a situation where you can place a tile down that has none of your other tokens on it because all of your soul tokens were removed from it so this game has a a couple different ways that you can uh approach it so we played a four player game and uh in this game i'll just go right out and say that i won but it was close uh now as we were playing through the game i had a strategy of well it seems really difficult to figure out what people are going to be trying to do and what they're trying to bid on so i went for a piecemeal strategy i said you know what i'm just going to get points slowly but surely i'm going to score tons of single uh uh spots you know you put it one tile down and it's immediately uh uh closed off on the edges you score it i have the most tokens boom i got a point i pull one off the pile and i think at the start of the game there are 11 of these tokens on the pile so that was my um my mode throughout the entire game i i probably got most of those tiles off most of those soul tokens off one at a time whereas other players were doing this massive boom or bust thing in particular jessica she um i think she pulled all of her tokens off with just two scorings one of them was like seven or eight tokens that she got to pull off because she had you know like 20 plus of her own tokens on this massive path that was out there on the board that was ever growing and it was
just highly contentious now it's worth noting the second place player will get half the number of soul points as the first player and then third place will get half of the second so you will get points for not being in the lead but you get a lot more for being in the lead on these and what ended up happening is um in the game state i had emptied essentially all of my tokens off of this tile but you only win once the tile is removed and there is this really smart mechanic it's almost like they play tested this game and they played with people like me because in order to pull this last tile off to remove it because it essentially counts it is two soul tokens which means if you just do a scoring and you would get one you get nothing because you have to do a scoring of at least two and you have to win that scoring so that means in order to actually win the game you have to have a majority of your tokens on a scoring that is at least two paths long and that is significant again i went through the whole game doing little single uh scores here i maybe scored two once or twice but i was mostly focused on singles and i got to the point where i was just down to my last tile and i was trying to orchestrate a situation where i could actually be in the lead on a spot that had more than uh more than one but since i've been doing my piecemeal strategy i didn't really have tokens on the board and then a turn or two later jessica came roaring back and pulled all of her tokens off of her tile and just left the tile back in fact she was so close to um removing the talents well she almost went from having like i think seven uh tokens on her tile to winning the game because she almost scored a nine size path but i think it ended up being eight size based off of how the bidding went and the control and all that uh so as we continue with the game i
seem to be a clear leader and my friend dave also seemed to be really we were neck and neck like just one away from each other we kept doing small scorings but he was also getting in on like the second and third places on the big ones and then there was a moment where suddenly everyone had cleared all of their tokens off of the tiles so what that meant is we entered sun death and we all got there in different routes again jessica got there with two massive scorings i got there with like eight tiny little scorings but here we are at the beginning of a round the first person essentially to do a two scoring is going to win the game and based off of how the tiles came out i was able to manipulate the bid for the first half of the scoring to put myself into a situation where i was able to lock it down i wasn't the first tile to be placed but the way the board was i was able to have it essentially guaranteed and it was kind of a weird situation actually my friend was in a situation dave where he knew that i was gonna win that was guaranteed but based off of how he placed this tile down another friend could also win because you can actually share in the victory based off of some tiebreakers so what that meant was my friend was deciding do i win by myself or do i win somebody else and they ended up just flipping a tile or something like that to decide and it went in the way that i actually won so by myself so it was a bit of a king maker dilemma in that situation i've only played the game once i have no idea how often that's going to actually end up happening but it did happen in this specific game but it was fascinating to have a sun death situation after all of this time and after all of these tokens piling up and all these paths to to find ourselves in that situation and based off of some moves that i did
with some special tiles there's some special action tiles that change things around um i was able to make really good use of it if you're familiar with the game i i did a big void tile placement on the previous round which let me have a lot of control for the next one but again i'm not trying to go into those details so uh from a like impression perspective uh i think everybody enjoyed the game i think everybody was fascinated with the game but i'm not sure if everyone around the table would be interested in playing again if that makes sense uh i think this is a really good game mechanically but i do not think this is going to be a game for everybody in particular i had a great conversation with jessica about this afterwards because she felt like she was really stumbling because it was such a psychological game like she was uh constantly in these massive scorings with these huge uh paths that were being made and so she was constantly thinking what are they going to do what am i going to do where am i going to go trying to think and double think and triple think and i thought that was fascinating because for me i didn't play a psychological game at all i played completely selfishly every single bidding round i was just trying to find a tile that i could snipe have control over slap down onto the board score it get my one sole point move on to the next round so i wasn't really paying attention to what other people were doing for the most part i mean i wasn't playing my own isolated game but most of my thought process was how do i corner one of these tiles to score a point or two whereas um jessica because she had she was already super invested in these massive potential scorings she was in a situation where like she couldn't not think about what other people were doing because they could snipe it away and
then this all of this work that had gone in through many turns to get this huge scoring would just crumble so there was definitely an interesting two paths to take and then we ended up in a sudden death situation where really anybody could have won so that was really fascinating to see two different ways of playing the game but it also was a situation where jessica isn't sure if she wants to play it again because she's not crazy about playing games that are very psychological like that now she doesn't dislike the the mechanic of the game it's just a personal preference type of thing and from a mechanics perspective for me i definitely have a hard time pulling my individual thoughts away because from a mechanical geek perspective there's so many cool things going on here for such a simple light game but then from like a pure enjoyment perspective i had fun uh it was a fine time i would probably say i'd play lots of other games instead of this one but that's again because i'm not crazy about blind bidding in general from a personal perspective me as jonathan cox but me as a mechanics nerd oh my gosh this is so cool there's so many amazing layers like i think like feel like this game was very well designed um for the one part i've already talked about why i think the two-phase bidding is so much more interesting than the first phase bidding but on top of that the fact that these tiles are placed down in the order in which you have the majority of tokens on them from any player's color is also fascinating because what that meant is i was often times in a situation as other people were of wanting to control a tile but also wanting to place it before other tiles were placed to try and position myself in my cases because i
wanted to do it so that i could actually get that little scoring and for other people they wanted to like maybe make a big path bigger before they were able to score it and get even more points for themselves but of course if you want to control that tile you have to put your tokens down onto it and the more tokens that are on it the later on in turn order it's going to be so this is a really fascinating uh seesaw of decisions that you're doing and there were definitely times where after the first bid um i was like in a slight majority and i would put like one more token down onto that tile but then i would load a bun my other two tokens down onto a tile i didn't even care about to make sure that it went later like i wasn't even dry vying to control that specific tile in that situation i was just trying to sync it in the tile placement order because that's something that i really needed to do also these sole tiles are worth two for the purpose of winning control of placing this tile down and then of course they're removed so that means they are worth double the um uh winning power of the regular tokens so that means you can certainly use those to try and gain control of a tile that you want to be placed earlier on in the round because it's worth two instead of one for one token which is again how this order is decided and that oh my gosh i i'm just so impressed with how all of that works and how those decisions came together then out here in the main board i don't think i've ever played a majority scoring game where the majority areas evolved like this like i said i went the whole game making these tiny little things honestly because it seemed less stressful for me personally because it seemed very stressful to be involved in these massive scorings i could see my opponents in general it
seemed like the other three people were kind of vying in them uh jessica and nick were trying to get the majority dave did a really good job of streamlining behind and getting some second place and third place scorings and i ignored those massive ones essentially not entirely but i tried to ignore them for the most part while i did my other things and occasionally i would get bought into them so from a stress perspective there could be a lot of stress in here i played a relatively low stress game because the strategy that i went for was low stress whereas other players seem to find themselves in much more stressful situations and a lot of people are going to love that stress and they're going to love those moments of revealing that uh the the players shields and seeing how people went and i'm that makes it sound like we didn't love it um in our situation we definitely enjoyed it we had lots of groans and cheers and stuff when we pulled the the boards back and when we realized how this order would go and what this would end up happening again more groans and more tears when the dust settled i think everybody enjoyed the game and was happy they played it but again based off of personal preferences it wouldn't surprise me if a couple people around the table would not actively try to play the game again i think for me a big draw for playing this game again would be just exploring this interesting space you know it's a blind bidding area majority that changes and there's just so many little things and jessica made a point uh when we were about halfway through the game where she was just like this game is so much more complex than i expected uh i think she might have said it was more interesting than she expected as well because when i first taught the rules it's a quite a simple game overall um her perspective was oh this is going to be like you know a light little you know 45 to 60 minute game you know
there's some things going on there but whatever and then when we got in the middle of the game it was like no this is this is really deep to a lot to a large extent but also since it's a blind bidding style game there's no perfect information and i like that i mean downtime could potentially be a thing as people are arduously thinking oh do i do this oh do i do that with the bidding but at a certain point you have to just commit like it's not like you can think about it until you come up with the right answer because there's blind bidding you just have to come up to the point where you say my gut's saying i go this way and i give it a shot there are definitely some down timing moments later on in the game with the massive scoring where we had to like count all the tokens and kind of group them up to figure out you know who has 14 and who has 17 and who has 13 and that kind of thing and thinking about the ramifications of those when you add these new tiles down because that one has two and that one color and one of the other there are definitely some things to think about but i wouldn't say that downtime was a problem for us and i wasn't paying super close attention to how long the game took but it wouldn't surprise me if it was 90 to 100 minutes something like that and again this is a four player game which is the maximum player count and as i mentioned in the beginning according to board game geek it is best at three uh i don't think there are any balance uh or setup changes for three versus four player games there are some different things for the two player game which i did not even look into and it wouldn't necessarily surprise me that it was better best at three i think it'll be a little bit less stressful overall with just two other people that you're competing against instead of three uh and i would probably be more interested in playing this at three than four in the future but
i don't think i'd say no to playing it again at 4. so that's kind of where i land with umbra via i think it's a fascinating very well designed game i think it's a great game honestly but i'm not sure how excited i personally am to keep playing it and i do think some of my friends might take a little bit of convincing to play again i think they came they saw they enjoyed but they didn't necessarily fall in love and they'd probably be more interested in playing other things uh charles said that they're strongly considering umbrevia they think it looks fun but we'll probably try it before buying um it could turn out to be a game you're really terrible at um yeah i think this is the kind of game that most people will feel really bad at i have a hard time imagining a person who's like oh yeah that's going to be in my wheelhouse but maybe some people do i will say that this is available to be played on the internet somehow i didn't do my homework i think it is tabletopia or tabletop simulator or maybe both but i do believe this one is playable online um i could also be wrong so definitely double check that it should be not too hard to figure that one out but there's probably a way to to figure that one out well i think that is going to bring this one to a close uh if you have any questions or comments about any of the games i've talked about today then please leave those down below i'd certainly appreciate that also i would love uh feedback that you might have on how this vlog went in the past i've had images on the screen that i've kind of waved at with my hands but this time i had an arrow being poked around trying to show different things for context and honestly i take any feedback that anybody has about how all of this stuff worked and yeah thanks for watching
as always i'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this channel including these producer-level patreon supporters if you too would like to directly support the channel in the creation of future videos just like this one then please go to junketsgames.comsupport also if you enjoyed this video then please click the like button for it down below as well as the subscribe button for the channel thanks for watching