Skip to main content
Loading video...

Let's Play Excalibur - Mind Games with 2 Players!

Transcript 24:55

Ryan and I are going to play today Excalibur. Excalibur, if you're familiar with the game, you might be thinking to yourself, "Wait a minute, isn't that for more players?" Well, it plays from two to eight players. Uh, and truth be told, it is, I think, meant for larger groups. It's going to have a slightly different experience, but from what I've heard from the game designer, his two children, they love playing it head-to-head, which is what we're going to do today. Yeah. I mean, this is a deduction game. So, anytime you've got a deduction game like Excalibur, the experience is so different at higher player counts versus one to one. And to be honest, it's almost like a different experience of the game because when you're playing with so many different players, it is really very difficult to track what everyone's doing, what everyone's got in their little secret piles. But one to one, it's much more about outwitting the person sitting across from you. Yeah, it's definitely it feels a little bit more like a shell game with one other player. You're really just looking for your opportunities to sort of like trip them up with a lot of the powers that you're going to be implementing. Uh just to give you a brief explanation. You see the game here set up. It's very simple.

By the way, amazing production. If you haven't seen that, check out our other video. Metal Swords. This is the high-end version of the game, but all versions are really cool. I don't know. This might be one of the coolest board game components I've ever seen. We're But we're here to play the game. I know, but I want to be like King Arthur and use Excalibur. That's been my dream since I was a child. Well, maybe you will because the object of the game is to at the end of the game be holding Excalibur, but not beholding the cursed sword. I have them both here in my hands. We don't know which is which right now. I have shuffled them up. One of us is going to get the cursed sword. One of us is going to get Excalibur. at the end of the game, which is going to be triggered when any one of these three areas of Avalon are emptied. Uh, in higher player counts, you'll empty two of them, but in two players or even the lower player counts, it's just one. Once one of those is empty, that's going to be the final round of the game. And at the end of that round, if you're holding Excalibur and only Excalibur without the cursed sword, you win. If you're holding Excalibur, but you also have the cursed sword, everyone else at the table will win and you are the only loser. If by some chance at the end of the game, you're just holding the cursed sword, whether Excalibur is held by someone else or it's still an Avalon, you are proclaimed the ultimate loser. Uh, and everyone has a horrible loss if no one has Excalibur at the end of the game.

And the cursed sword is also not help. And for those who don't know, the curse sword is the sword that was used to stab King Arthur. That's, by the way, came from Ryan here is the resident King Arthur lore, Arththeran legend. I'm just I honestly like I'm going to try not to geek out too much during the course of this video, but I I love the attention to detail. This obviously came from a place of respect uh to that lore. Like even the swords that we've got here, there are three. They're they're real swords from the Gallantine. That's that's Gowen's sword and Lancelot's sword over here and then obviously King Arthur's Excalibur. So just the idea that they've that they've done that and you can kind of see uh mixed into all these chips just like any kind of social deduction game there's different effects that are going to be carried out. Some of these are just like generic towns people. You might have the merchant, the priest, still very powerful, but then there's one of each of like the main characters like people that you'd actually see like there's a Lancelot token and a Gwen and they have significant powers. They have very cool powers. So, I I I really like that that addition to the game. Yeah, you'll see all of that as we play, which we'll get to right now. We've got to decide who's going to be first player. I'm going to say because you're such an expert on the law. I don't a fan. You have the crown right now. Um, and that's just going to bounce back and forth. I'm going to give you also a choice. Which chip do you want? Oh, no. Oh, this one. Take it.

Would you? Oh, but you offered this one a little closer to me. That's okay. I'm not going to tell you what. And just so you know, since we're playing at two players, we'll tell you, but you wouldn't normally because with more players, they could be anywhere. But I have the curse sword. He has Excalibur. I love it. In a two-player game, you know this information going in. And that's a huge already from the start of the game a significant difference because I said scabber down here, but at the start of the game, we're gonna draw three more tiles from outside of Avalon and mix them in. So when David said that there's a shell game aspect, he wasn't literally he wasn't being metaphorical. I'm literally going to draw three and I'm going to mix these all together and hope that David does not know. I'm going to draw one from each. Which one of these? Oh, cool. I want to take a look at mine first. I'm not supposed to move these. Well, at the start of the game, I'll move these so they're all on camera. Yeah, but like but once they're once we start looking at these, they don't change. Yeah, because you could place one back in a specific spot and if everyone's looking, they'll remember that you placed something there. What it is is another thing. Now, these these tokens I'm not going to tell. Okay. All right. All right. I'm ready. So, every round is going to happen like this.

We're going to put our fist in the table with one of our chips. It can't be the curse sword. It can't be Excalibur, but any one of the other chips that you have. I'm waiting for Ryan. I know. I'm I'm thinking about it. And then you reveal at the same time. I've got the peasant. I've got the priest. All right. So, in turn order, the person is going to activate their chips. So, you're going to activate the priest, which does what? Lets me draw two chips. And I can draw them from anywhere outside of Avalon. Now, if I were to draw one of the swords, I say huzzah. So, everyone knows. But the swords are safe right now, and I'm not going to draw one. You just want two chips? I just want two chips. I I want to get some better chips in my hand. And these were good. These were good. I'm happy with that. And then out of the game. Back to the box. We're just going to set five priest. So now we know there's only four left. I have the peasant. Uh the peasant allows me to either draw or steal one chip and then I return it. I am going to steal a chip from you. I'm going to give these a good mix. Now your your personal supply. You can mix up as much as you want. I'm going to change their directions and we'll see what you do here. All right, I'm gonna take this one.

Interesting. Let me see the expression on your face. And again, that's another big change from two like in in a multiplayer game, no one knows what you took, right? But in this game, I know what you took. If I remember what's in front of you. Well, even in a higher player count game, you'll still know what to I will, but but not everyone. But so that was interesting. So now the crown comes to me and we just do the same thing. That was a round of Excalibur. And normally we would draw back up to four, but we both ended with four there. The beginning of each round, everyone who has less than four draws back up to four. If you have more than four, we believe you can keep those. But, uh, let's see. What do I What do I want to give and not give? I'm going to do this one. We don't know all of the roles by heart, so you'll have to bear with us.

Merchant. Perl. Perl. Yeah. PL found the Holy Grail. What's Perl do? Percal uh lets me flip four chips face up and then I get to choose one of them and then flip the others face down. You have the crown. So you're going I have the crown. So I'm going to go first. I'm going to use the merchant. The merchant lets me draw or steal two then return one. Do you want to mix them up? No matter. I don't care. I'm changing it up and I'm going here. I don't even know what they were. I do. Okay. Well, now you do. And then when you return, I can return from my hand. So it doesn't have to be one of those two chips. That's true. And I know you've got the curse sword in there. You could just give it to me and hope that I'm stuck with it for the rest of the game. It's possible. I mean, it's it's possible. It's probable. You don't want the curse sword, but I'd be happy with you keeping the cursed sword.

Interesting decision. He did not give me the cursed sword. I like spoiler alert. You know what? I like that in a two-player game, we can talk out loud because you already know. It is interesting. It is interesting. This not so great in a in a two-player game. This This one I'm not going to use it. It lets you look at your opponent's hand, which is okay. But I already kind of have a good idea of what's in your hand. Yeah, but it can come into play later, like towards the end of the game. It might be good to know what the other player has. All right, Pival is going to flip four up in Avalon. And I take one. So, let's flip up one. merchant is available. I've got a peasant. I can choose a thief. Thief could be pretty good. Thief's not bad. Another merchant. I think I'm I really actually like the merchant. The ability to steal two from your opponent. The merchant is just basically a better peasant. It's a And then these flip over where they You mean the merchant is what a peasant would be if they made something out of their Exactly. Just try. You're going to go the crown's going back to That's what's stopping the peasants from success. They're just not trying.

Exactly. Don't try to cancel me here on this video. Peasants, you be peasants. All right. Pretty good. Pretty pretty good. Oh, I need to take I like what I just got. In fact, I'm going to use it right now. I need to take a look at one. I like this one. And I'm going to I'm going to use it to hopefully I to some great effect. Oh, I have the crown, too. Morgana. Another character. What's Morana? Uh, draw two, then play any one of them. And I think I think I'm going to draw this one. Okay. And this one. Um, and I'm going to play one of them immediately. I'm going to play the thief. Steal from up to two different players. We only have one player, so I'm going to steal from you directly.

I got a one in three shot here of getting that Excalibur back. Did I? You might have. I think you did. I mean, you know, I don't have it anymore. So, you must have. I must have. You must have. Now, we're playing mind games with you. I know. Try to follow. Is it over to me? It is over to you. The Baroness. Draw two chips, then trash one from your hand to the box. You cannot trash Excalibur or the cursed sword. Oh, that's uh Did you use the the Oh, you're putting them over there. I'm I put my discard pile over here. That's just fine. We can look at that at any time if you need to know if a specific character is out of the game. Um, Baroness, draw two chips. I'm going to draw from here. Okay.

And then what she do? Trash one just Yeah, I get to know what it is. Um, you get to know what it is. Oh, yeah. I'm trashing a peasant. Nice. You trashed on. No offense to the peasants. No offense now. That's twice. I'm a bit of a peasant myself. Um, so that's that round. So you I get to draw one cuz you're short one. I'm going to draw from here cuz I kind of want to get the game going. What I get? Oh, okay. Okay. Okay. I'm gonna do this. I'm gonna do this. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's a triedand- trueue merchant. I've got the artisan. Oo. Draw two or steal two, then return any two into Avalon. Interesting.

And when you return to Avalon, you can return them to any one of these three areas. So, along with my strategy, I'm going to take these two. Oh, hold on a second. Does that change things? Uh, well, no. I just need to do some thinking here all of a sudden cuz sometimes you pull something you're like, "Oh, it's one of those." Sometimes you pull something else. Um, okay. Um, and I know what I'm hunting for. I like the character. I'll take him, too. And then what do I have to do? Then you have to add two back to Avalon. Oh, just two. Any two back to Avalon. Oh, boy.

I will add these two back to Avalon. Okay, I am going to play the merchant. Draw or steal two, then return one. I'm actually going to steal two from you, David, cuz two from me. Yeah, it seems like you like what you drew there a little bit too much. Little little little uh What did I get? A thing. Okay, he got things. And I got to give one thing back. You just give one of those things back if you want. You can have that back. You did give me one back. I gave it right back, but not one of the ones I just gave. And then the merchant is gone. All right. And I still have five. I'm still not drawing from the Oh, I'm drawing. Uh, I'm going to draw. Going to keep the game going. Keep it Keep it speeding along. Trying to draw from the same area. Okay. I don't like that. Or that. Or that. Or that or that.

I actually don't love my tiles. Okay, I'm going to do what I have to do. Am I first player this time? I have the crown. The spirit all at once. Everybody steals one in one direction. So, we we're going to steal one from each other and you go first. So, we're going to do that at the same time. That's a risky move. Sim Well, I if I had more options, I would have chosen a different option.

Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. All right. My turn. It is. I'm going to use my merchant to steal two. Yep. Uh I can do that right from you. Draw two or steal two and return one of them. We're stealing two from you. All right. This is where I get This is the mix. Huh? All right. What did you steal? Oh, what are you giving back to me? I could have seen that coming. I He stole something. He stole the cursed blade and gave it right back to me. So, I'm stuck with this cursed blade, but I get to draw one from the middle.

Okay. Well, I'm doing this for a reason. It's going to make sense when I explain it. Oh, you get the crown back. I have the crown. Yeah, you'll have the crown here. Uh, all right. King Arthur and I revealed Galahad. And Galahad, just so you know, I need to jump in and say this. Galahad says, "On reveal, close your fist on one ship in your hand. It is protected from all effects this round." Well, so Arthur says, "Each sword in hand. Each sword is held out and I steal one of the swords."

So I played at Arthur just to get him out of the game, but also if you had stolen it, I would steal it back. So we each have to put one sword out in our hands. The fact that you don't have a sword should be concerning to everybody. I put I'm going to steal my own. Okay, good. I stole my own, which you knew I had. Uh, but that gets King Arthur out of the game. I didn't want to risk a situation where later you could use it to steal back from me. Plus, I don't love what I've got here. Let me tell you, having both swords in your little pile clogging up two of your slots, it's not a great feeling. Yeah. Well, it's I need to get rid of one of these. It's It's on you. I'm going to draw from here. You're drawing from the Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Well, well, all right. Um, all right. Ready? One, two, three. Boom.

Merlin the Great. Again, I I don't want to play this other one, so I have to I'm stuck playing the one I drew. It's Merlin. Sword bears must shout, "I shall be king." So, I'm a sword bear. I shall be king. Oh, yeah. That was with conviction. I liked it. That's all. So, I know you have a sword. Although we know we knew that he had a sword. I have the thief. Steal one from up to two different players. Thief also a little better in a multiplayer game because you can steal. Here we go. Shell game again. You know I've got both blades. Which one are you going to get? Excalibur. Nope. No, you did not. Nope. I don't necessarily want the game to end right now. I'm Oh, man.

I don't want Yeah, you probably want to prolong things. I I literally have both s you need to draw things to get rid of. I do. And I like I like that in two-player game we have all this information. It just makes it feel We've played it more players. It just feels so different playing at two. Yeah, we just played it just prior to this with my son Spencer at three players and it does feel quite different even at three and I've played it I think at six uh which you can check out on Roxley's uh YouTube channel. It was kind of a crazy game, but check that out. Are you ready? I'm ready. And I have the crown. Uh, yeah. All right. Yeah.

What you got? Peasant. Draw or steal one, then return one. And I've got a spirit. So, I go first. I've got spirit. How about you? Yes, I do. I'm going to draw or steal one and then return one. So, I'm gonna draw one from you. I'm gonna draw this one. Man, we've been pass. And I'm gonna return one to you. Gee, I wonder I wonder what it's going to be. Okay, now it's it's my spirit's turn. Per pick left or right. All players simultaneously steal one chip. So, I'm I'm going to give these a really good shuffle. A little under the table shuffle. Oh, a little little under the sleeve shuffle. Is that what you mean? Yeah. I'm putting all cursed swords in here. I've got I've got eight copies of the game and I'm just holding cursed swords. All right.

What? Okay. Interesting situation here. My turn. How many you got to draw up? Oh, yeah. I got to draw up. So do you. Oh, we could make this close to the end of the game here. H

uh I got to think this through. And I have I have the crown. Yeah, you No, you have the crown. I think I have the crown. All right. Who What did you play last? I played second. Yeah, you went second. Um I'm nervous. I'm I'm I am I am feeling the anxiety here.

It's one thing when you know that anybody at the table can mess with your plans, but they might not. They might mess with each other. And in a two-player game, knowing that anything David does is ultimately just going to hurt me. This will be a unique play here. This is for me, too. Spy. Merchant. Merchant. Interesting. So, the spy goes first. Now, here's the interesting thing about a spy. Not a great pull in a two-player game. I get to look at his entire hand. So, I'll just show it to you. Now, so do you see why I haven't wanted to play the spirit? I've been holding on to that spirit because it makes every player steal. Here's what he has. Now, in a multiplayer game, just so you know, not that this means anything in a two-player game, I would now say one truth and one lie about what I'm seeing here, which again can inject a lot of interesting you know, but faulty information to the table in a larger player. You know, it's true. Give me a truth and a lie. He's got Excalibur. That That's a truth. He doesn't have Excalibur. Oh, wow. That feels like blueprints. Like I'm looking at those boxes again trying to figure out the truth and the lie. All right.

So, Oh, that was me and now it's you. This is not going to be great for you. The merchant. The merchant. Draw or steal two and return one. I'm going to steal this one. Oh, that is bad. I didn't think it through. Steal this one. I didn't think it through. And that will trigger the end of the game. Yeah. So, as soon as it's as soon as one is empty, it the crown goes to the center and then you finish that round. They have to return one. Oh, wow. What a piece to Avalon. I should have played this. I should have played this. This would have been the better play. What was the better play? What would you have played? Well, I had Uther. Oh, so Uther is anyone who has Excalibur must give it to another player of their choice. That would have also you would have lost that way too. Would I? Because I would have used the merchant to steal two from you and I would have given you the cursed sword cuz the merchant let you draw two and then replace one. So wherever you draw or steal from uh cuz the merchant can uh steal from another player. So if you had to return back to giving you the cursed player even if you didn't get Excalibur back, right, you could stick me with the cursed then you'd have both of them. So me getting that me having that merchant I think when it gets down and that is the danger of pushing to the end like that because when it gets down to you you give another player control like even if there had been two chips if I play the merchant I can end the game earlier than you think like you think you have another turn you're not going to have another and if you want to see a different experience like I said earlier when I played with six players I think

it was six or seven um we all just kept wanting the game to go on so we actually emptied a lot of it's a lot different Because you think, yeah, in a two-player game, if you're holding Excalibur, you're like, come on, let's get the game to end. Like, I want it to end now while I still have Excalibur in my hand. Whereas, in a six-player game, you want to extend it because that increases the chances of you getting Excalibur, unless you're the one guy out of six. But, I think in a six player game, two spots have to be empty. Yeah, two spots have necessarily take a little bit longer. Um, but it does get down to it eventually, right? Like when there's two spots almost empty, one spot will empty and then it's down to one that it's getting empty. The other thing is interesting is when you have Excalibur, you think, "Oh, I do want it to end." But in a higher player count game, one round around the table, anything can happen. True. Like, three people play merchants and they everyone knows you have Excalibur. They are coming at you.

You're losing it. Hunting for Excalibur. So, you got to get pretty crafty about how you want to play things out and protect yourselves. For instance, player order, right? Like so if you have Excalibur, you might want to try to win when you're last. Well, that's and that's why I was able to do that because if you if I had been first that time Yeah. You'd have been and then you Oh, then I would have won just straight up, right? Well, potentially if if you had played a card that stole Excalibur from But you know that, too. So, I get to see that you'll have that. So, being able to having everyone reveal and then you taking your action in a two-player game, it's huge. But the real like the main reason we wanted to do this I think a lot of these games can't even really be played it to yeah usually usually they they just like they suffer at two and I I don't know I'm not going to say give you an opinion you can make your own opinion from watching us play. It is a different feeling game. Go watch some of the six player footage. I think you're in one of those six player videos. Yeah.

Yeah. It's it's it's a very it's it's definitely a game geared more for I'd say and like I said it goes up to eight but I would say anything from four to eight and the more the marrier. Now, when you get up to eight players, it's certainly a more chaotic game. And this is, it should be said, this is not a heavy, thinky, euroy type of game. This is a light-hearted mind game, sort of like, do I have this? Is the poison in front of you or is the poison in front of me? And the more people you have at the table, they can like lean into that and start messing with each other's minds. And there's also uh chips that you didn't see roles that kind of a whole bunch of characters did not come up. Yeah. they inject more information into the table and like I said even the spy you can inject some faulty information you can start doing things just like saying like oh I have both swords even if you don't right like you just start playing mind games at the table but that is Excalibur at two players if you have any questions at all about it or if you have any thoughts on the game yourself please make them in the comments below we'll get down there and answer whatever we can until next time make sure everyone has fun at the table and we'll see you

Progress saved