Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 17:35

welcome to John gats games today I'll be reviewing black flea this is an aggressive sailing game where you control a merchant trying to deliver Goods a pirate trying to stop everyone else's Merchant and a neutral Navy ship trying to sync as many Pirates as they can along the way you'll be developing unique and Powerful Technologies which will really diversify each play experience first I'll go over the rules and then I'll jump in my review all right so how do we play Black Fleet each player has two ships Merchant and a pirate the merchants start on the board and the Pirates start off the board and then there are two Navy ships here which are controlled by all players they're kind of a community ship so let's jump into how a turn actually works each player starts the game with two movement cards and one Fortune card the way a turn works is you're going to pick one of these two movement cards and then you can play as many of these Fortune cards as you want they're onetime use and you discard them so let's look at these movement cards here we see that on the top we have a purple ship here and a yellow ship so this card would let us move the neutral purple Navy ship two and this one would let us move the yellow neutral ship too we also see a movement value of three for our pirate ship on this card five on this card three for our merchant ship here or five for our Merchant here obviously this card seems better because we have higher numbers however if we look at the bottom of this card we see at the end of our turn we're going to draw two more of these Fortune cards which are quite powerful so that balances the fact that this card makes you move faster but you draw no fortune cards this one you move a little bit slower but you build up for a better next turn moving your ships on

the board is very simple you move the number of spaces equal to the value on the card and the spaces are demarcated by these little dotted lines we have our Pirates over here and they start the game off the board so you bring them on in one of the three open spots at the edge of the board and then they continue their movement so I could go one two three if I picked the car that let my pirate go three spaces it's important to note that you're never allowed to move a ship through an opponent's piece or through a non-friendly Navy boat so if I played a a movement card that had a purple boat on it I could move through the purple Navy ship but if I don't if I play the yellow one then this Merchant might find themselves really locked out and they'll have to go the long way around in order to get to this port and that applies to every single Boat Type you will also notice that there are five ports around the game as I showed you that our little Merchants start at ports but there's also a green Port here and a red Port here there are numbers on these ports and these show you the sell value for Goods at these ports this means that over here we could sell green cubes for three money yellow cubes for two money purple cubes for two money and so on and so on so the farther away a port is from where you pick up cubes the more money you're going to get for it in addition to moving each ship gets one action that they can perform those actions are different for the different types of ships let's cover the merchant first so if our Merchant was able to move one two 3 four they're now on the gang plank of a port which will accept the type of goods that they have so we'll just dump those out we have three of these times

three that's going to get us nine money from the bank so that's pretty great and then as part of the same action we're going to load this ship up and if you look at the figurine here it only has space to hold three cubes which is pretty great so we load him up he's on the same spot he's ready to sail out and try and sell these Goods at a different port now we have the pirate ship If It Moves one forward it'll be adjacent to an opponent's Merchant which will allow him to plunder that Merchant so for an action you can take a cube from the merchant put it in the back of the pirate and as you can see there's only space for one Cube on the pirate and for doing this you're also going to grab two gold off of the merchant ship as a bit of a bonus on a following turn Pirates can use another type of action to move over to a beach that has a shovel and a number on it they can bury this good as treasure get four bucks from the bank for doing that this Cube goes back to the supply and now they're ready to go and plunder another merchant ship now now for the neutral Navy ships if they get moved adjacent to an opponent's pirate they can spend their action to destroy that pirate ship and they're going to get two money from the bank uh for doing this and this pirate ship gets taken off the board but don't worry about that too much this white pirate ship will be able to enter the board from any of the three spots around the board on the white players's next turn let's briefly look at a couple Fortune cards to give you some idea of the types of cards that are in this deck you're allowed to hold three of them in your hand at any point in time you can spend as many of them on on your turn as you want so if we look over here we have the

naval wind this lets us move our Navy ship an extra two spaces on the turn for discarding this card we have lucky wind which lets us move an opponent's piece up to two spaces in any direction we want which can be pretty great for catching with a pirate or moving somebody out of the way so you can get through and we have tidal wave which is everybody's favorite which lets ships move over Islands as many many times as they want to on that one turn it's pretty great at the beginning of the game each player is going to be dealt out a random five eight 11 and 14 value technology card that are face down at the beginning each player is allowed to look at every single one of their cards but they keep it hidden from all of their opponents now every player has this 10 value victory card at the End by flipping this over you end the game and if you're the only one who is able to do that you win outright but you're only allowed to uh do this endgame card if you've flipped over all four of your previous Technologies now in order to do that at the end of your turn you can purchase one of these and it costs gold equal to the bomb value in the top leftand corner of the card once you purchase a technology it's going to give you a power that's going to be effective for the rest of the game and in general they are very powerful and they alter the way the game plays significantly for instance this one here lets your pirate deliver a good that is plundered from someone else to any port for five D Bloons we've got this card right here which lets you uh when you deliver three Goods it's as if you delivered four Goods so you get a lot more money and a little bit of a bonus if you deliver two goods because the pirate attacked you

you get two deons from the bank so that's nice we've got this card right here which lets you pick one of your ship one of your ships on this turn and you can move it an extra two spaces every single turn very powerful and then what do we got here oh this one's great this one lets your Navy the Navy ship that you control attack Merchant ships for the rest of the game and you get three deons for doing that so suddenly not only the Pirates but the merchants are terrified of the Navy ships as long as it's your turn there's six different cards for each one of these technology slots in the game so it's highly unlikely that you'll ever play with the same set of abilities in front of you so the way they synergize together is going to make every game play differently as I said before once you've upgraded all four of these and you have 10 deons at the end of a turn you can flip this over starting the end game you make sure everyone's played the same number of turns if more than one person has done the endgame card then whoever has the most of balloons wins the game for my review of black Fleet I'll be explaining my thoughts on each item of this list as we go down so let's start at the top with positives the first thing that I like about this game are those technologies that you get dealt out at the beginning of the game before you even take your turn you have this moment of excitement where you're peeking at all of them you're like oh gosh that one's cool oh man that one's really cool and you're thinking okay well I want to get that one before this one because that's good but it's way better when I can combine it with this and you haven't even taken a turn yet but you have all these cool things you're getting excited about and on top of that it appears that the design uh scheme for the game was make every Power imbalanced and it'll kind of be balanced and I love it when

games do that when I first got the game I was looking through the technology cards I was like oh my gosh this one's amazing oh my gosh this one's amazing oh my gosh this one's amazing and that just made me really excited to play it because it means that you're really changing the game as you go the first turn is always going to be pretty similar in the game like there are no Technologies in play yet but once you get a couple turns in they start coming out and oh my pirate can cash Goods into ports and oh well my Merchant can attack other Pirates it really changes the vibe of the game and I just think that's awesome the second positive is that this is a hyper aggressive game that somehow doesn't feel mean uh normally in aggressive games you kind of be like oh crap stop sinking my ship over and over again I can't do anything I'm never going to win if that happens but in this game you kind of don't care you're more bummed that your opponent just got the two gold than you are that your ship got taken off the board now occasionally you like you had a good and you're about to go buried on a beach and you you are kind of upset about that but you know next turn your pirate zooms onto the board from one of three different spots odds are often good that you can actually plunder someone right after you do that because it's hard to dodge all three of these things and you have lots of favorite cars that can make your ships go faster so the penalty for getting sunk is relatively minor and you don't want it to happen but it happens so often and everyone's kind of smacking each other back and forth and for the most part just kind of laughing about it so I like that it's aggressive without being mean because being mean can turn off a lot of people in including me the third positive is I have to mention how gorgeous this game is you

probably saw it in the rules already how wonderfully Illustrated every single card is in the game and these boat pieces are like tiny little details like all the guns on the sides you have little waves Rippling on the bottom and they're even designed well so that you know how many cubes they're supposed to take because that's the number of spots they have in there we've got this money that's just like really substantial it's way better than little cardboard shits and uh unfortunately the uh the gold and the silver so the five and the the one value are kind of hard to tell the part which is a bit of a bummer but in general that doesn't take away from the awesome production I mean look even the insert in the game box works everything gets stored in it and it's a skull and crossbones that's so cool the one neutral point I have has to do with those Technologies I love so much but I wish there was some official variant that had to do with deciding or choosing which Technologies you actually got to play with uh they're dealt out randomly at the beginning of the game and the first game I mean you absolutely would need to do that but I feel like on subsequent games the excitement of seeing what cards I get is a little bit diminished and a little bit more of a feeling in my head like I wish I had some way to make a combination work so I feel like I might try a house rule where we deal out all the cards into a decks and then you maybe pick one draft one and then pass to the left and draft one pass to the left so that you have a little bit of say in the engine that you're kind of building in front of you I don't think this is the end of the world world you definitely want to play with randomized Technologies the first time you play with people uh and obviously I could just make my own house

rule but I'm definitely going to give that a try because I think that will probably add a little bit more to this great game the first negative point is that in every game of this I've played so far there has been a fall behind loser uh I see kind of a cluster of two to three people who are doing very well and one person who is just far behind and unfortunately the way the game works you do good you get some gold and then you spend that gold to reveal some technologies and now you get really good and it kind of cycles and keeps going whereas if one person can't really get their foot in and maybe even has trouble getting that first technology to to perhaps playing poorly or just getting unlucky they are really out of it there's no catch-up mechanisms at all in this game besides potentially saying okay well I want to Target the person who is most likely to be my competitor to win so I'm not going to attack the person who is you know that fall behind loser unfortunately this game really does benefit highly tactical play where if there's a merchant that you can attack then you're going to attack it even if it is that person who's not doing very well if you have a choice if you can attack that person or somebody who's right behind you or right ahead of you you're definitely going to attack that one person but it seems like oftentimes that one person who kind of falling behind they don't have that ability to shoot on the board or get extra bucks when they turn things in or have their merchant attack other Pirates and they just kind of get a little bit farther and farther behind and that person is having an okay time but I could see in their eyes they're they're a little bit bummed that they're not doing the awesome stuff that the people

who are kind of in the thick of it are doing and that's a bit of a bummer the other negative that I have has to do with a slight imbalance uh between the ports around the game which kind of surprised me they the Blu good is the only one that has two different ports that will sell at three deons per crate whereas every other color only has a single other Port that will give you three what this means is the obvious choice for the start player the first person to put their merchant down is to go to that blue port and I don't know that I kind of hate it when a game gives you options and then really doesn't give you that option because there is a best move and it's best because if you're going straight down and Pirates come onto the side well you can just detour and you still have a great secondary spot to go and try to go for those nine de Bloons on the First Cash in versus every other color you know if you're gunning for that one three to balloon port and something happens well you're in off and you're only going to get two D Bloons per now it doesn't seem like that big of a deal but one Deon can be the difference between getting getting a technology this turn and getting it next turn which can have big scaling uh impacts based off of what that technology is now multiple players can go on different ports at the beginning of the game there's three gang planks and so I've seen in almost every game now at least two people start in the blue three not so much because you start to clog in on each other but I just wish that they had made it slightly more balanced and maybe it would lose some flavor but I don't want there to be a obvious decision for the first play in any

game so let's talk about replayability now in my opinion this game has a lot of replayability and it really all comes back to those technology cards that I keep talking about because they are the core cool factor of this game they do such different things some of them like oh here you get a couple extra de balloons but many of them just give ships entirely new actions that change the entire mental state of the group on the board for instance one of them lets Navy ships attack Merchants another one lets you swap the position of your pirate with the Navy ship so suddenly your your opponents are not sure where to even take their Merchants now they're scared of navy ships as well as pirates there's a pirate Hideout where you can teleport your pirate to one spot and then jump out different spots there's all these different things that make every game play very differently because you really need to think you know mid game once two or three abilities are revealed you're constantly thinking about what that person has the ability to do and that person has the ability to do and I don't think you're ever really going to have a situation where it's the same because even though there are only six different abilities for each type and you're going to have see four of them in a four player game not everyone's going to have the same ones at the same time and they the way they combo I just think it is going to be fresh for a very long time I think replayability is higher than I would have actually at first thought in a game where you're just playing these cards and moving little pirate ships around now let's talk about player count on the box it says this game supports three to four players although there is an official two-player variant that was published on the board game geek by the

designer there are a couple non-official two-player variants as well I have not played it two-player yet however I have played it three and four player and I think this game definitely plays best with four players it worked with three I would totally play it with three but the Caribbean Little Island map is a bit more empty and this game really wants ships everywhere lots of options ships you're running towards ships you're running away from it's a big chaotic it's a very tactical and that's the way the game was pretty obviously designed to be so I would play it three but if there was a fourth person kind of not sure I would really try to reel them in and get them in there because four definitely plays best in conclusion I've been really excited about this game from the moment I heard about it I saw little photos on Board Game Geek I bought it as soon as I could I opened the box and I got even more excited because you have all these great bits and I'm reading through all these powers and they seem so cool and I played the first game and I loved it I loved it every second the way through and I've loved every second of every game I've played since this game is really fun it's so unusual to find a hyper aggressive game that doesn't come across as being mean uh for the most part people are laughing and groaning in a very entertained way uh in addition to that the powers are so much fun it's I love asymmetric player powers in games and that's essentially what this game has even though you don't quite realize it at first because with every technology you play you differentiate yourself more and more from the different players around the board and they could be big differentiations because of the crazy powers that come out especially that first game if you haven't cheated and looked through every single card you're

in for a lot of really cool surprises from the things that you reveal at the beginning of the game and the things that your opponents play as the game is progressing I don't necessarily feel that the best player always wins this game there are there's quite a bit of room for Randomness but I don't really care I've had so much fun playing it every single time it's very tactical so you just have such a great time on every turn trying to figure out the best thing you can do with the options that are pres presented with you the fortune cards are very powerful and they can be a bit swingy especially if you have an amazing combination between Fortune cards late in the game but you could also argue that you potentially set yourself up to be able to take advantage of that so I don't think it's random who wins this game but there is definitely some luck of the draw that comes into it I don't care I love this game I'm going to keep playing it I'm going to keep this one for a really long time I think I hope you like this review please subscribe if you want to see more and thanks for watching

Progress saved