Onitama: Light and Shadow - Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and zach and i are doing a no run through review for onitama light and shadow uh this is the newest expansion to onitama and i gotta say it is a great expansion like it the other one way the spirit was it it exists it was made it got it got them money uh but this one i feel like they put a lot of actual effort into it to change up the game drastically um i guess wait wait the spirit or whatever it was called is was like a a mini expansion sure but this one is actually like a full-fledged expansion that comes with two modes and ninjas uh and yeah both of them play radically different um no new cards uh to to the game but yeah they have way the shadow and way of the light uh so let's talk about way of the shadow first which is the more symmetrical one or one both sides have these cool screens i was gonna say these cool tatami mats but that's not what they are uh so both players have have these screens that hide uh a miniature neoprene mat of the of the main board and both of them have a ninja that uh secretly moves uh on this mat taking out uh pieces of your opponents um and potentially their
master uh what's fantastic about that is the fact that when you use a card to move your pawn and master you can then choose to move your ninja in a different way than you use yeah yeah i uh i really like this mode um i feel like it both players have equal options and and equal knowledge i guess uh would be in a game that's onitama where everything is open knowledge yeah this does throw a wrench in things because it's not open knowledge which some people actually might not like like imagine if you were playing chess and some people had secret like something secret and you're like i don't have any of that like uh but um and because you don't have to move your ninja it uh like it definitely throws a wrench into things right this is really honestly actually now that i think about it yeah it drastically changes the game yeah it's a different game it has a different game it's now i'm thinking about it actually it does kind of it can easily make it equally frustrating because i know everything that you can do at any given time in any any game of only tama i can theoretically know okay you most likely moved your ninja but i don't know that so i can't i can't use my cards to try and capture him right hmm i'll say that if you
want a more a little bit less abstract game and more puzzling out your opponent style game so to me it's less chess it's more poker i guess yeah um is what the shadow brings honestly um because we played i didn't move my ninja every single time yeah it didn't seem optimal to move him every single time um but i and i did yeah yeah every time i moved him i'll say for me at least and it should be hard but thinking about moving the pawn with the card and then thinking about the ninja as a completely separate unit that can move a different way as the card from my brain just trying to think those two parallel lines of strategy was hard yeah with the shadow yeah no that's fair the um well the only limit to your ninja is you can't move it into a spot with your you can't move upon into the spot with it because it's it's theoretically if it's in the middle it's as if it's in the middle on the board right um and so if you're if your pawn is there you're blocking it if your opponent moves into there and your pawn and your ninja's there it gets taken uh but the fact is it i feel like yeah in the way the shadow it is kind of like you're hedging your bets and you're like okay i guess i'll move here and hope there are ninjas there you can probably do like 50 50 he may he might be there he might not based off the cards that you played and you start with two less pawns yes
you do which which opens up the i feel like actually opens up the board for a lot to the point where trying to figure out where everybody's ninja starts becoming semi difficult because there aren't enough pieces to basically either be taken or get in the way of someone's trying to move through them yeah exactly and i mean you can the ninja can take pawns and but you're only ever going to do that if you can look at your opponent's two cards and be like okay there's no way he can take my ninja right so it's a free pawn grab even then you give them information of where that ninja is and then they can start deducing again now it's another start point of deducing where that is going to be yeah because they can now see all the cards you have and can figure out well your ninja can only move if you use four that ninja possibly can only move to those three locations yeah or not move with all and then right but that with the ninja it means you have to essentially memorize the cards that you played in sequence yes and just imagine like since you don't have to move it it's like okay i played four cards no one's gonna think he didn't move it at all or he moved it four times but then it's just uh yeah actually funny enough now that now that we're discussing a little bit more i don't know if i do like it i think it's neat i think it's a cool concept and it definitely changes onitama completely yes but does it change what onitama is so great about the reason i give it a 10 out of 10 for abstract games it does yeah i would agree it changed it
so and again it's an expansion so it's going to be cheaper so if you want to essence a different game that follows a lot of the same rules you'll want to learn tons of new rules it's not bad expansion probably no it's not i mean uh specialize you're not playing hotline yeah yeah if you yeah if you really love only tama for what it is um chest replacement is that what it was for me the light and shadow expansion it's gonna be rough it is it is not that you do get two lanterns that are essentially one time use each that allow you to illuminate a column um uh or row and that tells but you can only do it at the end of your turn which allows you to at least have a guesstimate yeah because it's kind of like it revealing the ninja it's like okay i know your one ninja is there uh okay what car did you play okay that's probably where he is which i will say and i kind of figured it out is rows are more important than columns when illuminating because you can get like if you went all four times you had ability to move forward four times i can at least figure out are you in two of the four rows yeah that you could possibly have been in yeah that's true well see i would say the lanterns i think it depends on the cards that we happen to have because if you have a lot of vertical forward movement or a lot of horizontal movement that's when called knowing columns is good yep um so the lanterns are neat but i i
personally don't find them useful um in this because it's like oh cool i know where your ninja's at anyway go so now you moved him or didn't move him and i could because you want to essentially try and remove their ninja so then you're trying to chase them and you don't win if you kill their ninja so you're trying to chase them with your pawns and then it's like okay well now i'm just wasting my time yep um now on the reverse side um i mean it does definitely change the game so if you want a game that's a little bit more i want to get in the head of my opponent more than only towel is the only time i don't have to think about what my opponent's going to play really yes you look at the cards they have two options you can kind of deduce what's the most practical one with the shadow portion of this expansion you actually gotta think about okay is this guy bold enough that he's just gonna rush with the ninja is he you know stealthy that he's gonna take some time and work it around to try to get to just the premium spot or is he like more like me where i'm going to set right here in the middle you have four different options to take it but if it doesn't get taken i pick your king yeah and it's just gutsy move now yeah which is interesting because i didn't play it that way and i won in this mode was because i i basically i did look at your options yeah so i did the opposite of the way you were playing and i'm like okay i'm gonna i'm gonna move my ninja
up and you knew where he was but i also knew at that point you can't do anything about that that wasn't anything to do so i'm like so it's interesting so you can play the play the uh way the shadow in two different ways and it works i feel like your way works better for the other mode yeah the light this one because you can you manipulate your ninja just like you do a normal pawn uh it is kind of like thinking of what options your opponent has similar to chess like okay here's what he can do can i counteract that here's the card that he's gonna get can i counteract that with what i have can i position to where he doesn't doesn't matter what he has um with my ninja and then i just take his master um yeah it's it's really weird it's a weird expansion uh like at first whenever we were talking it like talking i'm like yeah this is good then the more ass i was like but is it like at what point does an expansion change the base game too much that it's a whole nother game and is that a good thing yeah like i guess it could be a good or a bad thing yeah it's just up to the person i think yeah so the the way the shadow is i feel like i feel like it's more balanced just because it's the same that your opponent can do um it's more similar to onitama than the other version so way the light is the second mode you can play or only one person has two ninjas uh and that's it and the other person has his his
full repertoire of um students and master and the the light player can win by getting his master onto it or by um killing both ninjas uh i personally don't like that mode um i don't want to sit here and guess even though in that mode you do have to move ninjas the fact that you have two makes it very very difficult because it's not like i can be like because they're both hidden i think that's the problem is since they're both hidden my lanterns effectively don't help me right um i think i can be like oh are you in this row or column yes okay that's it it doesn't tell me like how many like maybe if you had to tell me how many there were that would help it's for me with oni thomas specifically taking an open information game and being a head-to-head of strategy and then making it where one player has all the information and one player has none uh or very very minimal i don't i don't personally like that i don't know i mean i don't know if it's i can't necessarily say it's unbalanced i feel like it is um and if it's not then it's it it's not necessarily that fun and i didn't like it on both sides like i didn't like being the person hiding and i didn't like being the person that wasn't hiding so i didn't feel like it was unbalanced on either side i could see that
um the way the person playing the lights with just the master and everything i think there's a straight path more forward for that person than the person with a ninja yeah because again like you said because you have two ninjas um everything you do is masked yes if one of my ninjas is tired to get a little bit of a tricky spot i'm gonna move the other ninja and kyle hold because i know we can't take it right now and if he moves out of the way it opens me back up so i have in essence a stall to get out of the way that is true um i did find kai differently i didn't want to take any of your pieces if i was in the shot like if i was the ninja person i don't want to take pieces that's too much information yeah that's true there's no reason for you to no except for the off chance that i memorized the cards that you were playing and then just move because there i feel like they try to balance it out two ninjas but i have all my pieces and numbers should just jump across but because you can see everything and i just have to kind of guess like you could be here and play something but i don't necessarily know that you're there because you could have kept one piece not moved and moved the other one so you're moving all of the cards you're moving one over here just going back and forth and slowly inching one person over and that was like when i played the life and you were the ninja i kind of got lucky and killed the first ninja early but then i kind of knew where you were and i even
said like i think you're right here and you were close you're a space or two away but i wasn't exact and i was watching and memorizing exactly what cards you were playing right and knew that's the sequence and this is the most logical ones that he was going to be i mean because that's the thing is like the other the opposing player wins uh by killing two ninjas or um landing his master there's nothing stopping you from having both ninjas and just going in circles around the throne and then it's like because you think i'm moving up trying to attack your master and then whenever you advance and then you move it's like okay now i'm going to kill him it crossed my mind but yeah you just do that yeah and that's not that's not in the spirit of the game right i mean because in regular onitama you win once again by killing the master or by taking their throne so if you're if you as one player is not moving your master then you're essentially saying i'm trying to kill your master yeah uh but in the way of the light variant the ninjas win by killing that and it feels it's way easier to do that than the other player is to guess where you're at and kill both your ninjas yep so then you just puppy guard the arch or the throne or whatever it's supposed to be and then like if you move here it's like okay good i have crab now i'm just gonna kill him right and it's like i thought you were all the way up here it's like nah and maybe it'd be more balanced if the light player like with the pieces had four lanterns yeah but they kept it they kept it the same i would say
yeah yeah or or honestly even if you could in essence i have the lynch just that you could keep using them you get one per term yeah i don't know that so that would be overpowered honestly probably not because in my mind it's like even if i use a lantern i'm like okay are you in this row i have a chance of moving you have a chance of moving that's the other thing but the other part is let's say both of your ninjas are there you just have to say yes yeah it's like okay well it's been seven cards since you know since you because sorry the game are both of them there yeah um i just feel like in this variant there's there's a lot of there's a lot of ways it could have been improved to make it more balanced uh because imagine like if you were playing any hidden movement game and there were two draculas or two in there because that's essentially what it is kind of it is a hidden movement game so you have two draculas two jack the rippers two whatever and you couldn't discern you know where either them like which one was which yeah um so you have we have an expansion that like if i were to play it but that's the other thing is i don't think i would play this expansion over regular onitama like i i think the way of the shadow is the better of the two i don't know which which one you like better um i probably actually like the way the
lights but it's probably how my brain shorts um but which is interesting that you do like the way the light better because um because of the way like with um mind management like i don't think i don't think you liked it whenever you played it with with zach right i wanted to play again because we only got through half a game and i don't think i understood the rules how to like how people searched and stuff gotcha i gotcha and so it's one of those games where i don't know that i want to say i like their dislikes because i do like hand movement games right um but hidden movement games are definitely i remember seeing someone say like it was a post on like the board game group and it was like um are hidden movement games fun and someone comment they're like i feel it's more fun for the person hiding and i'm like that is that might actually be true i definitely enjoy being the hidden one versus if you don't like working cooperatively with people then you want to be the hidden one if you like what i call that group decision making which i work with those type of people you don't want to be the hider you want to be the one that's like oh but if this is the map no i mean i i definitely get that i love cooperative games my top 10 games were i think almost all of them were cooperative yeah uh i feel like i like being the person with all the information and most hidden
movement games for uh like probably the beginning portion is shooting in the dark until you finally get something and then it's like okay now we can start going going down the path but yeah the way the light or way the get away the light was one person i so between in that mode i liked being the ninjas obviously because i had all the information yep but yeah so you have you have an expansion of light and shadow that both modes drastically change where only atomic tour it's not only tama anymore right uh and for me one is better than the other because one is is is it's it's fair on both sides both sides don't have perfect information and it's closer to onitama than the other mode right so that's kind of that's kind of where i'm at on the on the light and shadow definitely a lot better than the spirit one which was such a nothing expansion yep so um yeah that's weird that's so weird because i remember reading this and i'm like oh that's so cool and then it's very rare that expansion makes me go no i don't think i i need this but i do say it is a cool concept it is a cool concept yeah it just takes a time away from what it is which again oh italian was such a clean game yeah i don't think you could add anything to it that won't muddy it a bit no besides just different cards different cards which they already did
yeah like that's that's in and of itself that's just like all right we're playing chess i have this special piece that exactly that you don't get because of this weird mode exactly yeah it's interesting so i guess i guess kind of whenever what i'm coming down to is both expansions for any tama you don't need i would like i can't imagine anyone's playing only tama and they're like you know what this needs a hidden movement element you know what this means ninjas well it might mean ninjas but it might for them yeah but even then no it's about like martial arts it's like it's a master and student and like like like schools yeah like what they did and then it's like oh by the way now there's a ninja um i guess kind of with way of the spirit if you're bored out of your mind with regular onitama then definitely get this one over way away the spirit um it is superior it flips it way on its head um and there's a completely different way of thinking maybe if people don't like the head-to-head like uh planning four moves ahead like like what chess or only thomas does regular where it's like okay this is everything that we can do now it basically comes down to skill right uh on who can map out the the correct modes um or counter what your opponent can do with these same cards uh if you don't think like that and you don't like thinking like that then definitely grab light and shadow because
it changes the game drastically it does to where it might maybe it levels the player playing field that way um i don't know i don't know that would be interesting to know yeah uh you got anything else online shadow no uh okay so on the scale of one to ten what would you give light and shadow probably 6.5 yeah just thinking it feels about right gave only 8.5 and the way of the spirit was a 5. it's better than way of the spirit but it doesn't improve only power no in fact it actually if if the light and shadow was how onitama was played it wouldn't be a 10. yeah like the only time it's a 10 playing with light and shadow would lower that but that's not fair to the base game uh yeah it doesn't improve it for me either six and a half feels that feels pretty good yeah i seven feels too high so it feels too my six does feel a little too low right because i appreciate the hidden movement and i like that in those types of games but i i don't like it in my abs abstract strategy games i guess right it's kind of like uh a good comparison is have you ever played battlecon okay so it 1v1 uh um like 2d fire game okay i think you would like it a lot uh that is almost perfect knowledge
because you know what your opponent has played and you know what cards are in his hand you just don't know the combo so you're trying to read what his most optimal thing is going to do and what can you play to counter that there's another game similar to that called exceed which is the same style 2d fighting game but you have a deck and i don't like exceed because it's like well i don't know at any point what you're drawing so i can't try and there's too much random yes so that's kind of what this brought that's what it that's the only analogy i can think of right all right so that's our thoughts on light and shadow let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day this view hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you