Fighting about the BEST Dune: Imperium vs. Uprising | Review & Debate
Transcript
we have opinions we've done reviews we've broken down The rules you might miss done game plays of both we've highlighted the expansions and let you know what you might want to consider when deciding which one is your favorite and now it's a time for a video that's all debate and all opinion entirely oh yeah I like Dune Uprising more than Dune Imperium and I'm the complete opposite so let's talk about it let's engage in a friendly debate around what I think we both will set the floor of the conversation at two remarkable games these are both amazing games it's like we're debating a 9.2 and a 9.3 I mean I mean they're well I mean it might actually be more significant but we're debating games that are very very solid to begin with you're going to win no matter what you play it just comes down at this point to preference and why we like certain things over others so I'm going to open the floor to you and I'm going to spend most of the time I think reacting to your opinions and and engaging in the conversation uh cuz the audience knows I'm going to interrupt enough as it is I don't need to have my own points to uh get my own thoughts in it's almost like this is your YouTube channel or something like that isn't that crazy guys on Reddit don't think so guys on Reddit every time I have a guest I just assume that the people on BGG are going like please let like anyone but him anyone but the duck no he's not handing
the channel over all right well I don't read the comments so well at least on redit no my comments are great comments on the videos are great it's just people with one gu it's just it's just people with miserable lives are terrible there's that one guy who always comments on your videos that I really enjoy that might be me yeah yeah might be okay opinions yeah why do you like Dune Imperium more than Dune Uprising so as I probably thoroughly annoyed boots with last night um I really enjoy the books I'm currently about as of the recording of this video about 200 pages into Chapter House Dune which is the sixth book and for me personally having played multiple times between the original and Uprising the one that I feel is more accurately depicting and like kind of you know making me feel more engaged with the book The Universe found in the book has got to be this one I mean you know the idea of having you know so so many things happening in the background where the combat is important but it's not necessarily everything and so many factions in the book The Ben a jesser the you know the you know house Haron and House of tradies trying to do things background you know where if I do this then I can do this and then this person will do that and that kind of planning the political subterfuge the the wheeling and dealing you feel like is maybe emphasized more in base game would you then agree that uprising is facilitated towards a more movie
based audience so if people haven't read the books and and don't intend to read the books and I'm not saying that it necessarily required especially the second half of of the recent Doom you know iteration certainly celebrate the military conquests they they highlight they make them beautiful they they they celebrate the journey with the sandworms and and so Uprising might fit a more uh current day um cultural understanding of Dune Asos to to a uh historical and and lore and fiction and fan based uh appreciation and especially Uprising is the one that introduces having sandworms into into the game which is a point for that for your side as well as far as you know even being attributed to the book yeah you know because those are there and I mean to be fair ba the Bas Dune Imperium game also happens to have a lot of the elements from the first movie itself it's not just entirely in the book and you you're not in by any stretch of the imagination required to read the book in order to play this game but for me as someone as I kept reading the books and then coming back and playing this game I felt so much more immersed in the base versus Uprising which talk me through that what what what an uprising doesn't doesn't match when it comes to the lore and the story that's being told in the books where whereas base game Imperium seems to um so like the Spy mechanic for example while the Spy mechanic is fantastic and I and I love it the idea I mean you do
have a couple of characters that kind of act like spies one in particular that I can think of and I won't spoil the book even though it's been out for many years but the whole like I can spy on this faction or I can spy on that faction that doesn't really happen in the book information is a lot more restricted and loyalty is loyalty in in the in the book unless an entire side is switching right like unless unless betrayal is happening either on a national level or not at all yeah exactly that's one of the one of the key examples also as much as I enjoy the sand warm mechanic I I don't think it stays true really to what the purpose of the sandworms were just add three to every battle what are you talking about and have them on different sides of the Waring factions yeah and I mean the sandworms themselves did not actually attack enemies they just broke stuff they they can they broke stuff and and were used as troop transports which amazing dig scene by the way interesting amazing visual SE being able you know even in the controversial okay controversial opinion I actually enjoyed the 1984 version of Dune just because it's campy and cheesy and it's and it's wonderful but the writing writing the sandworm scene was kind of cool from that from that movie I will say so I I understand your stance when it comes to the lore and what you experience on the game but let's set lore to the side let's let's set the the the the framework and the history and the experience that you bring with you to the table and and look at the mechanics of the game and look at the actual game that we're playing yeah Uprising for me
is a much deeper much more rewarding and much more longlasting game in my collection than base game Imperium is I remember when I first played base game Imperium we were we were comparing it to other worker placement uh deck building games and for the record deck building is if I join it with drafting which I think they're very ilar is like my favorite mechanic in a game period I love I love A system that lets me add things to my hand until I feel like I've broken the game and then the game ends and someone wins and they have an amazing turn and then you reset and you start from zero and you do it again I love the build I love the progression and base game d Imperium didn't do that for me it didn't focus on combat much but it also didn't focus on deck building much and the board places are fairly open they're fairly Bland they they don't give me a lot of growth throughout the course of the game when comparing it to things like uh at the at the time lost ruins of arnac uh or endless winter and so I actually didn't it was my least favorite of the collection of uh of this genre originally until I started playing expansions and now that I have Uprising I don't know that I could do without the enhanced locations the spies that give you manipulation over later actions in the game the emphasis on combat and the reformulation of the deck or the ability to just combine decks and craft your own all of that creates such a
richer and deeper environment when it comes to the actual board game I'm playing yeah see one of the things that I'll disagree with you on though is your you're you're saying about Dune Imperium base game you know as far as deck building is concerned for me I loved the deck building aspect I thought that with with the original game deck building was more highly emphasized now that could be argued to to to the detriment of combat which definitely is the main complaint that I've heard from people about you especially my oldest his main complaint with dun Imperium was he loves combat and dune the base Dune Imperium just didn't give enough combat wise but having said that I feel especially that the deck building aspect from the original and especially if you add you know especially the rise of X expansion which I'll get into more later like that deck building experience is so satisfying and the combos that you can get off of those cards so so I mean let's talk about this though because the reformulation here in the in the deck for Dune Imperium Uprising has lower cost cards with more powerful abilities and then some very high cost very high Punchy cards it's a more rewarding buy and draw more cards type of structure whereas BAS game Dune uh original game Dune has a more expensive deck it's a harder threshold to cross and I would argue requires or is greatly improved by
the wipe system that's not introduced until immortality comes in and so the clear the row should have been in the base game but it wasn't and so when I first experienced the base game I found myself struggling to get cards not rewarded by having a lot of them yeah to be Fair they did not include that in Uprising that clear I they didn't we theorized that they might have restructured the deck and kept that in mind but but I don't know maybe they just don't like wipe abilities in general but I also think with as far as the cards from the base is considered um you have also that varying progression of higher cost cards there is a there is a middle ground on there it's not you know like looking down here we've got twos and threes and and a four I feel like with the B with the original you're going to be having also five six more fives and sixes and sevens as well so that later on if you're able to have those rounds where you can get those higher you know persuasion cards those can be a massive benefit yeah I I I do think that you if you get into those higher cost those higher higher uh influence or or or or or or buy Power rounds in Dune Uprising you end up either buying a spice mus flow uh because you need it for victory points cuz cuz victory points can score much higher um which we'll touch on in just a moment I'm sure or I'll actually buy multiple cards of a similar faction I think the cohesion in factions here is also a very compelling thing they
they've structured these to reward close-knit and tactical play whereas base game I felt like you went for whatever was the best card because it was the best card on the on the on the table that you could afford not necessarily uh going for things that will synergize together see I would disagree with that and that may just be a a product of my gameplay I have no problem with looking at a set of cards and saying I don't care if I have five you know persuasion right now I I don't want any of these cards and I'm okay with skipping around because if I don't feel that there's a card out there that synergizes appropriately with my deck I'm trying to have you know 12 cards maybe 13 cards maximum and I want them to all synergize with each other so that when I keep drawing cards I'm gonna get more and more powerful bonuses every and make sure that I can get those every single round I think there's a greater emphasis on the the actual deck building rather than just swingy combat I think the last point I'm going to make here and then if you have any ruddle to this I'll I'll let you move on with with the topic because we're touching on the debt quite a bit but I think it's something that's very important to me and really did influence how I've experienced both games in uh base game one I find it very dissatisfying to not spend the money that I've collected I I like if I have a round where I have five or six buy Power I really hate not using it and and I'm very disappointed when a game puts me in a position where I can't use it that's fair uh and so you
know that's just maybe a feel bad moment for me that doesn't impact you as much however I also really like deck building games that allow me to do weird things with the deck for instance going on a call strategy where you Wile your hand down to where you have almost nothing left well base game I did that I tried and I ended up with like four cards and nothing left like like I ended up with so four cards is too too too few but I think I ended up with like with like six or seven cards and every round because of the draw power that I had in my deck I was drawing all of my cards and could not draw to my threshold yeah and I found that really disappointing as well because it was hard enough to add cards to my deck that a coal strategy wasn't a rewarding way to play the game for me a really hard heavy coal strategy whereas here I can fill my hand with so many cards so quickly that I can get rid of all my base cards and I have a whole new set to play with by mid game and that's rewarding that's nice when when I've thrown out everything I started with except for maybe one or two keep the signant ring you know everything else get out of here I hear that and that is a fair point all right I'll still disagree with you um the other thing that I that I dislike not dislike I mean I love both of these games yeah we set the foundation they're both excellent we'd be happy to play them at any point at any time one of the things that irks me however that's terrible about this game
it's terrible about this game you got to get the thumbnail you know yeah it's true why Cory hates everybody hates but what I intensely everybody hates everybody hates the one thing that I I can't I can't really gel with with Uprising is the the heavy emphasis on combat now as as I mentioned before based do an Imperium you know to its detriment maybe underemphasize for sure it does the combat for sure it does it's it's you think combat should be more fun than it is yeah and but I think when trying to rebalance it for the purposes of Uprising I think they went too far with it I think there's too much of an emphasis on I need to win multiple combats in order for me to have any shot of winning this game but the changes they made also greatly improve the experience I understand the argument that they went too far I I get that however the changes they made in terms of restructuring how our combat deck works so so second and third place have compelling things you might want to win more than first place position having paired objectives that allow you to decide when you're going to go all in in a battle and score victory points based off of matching uh different combat uh victories having the resource demanding extra victory points on the card and the duplicating effect of the sandworms which I understand might be a broken strategy if if if left to your own devices but is certainly fun and
impactful when you can do it and when you can take advantage of it when you've done it I get they might have taken it a little bit too far but I think they've done less of a wrong thing by T by overemphasizing combat than Dune you know original did by underemphasizing it well to that point what I'll say though is that a lot in Dune Imperium base is well if if everybody's fighting in combat I'm going to be the guy kind of behind the scenes and I can work a way to get up the different tracks and I can get spice mus flow and I can kind of work my way almost around combat and maybe sneak in and you know go to highliner and get a whole bunch of stuff for that one moment where I just need those two more points to you know just end this game right now and you know that kind of thing where I can be in the background is very rewarding because then when it happens and you send a ton of people in and everybody goes oh wait a second this guy's about to win the game right now and we didn't notice we weren't paying attention that to me is a very rewarding thing or on the flip side of that is just oh wait a second I completely missed that but it's also enjoyable in its own way and I think if you if you're too heavy if you have too heavy of an emphasis on the combat then it's it doesn't matter what I'm doing around the board if I don't interact at all with the combat I'm at a severe
disadvantage you you certainly could be I I think you can't ignore combat especially if uh multiple players are ignoring combat you're you're in trouble but I I will say that because of the opportunity to score victory points from a number of different access points whether it's buying you know TecTiles whether it's getting uh victory points by winning combat whether it's going to Intrigue cards that have hidden victory points you could have multiple of those in your hand whether it's buying cards from the row that allow you to sell spice get rid of salari trash cards whatever it is to unlock I often times find uh Uprising to be much more swingy than base game Imperium ever was and yes originally I didn't like that but as I've played it more and UND and and and grown to understand where that Swingin comes from I find that it's a controllable level of variance that makes me enjoy the puzzle that I'm trying to solve more than base game does base game I know that if you hit 10 I'm probably not crossing the threshold and getting to 11 or getting to 12 but with a little bit more depth an understanding of the puzzle that's in front of me with Uprising I actually sit back and say well I don't have to win I can win one combat and one combat well or not even win but just prevent someone else from scoring it I could tie someone on a combat and be satisfied because I have four victory points on my board that they don't know anything about or I have
that card that I'm going to be drawing up in the next round or two and I'm set up and ready to cash it in for a victory point that no one's expecting I like those moments of endgame scoring and Pops I like the fact that I've seen games run uh all the way up to the 15 16 point threshold and everyone almost across the board when I play Uprising is above 10 everyone's pushing above that line whereas I have seen people in base game Imperium hit four and hit five and not be in the game anymore by mid game they're just out of it CU someone's going to hit 10 and they're not going to be able to catch up I think you can always catch up an uprising and I think that matters so I understand that point I but I will disagree where I feel personally that the swing of the game how much it can swing I think to me is is a detriment in this game where base Dune Imperium where every decision especially if you're including some of the expansions again more on that later like every sing I've had I've had games where every single decision felt so important that especially in later game where that that game of if I do this and but he does that and then I do this and that that kind of chess match between the multiple players that you have at the table that that kind of interaction where every decision makes so much M so much of a difference especially in a tight game that swinging almost kind of
ruins it at the end where it's like okay so I lost by three points what did all those decisions where they all come from wait a minute I I played really well I hear I I think I think it's it comes down to the type of players that you have around the table I'm not a very AP prone player unless I feel pressure from the game and players around the game to need me to slow down I like leaning into chaos I like seeing how things play out I'm the type of player that says hey my objective for this game is to use a little Thumper to multiply all of the uh resource on the third area of uh of spice collection if memory serves actually there is a thumper card in the base game as well I'm just saying like like I I'm the type of player that from the beginning will say well this looks interesting can I win the game by doing this like for instance as we've started exploring and I've been doing research on how swingy the worms really are almost every game I play now I think to myself well let's win without worms it doesn't happen much it doesn't happen much and that's part of the problem however however that's why that's why I can say I think it's a problem but but I like that play I like that play style where base game is much more like a chess match you're you're right about that I'm not much of a chess player because I I always know there's a better action that I could take it's not so fun to memorize those actions for me I mean then you're just going up against you know ADHD and dyslexia against whatever it is that you have and I'm assuming you have at least one neurological condition but that actually
might be in favor of memorization and analytics as opposed to directly oppositional I'm rewarded by chaos I function well in chaos and this game gives me that oh don't get me wrong I myself aligned myself as chaotic neutral I don't care what it is that's burning to the ground as long as something is burning to the ground fair enough fair enough hey we we'll agree there thank you for watching no but I mean I think that's that can be somewhat mitigated though by having the different leaders and especially if you get to some of the higher you know uh the leaders that have kind of rated from difficulty I think when you get to those then you end up having some of that variance where you need to pay more attention kind of to how you're how you're drawing the deck how you're how you're manipulating the board or if you want more of a chaotic one you go for something maybe less complicated and you're just like whatever let's see what let's just see what happens I think you can do that with especially with the bass especially when you're adding because I think the bass ends up having more of those higher complicated um you know more intricate kind of leaders versus Uprising which only has a few of them Uprising did scale back on complexity of leaders for or in favor of complexity on the board and I actually it's one of the things that I like less about it however if you're going to own it all just you know
mix them together a lot a lot of them a lot of them cross cross over I had people complaining about the video that I did earlier you know about a week ago or so where I said don't buy both and like I had one guy in the comment section with like 13 thumbs up that's like I don't understand this video why are you to tell people not to buy both no one goes out and buys both of them I go out and buy both of them I buy both of them what are you talking about like like I we all own all of them I'm just saying you don't you get you should know what you're getting so that you experience the best way possible and then you'll buy the other one 6 months later like of course we all own both it's good marketing you know my young actually mentioned that to me today was dad daddy your friend actually said you don't need to buy both I'm like I I already have them both yeah yeah yeah yeah I'm making the video cuz we've all bought them both I'm telling the new people and I have no regrets about buying them this this is a fantastic game as well of course yeah you but I I I will say that I don't get base game or base game components to the table as much that I own Uprising and understanding that I like this one more means that this one plus expansions is probably enough for a long time yeah but if we're talking about expansions though let's get to it let's get to it Ian because you have to share I I understand two of them came earlier you know we we we've played Bloodlines enough to be able to talk about it now I I get what you're going to say the two that came out originally what I would argue fixing Dune
Imperium are shared expansions that can come here to Uprising as well why do you think those expansions stand better by your favorite version well I mean I agree with you that you can I mean the rules do specify how you can actually Implement and especially rise of X which is the which is arguably my favorite expansion of any game I've ever played whoa yeah I would I would rank it higher than prelude for ter I got to pause why we're going to be doing a whole review we're not going to get too deep into it here but ever played ever played for for any game because there are so many times PR so is your your game no it's not it's not even that I mean I mean I I remember I I rated Bas do an Imperium as a nine on Board Game Geek base yeah I think I had like a seven again we we disagree on those things but I loved do Imperium already and typically when an expansion comes out there's always that feeling of okay like what are you going to do that's going to be good and what are you going to do that's going to be not as great yeah there's always that kind of well this is the reason why they didn't have this in the base right it's like a new Will Smith movie I've already seen your best work sir on stage with Chris Rock yep just remember Ro yeah paper beats rock or whatever there was there was a joke but horribly derailed you continue you did why do you love the expansion but you know with with the with rise of X though
I think what ends up happening is they it actually adds so many things where it's like oh this game is now shifted dramatically um to the point where it's almost a new game even just from having an expansion with the same elements as as the bass but that kind of shift just made things completely brand new have you kind of how Uprising makes it brand new they should have released just a uh Dune Imperium rise ofix Standalone and you would have had three core games to to play I mean really that's almost the degree to which it seems like you're saying it it transformed the game for you so I'm not saying they should do that but they could they could have so why doesn't I match with Uprising in a in to the same degree of compliment uh that you found it matched with Imperium so I mean there are the rules where you can put x with Uprising my problem though is I think the the meshing of Rise of X with the original I think is so well done and it it it creates so many clever extra Combos and and different strategies that I I want to like it when combined with Uprising but there's I always feel there's something missing I'm like oh man but if we had this card here in in Uprising man that would be a good thing and then again you could mix those but it's it's not the same and then you know when the recent expansion
when they introduced Bloodlines and they're like oh here's some Teti and I mentioned this a multiple times when we were playing the game where oh that's a cool ttile but I kind of miss the ones from Rise of X in my in my in the way I play games all the tech tiles are just going together and they're either being stacked here or they're being stacked there unless they specifically have rules that are directly related to sandworms or you know recruiting different people that you don't have like dreadnots and stuff like those have to of course be modified but I like just combining components oh yeah and and it's certainly fun to do so and I think we're planning at some point to try to try and figure out a way to do everything all at once everything everywhere all at once fantastic movie by the way but now I've derailed you I I didn't say anything I'm not derailed that's true I didn't like the movie very much oh really we can get into that now I've derailed you now you've derailed me no but I I I love the interaction with with I and and the base game I I think it enhances the deck building aspect which I've already mentioned is to me it you know feels better I think the unload mechanic I think works better and synergizes more with some of the additional stuff in in bass and you know I I mean it's to the point where when I'm teaching somebody Bas doent Imperium I'm going to include rise of vix each and every time even if it's somebody who's brand new because it's like if you
want to have the optimum version of this game let's do this I I do think Uprising doesn't need much of what the expansions introduced that I felt like you know base game Dune did need you know that and that's that's the Crux of it for me is I do think they're very different games I think the experience of play is is remarkably similar and yet remarkably different and distinct when when you're sitting down a chess match vers a Helter Skelter what feels like area control combat throw everything at the wall type of experience and expansions enhance both of them in interesting ways and provide interesting modifiers but the first two expansions are very much designed for the first version of the game and they solve problems or enhance areas of the game that were lacking or weak and what would be a more introductory version of a board game whereas I think Uprising solves those on the table itself it adds modifiers like the sandworms as opposed to the dreadnots and lets you mess with stuff and when it comes to Bloodlines which is the first expansion that's been introduced for upright ring I feel like it just kind of grabs elements of the other expansions and says well you don't need everything from the other expansion because it it makes it just a little bit too messy but we still want you to have some TecTiles and we still think it'd be nice if there were other troops you could add to battle so like let's introduce these little guys and yeah but I I I don't entirely enjoy I mean the sa car commanders from Bloodlines are okay they're lacking for me but they're definitely I would take them out I I don't I don't find them necessary I
actually find them a bit cumbersome um I and I don't find the play overly rewarding I will say that my favorite leaders though come in Bloodlines see I will disagree with that I and we maybe we'll have a video on this later we're talking about each other's favorite leaders so expansions I would give it to you in terms of how expansions pair and enhance these games I think they both enhance both games I think they enhance base game Dune more and so if you're looking for the full collection and a varied experience of play across the full full collection then you know I think you almost set expansions off to the side and we're back to talking just about the core experiences and what we're getting from the original original boxes while I will admit the best expansions do fit your copy and either big points that you know you you want to go over when when when comparing these two and and being an exciting factor for you um not that I can think of Cu after this I'm going to set base game on fire and I believe you're going to set your copy of upright right as long as there's something burning then I'm not saying about this game is fantastic I love playing this game oh okay we'll set both my copies on fire and we'll make it look like you're burning one of yours you'll cry a little bit I can do that I'm very good at faking tears just committed I'm such a chaotic player and and this is where I'll I'll I'll sign this off and invite you all to let us know like what other highs and lows and and elements of the
game state uh are enhanced reduced changed adapted in ways that fit and don't fit your play style the last video I did was a direct comparison between the two of them trying to help people who are new buyers decide where they want to enter the market right because it's a great game and people should enter this game but I think they should do so responsibly and know and get a good experience like you said you always teach with rise ofx well then if they're buying base game you would probably encourage them to always purchase rise ofx right alongside of it absolutely as of course standard rise ofix is a 10 for me on Bo Game Geek this conversation is much more centered around why certain elements fit us better and I think the audience out there and the community out there Echoes a lot of these points and I've seen these discussions kind of across the board I think eventually my preferred way of playing this will be a handcrafted and hand chosen combination of of cards probably leaning towards more rather than fewer because I do love deck building but I don't want the deck to become so cumbersome that I'm unable to find the cards I'm searching for right so a a customized version of of of of this deck a base that includes uh you know that a base that is Uprising because the base game and the Spy mechanic enhances the depth of the game in a way that I I just think is necessary for more advanced players all the leaders mixed together so you can draft from from pretty much any one of
ailable uh and little subm modules from the other two expansions included you know like like our progression track is a nice thing to have like it's fun to like Whittle your way up that the extra Market to purchase is a great area to go explore that doesn't require you to be focused on other parts parts of the board I might keep you know this little Tech system here instead of having the full board where you're You Know You're Building engine but I'll bring the tiles over I think a hybrid will be where I prefer this game and I don't think that's how you're going to experience it I think you'll play it with me that way I looking forward to I haven't heard in our conversations off camera and this is why I'm bringing up this point I haven't heard in our conversations off camera that you have an inclination towards the mixing that I do I want to smash my game together and see what happens and every time I bring it up you're like oh that sounds interesting oh I I'll I'll join you for a game but never once have I heard you go oh yeah maybe I'll do that myself maybe my copy will also bridge that Gap and this could reflect our preference the chaos the the the the craze the the score whatever whatever happens happens type of experience versus the chess match the the known puzzle that's been solved you know that that that's there that you can you can engage with fully and you know what's in front of you I would agree with that I also also will say that I don't feel like much of a game designer I'm not entirely sure how I would best be able to kind of merge them together without kind of ruining the experience and that
that to me is my big worry is I love this game so much I don't I feel like I don't get it to the table enough and so when I am going to play it I want to make sure I can guarantee myself to have the best experience possible so what does that look like what we we we'll end on that note I've told people what I think my end crazy crazed result might be which I'm interested in playing and just to be clear I might ruin the experience and I and I would have fun having experienced a broken version of the game and then I'll reset it back if I did or I might discover something really cool and really weird and really wacky that I don't get to the table often but is super fun and unique when I do for you if you could pick and choose and set up and and you were going to host game night and everyone defaulted to your preference what does Dune look like at this point with all the expansions with all the modules what do you have on the table so I so I definitely have the baseboard okay I'm definitely playing with rise of vix as previously mentioned um sounds like that's standard sounds like that doesn't go anywhere that's absolutely standard um I think most of the time I will play with immortality okay because I like that especially thematically um having the TX you know the TXU faction being on there is is fun um I might play with having sand the sandworms try to figure out a way to get that mechanic kind of in there just
again for thematic reasons because sand wors are such a prevalent thing in the Dune books you know um but other than that I mean maybe bring in the the conflict cards that have the matching possibly um but yeah no it's going to lean heavily more towards kind of those base game elements yeah I mean it sounds like the game that you discovered that you fell in love with has things that could improve it or tweak it but not a lot has beaten it not a lot has challenged it and that's what you were concerned about the expansions doing the first place and the fact that you know rise of vi just solidified Your Love of it um is neat I like that I also like the advice because I I think your opinion is a more reliable one on what someone should do if they're buying base game because I don't encourage them I I encourage them to buy Uprising unless they're teaching or they're a new gaming group and then my advice was you know buy base game but if you're a more advanced gaming group that wants a more strategic more controlled puzzle or a more thematic like to the lore puzzle if you love Dune then I think your advice of uh you know buy based game with rise ofix period MH is probably good yep absolutely cool thanks for watching thanks for being here let us know what you think let us know if you enjoy these conversations and let us know when you're showing up for game night we've got a big Helter Skelter version of this game we need to get to the table and I think I hate the five and six player variants of uh of this game uh I think I
do I think I hate it um I'm not sure because as far as I can tell it's impossible to facilitate and play so if if anyone whether it's a publisher a you know friend that lives close or far away to Cleveland Ohio and five more of his friends because I don't think Cory's joining joining he's also very conflicted if anyone wants to show up and prove me wrong that five and six player version of this game I have no idea what direwolf did you want to prove me wrong on that like please do we'll record it I'll talk about it I'll apologize on camera whatever you want I think it's horrible I think they should not sell the game with five and six listed on the box I think it's a scam ouch yeah I think it's terrible I think it's unplayable gez Jesse tell us how how you feel I I feel that way I feel that way and I have tried to play it and I have tried to read the rules and I have a friend who did play it with a designer at a convention and it took that friend seven hours with a designer with one of the people that made too long and they and they it was a like hour plus long teach for a game they are all already knew it's like I don't know what they did ah yeah I just I don't know tell me if I'm wrong on that it's okay you're in a safe space here just on BGG also I don't think I see anyone mentioning five or six I don't know like in in forums in chat groups and I have I don't know I've ever seen anyone bring it up like it's something that's being played I don't know maybe
that's for another time thank you for being here whatever the case whatever you do remember to do the important thing don't get five and six player games you don't have that many friends anyway stick with two ouch we'll see you later bye