Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Most Meta Game Ever | The Game Makers First Impressions

Transcript 18:51

Hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor. My name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today. This is this video is going to be my first impressions of the game makers, a game that is coming out in 2026. I believe it's going to be uh Kickstartered or crowdfunded soon designed by Ben Rosset. Uh if you're familiar with Ben Rosset, he has designed games or taken part in the design of games such as The Search for Planet X and Formage amongst others. And so, uh, yeah, great, uh, pedigree of games from Ben Rossid. I've, you know, played these games. I I own The Search for Planet X and have played Formage as well. And I was, this game has been on my radar since its announcement a couple of months ago, uh, when it, you know, has been in in the works. And I was pleasantly surprised to see this be uh developed and put out into public alpha on Board Game Arena. The the good news is that you can play the game. The bad news is there aren't any uh rules. I looked on Board Game Geek. There aren't any uh rule books that I can see. The only resource that we really have for how the game plays is from a video by the Heavy Cardboard group. So, I'll go into a little bit more of how this game works in terms of rules than I usually do in case uh this is a secondary source for how to play this game. But in addition to that, I I do want to talk

about uh some quick game comparisons and peer review from some of the people who have already played this game and my final first impressions as well. So, this game features a few me few different mechanisms in terms of a rondelle and what you do is you have three forklifts on this rondelle and you choose one of three spaces to put them on. Uh the neat thing about this game is especially when you look at this in physical form is you have all of these different resources that are um allocated and annotated on the edge of this rondelle. And the way that these slats are arranged with this rondell is that you have different resources that are uh allowed you know face up at any given moment when this randell is in this configuration. And the strength of the work or the resource that you're trying to gather is determined by uh how this is arranged. And essentially the higher the or the more spaces that you place your worker away from or the forklift away from the starting position, the better the resource type will be. You have a couple of different major categories of resources. You have cards, you have and these are all like components, right? You have cards, you have dice, you have uh workers, uh tiles, uh plastic components, and then this is a wild section that can represent any one of these. So, for

example, here with this forklift, u and this is a a solo game that I have going on right now. Let's say um I choose to place one worker here. I will gain a third level worker, which is this panda looking worker. The other types of workers, as you can see here, are these like orange meeples. These are the second tier. And then the bottom tier are these uh straighter looking meuples. So then uh and so on and so forth. When you choose a mele, you get the chance to either uh place them into your components section. And so these components can't be allocated anywhere else on your board, but they will be used for set collection or sorry uh contract fulfillment, which is in terms of these cards. And of course, this is the draw and theme of the game where you are board game companies and industries making contracts uh with all of these real life games, selling them to the public or essentially putting out the uh the cont signing the contracts and putting them out for sale. And so you have uh for example, bonfire here requires uh the components of a three like the highest tier tile which is three hexagons linked together and a second level worker. I have the second level worker already. So I'm just missing the tile. And each of these cards are separated into uh different types of uh general categories of games

such as the blue ones which are strategic games I believe. And there's like red, yellow, and um let's see, do I have any other? Yeah. So like red are war themed games. Yellows are engine builders. And I forget oh purple is co-op as well. Those are the represented games so far in this uh in this game. So yeah. So, with my panda, I can allocate it to become a component to be used on any of my contract cards. And keep in mind, these cards can be they're used to fuel component-wise other cards as well, like 8-minute Empire requires two cards to uh to sign that contract with and fulfill the contract. Or you can allocate these resources onto various different parts of your board.

For example, um if you put them uh like in the enhancement section here, uh when you draw from like the cards or the tiles, you get to look at more of them. Uh for example, if you put your workers down here, and if you roll some dice, uh anytime that you pick up the dice, uh we'll we'll actually let's do that next. So, um, uh, yeah. So, you can I forget what this part does actually, but fortunately, you can hover over, uh, these these sections here if you're playing on your PC. And, um, yeah, at any time you have a required worker in the break room. Um, oh, yeah. So, you can get a any kind of material at that certain level. So, if I turned in this uh this third level worker, I could uh exchange it for a third level resource of any of that type. So, yeah. So, I can place my worker. And I think what I'll do with this this guy is I'm just going to put him in the break room for now. I'm not really playing to minmax this, but uh let's talk about dice. If you place the worker on the dice section, you will automatically roll it first. And so, you have a dice of four. So you can always use that as a component. Doesn't matter the number on it, but but the color for uh components for cards. Or you can apply the number on the dice to the uh marketing track. As you ascend these tracks, you will multiply the amount of

points that you get for each type and color of um contracts that you fulfill and place onto your uh scoring your shelf, your tableau, and other things as well. Uh there are some there's another resource in here uh in the form of trees which you can get from various cards and effects. Um you can place them on here to uh gain different ways of uh scoring points and and so on and so forth. I'll I won't talk about these in depth, but um so for example, I don't need any um component for the dice. So I think I'm going to select that. And let's go ahead and move up the yellow track here. Um, and so I have almost reached the point where I can uh for every uh engine building game that I have in my display case, I would get an extra point at the end of the game with. And then finally, for example, um let's place my other forklift on a card to draw a new contract in the form of meadow. Let's go ahead and place that there and end my turn. Call that good for now.

So then the rondell moves afterwards and uh you can now place any workers that are in that section, that wedge that is deemed ready. So uh this is an early comparison of course is another game by Ben Rosset which is fromage in which the higher the the level or the you know the the bigger the reward that you get for your worker the farther you place it from its starting sector the longer you have to wait in order to use that again. So uh there are some you know decisions to be made in terms of what resources do you need? How far are you willing to commit a forklift in order to get a certain type of resource, whether it is for uh parts of your board or for components that you need to fulfill your contracts um and so on and so forth, right? A couple of other things before I continue with my uh my review include like this assembly area. So, the tiles in addition to them being components, you can place them onto this kind of puzzly type of, you know, section where uh if you have I want to say if you have like three in a row, uh you get a certain certain benefit. I think you might get that resource. I I forget. Uh you'll have to watch the video for that. Uh but you can also you have a bunch of these onetime bonuses that you have on your board. And if you form a little diamond with these tiles on this board, you can choose one of these at any time and gain that benefit as needed.

And I think Oh, yeah. And then there's also this area that is draftable. Uh these tiles are are drafted at the beginning of the game or deal dealt out uh randomly where you have another area to place your uh components. more specifically with the plastic uh building looking components here. You can place them here one one time and some workers can also go here, but they will allow for different ways to score points at the end of the game as well as uh one-time uh benefits as well. So yeah, so essentially what you're doing is placing these workers out on the rondelle and getting benefits that are variable in nature. Uh, all of these resources are like in certain categories, but there are certain levels or tiers of each resource that you're drafting from. And all of that is to say that you're trying to uh contract fulfill these contracts that are board games that have resource requirements.

And they each also give you certain ways to benefit in the game. Whether it's different ways to score points at the end of the game um based off of the configuration of where these board games are on your display case here or other they give you like one time uh uh effects or or benefits rewards for fulfilling them just like with challengers here. Whoever places their last game on their shelf uh the the 12th game will trigger the end sequence of of the game. Everyone gets to finish the round and then play one more round and then call it good and add up the points. Whoever has the most points wins. And if there's any tie, whoever has the highest ranked board game on their shelf is the winner, which is pretty neat.

So yeah. So in terms of my review and comparisons, obviously Fromage is the biggest comparison, I think. Uh here's here's my final rating. It's a 7.2 out of 10. Um I I really enjoyed this game. I compare it mechanically. I feel like it's it's an interesting comparison when I'm thinking about specific games and and obviously like I have played, you know, physically and and digitally played certain games that might be different to you. And so the comparisons might be similar, might be different. Um, and so sometimes my I feel like my my comparisons come out of left field, but it's just based off of what I have experienced in my time playing board games, which is relatively short compared to many others. But um, the Oh, and and I should mention too that this game is played simultaneously.

So if you know we if I was to play this on the table, everyone's who has their forklifts here will allocate them out onto the rondelle at the same time and take the benefits on their board uh fulfilling contracts as needed and until everyone has done that and then you can move the rondell and continue the game simultaneously. So there you know for example there are so many games that are kind of simultaneous in nature. You have like Earth, you have Race for the Galaxy which approach this by one player chooses an action and someone else everyone else gets that action at a lesser degree. Uh there are other obviously like simultaneous games like um Galaxy Trucker that come to mind. They don't exactly fit mechanically in how this game works, the Game Makers, but in terms of how it feels like when you're playing it on on the board. The Game Makers I feel like has a more chaotic nature to it when you're playing it with multiple people. Uh similar to Galaxy Trucker where you know everyone is moving their own uh forklifts at the same time doing you know uh calculations and allocations of their resources at the same time which can feel kind of chaotic. And so if you're a player who would rather like play everything by the book and make sure that everyone is doing it correctly, uh this might be tough to do because uh of that simultaneous nature.

Uh we talked about Formage already. Um it was tough to think about a game that had different resources that are tiered. Off the top of my head, uh, a weird thought that came to me was this game called Chimera Station, which you can play on board game Geek or Board Game Arena, which is a worker placement game where you modulate your workers with different uh, parts. They're like aliens, right? And you have different colored parts of each alien that you can assemble onto it and it allows you to take certain actions at certain abilities and and gives you certain rewards, right? And so that that was the first comparison. It's not a very good one uh to the game makers, but all in all, it the the fact that it was really difficult for me to find immediate comparisons. I'm sure if I did some more research, I could find exact comparisons to some of these mechanisms. But in all, I felt like this game was pretty unique mechanically in addition to its theme. It's very meta, right? And I think that's the biggest appeal of this game. I think this game, and I gave it a five out of five. Um, I think the fact that we have real life games being represented in this is amazing and it's what draws me to games like Rolling Realms where you have representation of real games as a sort of celebration of what our board game hobby has done in modern times to expand its, you know, outreach and the the depth and complexity of, you know, exploring different themes as well as mechanisms and iterating upon that has been a really cool journey in the past

you know couple of decades or so and this is a celebration of that I think and so that for me even though um as I might mention here in my summary like it's not the deepest game strategically I think the decisions are interesting for sure having to decide whether to scrap components or you know resources for components or to utilize them in certain ways on your board and deciding when or how, you know, how to use your forklifts, whether to uh allocate them out further or shorter. It is the same decision space that you kind of see in Formage, right? And so, yeah, I I think I would play this game over Formage. I think the the mechanical uh nature of the game and the depth of the of the strategy of this game is somewhat similar, but um but I like this more because of the theme. I I like the spatial arrangement of of the different board games as well. That adds a spatial puzzle to the game. Um the solo mode is it's hard for me to and I haven't really graded it for the solo mode because um if if it if if it is as it's played on board game Arena. I'm just taking these turns until I fulfilled my board. And so I could theoretically just continue to rotate around this board until I gotten everything I needed and uh minmaxed my my ability to uh provide the best games on my shelf and you know figure out the best thing. I there there might be a timer on that but I'm not sure and I can't compare that to any published uh

resource whether it's prototypical or not uh because I don't think that was covered in the video that I used to learn this game with. And so, so the solo mode I can't comment on if it is as it is here in board game arena. That feels a little off to me. I think it would be better if it was a tighter experience and probably is, but um if it was a tighter experience, you're on a timer and so every decision matters more as you're playing the game of where to put those forklifts. Um, but I think this game is definitely made more for the multiplayer experience. And it does go and have enough resources to place up to six players, which I think is awesome. So, I think this game will have legs because of its theme. And mechanically, it's a very sound game. I think it's going to be very approachable for those that are newer in the hobby to understand. And it will provide, I think, a lot of opportunities to reminisce about certain games that people like, open up conversations about, hey, what is this game all about? This this looks really cool. That kind of thing, right? And so, I think this game is a great celebration of our hobby and is it might be a great focal point to diverge uh other people, you know, into what types of games are out there on the market. And uh I believe that there are going to be expansions to this game to represent older and newer games as well. So I I think that'll be awesome mechanically as well. It probably might get deeper uh strategically, but it'll continue to add

to the representation that we see in our hobby, which is very vast. And so uh if they can accomplish that, I think that is a job well done. So yeah, I really enjoyed it and I will enjoy playing this as it becomes uh a physical thing that is uh available to be purchased. I can't wait to try it out in person and in the meantime I will experience it on Board Game Arena and probably will continue to enjoy it. So those are my first impressions on the Game Makers. Let me know what you think if you had the chance to play it uh or if you're excited to play it. And hopefully I'll catch you on the next one. And if you schedule an appointment with me and I'll talk to you next time.

Progress saved