Cascadia Review | Pacific Northwest Puzzling
Transcript
hey I'm Ryan this is my brother Daniel and this is rolls in the family and today we are reviewing Cascadia a puzzly nature themed tile laying game yes and if you enjoy games with simple rules where you get to work on your own little puzzle then Cascadia might just be a great pick for you and as always we've got a link down to Cascade down to Cascadia down below whatever that is nailed it Ryan let's jump right into the review in Cascadia you are building out your own landscape filled with different habitats and Wildlife puzzling everything together to score the most points for large groups of the same terrain and meeting the scoring conditions for each animal type each turn has you selecting one of four pairings each with one habitat tile and one Wildlife token which are then added to your personal area habitat tiles adjacent Tenny existing tile and Wildlife tokens on to any open tile that shows that animal type a new habitat Wildlife pairing is drawn to replace what was selected with the occasional clearing of animal tiles when there are too many of the same type once all tiles have been drafted final scores are determined by scoring how well each player grouped their habitat tiles as well as how effectively their animals meet the conditions on the corresponding Wildlife cards the heart of Cascadia is found in the intertwining of two puzzles trying to group tiles of the same terrain type and arranging the animals on top of those terrains you are always forced to take a Terrain tile and
Wildlife token that have been paired together leading to a lot of interesting tradeoffs as you weigh how much you value each of the options that are available each tile that you place limits which animals can be placed there in the future so you are always thinking ahead to how you can keep the second layer of the puzzle flexible at the same time you don't want to waste any turns so you are always trying to select an animal that you are currently able to place inevitably there will be times when none of the pairings work well for you but the game gives you a tool in the form of nature tokens that can be acquired when an animal is placed on specific Keystone tiles while you can hold on to these for a point at the end of the game it is often more valuable to spend them for the powerful abilities of either selecting a tile and animal that are not paired together or replacing the animals with new ones from the bag there's a certain element of pusher is you decide how flexible to keep your animal placement options and how aggressively to pursue high-scoring Wildlife Arrangements that may require many of one type of animal it is often players that can balance keeping their options open with optimizing placements across both layers of the puzzle that come out on top Cascadia plays well from two to four players and if you want to get more of your puzzling fix there is also a solid solo mode the inviting nature theme is certainly helpful when introducing the game to new players and there are some clever ways the theme is evoked in the wildlife scoring conditions but it is mostly window
dressing on a dual layered spatial puzzle while the turn-by-turn decisions are simple and the pairings are drawn randomly there is a lot of room to optimize your scoring and have skillful play determine the Victor at the end of the game there are some hints at interaction with the habitat scoring at the end of the game but there is no doubt that almost the entirety of the game is focusing on building your own independent puzzle in front of you there is a little bit of setup as you remove tiles based on the number of players but still relatively quick to get playing cascadia's low rule complexity is one of its big strengths in introducing it to new players but there are still a handful of modern mechanisms here that need to be understood each game of Cascadia is going to feel fairly similar but there's some nice variety from the different Wildlife scoring conditions and the randomly drawn tiles ensure that your landscape develops differently each time you play the drafting in Cascadia always requires you to take a tile and an animal together a decision that is more interesting and nuanced than selecting just one in isolation you're always assessing the value of two pieces to determine the overall value of the pair which has a nice complexity but the inclusion of only four pairs keeps the decision space from feeling like too much every decision you make is with two different puzzles in mind and there's a lot of satisfaction that can come from optimizing both both layers of the puzzle simultaneously that optimization feels tight since if you always play your Wildlife token you will only ever
have three available spaces that do not already have an animal this also has the nice side effect of making the game easier for players that don't perfectly optimize a missed Wildlife token permanently increases the number of open tiles you will have available at any given time one of the key reasons Cascadia appeals to a wide range of players is it's flexibility and gameplay depth casual players can enjoy simply selecting Pairs and building their landscape without the pressure to perfectly optimize habitats and Wildlife while more strategic players can focus on maximizing every decision for a more complex thinky experience the game even works well with younger kids as the rules are straightforward and there's little risk of them forgetting or breaking core mechanics even if they don't fully optimize their scoring opportunities and for a game that is easy to get to the table with a variety of groups it is a huge benefit to have different versions of the wildlife scoring that you can mix up from game to game a lot of the variations feel very similar but it is just enough to keep the experience fresh over repeated plays since the terrain bonuses can have a big impact on scoring strategic players will want to be aware of how they compare to other players however this means a lot of looking across the table and trying to count tiles which can not only slow down the game but can make players feel like they'd rather just wing it and see what happens even at the expense of optimal strategic play and now let's get to our personal ratings for Cascadia so
I'm going to be coming in with an eight out of 10 for Cascadia this has been a game that I I've really enjoyed the times that I've gotten it to the table and I wondered if it was going to kind of have the longevity for me um and I think it does like I think I definitely lean more into the side of like some who wants to think harder with this type of puzzle are you saying as in opposition to me yeah unlike Dango who his capacity his capacity just you know is so much lower okay I just want to clarify uh you know because we've played it with people um that just kind of enjoy the process of it and are having fun you're getting points kind of regardless of what you do um but you can if you want to like optimize as much as possible in the game this can get prettyy brain burning and I personally like that the kind of two layers and how do I keep this you know as efficient as I can doing all this and making sure that I have the spots for the animals and everything um and so I think it just has enough um interest with that dual layer puzzle to to keep keep me coming back um I know recently we got to try the the expansion to it I did get the landmarks expansion which I think is helping to solidify it as something that I want to continue playing you know it add some interesting things in that expansion um that I wouldn't play with people that hadn't played the game much but had some interesting things of like some other scoring opportunities and actually by taking them you know we talked about how if you always play efficiently you
always have three spots that you can put animals well if you play perfectly efficiently and take one of those landmarks you're actually using up one of those and constraining yourself even more um so I think it leans even more into that like how how uh hard do you want to make it on yourself as you're thinking thinking through this um but man is it nice to have a game in The Collection that you're just so kind of confident in the combination of the theme and the like Simplicity of the rules set that it's like it's just a game you feel like you can go confidently into to teach to a variety of groups and like I just think people are going to like this game um and it's gone over super well I mean with a lot of different people um so it it manages to strike that balance right of being easy to teach fun to you know introduce to people and most people enjoy it but I still enjoying playing it and feel like I could play it over and over and not get tired of it yeah um so yeah Sol solid 8 out of 10 for me I'm curious for you you started by playing my I had it originally you've since added it to your collection but I remember I have vivid memories of Daniel uh looking pretty pretty uh elated over his Cascadia Tableau there um yes that's right and that is why I'm GNA be coming in with an 8.5 out of 10 for Cascadia um this this game for me really is kind of one of the definitive uh family weight style you
know games that I have I mean it has so much going for it uh to make it one of like the top games that I go to uh for maybe people newer to board games or just or looking for something just strategic but simple kind of you know um kind of one of those uh Gateway Games and I think first you know you did talk about the theme it really does just have an inviting theme and you know I think a lot of games right now are capitalizing on the the nature thing I think it it's like overdone at this it's like everyone's doing it and I tell you wingspan broke open the flood gates after wingspan was so successful yeah and so you know it's got uh it that part is is inviting I think the fact that I can teach it so fast I mean I just taught it recently uh to uh another couple and that's just it's so awesome when you have a game that you know is is a still fun for yourself so it's not like it's got like no rules and you know not very little rules and you're like okay I don't really but it's like it's got a lot of meat to it in terms of the decision space but man the rules are simple and you can just it makes sense very quickly how the game plays and so uh you know it's got that going for it um and then it's just the pair drafting is one of my favorite things like it feels like such a like almost copout mechanism it's like just put two things together oh suddenly we have a really interesting
decision I know it really is well and I think we both love just drafting in general you know kind of you know whether it's car drafting or or chip drafting you know whatever it whatever that mechanic cover kind of plays out but man putting putting two things together and it's not just that okay there's two things together that you're drafting but then because that's both the landscape going out and an animal going out and everything you're you're trying to optimize and so it you're trying to figure out the perfect way for things to come together and so you're kind of constricted uh in in terms of you know optimizing in the best way possible and that's just a for people who like to think harder and want that this game gives it to you in Spades that it is you got to be really good at planning and you know and there's been many times where I'm like oh my gosh I messed it all up you I messed this up because I you know missed this but man when you get it when you have a game where it all comes together and you you just you know knock it out of the park with optimizing feels like you know all of your animals and your Landscapes are your terrain you know all comes together that is so rewarding and so for a game that is that simple but can give such a rewarding uh experience for people wanting you know a little more uh meat on the bone uh to a game um that for me it just it really
hits a sweet spot uh in my in my game collection there so yeah I think dangel still dreams about his his perfect hexagon of Haw that just scored it was whatever the scoring was for like pairs across from each other and it was like literally you could not have optimized oh that was just such a I think that play alone elevated cascad one of the greatest board gaming memories I have Ryan I tell you what there you go right up there well those are our thoughts on Cascadia but the real question is is Cascadia a game that you should check out if you want meaningful player interaction or aren't drawn to crunchy spatial puzzles then Cascadia might not be for you but if you want an accessible and broadly appealing puzzle game that is quick to teach and play and gives players the flexibility to think as little or as deeply as they prefer then Cascadia is an excellent choice hey if you think Cascadia might just be the right pick for your group you can check it out below um following the link in the description otherwise we got some other videos here that you can check out in the channel and we will see you in the next one