The Blood of an Englishman Review - JonGetsGames
Transcript
welcome to Johnny's games today I'll be reviewing the blood of an Englishman this is a two-player only a symmetric card game where one person plays jack who was trying to climb up the various bean socks and they're trying to steal three pieces of treasure from the giant player and all the giant player wants to do is catch Jack and they do so by either saying fee fie foe and fum or by kind of chopping away all the vines of the jack can't make it all the way to the top first I'll show you how the game actually plays and then I'll jump into my review the center for the game is really quite simple you just shuffle up the deck of 50 cards and then deal out five columns with ten cards in each there are three different types of cards in this deck the majority of them are Bienstock cards which range from 1 to 9 then we also have these treasure cards there are two of each with the harp the goose and gold and lastly there are the fee fie foe and fun cards of which there are two each at this point the game is ready to be played and the first turn is always taken by the jak planner before they take their first regular turn however the jak player always gets one special action to help mitigate the luck of the draw they can take one card from anywhere and move it to anywhere so for instance they might take this five card right here and put it up here after this they move into their first regular turn and there will be no more special actions to run out the rest of the game now on the Jacke players turn they get three actions to take and they have a total of four different options from which to choose those actions the first is simple they can just take any card from the front of any of these column and move it to the front of another column for instance they could take this heart right here and move it in front of this nine the second action option lets them take the card from the back of any of these columns and move it
to the front of only that specific column so they can Princeton's take this seven right here and move that in front of this two the third option lets them take the front card from any of the five columns and put it into the big box that they're currently working on as long as it is a legal play now they are going to be building three beanstalks throughout the game and they can only work on one beatstock at a time a plate is legal as long as the next card is a beanstalk that is a higher value than the one they place before or once they have six beanstalk cards in their specific Beanstalk they need to take one of the three treasure cards and put that on top as long as it's not a treasure they've already picked up so starting with a1 is a good idea but if they really want to they could of course start with this four it will just be harder to find any five extra cards to put on top in order to stay ascending as they build that Beanstalk and the fourth and final option allows them to grab a legal card from the back of any of these five columns and put that into their being stock that they're currently working on here you can see an example of one of Jack's completed beam stocks there are 16 stock cards that ascend in order there can be gaps between the numbers as long as there are 6 cards and then there is a piece of treasure at the top once they finish this one they are going to start working on their second beam stock and as I mentioned before they can no longer grab a harp the jack player is going to win the moment they complete their third beam stock but of course the giant player is doing everything they can to stop them so once the jack player takes their first turn it would go on to the giant player and on their turn they take one action from a choice of three possible options now the first action is they can take the front or cards from
any of these columns and move it in front of the next column so for instance they could take these four right here and move it right there it's a very big action but they must take exactly four cards the second option they can take for their full turn if they can grab any Bienstock card that is currently out on the table and remove it from play permanently so for instance they could take this nine right here and once it is gone it is no longer an option for the jack player to use the giant player will just kind of keep this in front of them in their area for the third and final action option available to the giant player they can simply take to move one card from the front of one column to the front of another call on action so they can move that one and this one over here this is of course something they're going to do rarely because the jack player can do the same exact thing but they could do three actions on their turn versus two so obviously the giant player would be in a losing battle if they continued to try and do this unlike Jack the giant player has three different winning condition options the first is that they can manipulate the board state in the middle of the table so that the fee fie foe and funk cards on the front out of four of these five columns they don't necessarily need to be in this order and immediately the giant player would win the second is that they get fee fie foe and thumb together adjacent to each other inside one specific column again not necessarily in order and finally the third way the giant can win is by grabbing enough Bienstock cards from the center of the table such that it's impossible for the jack player to actually complete they're all three of their beanstalk so or in this case the jack player would need a nine right here but they've already used one nine and the giant player has pulled the other three out with this the giant player now wins because
they made it impossible for the jack player to win and that's pretty much it the players will alternate back and forth taking turns from their selected options in the gable end once either player reaches a winning condition let's begin the review for the blood of an Englishman by starting with a couple plus two points and the first has to do with the asymmetric styles of play like that really is the calling card for this game it's a simple card game but both players play very different style games and not only is this interesting from a mechanical perspective but it has really good somatic tie-ins as well so let's start with Jack so the person who's playing Jack has to build these beanstalks and they have to do three of them they have to do them in order which makes thematic sense it's like glass Jack is climbing up grabbing a piece of treasure climb it all the way back down and then climbing back up again you can't climb three times simultaneously and there is some really great decisions that go into play for the jack player because they are getting to take three actions a turn and they have a variety of different options so like looking at the board say and trying to figure out how best to get to where they need to go while also playing a bit of defense like it seems like the jack player is a very offensive character like they're all about running as fast as they can but then also doing a little bit of defense to make it so it's hard for the giant player to either catch up to them or to assemble those feet by photon cards and he's very nimble he's able to change his plans on the fly vs. the giant player who takes one big action a turn and that action is either take four cards for the top of one step from the bottom one sack to another spot or of course just removing
one vine card from anywhere on the area and from a mechanical perspective this is quite interesting because even though it's just one action you could do some rather significant things by shifting four cards over obviously the jack player can move three cards to turn at the most and you can move forward with one swoop but you are much more limited with the options you have to do those four so it's kind of like you know just swinging a big club or something like that it's just it's a big brute force powerful effective action but it might be hard to wheel and the other action the giant can do is just rip out one card and to me that's kind of like the giant has like a hatchet is specifically cutting away at the the fronds of the the vines going as the jack players trying to climb up to try and for Jack from even getting all the way up to the top or having the vine fall back down again so I enjoy the fact that the game has these two different styles of play not only do they have different mechanics were associated with them but they feel different as well like they it feels kind of like there are two games in this one box and every time you sit down to play each player is going to choose one of those two games and then try to beat their opponents at that one specific style and it's a cool thing to see in a simple style card game and I've quite enjoyed that for positive point number two I want to discuss the depths of planning and strategy that come into play for this game now when I sit down to play a normal card game I'm thinking it's going to be a largely tactical affair with maybe some strategy mixed in where the tactics are you just figuring out what's good for me this turn and how do I play around and stuff I have my hand but in the blood of an Englishman that you don't have a hand of cards you
just have the ones that are in the middle of the table and what that means is that in order to play this game well you need to be planning for this turn the next turn the third turn after that and maybe even forward turns down the road and I'm not saying that you have got to do that but it is one way to be effective at the game and it's one way to win at the game and I found it to be very satisfying trying to figure out everything I want to do if I am the jack player I need to think about how I'm building up at my specific stocks now so that I am leaving my options as wide as possible for future use stocks I'm trying to go up in the future I'm also looking at what the giant is doing trying to make sure they don't get the fee fie foe and fun cards together too much and then let's flip side the giant player is trying to figure out what the jack player is planning so they can plan around the jack players plans so if just both players are sitting there just planning about what they want to do what they think their opponent is going to do and just analyzing the board and trying to figure out what the best exact move for them is you know with the giant player what they do more often than not probably like 60 or 70% of the turns I've seen for the Giant is removing one beam card from the board and this might not feel like a gigantic action but it has gigantic ramifications on the later end of the game and the giant player really needs to think about where all the numbers are how close they are to each other how many cards of a specific number the jack player has pulled so that they could get the jack player into a really tight situation later on the game where they don't have much wiggle room the giant player can really dictate the course of playing with a really gigantic action so I just love all the planning that both sides of the board have to do
while they're actually playing the game it's just really good stuff let's not move into some neutral points for the game the first of these relates to how the games have felt between the two wind conditions and for the players and that is that when I'm sat down to play the game it seems like it's easier to teach the game to a new person when they play as the jack player like they just the decisions they're making seem a little bit more straightforward okay you're building your little bean stocks they have to be ascending and you're putting this all of this stuff together but the flipside to that from what I found is that it feels a lot more difficult to actually win as the jack player now I've played the game five times at this point and I've seen Jack win twice and then went three times so I'm not saying that the Giant is overpowered by any means but what I am saying is that the jack player it's deceptively difficult I think to actually pull off that third vine as the the giant player is pulling these cards out from the overall cards that are in the middle of the table and so it's a bit of an interesting situation where the more straightforward character has what feels seems to me to have a much harder time actually closing out and winning the game often times you think of those two things that's not necessarily going together the giant player can feel a little bit abstract as far as what you're supposed to do could be good you know moving these four cards over is that worth it okay maybe try and make one really big long column in the middle of the table and you kind of pull these cards out but it feels a little bit more abstract than obtuse but it also seems like as the game goes on the game becomes much more in the Giants favor and I haven't seen the jack player able to race fast enough to get to the point
where they easily win over the giant player and I'm not saying that the wins I've had with the giant have been necessarily easy but they felt like they'd taken less brain power than the jack player ones and it's they felt a little bit less you know on the edge of going one way or the other than the jack player did i've won as the jack player twice and especially in that second game and it seemed like I had to work incredibly hard to pull that off versus one or two of the giant wins that I did it just seemed like I was just trying to do a little bit of whack-a-mole and I ended up just outlasting the jack player and part of this is going to be the skill of the players around the table but I thought this was something that was one for drill number two I want to point out something that might seem a little bit obvious but that is that this is a hundred percent open information style game there is nothing hidden going on you're not drawing any hands of cards in fact the only randomness that comes into play is the how the cards are all it's played out in the middle of the table at the beginning a game from that point on this is kind of like an abstract style chest like game if you will bet where you know all the moves that your opponent can do you know all the moves that you can do and you're trying to just out think your opponent and for some people that is going to be a bit of a turn-off because I know that many people like a little bit of tactics a little bit of randomness thrown in as the game is going to force a player to evolve their their strategy as they're they're playing but the only real pickups that are going to come into play while you're doing this game is maybe your opponent doing something that you really didn't expect or you really didn't see and that that is certainly cool and so that's why this is obviously not a negative point it's somewhat unusual to find a card game that is
completely open information like this it almost plays like a board game if that makes sense they just happen to have cards out there on the table and I thought that was something that you should know going into it and now we have neutral point number three and it simply put this game can definitely exacerbate analysis paralysis in people who tend to fall for that and again the idea here is you have so many options so much to think about that you kind of lock down and have trouble actually making a decision and I have seen that crop up in most of the games that I play to this and it has not really been a problem because as I mentioned before it's all open information that both players can be constantly planning so it almost feels like a simultaneous game to a certain extent because there's so much think about for both people that while I'm kind of walking down a little bit having a little bit of AP my opponent is not just staring out the window they're also trying to figure out what they're going to do on their turn and the turn after that and the turn after that and what they think I'm going to be doing with it as well all this comes together to be a very quiet gaming experience from what I found like it's just a two-player only game you're sitting there and you're pretty much not talking because you're just thinking the whole way through and for some people this is a huge benefit and for other people this is not but that's the style of game that you're sitting down to play with this one it's a lot about thinking there's potentially some downtime if one person is able to crunch the numbers a little bit better the other and that's just I think the nature of the beast with this one at this point I would normally go into some at negative thoughts I have for the game but honestly I haven't been able to pick up any specific issue I have with the game mechanically or even with the production quality that would that detract from the
overall game experience for me so I think let's go ahead and move on let's now discuss the variability for the blood of an Englishman and to me I think that is slightly above average for what I would expect for this style of card game and that is completely on the back of the fact that there are two different ways to play the game you can either sit down and play as the giant or you can sit down as play as Jack and once you get beyond that the way you play all the cards that are in the middle of table you shuffle them up and put them out that almost to a certain extent feels like the kind of randomness you would have from bringing up a hand of cards and figuring out how you're gonna play through those hand of cards in this instance every time you sit down to play the game there's going to be some interesting weird quirks of how the cards came out like maybe the seven is a really bunched up or those two harps are over there or maybe the giant is just and a huge advantage because the fee-fi-fo-fum are really close to themselves right from the very beginning and that is going to change the way that both players are going to play that one game based off of that one sitting to the next one but realistically most of the variability comes from playing the game from one side or the other and I think that it has a pretty reasonable amount the blood of an instrument is a two-player only game so at this point I would normally discuss other player counts and how they play back and forth but this is the only way to play this game and I think it's certainly a good way to play the game with the two asymmetric sides so let's go ahead and move on in conclusion I played the Blenheim Englishmen five times at this point three times as the Giant and two times as Jack and as an aside I will say that I've never actually lost the game up to this moment and that could potentially cloud my opinion of the game back forth because you know it is kind of fun to win games and I will say that
while I've enjoyed every single play of this game and I do think that it's got some really great ideas and good mechanics it does not necessarily excite me and I think a big part of that has to do with my specific gaming tastes and how those don't necessarily come to play with this game like I do it love asymmetry in game so that's the biggest thing that draws me to this game it's sitting down to the table to play it but I'm not crazy about 100% open information style games and that is just what this game is that's not a critique of the game in any way it's just the style of game that this is and I like card games because in general I the hand of cards and I know what my cards are I trying to figure out how to play them and my opponent does not know what they are and when I'm thinking about what to do with the stuff that's on the table I'm thinking about what my opponent might have in their hand and how I can play around that whereas in the blood of an Englishman all you can do is think about think around what you think your opponent is going to do with the same exact set of information so that means that this is certainly a strategic game it's got great amounts of planning and all that stuff going on here and if you love it strategy in games then this one really might be for you because there are very few lighter style card games they're also quite deep when it comes to strategy and everything that you're thinking about here like at the end of the day this is not a heavy game even though you're doing a lot of thinking and so I think for a certain group of people they will be very excited to play this game it's a very fun mental experience but I also do like having the opportunity to converse with someone around the table have a little bit of noise or something happening in the room it's just this is a very quiet experience of just constant crunching
and since its two-player only it's not like you can talk to one of your opponents while a third person is thinking about what they're going to do on their turn you just have yourself met or the person you don't want to mess up their train of thought and honestly you should probably be looking down and figuring out what you should be doing on your turn as well so I think for for some people they're going to love this and for other people this is going to be a even bigger turnoff to them than it is for me I'm very neutral to all of these points which is why I have enjoyed the game in general and I look forward to playing some more in the future but as I said I'm not clamoring to get it to the table while recommending it I think it will not actually get played all that often for me as always I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this channel through patreon including all of these producer level pledges if you two would like to directly support everything that I do here you could do so at patreon.com slash strongest games and I'd really appreciate it also if you'd like to see more in depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and vlogs please subscribe to the channel thanks for watching