Colosseum Review (In Depth) - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to hired or fired the show where I take a closer look at a game to see if it's worthy of a place on your shelf or not today we're looking at Coliseum by Wolfgang Kramer and Marcus Luque the game was originally released in 2007 by Days of Wonder but it was more recently released by pasty minstrel games this is the version I have here Coliseum is for three to five players and plays in around an hour to an hour and a half so the idea of the game is that each player has their own and the theater and they are all trying to put on as best show as possible in order to attract spectators whoever has attracted the most spectators after five rounds will be declared the winner so let's take a look at some of the mechanics involved in Coliseum so the main kind of driving force behind the game is set collection because each show you have to put on you require a number of resources such as gladiators or horses and chariots so the easiest shows which obviously grant you less points than the more difficult shows require less resources and the more difficult shows require a lot more so the main way you're going to gather your cast and crew of your shows is going to be through a series of auctions now I happen to be a big fan of auctions in gaming so naturally I was happy to to find this out but what makes the auctions more interesting in cost Coliseum than a lot of other games is
that you buy things in lots of three so see for example I really wanted some gladiators but the only up there was you know maybe two gladiators and a horse and I know they might not be remotely interested in horses so it's really interesting that you might have to bid on lots that you're not so interested in in order to get the things that you are interested in and then the way to gather resources found to make use of the resources that you gained that you're not so interested in is to trade them in the trading round now there's a specific round designed for this where you have negotiate and trade your goods or money in order to get the things you want and people might get they won now I really like the way that this works in Colosseum but the rules do say that the the trading round is supposed to be kind of resolved in a certain order by one player kind of doing all their trades at once and then the next player doing their trades but personally I would recommend it to kind of scrap that idea and just to give players a complete kind of free forum to do what they want because when everyone's treating at the same times you can really kind of string together a lot of deals so like certain deals might depend on the other deals other people are making and it just makes for a lot more interesting round than what the game actually suggests itself but this is a really cool mechanic in the game and I do really like the way that you can be really creative and come up with some really cool deals I do think it's
important that players do not kind of discuss anything any potential trades outside of the training round because it can really damage the fun of the auction round so that is a bit of an issue because say for example I was really interested in an auction because of a certain tile that somebody else had their eye on that lot as well and I say to them well if you let me have it for dirt cheap I will give you the bit you want that I'm not interested in they're very cheap too so that can really hinder the kind of the way that the auction scale so everybody's kind of paying minimum prices and I think that really damages the fun of the game now I will say it is a very very easy rule book just saying that you can't discuss trades outside of the training around but I'm surprised that the rule book didn't actually have addressed this so that's just a little small thought but I think could be improved in addition to the set collection the auctions and the negotiation there's also some roll and moved involved in Colosseum and this is kind of portrayed through the movement of these Nobles so basically every time someone every round sorry every everybody is doing to roll the dice and move nobles around the board in a clockwise manner now if those Nobles land within your amphitheater then you are granted a certain level of additional spectators but you know any can you move them into arena you you can choose to move them out of other people arenas so not only can you help yourself
you can also hurt others it's also important because you can actually land these Nobles on certain spots on the board which grant you Emperor's medals and these Empress medals are really useful and versatile in your strategy and also for a tactical decisions because they can be traded in for money you can trade them in for and store them back you can stir up a number of them and then trade them in for an additional spectators and you can also use them to further manipulate the nobles because as I said earlier you can normally only move them clockwise around the board but if you spend one of those Emperor's medals you can then you can move them back counter clockwise and move them back into your arena so it's really interesting how those Empress medals are used throughout the game now I guess from kind of on paper those mechanics do seem a bit jarring you know you've got the second action you've got the auction you've got the negotiation and even the rather move but I have to say these do come together very nicely because each phase kind of resource in its own kind of in its own right so basically phase one is like an investment phase where you kind of plan your potential strategies phase two is the auctions phase three is in the negotiation and face four is a kind of rolling move when you and then you count your spectators and then bro phase five is when you kind of do a bit of a cleanup but so it you know they don't do come together very very nicely and because those all those phases are so kind of individualized
the game is actually very very easy to teach you're not kind of overwhelming in the slightest now what interests me most about Colosseum is the fact that you are forced to think long term at least if you want to do well just winning it is going to prove disastrous you really do have to start building towards your final show from the get-go but you can't completely Knick the lek to your current year's show because you need those shows in order to make them money to make the investments and you know also to win the podiums which will grant new permanent spectators so everything is very well balanced in that respect because you know you're forced to think long term but you can't neglect the current and I didn't love that about the game the five rounds or years provide a really tight timeframe in order for you to execute your plan and you know if you make one bad investment or miscalculate your investments then your plan can go completely down the toilet but equally is so rewarding when you're meticulous plan does pay off after each show you put on you have to discard one of the resources that were used in that show and that decision can prove very very difficult because it can completely mess up all your future plans if you get that wrong so even that kind of tiny decision can prove very very significant to your long-term success in the game it's also
really important to consider the risk and reward by putting on those bigger shows because those those shows that offer the most points are really difficult to assemble you know to gather all the different parts you need so sometimes it is better to kind of go for the smaller shows and try and boost up your spectators by um investing in season tickets or you know maybe buying the Emperor's Lodge in order to move more Nobles into arena so it's interesting to know that you can kind of go different routes by you know playing it a bit safe there but going for heavy investments or taking a huge gamble by going for those absolutely enormous shows I also think that good negotiation skills go a long way in Coliseum because if you're good at pulling those strings in order to get what you want you know that can be the difference between winning and losing well not only have you got to try get what you want you've got to be careful not to give other players the towels that they want so you've got to be really kind of on the ball in that respect and you know be careful not to grant there's loads of points even deciding how to move the neighbors can present some really difficult decisions because not only have you got to think about moving Nobles into your arena which will grant you additional spectators but doing so might leave even more powerful Nobles in other people's arenas so you may want to move them out of their arenas so they don't get such a bonus but in addition to moving available in and out of your arenas you have to worry about Emperor's medals
because those medals are so versatile can help a lot during the game you know they can give you additional money for the auction rounds they can they can you know even provide you the ability to make additional investments which is so important because you might you know you may have miscalculated your investment phases and not being able to get the show you want or you might over you might need the extra kick of selling a season ticket so there are so many decisions to make even in just that role of move around calculating your score each round can seem pretty mouthy at first because there are so many different contributing factors that change your score but once you get head around it it's really not too bad and I absolutely love the scoring system in this game because it's not like a cumulative score like and most games you know where your previous round is added to your last round only your best show is going to be it's going to matter in this in this game so you could do really poorly whole game through and then score a massive whopping score in the fifth round and do pretty well so I absolutely love that and I like games that kind of introduce new ways of scoring and I think that makes Coliseum really different it's also really cool to kind of see well the game kind of has a really cool kind of cadence to it because each round you kind of see your spectators slowly creep up or at least if you're playing well so I love that fact about Coliseum let's talk about the balance of course him now personally I
have no issues with this game's balance at all I think everybody has a fair shot of winning and the best player will always win now I guess sometimes the auction round kind of leave a load of towels up there that you're not interested in and then you kind of missed out on a whole turn and you don't really have many options so the luck of the draw can kind of play a factor in that respect especially if nobody wants to trade with you but I do really like the catch-up mechanic in this game because at the end of each round players or the player in the worst position is going to take a tile of their choice from the player in the best position and that really can help the player behind a lot but it forces the player in front and really kind of puts them under pressure because they have to get the towels they want back and it can kind of divert that kind of game plan a bit and I love that and it does seem to balance the game really well in regards to teaching the game to new players I think Coliseum is great because as I said earlier the game is divided into very kind of distinct phases and teaching those phases one at a time is so simple because you know one place is an auction phase one place of negotiation phase one phase you know is a you know where you calculate your score it's very easy to break up the way you teach this game so the mechanics of the game themselves are really simple but the strategy is where the kind of difficulty lies and to me it's important
that a game delivers that newer players will make mistakes of this but it's not because of the rules it's because of their kind of lack of experience in planning the way that the game works and I have to say the rulebook as well is really good with this game so clear and easy to understand so definitely two thumbs up for the rule book so let's talk about where playability so because of the large number of shows the different starting tiles and the different starting shows there is a really good level of replayability with Coliseum also the place themselves add a lot of kind of replayability to the game because the young the negotiation round is such a kind of freeform to do what you want so the different personalities are going to have massive effect on the way that the game plays out so even just by introducing a new player or two you're going to get a completely different dynamic and feel of the game now that being said there is no expansion for this game so I guess after several plays maybe some players will kind of figure out a kind of method that they stick to and then each game can kind of become a bit from your leg but it's never going to be you know a cut and paste kind of game because every time you're going to get different tiles and you're gonna get a different player on top so they're gonna you know have stolen off them etc but it's just something that I kind of speculate about and I can kind of foresee maybe people
following the same game plan every time they play it Colosseum does however really give you that feeling of wanting to beat your previous score and that kind of addictiveness does add a lot their playability and for me is generally a staple of a good game so in that respect Colosseum does a really good job now the level of player interaction in Colosseum is really impressive and I'm personally a huge fan of auctions within board games because the level of interaction that come to light is great not only by trying to outbid them on some knots but even by kind of just bidding in order to run up the prices is always good fun the trading round has infinite potential because you know it really does go as far as the players want to go if you've got those real kind of extroverted characters who want to make really extravagant and complex deals that the game can do that and I absolutely love that maybe kind of more introverted players aren't going to get so involved in that kind of an aspect of the game but that's no fault of the games it does give you the platform to do it that being said as I said earlier I would recommend that you do ignore the rules in respect to one player trading at a time and just let players have a free-for-all because the level of interaction really is heightened and I also like for the most part players they're just trying to hurt themselves and put on his best show as possible so there's no real kind of directive take that or nastiness which
is great coliseum plays out in a relatively succinct amount of time the box says sixty to ninety minutes and in my experience that's a very accurate there's very little downtime involved in the game because for the most part all players are going to be involved in the auctions in the in the negotiation round so this really is a very very little downtime the only thing I would suggest especially if you have particularly stubborn players is to put a time limit on the trading phase because if if people just want to keep going and going and going until they get what they want then the game can have the potential to a drag which is probably why they suggest one player trading at a time but again if you just put a time limit on the round then you know you can stay within the in the time parameter of the game and it definitely won't house say it's welcome so let's talk about the theme of the game so personally I'm a huge fan of the actual concept of the game and I think the mechanics do fit the theme of the game very well because you really do feel like a show organiser under pressure to put on his best show as possible within a restricted time frame and to be that SWAT theme is all about I really like how all the shows to matically makes sense for example legendary line hunters required you to collect lions and gladiators and cages yes Colosseum is essentially a euro game
but to me pretty much everything in the game dramatically makes sense from star performers to to scoring less by putting on repeat shows and even by having to erm discard a tile through wear and tear as you put on the shows and you know even the the Emperor's influencing they never expected to have in your show you know to me everything does tie up pretty well so let's take a look at some of the components here now I have to say overall the component quality is absolutely outstanding so we've got the show tiles here these are really clear for thick cardboard and they just feel really good quality so those are the big shows you've got the the second biggest shows there you've got the wooden pieces such as podiums and emperor's lodges you've got the season tickets here with a nice chunky bits of wood that you can add on to your arena your modular arenas are really cool they look great fit together really nicely again super thick cardboard just everything is such good quality you've got this star performers here they look really cool even that you know you've got the first player marker everything's so somatically well done even the dyes have Roman numerals on them you've got the nobles here which are really nice and he got a number of different stickers as well so if you want them to look different but I like like this you know good thick wood components you've got the emperor's our
emperor's metals here which again they look great nice thick cardboard again even the score markers are Roman podiums wooden pieces just look really good just look the part but most impressively is the actual money in this game the money is metal proper thick decent quality meso and it's just unbelievable quality the level of detail they've gone in and the effort they've put in to make all these components top-quality I did mention this bag as well that holds all the all the resource tiles so the tiles again are really thick and you get this amazing silk bag which again it just feels amazing quality and looks fantastic and finally let's take a look at the board itself so it's super big whilst it's super big it's not overly big but it's a really good size ultra thick cardboard again probably the thickest board I've ever seen everything fits together really nicely so you got the noble track that goes around the side here where everybody's amphitheaters are you got the central section where you keep all the art auction tiles where your bid on the different Lots I just I just really like the look of this board it kind of has this really cool cartoony look to it which I hurts some people criticize because they preferred the days of wander version but I personally think this one is just as good I really love the look of it really
clear really good look in bright colors and I actually can't fault this at all so overall Colosseum is a very fun game and really easy to learn and teach but still offers a ton of strategy interaction and amazing components in a very succinct amount of time if you enjoy auctions and negotiation but still want a solid game to go alongside that then classier really is the game for you Colosseum is not only family-friendly but it's also gave a friendly and it's a game that has so much to offer across the board not only does it look fantastic but it also is a great game through these reasons I highly recommend Colosseum it really is that good so I really hope you've enjoyed this video and it's been of use to you if it has please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos for everyone else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye