The Lord of the Rings DUEL - Better Than The Original?
Transcript
Emily and I just played the Lord of the Rings duel for Middle Earth wow and we've got some things to share uh but the first thing I want to point out is which of us are a Lord of the Rings fan Emily is not is not I'm the traitor amongst us um I am a fan but not like a crazy fan I mean there's people particularly in the board game hobby there's people who are Uber fan I mean hence that they've made a game and not just this game but many games surrounding Lord of the Rings this one if you're not familiar is Seven Wonders duel sort of reimagined and re-themed but it is not just a retheme with a new skin yes they've definitely put a lot of thought into changing this game and I think mechanically makes a lot of sense with the theme that they've got going on so we'll talk about if you're a fan of uh Lord of the Rings if you'd like this or if you're not a fan but you like seven wonders duel and you were like would I even still like this game even though four of the Rings yeah or or maybe you're somewhere in the middle of that um but just to give you a brief brief overview uh you're going to be there's a network of cards out here you're going to be taking a card from the uh available row if you will uh any face up card that doesn't have a card laying on it and you can take it and play it if you can pay for it with your resources or skills rather in this game or money um or you can discard it for money or in this game there's going to
be these Landmark tiles these are Emily's these are mine there was one left um and you're going to be able to instead of taking a card just build one of these but it is pretty costly it takes a lot of skills to do that but that's what you're doing in the game and you're working up way through that Network three different rounds or eras in Seven Wonders terms in this they are effectively the themes of the books The Fellowship of the Ring kind of like the two towers and then return to the King which as a fan or someone at least somewhat versed in the property that is very cool I'm going to say I didn't watch all three movies I just watched the first two and I fell asleep many times yes oh wow because I wanted to give it more of a chance after the first one I was like what happened nothing happened there's nothing going on in this oh my gosh the comments I can hear the comments coming in now but I never watched a third so as we're playing this game David is telling me more color as to what is happening and I actually think I like the property more now that I've played this than I did after watching way too many hours of my life watching those movies is it because we played this or because of my awesome explanation my flavorful desri no it's not that I don't know if it's that but I was hoping anyway that's what you're doing in this game and it follows that theme but to take that a step further the mechanics and some of the different conditions the wind conditions have been adjusted quite a bit also to capture that theme what what are the wind conditions in this game well I'm going to start with the cool one this is the
one that has the cool component uh it's the one that is extraordinarily thematic and that is this one of us is going to play the forces of Sauron uh they're going to have the NZ goul that are going up this track trying to catch Sam and froto The Fellowship of the Ring the other is The Fellowship of the Ring and you're going to move the bigger piece and you'll see they move along with you to stay the same distance to try to get to Mount Doom if Sam and froto get to Mount Doom Fellowship wins if the NZ goul ever catches Sam and froto they win that's just one of the wind conditions and it is a very cool mechanical and very you know it's got this transparent plastic thing it's a nice touch yeah and even if you don't understand any of the lering terms that David is throwing out here you're basically just trying to catch up to this guy they're trying to catch up to this guy whoever catches our first wins you it feels like you're my interpreter I when you're talking I'm like what is the nas G okay all right that's just one win condition another win condition this is probably more straightforward like science and Seven Wonders duel you've got the races of Middle Earth the green cards all of those represent the different races as soon as someone has six different of the Green Card symbols they will win the game as well they've got the support of everybody so they're good plus just like science but also kind of combined with the pantheon Powers the expansion for Seven Wonders when you collect a pair of the same or three different ones you're able to interact with these tokens by
taking a couple looking at them keeping one those are all really interesting powers that you can have going on some of them are immediate some of them are ongoing uh and they all have a really interesting effect Emily had a couple here that let her take extra turns whenever she did a couple things so like if I got a gold card which is going to give me just coins to use um I get to take an extra turn that's also different from here from Seven Wonders duel is that instead of Tak coins equal to the number of gold cards you have you're just straight up taking the coins on there you can't always discard a card from the rounds to get coins for the round number it is so either one two or three depending on which round you're in yeah and then the other thing to win is this map out here this is kind of well not kind of it's very much like the military aspect of Seven Wonders but in Seven Wonders duel it's just like a tug-of war that's going back and forth this you've got a much more thematic representation of a map where you're putting troops out and building Towers You're Building towers by taking these Landmark tiles almost all of these except for this one here are going to let you put a tower out into a specific area what you're trying to get is presence out here Towers can't be messed with they are there there is a couple with one with a few Exceptions there are a couple exceptions but generally speaking they won't enter conflict the troops however every time they interact with each other in one of those spaces a conflict will happen and effectively that's just very deterministic whittel down until until there's one left yep uh or none left on the other side but as soon as someone
had presence in all of these areas they're going to win yes that's one of the parts that I want to kind of focus on in terms of how it feels very different regardless of the theme but this compared to that tug of war and I've always loved the tug-of War I always love games that have like multiple wi conditions and one or more of them are just a back and forth but I think I like this better because when you look at this at the beginning of the game I have two people here Emily had two people here and you're like okay this feels like it's going to take a while to make any progress but any military card is going to let you add people troops to one of two locations and then later there are cards that let you move them there are some landmarks that let you move them after one simple move of two people all of a sudden you can look at that map and go oh my gosh you're two or three away from winning that and it's a really interesting thing because even if someone looks like they're about to win it you're not out of it like when you look at the tug of war if someone's about to win you are way far away from winning because you have to get it all the way back in this one things can change quite a bit because once people start coming off the map maybe Emily builds a couple landmarks puts a couple Towers now all of a sudden the tides have completely turned and we're both concerned about who's going to win that like like in this example like I have a tower here and you have a guy so we both have presence there and we're not really in active conflict but all I need to do is send one of my guys to this place and then these both are going to go away I still have presence though there though
and you don't so it's very quick to turn the tides between like okay right now I have presents in four spots I need all seven you have presents in five spots I need all seven so you're very close to just getting your last two faces yeah for sure immediately winning and I've seen now i' she's only just played it I've played it a few times now and in just like the three or four times I've played it I've seen a win here which Emily just did to me this came down to it and we built all the landmarks it was a rough win but she got the NZ goul to catch samon Frodo poor samon froto moment of silence um I've seen the map win which I did and then twice against me I've had a a I want to say science but the races of Middle Earth where I was playing with Alicia and she actually had a power that let her go back into the discard pile and she found the one uh race icon that she needed to win it um but it's really really interesting I mean we all love Seven Wonders duel quite a bit it's one of my at least top 20 if not top 10 games for me as a fan of uh Lord of the Rings I do think this this feels like sacrilegious to say but I do think I might prefer to play this one for some of the things I've already mentioned some of the things I like more the theme of course but it's not just the theme I do like a lot of little things they did to to streamline this even though Seven Wonders duel is pretty straightforward and easy there are a couple things that are even easier here
like Emily said earlier when you discard cards you're just getting money equal to the round number that's you could sit down and teach anyone that it's very easy um whereas the other one is makes it a little bit more complicated the biggest thing too is also that you don't have any of that like if I have a resource but my opponent has a resource I pay more or less there's none of that it's always just one coin for any resource you don't have just one coin for any one resource so it's very very straightforward the one thing I would say though against uh seven against this for 7 Wonders duel is that the end condition is always going to be sudden right because it has to be either that you're catching up to something or that you're getting all the presentence um there are no points in this one yes there are no points that's probably we maybe buried the lead there are no points and at least in my games of Seven Wonders duel most of them come down to points come down to points in this one if none of these things have been triggered the by the end of era three you're got to look at this map and whoever has the most presence in on this map wins and that's not each individual piece for example Emily has presence here here here and here right now so she has four to my 1 two 3 four five I would win in that case yes but if it comes down to it and she has four and I have four it's a tie it is which a tie which is an interesting thing which you don't get in seven Wonder stol really yeah you don't really get I mean there must be tiebreaker for the points um but yeah there are no points in this so it does come down to that map um and I would say this too if you're playing this game and you're teaching it to someone who hasn't
played this version of the game I do think there are a few things you want to point out to them about how things progress yeah um for instance the purple cards in this one in seven wonders duel those are a lot of kind of endgame scoring things in a lot of scoring things um in this it represents that battle uh in Return of the King so there's a lot of jockeying for position out here you can take troops from your opponent right off the map steal their money or not steal but get rid of their money and a lot of this movement in the first two eras you're kind of putting people out with the military guards in this era you're moving them around and like I said earlier a couple movements can just go boom I won yes it's very quick there was a moment where you thought you won actually and we forgot that the guys are going to cancel each other out yeah oh man I thought it was literally like one or two cards before you ended up winning I would say if your favorite part of Seven Wonders duel is that part where you got that gotcha moment and then you like suddenly win the game this is better for you and I think you like this game better um that's not my favorite part of it since I already own Seven Wonders duel I probably wouldn't go out and replace it with this that's fair um but if someone asked did I want to play I'd say yes I would on the flip side if you are a fan of Seven Wonders duel and if you're a fan of Lord of the Rings it's a no-brainer for you it's a no-brainer I'm sure you probably already know that if you're fall fall into those two categories but if you're afraid of Lord of the Rings and the people who are very fanatic about it I'm sorry if you're one of them you would still like this game I would say yes it's a it's a really
really good game this ised solid Bones from being built on the shoulders of Seven Wonders Duel not to mention I think this is a little bit more accessible based on the things that we're talking about in terms of the Streamline nature but if you have any questions about it after all of that or tell me why I should like Lord of the Rings oh my gosh you just invited more comments than we've ever had in a video I just don't get it please let her know why she should like Lord of the Rings uh and to be fair it's not for everybody and the movies are long she didn't even watch the extended versions which I too wouldn't recommend like I like the theatrical releas or better if you have any comments or questions about the game we'd love to talk to you about that as well no no no tell her she did like Lord of the Rings anyway whatever you want to say get down in the comments and let us know until next time make sure everyone has front of the table and we'll see you then