Middara Unintentional Malum: Act 1 - Discussion 2.0
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for Madara unintentional malum act one this is the technically discussion 2.0 as well as a discussion for chapter 5 because we will talk about that uh go over all of our thoughts now that we have completely finished act one and boy oh boy was it a ride it sure was this entire thick book we have gone through well not entire obviously you skip a bunch of stuff if you don't have certain uh story flags and and so on and so forth uh so with the end of chapter 5 what I find the most fascinating is actually it does does not tell you to like wrap up or anything so I'm assuming you just put everything it's all just going to carry over yeah I I hope they do have something in act two to kind of like make that easier transition easier transition get caught up uh I'm sure they'll have like a synopsis or something but yeah cuz it's like there's so much stuff that's all over the place but yeah as far as uh it's concerned you just wrap it up like you are like you're like you're going still play act one yeah uh overall Devon what did you think of Madara I enjoyed Madara you did I had a good time with Madara it's it is
everything a Dungeon Crawler needs to make a Dungeon Crawler work because of them that I've encountered it needed something and this thing had it it had that uh that overarching story line that it to draw that gameplay in to make you want to continue to keep upgrading um yeah I think I mean unique aesthetic there's so much you can go on yeah that's true uh yeah overall I also had a good time uh although if you watch quite a few of this series it's like oh he hates this game uh there are aspects that I absolutely despise uh there is just no no hiding that but what this game does well it does really well and the two things that I think Madara does better than a lot of other games is its story um is topnotch especially with the for teller app the rewriting it does is better than what's actually in the book If I Ever Had to actually read this out loud hell no I'd kill myself yeah no it's not getting played uh exactly so side note I am very excited that four teller for Act 2 and three is actually going to be doing professional voice acting it I felt she get a really good job she did uh yeah um and they are bringing her into act two and three so I kind of I think her as the narrator maybe her as the voice of certain characters uh will be good but I think like the finale for example in chapter five was kind of lacking because she
just obviously couldn't do the voice of the Shadow Lord having Ambiance or another booming Voice or whatever would really make it like intense some music great exactly so I I'm very excited for that but overall yeah I wasn't like it was it was I she did a good enough job that I knew who was talking whenever she was doing it which is impressive for uh the range of a female voice actor which is awesome uh but the story is leagues above a lot that we have played uh and the second thing that I think this game does insanely well is the character builds um very jrpg tons of different ways to build that while not every B well I would I would say every build is viable you just have to do a lot of tweaks um because at the very beginning like of chapter one two and maybe three Zeke's qars were not the the quick attacks were not doing it m and then chapter four and five it's like now he's doing 90 damage right we're doing 100 hex around exactly so the scale of progression uh does work like mhm not bad scaling no um like whenever we were yeah getting further and further and it as it was unlocking more and more gear it's like that shit's so expensive and I was worried it was going to do kind of
like a KDM thing where it's like oh well only one person gets to upgrade everyone else will stay behind but you're really given enough money that everyone gets to upgrade a little bit and still feel like they're participating right um but we all had completely different builds that were crucial and you have your own campaign going on with completely different builds yep um there just so many weapons yeah and so many armors and Relics and unlockables that we didn't even see all the unlockables that's like ooh this is the perfect build you can do this mhm I mean just a an example of like what was there was a weapon I think we saw that was like you deal extra damage based off your strength like so if you had like the brute serum with an it oh the his Cleaver the cleaver yeah yeah which it's like oh yeah just those two alone it's like hey now I do extra damage uh because my strength is insane yeah yeah it's a more guaranteed zotto mhm like every character at the very beginning of the whole campaign it kind of is like hey here's kind of what they want to do and you can stick with that I think that's a really smart way to do it is be like hey night Andale is kind of the magic user oh okay well that's easier for new people but if you don't want her to be the magic user you can put her however BR has more hit points he can be the grower yeah uh and it does things that I've just never seen in other games usually it's all very
limited or it's just a bunch of loot drops and it's like H none of this really matters right so I enjoyed I enjoyed all of that the consumables upgrades the relics you got your accessories then you got disciplines and yeah your disciplines you're not and you're not locked to like oh this is only equipped to n Andale it's like oh okay well I don't want to play night Andale right now let's bring in gamle and it's like oh well let's just kind of mix and match what we already paid for right that's just so it's very free flowing um yeah the story is just really gripping which is hard for board games I feel to be engaging like by the time we were done with Gloom Haven it's like I don't really know what the story is right right it's like we were talking about the story of Madara outside of playing it's like what do what do we think's going to happen you know who's going to die who's going to fall in love yeah who's GNA yeah who's going to die what's going to happen where do you think it's going how how do you think act two and three are going to go which you just don't really do with board game narratives right at least I don't it's more like that's what you do for shows or video games uh well I mean that's how they they built this thing around is this big old two Your Own Adventure style I mean several of our tags didn't really pay off but they'll pay off in Act 2 and three so I think that's interesting that our flags are going to carry over
exactly yeah cuz we had out of uh the time is of the essence two never showed up mhm uh one two so let's see 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 17 18 19 20 21 22 there are 44 or 43 Flags mhm in act one we got 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 we got 15 we got 15 we got five achievements which I I could the achievements never even showed up later on as far at least I think they're just more for one time payoff like okay if you can do this in this encounter we're going to give you something free yeah and I think that's really cool it's like you can really try to go out of your way to get them M but yeah it's just it's insane there were so many flags that we got that just never showed back up and so many that kept showing back up it's like we didn't do that right like we don't have that where do we even get that and I think it's smart because that's kind of how they keep track of like voice actors it's just like oh if we don't have this then that means we must not have this character with us right uh it's just done insanely well uh I do cuz a charact the characters and I like that they're actually written characters like we
don't have to project role playing onto them it's like nope this is exactly who nigh Andale is and that's who damle is even the side characters that aren't the main four I really liked like dam is my favorite character mhm he's probably come more it seems like he's become more core now he's going to be the original crew because he didn't die or anything and nothing made him leave and then it sounds like Patrick's going to be pretty core now too yeah they split the party in Justice I mean yeah they yeah she was a given well I they were all yeah it it seems like padrick damle is Justice like you are getting eventually at some point Zafir is the only one that's been nebulous Zafir yeah shayas later I guess I think yeah you get you get shus regardless yeah I should have said sh or not shus I should have said spoilers at the beginning cuz but then there's Echo we don't know what happened there yeah cuz there was that 10th slot on the sheet right like there's going to be another so yeah uh potentially that also it's like what if we chose to give up rook like that was a hugis know oh [ __ ] that was an option yeah to be like okay yeah Rook if you're that is your role would have happened would have like forc us into the combat anyway mhm or would I mean we could have potentially not got damic cuz you can fight him right right I think he's a he's a boss mhm um so yeah it is it's it's Loosely
Choose Your Own Adventure like you're given very like it's not like oh look at the map and decide where you want to go it's not that kind of but you are eventually given choices but and I like that because I think the choices because there's so few of them that means they're more important instead of being given a bunch of choices where it's just like does this even matter probably not right it's like nope time to make a choice the character playing this the person playing this character gets to make that choice uh means it's probably very significant to the story and I enjoy that um so yeah I mean I'm I'm extremely excited for act two uh we know from talk into the designers in the team that act two is smaller and well act two and three are about the size yeah they're they combo but they're like a little bit less than Act One mhm like about the same size but just a smidge less it sound like the way he described it which makes sense because this was a lot of World building so now that we're in the thick of things it's like act two I bet I feel like act two is going to be kind of like how the Game of Thrones books are where it's like they're going to be split so you're going to have stories from the half like padrick and shayas and Zeke yeah from their side and then you're going to have Nightingale and all those other people and it's probably going to act two is going to be the jumping back and forth okay and then act three they come they come back together and then do the whole you know big bad and whatever is happening at the
end of act two yeah that would certainly like stretch out the rarity levels by swapping between the two of them so it would slow down progression right cuz I we know that they're going into epic and Mystic Legend yep yeah legendary and Mystic and all those kind of items which I'm very very excited for they show a lot a lot more disciplines coming yeah I'm interested to see how what the scaling turns into cuz I knowz I mean I I guess in this conversation we're combining chapter 5 combo right yeah so I mean woo chapter five they really cranked up the volume yeah uh it wasn't as chapter 5 I I actually enjoyed um out of all of them I think I like chapter one better but I'm I'm a sucker for like the beginnings of stories like the very first Lord of the Rings is my favorite the first Harry Potter book is my favorite so I really like chapter one cuz it's like oh that's where we were and now we're here MH but chapter 5 I did enjoy a lot because it just it felt it felt succinct like it didn't feel like it was just over like just overloading you with just [ __ ] all the time chapter 4 was just such garbage [ __ ] hated chapter 4 chapter 4 that was the swamp the anointed yeah it was the soul Stitcher yeah okay and then so chapter five was okay we had the you know Justice was K was captured was it was captured and we went to rescue her at the Eerie yep it was kind of yeah going
into the shadow of Lord's domain uh we had the potential to do one a few boss fights that we actually skipped mhm uh through decision making but the one boss fight we did which was a shadow Lord actually felt good uh yeah yeah best boss fight in the whole game yeah yeah they definitely I they kept him under control cuz that you know that was going to be an end game scenario I think versus like they had so many different outs for you if you like lost to Alana or eeling they had different effects that would occur um that would keep you going but uh you might have things dividends you have to pay in glater ax possibly I assume but exactly but with him it was like obviously going to be a game over scenario if we lost yeah and I mean the the best thing about this game though is that if you do fail it's fail forward so you just keep going it's not like oh redo it like no I'm not redoing I think that's where like a good number of those flags come from is failing certain fights true that's true yeah so it just yeah it it just flowed because it was also like they couldn't make him so op because it's like it didn't matter at the end like we beat him and he's just like anyway that was fun anyway get out yeah oh I'm not sure how I feel about that I like to be able to satisfyingly destroy a God yeah there's no way you're going to just got an Act One MH like I I didn't expect to actually beat him yeah
um but it was uh it still was like Hey Okay well we like we proved something we got Justice out it's like yeah I wonder if it's possible to have just you just take way too long yeah like yeah I'm kind interested cuz I mean we had several options so we lost time when we uh help helped the coffin yes but I so I assume if we had battled in we wouldn't have lost that time oh yeah maybe and then we had the option to help Ekko which I assume would have lost this time again and I guess taking the time to fight him would have also lost us time right so if we had if we helped the well and then who's to say what path it would have sent us down if we didn't help the coffin cuz it sounds like he showed us the perfect path once we helped him yeah he was like you know you follow the blood and then like later on it's like Zeke's looking at the blood and the shadow Lord's like ah I see how you [ __ ] found me godamn I've got Lava Pits I've got soul captures what the [ __ ] how'd you get here yeah he's like now I'm annoyed yeah he like coffin dude yeah so overall I I had a great time um if the story wasn't what it was oh God I would have quit a long time ago mhm uh the story is what kept me wanting to come back um and and the character building mhm but with all that being said okay before
you get to the game mechanics dis like uh I did really enjoy how it had us like it it it gave us a run uh before we got to spend our money and then we had like 2,000 the point so it really felt I really enjoyed the the gearing up that last upgrade before the boss I thought that was really cool yeah that was yeah because the entire time we just kept fighting and kept getting in scenarios and it's like we have so much money mhm uh like what the [ __ ] and and then yeah it's like l shows up and it's like we can get anything we want what the [ __ ] did your [ __ ] glass do it gled my my malum my yeah glowed they talked about it but then nothing happened with it that's what I'm maybe we had to I bet you we had to lose a fight I bet there was a fight we would have had to Lo lose and it would have kicked off maybe just like the black ticket I don't even know what that is oh that's in my in yeah if eeling IED you get the black ticket and then if you lose against a certain boss it kicks off and you get saved gotcha okay yeah maybe we never lost yeah yeah um so it uh yeah I I don't know because oh yeah that is one thing it's not CU in a lot of jrpgs especially video games there's one thing that I always love it's also an anime which this is heavily inspired by jrpgs we never once had a moment where like we were fighting like
a insane boss and other people jumped into help I always love that in anime whenever it's like oh we're getting our ass beat and then like your friends come in and it's like oh yeah tid's turned there's a jrpg series I'm playing called Legends uh it's the Sky series God uh totally it's I want to say Legend of heroes or Trails of the trails in the sky uh and that happens a lot and it's always just exciting and I love it it's like it just never happened like we never had like The Cinematic moment cuz they don't do cinematics in the middle of fights it's like you finish the encounter then then story happens but it's like it would have been really cool if we were fighting like whatever the lorm and then as we're like getting our ass beat you just hear like gunshots and Patrick shows up and then shus comes in it's like it always kept with the core four which makes sense it's a lot to manage like we were able to do it really well with controlling two but uh I just like that from a story element it's like you have so many other characters you could have had like side NPC show up as a narrative to help turn the tide as we're losing but uh but yeah at the end of the day in chapter five getting all that gold and then the final one where it's like the big one we can just purchase whatever we want yeah that was a good time uh all to what's really cool is I'm glad it's not like Anyway pack everything up we're going to have to try and we're going to
going to do that typical video game thing sequel where it's like yeah you lose all your powers you lose all your armor yeah I thought for sure they're going to do [ __ ] like that but no they they they keep stealing going yeah all right negatives dice dice dice dice dice if you do not like dice which I don't like dice uh yeah it's like I don't have like a solution to the problem don't without completely fixing or completely reming yeah it's like here's here's what I if you don't mind me going first go for it like um cuz like I I like and I don't have a good solution but it's like you can't really I don't know I don't know cuz there's Pleasures in both I guess the like when you're rolling the dice you know okay I do my attack and I hit it's great I'm doing this it's like it kind of you have to kind of step out of the fight it's like you know there's the you know the D you get to visualize your kind of character fighting but it's like okay now I have to stop what are my symbols how far am i over and then it's just hard calculation which to some people and I'm I'm part like that that I I like doing the calculations I like seeing my numbers go up and then I have to calculate my damage but then it's like I don't get to pause and think okay that he just swatted him across the leg and knocked him off balance and it's almost like the the role of the other players to do that for you while you're you're running the numbers um yeah it kind of takes you out slow in that so
each attack is okay running the numbers running the numbers what are my different effects because they and this is only going to get worse that's true that is true that part I actually really enjoy uh I'm with you on it I like you know rolling whenever you hit and roll high it's like boom boom boom okay so that's five over that's five damage okay five 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 okay 20 uh 40 damage that it feels good yeah cuz that that's good but it's bad it is bad yes it completely pulls you out out of the theme mhm my biggest problem with these Dice and this is not just Madara it's any game literally any game I don't mind Randomness in games I'm not I don't want it to I don't want combat to be deterministic I don't want to be able to go we won or we lost cuz that's that's not fun either uh my problem is when dice determine whether you succeed or fail um I like dice whenever it's like I mean it doesn't work with these but whenever it's like there's there's various other games where it's like okay here's what I got what can I do with that so you're you're still getting Randomness it's like man I really want to do the special attack I need these symbols okay I didn't get them that's fine what can I do with what I got so you're still presented with options what I absolutely hate and this is 100% in Madara so you might also hate it and it doesn't go away it doesn't get better it's not like Oh chapter 1 is like that but later in chapter 5 it's mitigated no it's the entire game it's like I'm going to determine what I want to do I'm going
to spend all my SP I'm going to move I'm going to move I'm going to spend this to do this massive attack and I missed okay done and then it's like and that's just so demoralizing if it happens it's like I can miss like I don't want to always hit it's like I can oh I do always want to hit but I'm not going to be upset if it's like okay I missed that's fine but when you miss over and over and over and over it's like why the [ __ ] am I here you know let's just say I died and I don't even have to worry about it uh it's a balance issue yeah I'd be interested in like talking to one of their designers on the like the the choice of the design of their dice which is really interesting cuz yeah they've got you know your lower numbers which have no symbols so it's a 50% chance that you're getting like barely any symbols in a lower number and then the other 50% chance that you're getting a decent number with uh solid symbols and there's like a gap between them some of them have a gap G anyway the magic dice do where it's you know we've got four through six so is our low side but then we have 8 through 10 on our high side so there's a whole missing seven right yeah cuz to me it's like they they wanted the highs to be really high and the lows to be really low and that's just not fun because everything in every encounter is hinged on die rolls so your encounters are super easy or super hard depending on which side is rolling really well right cuz I'm like yeah I I would be interested to have to
see why right and like what their like calculations were cuz I'm like I hm I guess like on average you're going to roll one and the other so you roll I'd roll a low and then I'd probably roll like a higher one and then that's going to be my average still going to be a Miss yeah yeah it's true and if we run the numbers and that you know on average you're going to miss more than you're going to hit it seems in certain areas definitely in the early part of chap four we were more likely to miss yeah cuz you found the guy who did the like some charge yeah and it was like a 30 like if you're fighting uh I think it was like green or red I forget you were at I think it was red I forget but anyway it was like a 36% chance to hit yeah the defenses of the enemies were slightly higher like one or two higher so you were more than likely to miss like it was like higher than 50% chance that you were missed and that was our big problem with folklore was it's skewed against you and it's like well that's not fun Madara does the exact same thing right and it's like they do have like methods of like several attacks which we discovered you you can have multiple attacks you can get rolls with certain effects and very specific cards yeah uh but then sometimes you don't have that it's like uh if you don't have that it's a bad time yeah and there that kind of ties into we talked about how the openness of character builds yeah you can build whatever you want theoretically like you can and you're going to need some dice exactly so it's like okay well then no you can't really build whatever you want because
the game's core system does not allow that like with KDM it's like okay so if you don't have that headband you're going to have a bad day exactly and it's like well then you're not really uh you know free to choose how you want to play because so you don't have hammerhelm or Kill the Messenger yeah you're you're at the wh of the dice and it almost feels like they should have inverted it like like how would it be if because you want to roll high and some people may not like this may they I really love rolling two10 like one of my attacks against the shadow was two10 and it's like that's [ __ ] 40 damage and that feels really good um but what if like the high number had no symbols but the lower numbers had symbols so you actually and the symbols mattered more you know but the problem with the symbols is all they do is add to damage no almost none of them add to your hit mhm so very rare it's only for very specific weapons very specific weapons yeah yeah the saber was the only one I saw yeah like it star would add the bone chipper guars technically had an ability that if you got consecutive hits it was easier to hit which is cool um so I mean I'll give them something that at least there is some mitigation but my idea of mitigation is kind of like imagine if it was yeah spending symbols to get plus one to hit MH uh like or even give you a decision hey you could use these two Shields to add plus three to hit or you can use them to add plus three to damage you know so it's like man do I want to add more damage no do I oh well I I'd really like
to hit mhm but I'm not going to do as much damage it's just yeah I don't I don't and I don't know if like having the high numbers like a 10 on a blue be blank mhm uh so you actually kind of want to roll high and roll low yeah I couldn't say yeah I I don't cuz like you said with all the certainly made like you know hitting is definitely very beneficial there was no I mean in the higher levels you could really like just ditch touch them okay I've got all these abilities I'm still going to do all the [ __ ] ton of damage yeah uh and then I can do my followup because I actually hit so I understand the kind of the reason you want to reduce the percentage to hit but then that also doesn't lean to a happy fun time right so I guess that's certainly a trap in this type of game is that like okay I want to add all this cool [ __ ] to making attacks but then it's like okay the power the are going to be way too powerful so maybe you doce the likelihood of them hitting at this point and that's not fun like with folklore okay okay I am what was it I think it was like a 40% chance to hit in folklore like from the like the beginning and it was like this is awful yeah you just feel so weak the entire time so it's like it felt they wanted it to feel like an epic you know very animesque and it is animesque with the items and all that but it's like you feel like a little [ __ ] whenever you just miss all the time like I guarantee you we we missed more often and then we hit this entire campaign yeah uh even though we never lost so I guess I can't say it's unbalanced um but it just doesn't feel
good whenever you're in a thre hour side quest and it's just like you're like I thought this was going to be an hour but it's taking forever because we're missing the entire time we're fighting cave sickles again and we're missing there's no fix for it because there's just dice the only have to do with a large game that's going to go and SC that has to scale with time so I don't know I mean war game makers would know better than I do yeah but but we have two great examples of of games that use dice that are phenomenal oorn uh and Aon trespass yeah Aon trespass is like you have the Fate dial so there's a risk to being like you don't want your fate high but it's like so seems risk reward seems to be the method I I think it's like hm it's like yeah I I okay I want to hit that agency to make that decision exactly okay you could push the odds yes it's like so if if I choose to risk it to try and hit and let's say I do hit I'm like Yay but then they hit back and it's like if your fate is six or higher [ __ ] it is you have no one to blame by yourself so you can't be mad you have to be like well I made that decision at least that's how I am is I'm like I actively knew the risks I chose to make it now reaping what I sew uh and that's always nice oorn is just like yeah it's push your luck yeah go ahead roll more dice yeah they're
also more curated they are because like they specifically designed it to be exquisitly balanced which isn't um which is really cool um but if you're wanting to do this like customiz if you want to customize you want have a build you don't get that that is true yeah oor is definitely not it's not a loot game um like you could be like like in Madar we can be busted true um in like in KDM you could be busted is true U but like in oathsworn in an trust bath you're never going to be busted yeah well we might be we don't know yet if it's if it's scaled off KDM the way I've seen the way it's like maybe maybe still be wrong but uh I but they're both very yeah like curated it's you're going to get this defined experience like they have it measured like how challenging this is going to be and like how they want to make your choices matter more in the in the throws of Combat versus your engine you know that you're creating that that's true yeah so yeah I mean that's all very true so it's kind of like it it's going to deter it's going to come down to yeah it's like cuz the like I said the highs are high when you have your build and it finally pops off it wasn't until chapter 5 where Zeke finally is doing [ __ ] and we kind of had to be more tactile about where we're being placed which is very cool I love
the fact that movement actually matters in this game it matters in a few others but there are some games that I've played that are campaign where it's like oh you can move diagonal oh okay so movement doesn't matter right so the orthogonal movement is the best way to do combat in these things because it's actually limiting having terrain mattered positioning of other players matter SOI and Ling of sight and being like okay to make Zeke work we're going to need Remy or someone's ability to kind of get him into position and all that is very very awesome and I do enjoy that whenever it's going off uh but then it's like we do all that work and it's like [ __ ] missed again mhm all right and it could just be because we played four characters we had Rook as a pseudo support there's probably a support that's all about SP buff that's like yeah Zeke who gives a [ __ ] you have it wasn't until the chapter 5 where it's like oh at the end I used all my SP I have haste and now Rook gives me one and now I gain my three so I have five SP again right so it's like I'm not as upset if I miss because it's like oh all attack again I'll Attack again so it all ended up coming out in the wash but man so many so many times I was like I'd go into Madara being mentally prepped to be into the theme and I do that for a little bit but eventually just the dice get to me and I'm now just frustrated the entire time it's like I can't do anymore mhm mhm never really had a problem with Nale yeah but magic is like magic seemed a little more balanced at
least little more even Keel yeah so pretty much all I want to say is the I I much prefer at least their symbols they are unique dice instead of just d6es mhm you know they are adding new dice new colored dice maybe it's the I think it was the the fact that they had the role because both parties had to roll when it comes to spells that's true yeah versus you just checking a flat number like I hope I hit it uh that is true that does feel a little bit better where it's like if I still like no yeah no I think you nailed it because it's like if I roll a six on this gray it's like I can roll it that's a 12 they won't beat yeah they could roll low versus like you don't roll for defense so it's all or nothing with your personal role but it's like well why is there defense that M or it's like hey I hit it oh wait they have armor well never mind so I'm very curious uh they are adding new dice new disciplines I I really hope in Acts 2 and three they just give you stuff that allows you to add to your roles like that type of mitigation rrolling is not enough in my book um at least make that a viable build like hey I don't get rerolls I just get ads so we'll see it's like if I roll low my ads are still doing nothing but at least I have those options mhm um who knows yeah uh that is my absolute biggest complaint is the dice my second
one is the designers must have surrounded themselves with just Yes Men because these some of these side quests or most of them and the boss battles were so egregious like dear God they were I mean just non stop of just fiddly [ __ ] diving back in for the same enemies it's like it it never felt rewarding not a single time did it ever feel rewarding to go after a loot that was off to the side mhm and maybe there was something for you in your campaign but every time I was like you know I think there was one time you're like come on let's do it I'm like you know what I'll humor you let's go out of our way I'll we'll go through it and it was like oh it's Immortal terrorist or whatever they're called and I'm like I [ __ ] told you it's never rewarding and that's that's just disappointing MH and maybe it was the style that we play cuz we we always do like three try at least three four sessions at once and it can be like okay I was like we've been doing this for 7 hours yeah or cuz we played like once a month but I think with like uh you know cuz like me we just do one session each time and it's like you can really kind of like just grind it out get through all thees and it's like okay we got them all it took a while but okay you're also not recording so it's slightly way more relaxed it's like you can play music and you can have food and stuff helps yeah God it really it's a
bummer that we can't play music it really is see well technically I can I'll just get copyright struck yeah uh which I'm not trying to make money it's just I just don't want my channel deleted right um they would just delete your channel yeah you get enough you get enough actual strikes on your I think if you get three strikes they just remove your channel oh [ __ ] you might actually be able to get sued too if you play if I played like actual music it's not like you'd be making money off of it though uh yeah you work way off topic now but anyway but it's uh yeah so it's like it's the fact we were recording but we were also we played once a month so it's like oh you fin we finally got together let's try and get through this chapter and oh we did one side quest because it took four hours that's very frustrating and oh let's go after that loot all the way over there oh got to add more tiles and we got 50 gold wo that added 45 minutes woo it almost just felt like he just wanted to just add more just for the sake of adding more but didn't want to make it interesting or exciting I can't even remember a single side quest like oh wait getting Patrick's gun yeah that's chapter one I think wait no it's chapter two yeah I mean there was the one to kill the flower for that one to try and get that chick's daughter but we never gave it to her we took the money oh yeah which I'm sure that will probably show up in act two or three which is interesting because that was uh that Hendrick guy's wife oh they had the same last name they Patel so it would been his daughter or whatever HRI was the guy
who became the brute bled Guardian also poisoned um Dam's mother yep inter fascinating yeah so there is World building it's not like the side quest for you it's just they they just were so long and it's like ow yeah and I just hate when anything just kind of drags it's like okay yeah the side quest should probably take an hour and a half that was four hours that was and like people think I'm exaggerating no we legitimately had side quests that over four hours and I'm like we we got nothing out of that MH and the Boss B battles like I remember every single one of them so they're there but they're just bullet sponges they're not designed they're not interesting enough to be like this is worth 800 Health 500 from The Lord of Shadows that felt good especially because it's like okay we can see he's going to heal we don't know what he's doing in here but like that lorm dude that lorm was pretty [ __ ] up and it's almost like he wanted he wanted to be a masochist about it it's like dude you don't understand you're you're a board game designer there's nothing stopping me from being like it has 100 Health like there's nothing stopping anyone from cheating because they're not having fun because you didn't design a fun boss M now from what I've seen X2 and three looks like the boss sheets are way bigger yeah they definitely need a little more room to ex have
more steps I guess more complications more steps going on more interesting like that you feel like they're an actual boss mhm uh like right now because this is very pertaining it's like it almost feels like the boss fights in here compared to like the boss fights in oorn this oorn boss fights are like dark souls and bloodborne this feels like Remnant boss fights yeah where it's like yeah you tried and it's frustrating this is a gimmick boss it sucks I'm not having a good time uh like and that's the thing is there's not that many M like we had the like the gatekeeper Melody ising Whopper Whopper yeah the crab um uh Hendrick the Lor couple times Eko couple times yeah yeah and the Lord of Shadows Shadow Lord there might be one or two more in there but that's eight eight boss fights in a chap in five chapter year and a half long campaign uh they should have been like bangers or you should be like I didn't really like that one but I like these M I didn't like any of them except for the last very last one but that's because we were op and again we we were just killing it on rolls mhm it was like oh man Max roll Max roll Max roll Max roll yeah so and
mult like eing our fight was like she just couldn't move so we just okay well she's not running past us or she's getting her ass beat Ekko glitched out it's like well she can't hit me because she's not climbing we killed her soul Stitcher so I guess we just win MH so yeah maybe more steps I think they need to have a lot more um contingency plans to where it's like just to know that things can happen so it's like they don't just feel stuck and dumb yeah uh and just don't just be like well I can't really think of a way to design this boss to make it interesting so I'll just give it a th000 Health it's like that's that's just poor design yeah yeah especially like oh okay I could have just focused her on the first fight yeah it was really the uh the the um the Lor one that was like through the 800 portion of it did all that and then the whole theming of her being like she's tethered her whole life is Tethered to this Lor it's like oh if we kill it she'll get weak and it's like no actually you all get pen it would felt a lot better if it had just like dealt 100 damage to her or something or half her health she still fight but that would have been great that would have felt a lot better yeah I would have been like okay cool we made the conscious decision it had more Health we it paid off this was like no we actually got penalized for doing that mhm so especially in chapter five 5 when it's riging rare items and you did all that for one rare a little bit ahead of
time yeah yeah exactly it was it's just awful so so you kind of like I mean I look ahead to set up for the channel but it's like you kind of look ahead and like can we avoid a boss fight like I'm not kidding there are times where it's like okay if we choose this option we're g to we're going to have to fight a boss if we choose the other option we won't I don't want to do a boss fight cuz none of them have been good so it's like I mean if we choose that as a group we can but I [ __ ] really don't want to and that's not what you want in a Dungeon Crawler you want to come across big fights and be like oh yeah let's do it like I was excited for the shadow Lord and I was rewarded it was good but yeah so the dice the and it's funny because it's like people are thinking so you just don't like the game I don't like the dice I don't like the encounters uh I don't like the bosses so what is about Madara that's like that kept me coming and I said at the beginning it's the character building in the story is and like the character building in the story is like a 10 out of 10 the encounters and the actual game mechanisms I'd probably give us six so average those out you get an eight which is at the beginning I think when we did our very first preliminary discussion I think we might have given it a nine yeah we were very into it I mean same with like KDM and all that these big Campaign games they promise the world right which is then like we
play a little bit like okay it's tapering a little bit but I but I'm having a good time it's like I'm starting to see more of it when and and yeah every time we'd come up and I'd set up I'd be excited to go back into it so it wasn't like let's just [ __ ] do this you know like with like uh with other Campaign games where it's like let's just do this or you know what I don't want to do this anymore uh so I did always want to keep coming back and I'm very excited to see what your decisions are and how that impacts your story because I'm assuming we'll do act two and three together while you're doing act two and three with your other group so it's like making radical decisions um so yeah I mean that you got anything else so where do you think it goes from here what do you what do you think well we're splitting the party and well eventually I guess and was hunting a dragon and then going after hoger that'll be interesting yeah I'm really thinking act2 is a total party split till the very end where it gets back together yeah I'm hoping I want to see some more hm I don't know I don't know if they're even going to be able to do that because it's like you know the more that you make big decisions that are wide wildly disrupt the story the bigger the book has to be right because it's like okay well this this big change happened Okay jump over all this [ __ ] like when we made that call like you jump through 30 pages yeah and of stuff of stuff so means I have to
March through that because I'm going to have to fight him yeah you are God uh yeah I mean and you also look at these which I'm assuming X2 and three will be like connecting the so you have the map and it's like there's so much stuff here that it's like as far as I'm aware succubus publishing wants to make this a lifestyle game their world is so unique like it's not like oh another Fantasy game it's like no it's like a jrpg modern time like their lore is so intriguing so I know they're doing more bounties they hired a bunch of people to write and design like we had the blinded garding Bounty more of those um yeah and then like two and three will kind of resolve the storyline but they said that they want to do more they want to have more to this game yeah so i' imagine it's like a lot of Side Stories like it's like okay in between act one and two here's you know a short mini campaign that takes you to the crater or takes you up into The Witches ziggurat yeah who was to say yeah and I am all for that like the more I can spend in this world the better like I can I can get over the dice and the encounters I just can't binge it like we committed to binge and finish it today but it's like I can't do that eventually the dice really just start pissing me off and I start not liking it but we take a break play a different game or we come back a month later and I'm like I'm good let's play again mhm so I hope that they just continue that acts 2
and three once they're done they're like all right we're done uh and where I think they go from here um yeah I mean yeah I mean it's kind of that it's just more lifestyle stuff like there's a lot of stuff that you're looking here that's like why would they have it here except to just be like as references like they mentioned the Middle Passage it's like oh that's right there I never see it but what's fair Edge what's up in tea where the [ __ ] are the king and queen right on this hunt yeah how irresponsible they're just gone I expected them to show up at one point like when the shadow Lord that would have been [ __ ] badass is the shadow Lord's like you no mortal weapon can kill me and the [ __ ] King shows up with this God blade and just cuts him down it's just like huh huh yeah he's like don't stay away from my dog that's I expected someone to show up right but nope didn't which I get it get them out of the way cuz if they are super powerful it's not about them anymore um yeah I I also enjoyed that it wasn't like it wasn't cringy the the like it it it had curse words but it wasn't like over the top it it had I mean it mentioned padrick and eing were good friends it's like no he's he's blowing that back out like she she doesn't make him work for
it that hard she has a loin cloth covering her uh but yeah so I like that it was kind it was more young adultish MH so uh that was I was I was definitely behind definitely very anime inspired so I want more of that I would I I'm excited to actually see the character designs because if they're going to skip maybe ahead I'd imagine they would give them a different look M so maybe different abilities I really hope it's not just like oh pull out the Ning Gill thing she has the same ability right H I don't know uh more stuff with that so yeah I don't know but I am very excited uh I can't really think of anything else yeah this uh discussion I mean we're obviously going to have different rules because we'll I'll have the rules people like we kind of you knew more about Aras and Rule changes that I did but I'm like I don't have those so we're going to go with what I got so hopefully more balancing better boss fights more reain in like yeah I'm hoping with the release of the two and three and the 1.2 they clean up yes cuz God what was it um another criticism here um I remember I was uh I for I think it was the uh the corpse collector and here's the thing so it's got rules on his card mhm it has tentacle tokens with effects on the back of the tentacle token yeah and then more
extrapolation on the tentacle token's effects in the rule book yeah that I so I have three places I have to check for this yeah for one so for one thing so I was pretty irritated by that yeah no and that's a very valid complaint there's another game key same with the uh I'm interrupting uh the Effigy and his roots oh yes so it's like I mean the roots didn't tell you anything you have to check the rule book and then it's like okay and then I have to check his card yeah no and and I'm hoping they do that they very much need to because there's another game Keith and I are doing called isopar and guard they just uh went on Kickstarter for their second edition and they're succing and combining the rule books because they had like four different locations it's like I just want to know what I do with an honest node oh you have to check this book and then you have to go check this book it's like that's too fiddly to [ __ ] with yeah give me one solid location to look for all my answers so they're doing that they also heard that the game was way too grindy so they came up with a bunch of like all the upgrades in that Edition were ways to make the game still a lot of fun and true to its design but fix the grind like an example is you can upgrade your base basically and like you can actually get Workers to send off to go to the mines to be able to get you resources you need instead of you having to trudge all the way there mine and it's like it's anyway it's a super
grindy game but they came up with ways to make it less grindy but it's still you still need materials it's like that's that's great you didn't just give people what they wanted uh by being like Oh you just can have any resource you want it's like no but you made it way more manageable this game really needs to be if there's an overall theme if I could tell Brooklyn one thing is reain it in godamn dudee reain your game in it would you're not you're not hurting it you're actually making more people want to play it cuz if people are like oh should I play Madara it's like do you have four hours to do one encounter MH no well then no but if you can actually play it and be like I feel like I got a full experience out of it and half the time like a pretty consistent time frame I would see cuz that was wildly different yeah or better yet you don't have to make them all succinct you don't have to make them all short and ply but if you were looking at like I was hoping they this kind of like oh hey we're doing bungled Caper put a time limit like an average time limit when you play test your goddamn game be like bungled Caper average 90 minutes so people can see that and be like okay instead of just being like H well it looks like a small map like okay this looks like okay it's going to be a 4H hour one guys like when you play Mansions of Madness it tells you on average what he so you could look at it instead being like oh it'ses okay that shouldn't be too bad and then you see Aid totem and it's like check the other diagram book
and boom boom boom boom boom thanks for coming over guys see you in two weeks sorry we can't finish it my kid just started crying or you have to go home because you work in the morning mhm it's just you're selling to adults yeah exactly uh so that's that's what I'm really hoping with Acts 2 and three time will tell but overall still had a great time yeah with that being said on a scale of 1 to 10 what would you give Madara act one oh what would I give
Madara let's see I'm in the realm of like I really enjoy these kind of games I'm give it like nine a nine n 9.5 it's it's a good game I enjoy it I have a good time with it I am not that high anymore um I am down to I feel like I rer ranked it actually on Board Game Geek and that was kind of in the midst of oh no I did not rerank it I still have it at a nine it is not a nine uh but I think I'm actually I'll go with an eight like I think kind of whenever I said story and and character design are 10 out of 10 but the actual game mechanics are six if I'm being generous so 10 to six divide by two averages out to an eight and I feel good with that yeah like I am looking forward to Acts 2 and three uh and even if it's more of the same I I mean I'm along for the ride with the story so it's like okay hopefully it's not more the same hopefully they learn uh and who knows I don't know are there R packs coming like for updated cards and stuff do you know I can't remember if they said like they're doing I I'm just assuming it's going to come with two and three I don't
think they're going to bother with another release I I have nothing hard to to base this claim off of but yeah see what was it so it's next year sometime we're getting yeah I think I push back back yeah so I think they're I assume they just wait till then to do their upgrading because they're going to come out with that they're going to need to redo their Darkness tokens they everything several tokens are getting reprinted yeah uh like Darkness isn't as bad I know and then Wilt is getting nerfed or wilt's getting changed and then like almost all these different sasses are getting modified slightly gotcha I me weapons and stuff like the the bone chippers we knew had different dice on so yeah and they're adding the new things to the zbad and they might rebalance a bunch of other [ __ ] yeah it' be cool if they like hey here are the bosses in act one here's their new sheets it's like fantastic yeah I mean they've got a [ __ ] ton on the print and play but that's that's it and I'm I mean I I check the aradas and I read through those but I'm like okay I'm got to print [ __ ] yeah it's like I don't want to do that I'll just wait for the actual stuff but that's it everyone that's our thoughts on Madara unintentional malum Act One let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have one what everytime day this for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the
channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run through or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you