Skip to main content
Loading video...

Is It Important to Have Good and Evil?

Transcript 9:09

In this video, I talk about the differences between good and evil and how it might relate to your gaming. Now, I don't watch as much television as I used to. Actually, these days, I watch a lot more YouTube, but I do uh sometimes try to get into some shows that a lot of people like to talk about. Two shows that a lot of people love, probably you, that just did not grab me are Breaking Bad and Mad Men. And I think for me, one of the reasons that I just never was able to get stuck in and completely finish, you know, the entire season is because in both of those shows, it was almost impossible to find somebody who you liked. basically everybody, specifically the the main characters, were not necessarily good people. And it's not that I'm saying that I want to watch shows that only have good people in them, but if you're going to have bad people, you also want to have good people. In my mind, that's one of the reasons why I don't like a lot of reality TV at all because in a lot of those types of shows, everybody's a bad guy because you're kind of seeing them as they are and they're, you know, pitting them against them and each other and the whole deal. And I just don't have time for that. Now, you're probably saying, "But you know, Adam, why do we care?" Frankly, and and that's a very good question. Uh the the answer is because a lot of times, um how you perceive the factions in a tabletop war game are very indicative to whether or

not you like the game, whether you stick in with the game, whether you stay with the game or not. Uh, I found that with Malifox when I was playing it, I didn't see any faction for me that was any much better. You know, there was like I'm not saying that I always want to play the good guys. I don't. It's just that when everybody's kind of not particularly good nor evil, I have a hard time sometimes picking my role. you know, I have a hard time saying, "Okay, well, I'm going to build a force of the bad guys, and then I'm going to build maybe a force of the good guys and be able to pick and choose depending on what I want to play or who I'm playing against when everybody's just kind of areas of gray, you know, I find it sort of difficult." I was going to go into a long diet tribe about how something like Warhammer 40,000 definitely has very strong good versus evil roles, but honestly I started thinking about it a lot more and though the Imperium of Man is supposed to come across as the good guys because they are defending humanity and all of us watching this are members of humanity as far as we know. But, uh, you know, we're supposed to really kind of go, "Yeah, those are the guys we want to win." The the the, you know, the humans cuz, you know, we're humans. But, um, really, if you start looking at the Imperium, they're kind of fascists.

Really, if you start kind of sitting down and getting into brass tax, they're really kind of fascists. If you go back and read some of the Horus heresy stuff from say Warhammer 30,000, uh, roughly that timeline, they didn't used to be that way. But after the emperor was basically betrayed and mostly killed, then all of a sudden then everything kind of became fascist. If you're really interested, go back, look at some of that stuff. Let me know what you think about it. Uh, it's it's great story and I I do enjoy that stuff. And I know that the guys at Games Workshop when they originally wrote it that way were trying to make some commentary on the times. I mean, you have to remember that a lot of the stuff that came out of say specifically Warhammer 40,000 came out during, from what I understand, kind of Thatcher and post Thatcher times in England. So yeah, I think a lot of that stuff probably kind of was being put out there as satire. Old Games Workshop, specifically old 40k, used to have a lot kind of a funnier sort of satirical bent to it. They've dialed that back over the years. It's still there, but it's much more slight. So, in that situation, you could definitely pick the good guys, though they're not that great or the bad guys. And at least for me specifically, because I like to have those kind of roles being a little bit more defined, I was able to look at it and go, "Well, when I want to be bad guys, I'll be Chaos Space Marines. when I want to be good guys, I'll be Tao because they're pretty good uh you know for the greater good or maybe uh you know regular space marines. I feel like it's a lot more

defined even still in fantasy uh or you know nowadays Age of Sigmar. The humans in Age of Sigmar are specifically much better I think than than the uh Imperium. And uh they basically are trying to just you know preserve the entire you know everything. we're trying to preserve the the lifestyle or the ability to live in those types of games. So, I kind of get that stronger sort of polar uh difference between the good guys and the bad guys. And for me at least, that kind of stuff is important. It's not that I, like I said, need to play the good guys. It's just that if there's a story line, an overarching kind of lore in the game, I generally find that it's really important that there's definitely defined differences.

You may have some factions that are kind of gray or sort of in the middle, but I got to be honest, more often than not, I don't find myself playing those guys. So, it just kind of depends on what the lore is sometimes on what I play. Obviously, there's also aesthetic values and things like that. For me, honestly, I almost never go, well, I want to play the guys who are best so I can beat my friends. I'm not that kind of competitive person and that's fine and other people are and that's fine but I'm just saying for me it's lore and aesthetics and a lot of times what really interests me in lower are the defined roles. Now the trick is and this is what's kind of interesting is that our hobby really started in historicals and it is very difficult in some historical games to really point out who's the bad guy and who's the good guy. So a lot of times in historicals it's like well we got these guys versus these guys and we know they had battles.

That's the thing we can go back and go they did fight you know so at that point for me that's one of the reasons why I've never been as big into normal historicals because it's very difficult to sit down and say well you know but these guys versus these guys they both had their reasons you have to assume um I think because it's something that actually happened sometimes that's also a little bit of an issue for me which is one of the reasons why I'm much more interested in something like conflict 47 which is weird World War II. It's alternate history stuff that didn't actually occur, walking robots and, you know, laser cannons and stuff like that versus bolt action, which is all stuff that did technically kind of happen. So, it's totally up to you, just as it's totally up to me what kind of preference it is. But I think it's interesting, and I guess I didn't think of it until just recently about how I have a tendency to pick stronger roles when I'm picking my factions. And I've played games in the past where it's very difficult to tell who's wrong and who's right. And I've been finding that I don't generally stick with those games or even pick up on them at all if I don't have that sort of laid out for me. Maybe it's um I don't know. Maybe I'm a simpleton. I don't think so. I think I just have a preference for the way that I like to have my stories told on the tabletop.

So, I don't know. It's interesting, but it's something that I thought I'd bring up because I kind of wanted to start a conversation about it and see what you people thought because it's uh it's a deeper subject, but I think that everybody's got their own opinions about it. And I think that that kind of differentiation between the the this group versus that group, whether these guys are considered to be particularly good in the story and these guys are going to be particularly bad. And again, these are all predominantly madeup situations and historicals. is a whole different story. But the differentiation between those things, at least for me, is a big deal and makes me want to be more interested in the game or not. So, if you've got uh some thoughts about it or if you've never thought about it and now you are thinking about it, let me know in the comments because I like to read these things and I like to try to answer them within a relatively timely fashion when I can. There's frequently a lot. But I think that as we see more and more games, at least recently, we're starting to see a lot of this is kind of gray area. You have all these factions, but they're all basically kind of the same. Not necessarily in lore or in aesthetics or even in function, but just like we're not going to say who's wrong and who's right. And that's fine. But for me personally, I like to know which side I'm on when I pick my army.

Progress saved