Skip to main content
Loading video...

Guards of Atlantis II: Discussion

Transcript 31:13

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.

Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and today I'm doing a discussion over Guards of Atlantis 2. This was a game that I generally would stay away from for a variety of reasons. one, it is mainly and designed to be a 2v2 game and that especially just with you know current you know circumstances is kind of difficult to actually get going. Um so that's one reason. Another reason is that this is based off of a moa style that you know is very popular from games like Dota and League and I have never played those. I think I played League once for a skit whenever I was doing um Mech Versus Minions. And that was literally the only time I ever tried League cuz I had heard that that fan base was just pure cancer.

But for some reason, this game had me intrigued because I do love the idea of kind of a bunch of unique heroes with completely different builds and and play styles being, you know, fought against, you know, you know, all all fighting one another. And this game has tons of heroes. Like I think it's like over 20. I should have counted. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 32 heroes in this game and that's with a bunch of expansions.

So that kind of just always has me fascinated because there's no rule set on who you pick. uh you just pick a hero you want to play, pair it with another person, and then you fight against it. So, how does this, you know, match that MOA style gameplay? And I would say it does probably the best of any. I know there's another MOA style game coming out onward and that and we'll see how that how that works. But this does a pretty fantastic job of capturing that cuz you have your minions out on the map as well as your heroes. And your minions are really kind of there to push the game forward that you are one.

You can win the game by killing the opposing heroes a certain number of times, but you can also win by removing the opposing minions in a given lane or in a given uh section. And once all of them are removed, you make a push cuz and once you make two consecutive pushes, then you win the game. So, I I really like the fact that they had managed to capture the use of minions without having them actually be like really uh complicated to run. They do add or subtract to defense of your heroes, but they are mainly just kind of there uh to help move the game along. And then the way that each person's hero plays is just so radically different from one another, which is exactly how a MOA should be. And you are going to utilize each hero based off their strengths and weaknesses. And the more you play this game, the more you are going to understand your opponent's strengths and weaknesses. out of all the games that I own, I feel like none of them really uh capture like more play styles. Like you don't get like this game requires a lot of play to be able to actually get good, which is kind of how a MOA game is as well that you can and it's like you're going to get the gist of what a hero does. I mean, in fact, on the back of it, it just tells you kind of what their

strengths and weaknesses are anyway. But on multiple playthroughs, you're going to realize, okay, here's what this person can do. How am I best going to counter that? I mean, I guess Battle Con does that when you understand how a fighter works. This kind of has that exact same feeling. So, if you're looking for a game that requires a ton of replay to be able to actually kind of get good and you almost want to play it with the exact same group, then uh and you also want a game that ends up kind of being a little sweaty, then this might be the game for you. So I It's interesting because this game isn't going to hit the table a whole lot for me, but every time that it has, it's always been an amazing experience because how you are going to play is just going to be completely different based off who you are up against and the situation they that they put you in. trying to read your opponent, trying to understand what buffs that they have, what cards they have played, uh what cards you have played, and they're doing the exact same thing. All while you have a teammate trying to do the exact same thing as you, trying to sync up with your with, you know, mind meld with one another and then they're doing the exact same thing.

So, it is a highly strategic and tactile game while also being one of the simplest games to learn. they have managed to capture, you know, this feeling of a game and this high level of a game without it being an 80page rule book. And that is something to be completely commended for that because I remember like the first time I played it, I was like, "Oh, this is it." And then it had been a bit since I played it. Uh, so I played it again and I was like, "Oh, okay. Let me refresh myself on the rules." And I'm like, "Oh, yeah. I forgot. I kind of already remember how to do everything." It is absolutely fascinating. So, one really cool thing about this game that they've done is everyone has a certain number of cards and they're all colorcoded. You have red, blue, green, silver, and yellow or gray and yellow.

You pretty much your gray and yellow are going to be your staples and then your red, blue, and green are going to be the cards that get upgraded and changed as your hero levels up because your hero levels up based off how like minions that they kill, heroes that they kill. Uh you get money and money is really only used to level up unless there's some heroes that I don't know. They might use money for something else, but for the most part it is used to level up. And when you level up, you take all like the next level cards, which there are two of each color. So you take six cards and you pick one of them. So if I want to upgrade my green card, I take one of the two green cards and then I replace it. And what's really nice is if you like the green card that you have been using, then there's one card that basically is an upgraded version of that or there's another card that kind of goes in a completely different direction. So, you have options based off the build that you're trying to do uh to help maybe counter who you're up against to sync better with your teammate or maybe you just want to try something different.

So, what's cool is that you take that card and then you just swap it. And now you have an upgraded green card. But then you take the second card and at the bottom of all of these cards is a permanent stat buff. Your stats are either attack, defense, initiative or kind of uh area or movement or whatever it might be and you slide it underneath your character and now you get a buff to that stat. I really really like that. I like the fact that both cards are useful. And sometimes you might actually be looking at a card and you're like, I really like this ability and I like the fact that it gives me two movement and lets me do this, but it does the bottom does give me more attack. So I might actually just take this for its attack and just replace my green with this one.

So that is just such a very simple but important decision whenever you are playing this game. And what's also nice is the game doesn't kind of leave people behind. If you are just kind of being put in a really bad position, you're not killing a lot of minions. You're not killing heroes. One, if your teammate kills a hero, you get compensation money um depending on their level. So if like the enemy hero that you killed was level six, well, the person who killed him is going to get six money, but then your teammate will get two money and things like that. But if you also at the end of a round, if you don't level up, you get I mean it's called a pity coin, but you get a coin. And so naturally, if you're if you're not, you know, doing so well, you're going to start being able to level up. It really does an awesome job of keeping everyone in the game relevant and uh and still feeling like they're, you know, they're contributing into into the the actual game. So, the leveling up I really really enjoy because each of these cards are multi-use in the sense that they could be used for defense or they could be used for movement or they could be used for their ability and the like even the starting heroes cuz they they go up to level four.

Yeah, star value four. Um, obviously the game doesn't have you start with any of those. you uh you start with it recommends like hey here are these two and here are those two and from the get-go when you are playing this game you immediately can see why they pair those two together the synergies between one another and even then after you're done playing like your first game it's like oh well let's just try a different pairing let's try these same four heroes and swap matchups like we can take I think it's uh oh I'd have to look look through There is Broen the Destroyer, Aryan the Tidemaster, Wasp the War Maiden, and Zaratha the change. Those are the four that it starts with. Um, and they recommend that it's Broen and Aryen compared to uh, you know, paired together. And then Zaratha and Wasp the War Maiden. And you could just play play that and have a fantastic time. And you could play that exact same team up against one another and really feel like a completely different strategy because as you play more and more of this game, you're going to really understand what your opponents can do and what you can do. And that type of gameplay might not be for everyone, but there is zero zero luck in this game.

So, I mean, whether you feel, you know, superior by reading better, like reading your opponent better than they read you, or you feel stupid because your opponent's reading you better than you're reading them, that's just going to be the kind of game that it is. So, if you don't like those, if you like a little bit of randomness or chance thrown into a game, this doesn't have any of that. Uh, but what's also fantastic about the heroes is I just love how they give each hero one, a backstory. who cares? But then also kind of like here's what they do. Here's their stats. Like, oh, Zaratha has maxed out attack. And some of them will say, you know, will be in like a lighter color. My assumption, I don't even think the rules explain that, but I think that the lighter color kind of is like based off of how they level up. But then they also have roles that they place. So, Zaratha, the change is a tactician, pusher, disabler, durable, and sniper.

Well, she's just all around. While W was the war maiden, is just a disabler, tactician, and sniper. And then you have Aryan the Tidemaster. Tactician, disabler, durable, and pusher. And Rogue, the destroyer, durable, disabler, pusher, and farming. So, I don't believe the rules kind of explain what those what those roles are. Maybe they do, and I just missed it. I don't think they do, but Oh, they do. Wow. I just have literally never read that advanced hero selection. Uh, yep. All of those roles they do explain. So, that's pretty pretty cool. Uh, oh, maybe they even explained brighter section of the stat bars are conditional. May depend on triggering specific cards. Fantastic. It is in there. So, the heroes are absolutely fantastic. I have loved every single one that I've played.

Um, and the other amazing thing about this game is it's not long. Your you actually get to set the game length. Whether you want it to be short or long is dependent on how many push changes do you want. Short game is three, long game is five. And that basically means if one side wins a push and then the other side wins the push and it goes back to the middle, that that will basically flip a token over. And that's two pushes in a short game out of three. So, whoever wins the next push wins the game. In a fi in a long game, you just go back and forth until four times and then the next push wins the game because either you're going to win by doing two consecutive pushes or you're going to win by defeating heroes a certain number of times. Um, I I really really respect that this game is not overly long, especially because the last time I played this, I was teaching new people and it was just something that felt very intuitive. One person wasn't really into board games all that much. Uh, they were just kind of invited to a game day and hopped right into a game like this. Um, and pretty much just got got it right away.

And then the other two are kind of newer into the board gaming since I started gaming with them. So, I was like, "Ah, okay. We'll just see how this goes." And it went extremely well. So, the fact that this game is incredibly easy to pick up, not long to play, actually, you do you determine how long it is, and has insane insanely high depth to the characters and to the play style is almost an anomaly because it's kind of like that triangle of like what is it? free time, money, or sleep, or it's like you can only have two of the three. And this this game is like, oh, do you want it to be simple? Do you want it to be fun? Or do you want it to be uh do you want it to be short? You can only have two. Well, this game has all three. Uh so I really really like it. And it has actually kind of it's from the group that after we were done playing it, I was like, should this be a staple? And I've never offered that to be any game.

Normally, I have so many games coming in that I kind of just want to keep cycling out new ones. So, replaying a game is very rare. And I'm not even I'm I'm not even anybody. I just buy games cuz I'm an idiot. Uh so, it's like, should this game be a staple? Because I feel like this would be an amazing one to always bring and start off a game day with. Now, there are a couple things, and these aren't really negatives, but they are things to be uh taken into consideration when looking to buy this game. One is they do something, this is again, like I said, it's not a negative, but they do something very fascinating with the cards. And the rules specifically go out of their way to say you either do all of the card or none of it. A lot of games out there are if you can't do if you can't do it then do as much as you can.

This game does not have that. It is very hypers specific on its text. And if you like the example that they give is Broen has a card that says move forward in a straight line two spaces then attack an adjacent minion. The example they give is oh well Broen is already adjacent to a minion so does he have to move? Yes, he does have to move. He can't willingly choose to not move and then attack the minion next to him. He has to move forward two spaces. So, if he moves forward two spaces and can't attack anyone, he can't play that card. Well, you can play it for its movement or its secondary action, but he can't do it for um you know, he can't just be like, "Oh, okay. I'll move and then just not attack. It's all or nothing." Now, there's a couple reasons why this can be a positive and a negative. From the positive standpoint, it makes it makes, you know, second guessing or guesswork completely out the window. Unless you don't really understand the way a card is worded, then it could actually throw the game. But it like that's that's the positive. Like this is what it says. I have cleave. Target a unit adjacent to you after the attack may repeat once on a different enemy hero. And the reason why I have this card, and I'm glad I actually happened to grab this hero, is because this says, "Target a unit adjacent to you." Okay, if there's a unit adjacent to a unit counts as a hero or a minion, cool. After the attack may repeat once on a different enemy hero,

that means that your first attack can be against a hero or a minion, but the second attack has to be on a hero. And and so in this case, this says May. So you can use cleave and just hit a minion or one unit. There doesn't have to be a second unit next to you. But if there is a second unit, you can only use that secondary attack on a hero. So like that's kind of how hypersp specific these cards can be. And if you misinterpret a card or if you, you know, would rather have some flexibility on the way that your hero works, that could be uh a negative for you just because, you know, you could feel very restrictive because so many things are are like, well, I need this to be in this way. And that's how like some a lot of the characters like Wasp the War Maiden is a disabler.

A lot of her cards are hyper specific. They could be really really powerful if you are in the right situation. And that's how disablers are. It's like, man, I'm not really doing much, but man, oh man, whenever I'm actually in the right position, this is going to be painful. Um, so that's that's one kind of thing to bring up. The second, and this is probably my biggest negative, and I get why they were doing it, but for some reason, they really, really wanted that aspect of no communication. Almost like that fog of war element of like, oh, I can know how fast you going. I'm going medium fast. It's like, just give me the number. Like, who? Like, shut up. I've never been a huge fan of fog of war, especially in cooperative games.

Uh, so I usually, especially if the game is fully cooperative where it's like, why do we have to, you know, beat around the bush on what we're doing? Let's just play the game and co- like the game should be designed to be difficult enough that we can openly communicate. This game almost wanted that element on why you can't talk to your teammate. And you can, sorry, you can talk to your teammate until cards are played. Because one thing I I guess I haven't mentioned is you play one card per round and you will only ever have five cards in your hand. So once you set a card down to play and everyone reveals them, you cannot communicate with your teammate at all. So like if you if you were like, "Oh, okay. You play that. If you go here, that means I can do this." That's out the window. You are not allowed to do that. And the reason why they say is one, I guess it's to prevent quarterbacking, but that should be a group thing, a group decision, not a game decision. And the second is to act like that thematic element of like you're too busy playing and focused on your role that you don't have time to type in the chat on how your opponent just cost you the game or whatever it might be. Because if your opponent goes to do something and we and I've had this in the last game I played where there was a a position I wanted my teammate to go to because it was going to work well and he didn't and I just

kind of had to sit there and be like, "All right, well hopefully he's strategizing in a different way than I am." So that is for me it's a negative because it's like I'd rather just be able to openly communicate with my teammate and be based off you know how how we're going to strategize to beat the opposing team cuz they they also don't even allow like you can't even be like oh hey should I play this? You're supposed to be very open about it. Hey should I pay pay play threatening slash for its five plus attack? Okay. Hey, hey guys. Hey, uh, opposing team, here is what I am going to play. Figure out a way to counter this. I really don't like that. I think that you should be able to strategize with your teammate as really any way that you want because it feels like the game is like, hey, how about you just don't just don't talk to one another. Just don't play the game.

Just I know you're on a team. your teammate. Don't don't tell them anything because whatever you're going to tell them, you're going to tell your opponent. And that would work if you if you had like a lot of cards that were close to your chest, if you had a whole deck and they didn't know what cards you had. But this game isn't like that. On your turn, you have one of five cards that you can play at the start. And you take one of them, you put it down, you flip it, and it stays there. You're playing up to four cards. So your opponents can look over and see, ah, they played their yellow. That is their highest initiative card. So, we know that one of their two attacks is gone. Or, oh, they it's turn four. They have their yellow and red. They cannot attack this turn. If I remember right, that means they have their blue and their green left.

1 2 3 4 foot five. They have their blue left, whatever it might be. Uh oh, no, because it'd be the fourth turn. So, you'd have Yeah, their blue or their green left. Well, those are their defensive cards. Hm. How can I best counter that? So, the fact that you are not technically allowed to show your teammate and just be like, "Hey, should I play this?" Or like, "Oh, what do you got over there? Oh, okay. If you play that, then that means I can try and do this and that would work here." Now, this is a pseudo negative, and I bring it up because it's technically in the rules, but you could easily house rule it and just be like, "Fuck it. Just let just have play the game however you want to play." If you really really like that that metaness that that thematic reasoning of why you can't talk to your teammate, then play the rules as written or modify it. Say, "Okay, you can't talk to your teammate when cards are flipped, but you can show them your hand." You can kind of be like, "Hey, should I play this?" You can do that or just make it fully open communication, whatever works best for your group. I just bring it up as a negative because they do really harp on it in the game. So yeah, those are pretty much really my only only two negatives because everything else about the about this game is extremely clean.

It is very straightforward. There is no randomness. It's not like well let's hope I hit. And it's funny because last game I played I was actually playing I was not playing Sargoth. was playing Wasp, the Warb Maiden, and she has a card that is kind of like this AoE. Anything in this radius can't enter. Um, and anything in this radius, anything outside this radius can't enter. Anything in this radius can't leave. And I was like, okay, this is going to be amazing because Broen has this open lane where he's going to run in and hit me and he's far enough that he won't be able to do it. Cool, cool, cool, cool. And I put it down. I'm like, sweet. And then we flip it and the other guy, the guy who was playing cuz I was playing with new people was playing Ary and the Tidemaster. He has a card that basically counters other people's skills and he had never played that card this entire game. And then so he plays it, cancels my skill, Broken comes in, hits me, I think just straight up kills me. Uh, and I was like, there's like I didn't even think that you would have canled that. I literally was in the perfect position for this card to be useful and it uh and it didn't work.

So that's just kind of like a one example of of great synergy between teammates and trying to counter one another. And that entire game I was just getting wiped like they were just really for some reason focused on me and leaving my my teammate to kind of just run around and kill a bunch of minions. Um the other really cool thing about this is that there's no health. Like heroes only have one hit point. So if you are hit and it takes a group effort to try and defeat a hero because they have multiple ways to defend. So it's getting attacked is actually double-edged sword one because if you don't defend, then you're going to straight up die. You only have one hit point. So if it if an attack goes through, whoop, you just go back. And I mean you get to continue like you just spawn back but that is a point for your team uh for the opposing team. The second is if you attack or if you are attacked and you defend you're down a card. You have to discard a card to defend. And you can only discard a card with a defense value.

Even if you have passive defense that's like oh I'm surrounded by all my minions and I have a passive defense of three so my natural defense is five. and your attack is five, so I defend. You still have to discard a card that has a defense value even. And so you are losing a card. And if you're attack twice, if you don't get yourself killed, you do not get a turn four. And what's amazing about that, again, this is based off the last game I played. I was for sure thinking that I was actually going to die cuz I was being attacked multiple times. But just the way it was, the opposing team didn't have any more attacks and the attack that they have, they couldn't get to me to do it. So, cuz I had just one card I had left remaining allowed me to move and then that was it.

So it is just such a an amazingly clean game and every hero just plays radically different from one another. So uh I I mean personally though I have not played a difficulty four hero so I don't know how like how they are. I don't know if it's like oh yeah know level fours they're just kind of a little bit more complex. I don't know if they're hyper specific on what they want or whatever it might be on the difficulty to control them, but I mean with just I mean over 30 heroes, you have pretty much an endless supply of of replayability with this game. Yeah, this might not be a game that always hits the table, but it is one game that I mean, if I'm trying to do regular game days and this is going to be the staple, then this this could be really like an alltimer strategy game for me. Um, oh, the other negative is for some dumb reason Guards of Atlantis 2 came in a thin box.

No idea why. I think like here's the thin box. For some reason they because I think the first edition or or Guards of Atlantis one had a big box for storage and stuff and this reprint they went with this the narrowest box ever and like five it's almost like those primal expansions these five hero packs. So, it's like either you really size down and just kind of have a bunch of stuff in bags or you have five expansion boxes lying around. It's It's so stupid. I really really hate that decision whenever they could have easily just made a storage solution. Oh, and also the fact that I mean I just have the playmat out here. Uh but there's multiple boards also. There's this is the one that they just kind of recommend you start with. But then on there's one on the back and then there's another play map that I have. So there's four maps and uh those obviously you could take again the same four heroes that the game recommends you start with and play on a different map and that's going to change how you're going to be playing those heroes. I just love these kinds of games. They're so much fun.

This one is a little bit harder to get to the table because it requires 2v2 but well I I guess I should say it doesn't require 2v2. You can play this as a two-player game, but you're controlling two heroes. So, it's four heroes regardless. It's not like they change the rules or the maps or anything to account for one v one. You are controlling two heroes. And I have done that. The very first time I played this game was at two. And I think it becomes way more stressful because whenever you're playing as a 2v2, you're just relying on what your hero can do and trying to Yeah, you might talk to your teammate if you're allowed to and then you might be like, "Okay, here's a situation, but everyone is doing that. Everyone's just focused on their one hero." And when you're playing as a two-player game, you have to try and synergize. I I guess there's a positive.

You are your own teammate. So, you can synergize. Okay, if I do this with this hero, then I can look over with these cards and I can do this and this. I can look at the board. But I felt that it became way more stressful, a lot more strategic because it's just you against one other opponent. So it could become Yeah, it just becomes a little bit more intense, I think. But it is completely viable and you are able to play this game at two. Uh but I much prefer this game honestly at four, which is rare. like it's it's normally the other way around. Anyway, I can't think of anything else uh to talk about with this game. So, on a scale of 1 to 10, I'm going to give Guards of Atlantis 2 a nine. I really, really like it. It's not a 10 because this is a game that will barely hit the table unless I'm able to consistently get game days where I bring it all the time, but it is a a phenomenal achievement for a game of this caliber. and I I really really like it. So that's it everyone. That's my thoughts on Guards of Atlantis 2. Let me know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, com, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time update it is for you.

Progress saved