Skip to main content
Loading video...

Union Stockyards Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 20:45

Hey everybody, today I'm taking a look at Union Stockyards, which is a two to five player worker placement board game that takes 45 to 90 minutes to play. Now, before I get started on my review of Union Stockyards, I want to give a shout-out to the show sponsor kienda.co.uk, who are my go-to online retailer, and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code, then you can get 5% off your first order. Okay, so I've set up for a two-player game of Union Stockyards here. Now, this board is double-sided, so if you were to play with three to five players, then you'd use the reverse side, which changes the the look of the game a little bit just to compensate for the extra space that you need. Now, this game is all about the stockyards in Chicago during the second half of the 19th century and the beginning of the 20th century. So, it's a pretty bleak theme, but a pretty unique theme at that. Now, the idea of this game is you're trying to get as much money as you can because money is points, and that comes from cold hard cash that you have in your hand, as well as the banked money you have represented by this score track here.

Let's take a brief look at the board just to get you familiar with the way things look. So, in the top left-hand corner here, you have these building cards that you can buy, and they come with a lot bunch of different information on them, such as the size of the buildings that you'll be placing on the actual Packingtown grid here, and they're represented by these rather chunky wooden buildings. You have the benefit of that building, such as letting you climb up these different livestock tracks to increase your profit margins. So, you have three different types of livestock, you have the the cows, the pigs, and the sheep. They'll come with some flavor text here, and they'll also come with these end-game points here. So, you can see here that if I was to build the soap works, I'd get three points at the end of the game. Now, some cards also come with these little white symbols in the bottom left-hand corner, and that correlates to the specialist cards that will give you some additional bonuses if you are the first player to reach those symbols. So, you can see here that for me to get this canned ham specialist card, I'll need two of those canned meats um symbols there, and that will give me an extra boost on the pig track.

You've got the brand reputation track here, which means you'll try to climb up it again to increase your profit margins, and but it will also give you some bonus points if you are the player furthest up at the end. You have the yards here, which will show the amount of livestock that are available to be slaughtered in order to um in get that money straight out from the the bank. You've got these different locations, which relates to these little um these little huts you're trying to put down, which will give you some more end game scoring. Um and again, we mentioned the uh the packing town here, where you're trying to build your buildings and create a bit of a network and hopefully touch these different symbols in order to put them on those locations. You have a union spirit marker here, which basically yeah, represents the morale of your workers. And if it reaches this red area, then you have to forsake your workers um and basically work with fewer workers at the um at the uh throughout the round.

Um and you'll also that will be represented by this picket line here, and you're also getting one of these kind of unhappy tokens, which will build up as negative points at the end. So, you're going to have your own little player board here, which shows what what holds your huts, that holds your workers. It'll hold your low morale tokens um and show the penalty prices. You can see there's quite a um few negative points there if you end up collecting five or more. And this is a really good little turn structure breakdown to show all the different actions in the the phases and how they're resolved. Uh general pieces consist of the money. You've got the first player marker here. You've got the spare livestock, which will go into those yards um should they need should they be needed. You've got these viaducts and all the different buildings. So, let's take a look at how the the actually works. So, the first thing you're going to do is you are going to do the start of year phase, where you're going to be adding livestock to the yards depending on the current price.

So, you can see here that at the start of the game, all of the livestock's base price is right at the bottom here, meaning you only add one of each to those yards. Now, this will be in addition to the ones put there in setup. And And as these price rises, you might be putting more um pigs or, you know, um cows, sheep, etc. onto those areas. You'll also be flipping over the year card here, which is kind of an event card for the current round. And this will also dictate the the morale. So, you can see here that this will force the union spirit marker to go up like so. As mentioned ear- earlier, if it did go into that red area, then you would have to forsake a worker and take an unhappiness marker. But, let's just say it did not happen. And this event card will also give you a particular kind of bonus or something going on in that particular round. You can see here a new worker placement space has been um revealed, meaning that I can place my worker here to go one up at the pig track. And there's a ton of these in the game. You're going to use different ones each time. Um and you use one for each year, each representing six or each of the six rounds. And once you've done that small bit of admin, you're going to go into the main work phase, which is where you are going to be placing your workers in turn and taking the corresponding bonuses. So, let's take a look at what all the different worker placement spots do. You can see they all are pretty straightforward. So, you got the contract work one, where you simply get a dollar from the bank. And money is quite tight in this game. You can build viaducts, which are these small black buildings, which are quite flexible in order to build things. And we'll talk about the relevance of that uh later.

You've got the buy land action spot, where you are going to either pay two or three dollars, depending on how fast you can get there, in order to place one of your land ownership markers onto the packing town grid. And this basically represents that you own that particular grid of land. You can see here, me as the yellow player, the Kudahae player, I now own these six squares. And that corresponds to the build action where it can you will pay money equal to where you're building essentially. So, let's just say I wanted to build um this this sausage kitchen. Um what I'm going to do is I'm going to find the building of the matching color. So, this is going to be the white square, and I'm going to place this somewhere on the grid. Now, if I place it on neutral ground like this, I will I will be paying paying $1 for each square that I cover. However, if I build on my own land, then it's going to be free. So, this will cost me nothing considering I already own that land. But if I build on somebody else's um grid, so let's just say the blue player built here, then that's going to cost them a coin to me for every piece of land of mine that they use.

Now, there's also going to be some additional things you can do by by placing buildings. So, for example, when you will get a point for every building of the same color that you're touching. So, if I was to build this one and then to build this one after, because this white building is touching a white building, you'll get another point for doing that. And obviously, once you've paid for the building and placed it there, you are going to take the corresponding reward, in this example going one up the the pig track and going one up the reputation track. And you can see here that also these buildings have end game points. So, that's the the building action. Uh you also have these few spots up here which simply let you climb up the brand reputation track by spending either two in order to go up twice or nothing to go up once. You got the campaign spot which will give you two points and let you flip over this um this market at the end of the round to basically reveal a new worker placement spot which will either be the Republican or Democrat side where you can do this 8-hour of day one which will let you shed one of those low morale tokens and go down on the union spirit track. Or this one here which will let you establish two branches instead of the regular one you'd get from this spot here.

Now, there's also these yard spots which you are going to be placing your workers like you would normally in order to slaughter that particular animal. So, this is a spot where I might want to kill this cow. I'm going to have a look at my particular standing on that track and basically work out the profit margin. So, you can see here that I'm buying cows in at 14 and I'm selling them at 16. Therefore, I'd get a profit of two money from the bank. And you can only ever go to these spots once per round. And once all the players have placed their workers on the board, the player who you went to the campaign spot will get to choose that workplace and spot which we mentioned earlier. You're going to retrieve all your workers from the board and then you are going to adjust the livestock prices based on how many are left on the yards. So, you can see here that if there is the least or the least frequent type of animal in the yards is going to go up in value by three. So, in this example, it's going to be the cows because that's the only one that's been slaughtered.

Therefore, that is going to go up three, squeezing my profit margins and even losing me money in this example. And the ones with the most there is going to go down it by two. Now, that would normally go down, of course, but these are right at the bottom anyway. So, you got to be quite careful about you know, not always taking the animals because sometimes the price is going to go up rapidly, get making you make a lot less money when you kill them. And that's essentially what you do for out out these six rounds of the game. The player with the most points at the end of the game will be the winner. And bearing it in mind that you will also be adding points based on these these branches here which correspond to this part of the game. So, if you ever end up building and touching one of these symbols, you're going to take the matching symbol and place it on the matching location like so, meaning that that's some potential end game points there if I was to build some branches there. So, you can see here that for each branch that I have in these locations, you're going to get two points per the particular symbols there. So, it's a nice little multiplier there and there are even wild ones that you can put down in order to double up. So, they're quite useful to have if you manage to get a bunch of your branches down in a populated city. And they're also going to factor in that you're going to lose points for these low morale tokens. And again, you're going to add up all the points you got from the end of the game with the money you have left in your hand and the player with the most points at the end will be the winner. Okay, so let's share some thoughts on Union Stockyards. Now, this is actually a

pretty straightforward worker placement game, but there is of course a degree of supply and demand. And this is a very important part of the game because you do need that cash flow, you know, when you do kill these animals, that is going to keep your your money flowing in order to take the actions that you want. And something that I didn't mention in the overview was that keeping these profit margins positive is important because at the end of the game you are going to get additional money depending on your standing. So, if you are really high above, that's a bunch of points there. Or if you're below, you're actually going to be losing points. So, that's a very important part of the game there. But despite being very simple, and there are a few things that I found quite intriguing. And number one is the land ownership mechanism. This idea of spending, you know, two or three dollars and then claiming six particular squares for yourself. Now, there's different approaches where you can tackle this. You know, are you going to be awkward and build exactly where you know your opponent wants so that when they build on top of your spots, you are going to get some passive income there. Or are you going to build exactly where you want to go because you are building towards something and you want to get these kind of adjacency bonuses or maybe even tackle these these location markers.

Now, I did like the idea and the potential of, you know, kind of extorting other players out of wanting to build where you want to, but in practice, and maybe this is a group-dependent thing on on my personal group, we kind of just kept to ourselves and ended up laying the foundation to where we wanted to go rather than kind of um encroaching on other people's, but maybe that's just me, but I didn't really see the massive incentive to mess with other players as it was to just build on my own land for free. So, I think there's a lot of potential here for the more for the um mechanism, but I'm not quite sure this used it to the degree that it could have been used cuz it's such an interesting um idea. Now, I also feel the same way about this union spirit marker. It's a cool concept where if you neglect it enough and venture into that ready area, you are going to take a low morale marker, which is extremely punishing, and but you'll also have to forsake a worker for the entire round. But, because everybody is affected by this, it feels like nobody is affected by this. You know, if you all have a worker less, then we're all on equal playing field anyway.

So, I think it would have been a good idea if everybody had their own independent um morale track rather than a communal one. Now, I understand this thematically makes sense as it is a union, um but it's just a nitpick there and something I would have liked to have seen a bit offset so that people are doing different things and it gives you something else to juggle, and um you know, it makes the urgency to get to these spots like this a lot more important because um you know, because somebody could get hit really hard if they ignore it completely. The supply and demand mechanism in this game is rather simple, but it does work well. You know, at the start of the round, um the animals are going to get replenished depending on the current value, and of course, at the end of the round, the values are going to change based on how many are available in the yards there. And sometimes you do have to be quite observant about where other players are going because if you keep on spamming the same animal type because it's your most, you know, your best profit margin, then inevitably the um you know the base price is going to go up meaning that your margins are squeezed and then you're not going to make as much money in the future. So sometimes you might think, you know what, I'm going to go for a different animal this time but to keep my margin strong here and you can even maybe manipulate the board state a bit cuz you know that your opponent maybe has a small margin on one and then you can squeeze it down. So you can actually you know manipulate these um quite cleverly um should you wish to.

The placing of these branch houses is relatively interesting because you can put the branch houses in there before there are these kind of a multipliers or vice versa and you'll find that you know sometimes if somebody has put all their branch houses down in one before there's anything there then inevitably the other players are going to do their best to prevent them putting these wild tokens down because there is only two of those and in reverse if there is say two markers in there then all of a sudden everybody is going to be rushing to these spots in order to populate them with their own tokens to get those end game scores. So it does have that pull it or back and forth there. You know, are you going to claim your stake there before it's guaranteed points or are you going to hope that you can sneak in there once it's been guaranteed or once there's points guaranteed there for the taking. The attention to detail when it comes to the theme here is quite impressive. You know, all of the building cards have flavor text on. The same goes with the specialist cards and also the yearly event cards. Um so it's nice that you can read up on here and learn a bit about the subject matter.

And it's nice that these event cards add a little bit of punch and spice to each round should you by adding a new workplace spot or you know this one here gives you money and but it gives you a gives you a an unhappiness marker so maybe you are desperate for money but are willing to take that marker. Having more supply there when it comes to the yards. Um there are tons of different things you can do here which are generally positive but some of them are not positive at all like some of them might be things like give up another worker for the round which makes things particularly tight. I think the game scales pretty well from two to five players. I think I think they've done a good job of keeping the board feeling tight but not too restrictive. And of course, the player interaction in this game is fairly standard with a worker placement game. There's good competition to rush to the spots, so there's that urgency, which is what you need. Um a rush to get to the buildings that you want because you might have the panic building that you need.

And of course, even the race to get to the specialist tiles and to establish those branches. So, very passive player interaction here. Of course, there's that little bit of spice when it comes to the land ownership, but I mentioned that doesn't really play out as interactively as I would have hoped. But still, um I think, you know, it's what you'd expect from a, you know, medium lightweight Euro in terms of the player interaction. I'm happy with the production for this game. I actually think it looks really cool when it's on the table. It might not be everybody's cup of tea because it is pretty drab looking, I suppose. Um but the actual physical quality of the components is is good, you know, these big, hefty, chunky wooden buildings um look great when they're on the table. Um definitely went above and beyond when it comes to those. And I think one of the strongest things about this game is the iconography and the fact that you have all the information available to you at all times at a glance. So, you can see here that, you know, you've got the year-end livestock price adjustments all right in front of you, all the end-game scoring in front of you, the turn structure in front of you. So, you very actually never need to go back to the rulebook to uh to learn anything. The card stock is high quality, they are linen finish cards.

Nice photographs on the cards as well. And of course, they really really went above and beyond when it comes to the flavor text and being historically accurate, that kind of stuff. So, full props in that regard. Maybe it looks a little bit amateurish at times when it comes to like the player boards. It looks very Kickstarter and prototype-y, but personally, I've got no issue with that at all. And I'm again, I'm generally happy with the way that it looks and the way it's put together. Okay, so let's share some final thoughts on Union Stockyards. And I have to say that this game is nothing like what I was expecting. This is a very simple, you know, medium lightweight economic worker placement game that's very accessible. And that kind of threw a spanner in the works for me because I was expecting something a lot more heavier and a lot more complex mainly due to the theme and the setting here because this is quite a niche setting.

It's not going to be for everybody. It's quite grim and macabre to some people because, you know, it is about slaughtering animals for profit. Now, I personally like the setting because it's different. It's a fresh lick of paint on a an overexposed genre of games, I suppose. Now, the economic side of the game is fairly light. You know, you are just trying to keep on boosting your profit by essentially buying buildings and doing little things here and there. So, the actual decision space here isn't massive. Um and certainly not what I was expecting. I think the gameplay generally is pretty predictable and paint-by-numbers. Now, that is coming from the perspective of somebody who plays a lot of medium-heavy to heavyweight Euros. And I understand that this maybe gameplay is not for me. It's not bad, but it's not for me.

Now, what I struggle to understand is who is really going to pick this game up and get longevity out of it considering that, you know, the gameplay isn't terribly deep. But, the setting is going to be off-putting to a lot of people because, you know, normally these entry-level worker placement games have a family-friendly setting to them. You know, you think of the classics like Everdell, you think of um Lords of Waterdeep, you think of games like Stone Age. Those games stand the test of time because they are so, um you know, welcoming to players. Even though the gameplay is fairly light and fluffy and there's not that much decision space, they keep people coming back to them because they've got a they've got a niche what they're looking for. This one has that style of gameplay, but the setting is very adult and it is getting very niche. So, sometimes, well, generally a passing in the board gaming space is that the more niche a theme and setting is, it means that the the the audience is going to be more niche, which generally leads towards heavier games. So, I think this one's going to struggle to find its audience for that reason, because it is just a polar opposite of what it's presenting to what it actually is. But, the gameplay is solid. It's clearly been well, um you know, well researched. It's clearly a passion project. And I'm certainly happy I played it. But, um but ultimately, this this has got enough to keep me coming back to it, despite being so interesting in terms of the subject matter. You know, the the economic part of the game, the supply and demand is is good. It's fine, but it's nothing, you know, mind-blowing.

The spatial puzzle of the buildings is is fine, again. Um I love this land ownership um mechanism, but sadly, I don't think it's been used enough or been brought forward enough to make it a standout feature. And the rest of it is all pretty straightforward. So, I can't really overly recommend this one. I would say, you know, if if you are interested in it, and you do want a a worker placement game that's easy to get to the table, but you want to veer away from those ones that you've probably played a thousand times, then maybe this is one to look at. But, ultimately, I think there are better worker placement games out there if you want something heavier and maybe more maybe more welcoming games if you are looking for something a bit lighter. So, that's my thoughts on Union Stockyards. I'm a little bit disappointed if I'm honest, because I was very much looking forward to it. But, I think that's more of a factor of being not a bad game at all. It's just not what I'm looking for right now.

Progress saved