Earth - Board Game Review - Relentless Flora & Fungi
Transcript
before we get started does anyone want to get out hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences we'll get on with the show in just a minute but first a quick word for my sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kiander.co.uk kielder stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on audio is over 30 pound further discounts on bulk purchases and even five percent of your spending refunded bacteria's points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get five percent discount on your first order over 60 pounds so let's make gaps in your collection a thing of the past get down to kinder and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so today in terms of the hotness I am diving into a little volcano as I take a detailed look at Earth from Maxine tardiff and inside up games if you have not heard of this game's existence then what cave have you been sealing yourself up in for the last few weeks in terms of reviews this game has been buzzed about like crazy the hype factor for this game was already high when it was on Kickstarter and when
it was just about to fulfill but then when Ice Tower and various other channels have been giving out reviews with this and I've seen nothing but nines and tens for this with barely a negative word said my God the the train is soaring at high speed of everybody telling everybody how great this game is and how everybody needs to play it immediately so naturally as the self-proclaimed biggest curmudgeon of the board gaming industry on the internet I need to give this one a look and see whether this game is justifying all that hype and one of the best games of 2023 or one of the most overrated titles of board gaming history and in the interest of honesty this is my own copy of Earth I backed this on Kickstarter last year I've paid my 55 Euros or whatever it was for it which to be fair is actually pretty cheap for a Kickstarter these days and of course this is my copy my stuff I'm giving it my own Fair honest thoughts here so ladies and gentlemen you ready for this over thousands of years of evolution and adaptation the floor and Fauna of this unique planet have grown and developed into amazing life forms creating symbiotic ecosystems and habitats Earth is an open world engine builder for one to five players with simple rules but tons of strategic possibilities the objective in Earth is to score as many victory points as possible to do this you will plant cards to create your own Island a 16 card tablet arranged as a
grid four cards wide by four cards tall the game ends at the end of a round after a player plants their 16th card which completes their Island players will take it in turns to trigger one of the actions on their player board doing the top action for themselves and everybody else around the table conducting the bottom action these actions allow players to plant cards and drawer cards but also gain various resources such as soil composted cards and Sprout cubes and tree trunks which gain you points but also act as their own little subcurrency for card effects in the game after the action is resolved all players are then able to go for their entire Tableau of cards from the top left to the bottom right triggering all the abilities on those cards that correspond to the same color of the action that was just taken with a huge deck of unique cards as well as a wide variety of objective scoring cards and even personal setup cards for islands and climates this game certainly has enough variety to make your engine as varied as possible it's time to jump into these rich environments and create some amazing natural synergies that replicate and extrapolate on Earth's amazing versatility and plethora of Natural Resources thank you as with all nature games you see the same stuff appear on the internet with regards to what to compare Earth to the same ones get mentioned and some of them make sense some of them make no sense whatsoever here's my thoughts firstly Arc Nova people know this is one of my favorite Euro games in fact one of my favorite games of all time you're building a zoo it's got lots of cards
with photographic you know pictures on them much like the ones in here and of course people want to know if this is better than that look arcanova is fundamentally different to this game yes you both build up a tableau of cards in front of you and that's about as much as the similarities end I mean assume they're all about nature which they are but arganova has the action row mechanic it's got a lot more like moving Parts within it it's got the spatial awareness of your map you know all of that is not present in Earth Earth is a much lighter Affair than Arc Nova it's a much shorter Affair than Arc Nova and honestly I wouldn't really even put the two in the same comparison now Wings man on the other hand this one does have more similarities to that both again involve you building up a tableau of cards each has cards with abilities that trigger off at different stages of the game and you can make those various abilities more powerful or make actions more powerful by getting the right abilities in the right places even some of the factors of scoring here the fact that every Sprout you get is a point well those eggs and wings man every card that you get in your compost disappointment will so I'll tucked cards in wingspan and honestly if you've played wingspan I feel that I can actually teach this game to you Easier by just comparing Concepts however with the two being similar wingspan is still probably a bit more streamlined than this game is overall in terms of its feel and certainly I suspect from its look it's definitely got a slight component upgrade over this one there'll be plenty of time to discuss your objections when and if you return now where I would compare this
one to mainly is games such as Aries Expedition Aries expedition was a spin-off of terraforming Mars where you you chose a different action each round you got one version of it and everybody else got a slightly less powerful version of it and you were building up again a tableau of cards you were getting icons and you were triggering abilities you were building up an engine with essentially a deck of cards you had the small like map thing in the middle but it was kind of inconsequential really it was mainly just about the cards honestly when I played this I was tying things back to Aries Expedition more with elements of wingspan thrown in but I think the comparisons to Arc Nova just don't really fit the bill you know there's a lot of nature games that come out and naturally everybody wants to compare them to the same games over and over again but if we're thinking logically about this a bit more closer to Aries Expedition than I think than Arc Nova and wingspan but there are definitely some similarities to wingspan now aesthetically Earth is definitely a looker on the table it's not glowing with component quality there are some Basics they have to do I'm not a fan of these very like very fiddly little spindly soil pieces and Sprout cubes I mean it's a cube it's green great it looks the part but then I do like these trunk pieces with the canopies on top some of them don't fit together brilliantly but most of them do and you know so the component quality is decent enough bear in mind this game what costs like 55 Euro whenever on Kickstarter
delivered that's cheaper Kickstarter You Gotta Give It credit but where this game shines is the look of the cards themselves the cards themselves are not the best equality they're standard quality you may want to sleeve some of these cards more on that in a second but they use photography but all the pictures and others I think that's the best way to do it people like to give photography a bad rap they say oh you couldn't afford an artist use photography shut up Wesley excuse me most people can't draw a hyena for example as good as the photographers can okay you know photography is a form of art it is still a medium in this industry okay it works in Arc Nova and although I think that uses a mix of Art and photography it's kind of way I think it's photography with a filter and use in arkanova here it looks like it's basically pure photography and it looks spectacular okay I look at Kyushu as it koshu or whatever you pronounce it the island here I want to go visit this island you know the Atacama Desert lovely picture these different flowers and fauna and mushrooms and that everything looks beautiful the camera is probably not doing Justice to what I'm seeing in front of me right now just so much color booms out of this game that it always turns heads as soon as anybody walks past and that's that's even not even including the cover which is so gorgeous I want it on my wall this is where the Aesthetics of this game shine even if component quality Wise It's still built to a budget the rules of the game are actually pretty
straightforward as well if you are teaching this to Gamers gamers are going to pick this up in no time at all because we're used to a lot of these things like card abilities and these little rules about oh I could combo this with this and that and no one this you know that sort of stuff comes naturally to us after playing games for a lot and the rulebook itself is not particularly huge and it certainly has a lot of pictorial representation and a lot of decent sized font so for the most part the rulebook does a good job we'll get on to the solo rules a little bit later on but for the most part this is quite an easy game to learn the basics of how it plays and if you want an even easier way to learn it then just go check out Paul grogan's gaming rules video via the QR code on here and you get a 20 minute video that basically explains everything you need to know about the game it really is a sound way to learn it so getting to grips with the starting point of this game is really straightforward now the complexity comes into triggering all these abilities we'll get onto that a little bit later on but the graphic design does a good job of making that a little bit easier to understand by not having a ton of text on the cards most of the text in this game is basically on some of the scoring objectives and you kind of need the text in these in this part but with all the cards I've got down here you've got flavor text at the bottom which is good to learn stuff but everything else is done by color banners with iconography there's a lot of it but you do have a resource guide on your board to help you with this but it's not good for colorblind people there's nothing in these abilities to distinguish them from each other so
you've got a red a blue a yellow and a dark green ability and then you've also got brown and you've also got black so if you're colorblind you're going to struggle to actually know which of these abilities is what dog Pig loaf of bread System error the game has an impressive amount of variety with the cards and everything I mean this this deck here is all part of the cards and I haven't even got it out of the pack to play a solo game here for example yeah but you still have a bunch of cards here and that's not even including this bunch of cards and this bunch of cards oh yeah and the cards I've got down here there's quite a lot in this deck it has to be set and on top of that you've then got a lot of different Island cards which you just differentiated setups except they're all double-sided same for the climate cards these give you a special ability and again all double-sided and then you've got a lot of these ecosystem cards which you should really throw into every game even in a beginner game and again double-sided and these double-sided there's certainly a lot of variation although don't assume that just because there's a lot of variation it's all entirely unique there is a lot of repetition with some of these abilities you may have one for example that says if you can do a continuous line for your Tableau only of sun habitats you get this many points there'll be one for sun there'll be one for water there'll be one for rock and there'll be one for snow and then another one there'll be you know nine cards with a soil cost of less than three you know less than three there's your objective turn it over and it's the exact opposite cards with a cost of more
than Free Soil so a lot of these abilities are varied but there's basically a lot of reversals and a lot of oh I just substitute this icon for this icon Earth's party piece there is in regards to the lack of downtime in this game this game has next to no downtime whatsoever for the most part we'll get on to that a little bit later but with this game because you trigger an action everybody else gets to do the lesser action as well so nobody's just sitting around waiting for an action to come round to them but on top of that you've got so many abilities on this Tableau by the end of the game that you are constantly going right I need to lose action right I'll get this bit of soil and then maybe I'll grab this uh canopy tree okay cool right go from the top left right so I can discard one of those and get two of these and then I can guarantee with those get another couple of these we'll put those on there and then all that lets me uh you know draw a couple of cards all right I'll draw a couple of cards uh let's see I've got to get rid of a free into my compost I'll take this one oh I draw another two compost take this one get another Cube more soil you have to kind of have your thinking cap on for this game because this one makes you chain abilities and combos all the time without rest you don't get a chance to take five and have a breather you will be doing your turn triggering all these abilities and by the time you've gone right that's good oh next action oh my goodness next one and then rinse repeat over and over again you can have turns with a couple of actions to do you could have a turn where you've got to trigger about 12
different abilities on your board and you know what for games where I tend to rag on them for having too much downtime it's nice and refreshing to have something that keeps you engaged throughout pretty much the entirety of the game but then this can lead on to a negative effect as well which we'll get on to a bit later but yeah the claims that this game has little to no downtime are true this one really does force you to just be constantly engaged you're going to burn in a very special level of hell now try not to kill me with pitchforks at this point people because no game is ever Flawless no matter how much I love it this is no exception and there are a few caveats worth mentioning now I have mentioned before that the rules are fairly easy to learn they are but people are kind of coming out and saying that this game is really approachable to just about anybody um just about anybody you might want to be a little bit more specific on that if you're a gamer you will pick this up in no time at all I mean it took me no time at all to learn the rules of this game and I've taught it to people pretty easily but some people will get caught up with this you have got to chain a ton of abilities by mid-game here in the early game it's not so bad but once you've got half of this Tableau filled or three quarters of it filled you've got so much stuff triggering on this board that anybody who is not very good at processing abilities on cards is going to trip up and constantly like fall on their face here don't know I've gone cross-eyed you're waiting for
certain players to be able to process access all this stuff going on and because it's Relentless that person doesn't get a chance to have a a little breather a little bit of like catch up so those people need to be a little bit more hesitant about playing a game like this wingspan for example is a lot more streamlined you don't have anywhere near as many abilities to trigger you maybe have like three or four tops and that's a good number and not all of them are ones that you would trigger and some of them are pretty straightforward anyway here you've got up to 16 cards worth of abilities here all the cards have some kind of ability on them yeah some of them might have already had their effect or they only trigger on certain times but you've still got to go through this entire thing and process it and I would not put this in front of anybody who is new to games or even remotely prone to analysis paralysis because any AP player is going to grind this game to a halt anybody who is relatively new to Games should stay away from this at all until you're comfortable with games or games where you have card tables with triggering abilities never if anybody tries to tell you this is a gateway game or something that they would teach to families or something I'd be very wary about such claims I know we Gamers skew the weight of games here that's putting in mildly 007 now I have mentioned that this game does have little to no downtime top marks do not confuse that for multiplayer interaction though this game has none of it there
are two aspects of this game that has you caring about the other players and even then it is with a minimal level of care firstly the action that you do on here you can't gauge whether an action is going to be beneficial for others or not other than potentially seeing that they have a low amount of soil to plant cards but there are cards in here that cost cheap so if they've got cards in their hand chances are they'll have something they can play so yes there's little to no downtime as a result of this mechanic but I'm not choosing my action based on other people I'm purely doing it for me the fact that what they've got on their Tableau I don't care about you won't be able to see what's on their Tableau for the most part you can pick out a growth Cube you can pick out a tree that's sticking out other cards but you have no way that you could have Zumo Vision to read the text and abilities and all that stuff on these cards and make any kind of influential decision on your action based on what they are doing on top of that the only other minor bit of interaction are these Brown objective cards where it's a milestone like terraforming Mars but again how on Earth can you possibly gauge whether you're anywhere close to that race or not okay I have to get three or more black abilities right well okay that's a little bit easier to tell on certain people's boards but then 10 cards with an even Victory point value yeah um unless you're gonna go around other people's tableaus and take photos with your mobile phone there is no way you can gauge whether somebody's got eight nine seven whatever of even Victory Point cards the text is too
small and there's just too much on the table going on for you to make those kind of judgment calls so it just ends up being kind of random when these Milestones get done you know these particular Milestones here it it just happens it's not like I'm going ah we were so close in that no it's just a case of oh you've done it now all right cool all right oh you've done that one all right fine right I've now done this one yeah not exactly interaction is it people I beg to differ sir and you may think well how does that differ from wingspan in Arc Nova wingspan is easier to tell what people have on their boards because it's clearer on the cards not to mention it's a lot quicker to look at Art Nova I can glance at anybody else's Tablo and art and over and instantly calculate how many icons they have a particular type because they stand out they're big they're colorful they're distinguished I got no idea what VP values everybody has on their growth bits or you know I can't count everybody's Sprout Cube at the other end of the table that's not gonna happen but I can in other games and so with the player count it means little to no downtime great but you could play this with two players or five players and the gameplay is still exactly the same except that when you have less players you don't have the problem as much of your lowest common denominator making the game slower for you if you've got five players in this game be very wary because there's a lot of cards out there a lot of people grabbing for stuff and even then you might be thinking well I've done all my abilities fine but then somebody else over there might have
quite a lot of abilities to trigger and isn't very good at processing them very quickly so there's no downtime with the action per se but once you've done your abilities you might have to wait a little bit for that person to hurry up with their abilities and if they're slow it's gonna drag the game out this game does have a little bit of fragility to it with regards to increasing the player count you can play it with more fine there's pretty much no reason to though five is right out there is certainly quite a bit of luck in this game as well I mean it's more approachable it's an easier game it's not as complicated as some of those other ones so naturally you're gonna have to expect a bit of card draw luck but in this one you have quite a bit of it compared to some other games you can potentially draw a lot of cards and have a lot in your hand but these objectives are pretty specific as they what they want and sometimes you just get lucky or unlucky it to try to fulfill them you know one ability might have free you know wants you to get two multi-color abilities two doesn't sound like a lot I played a game where three other players could not find multi-color abilities I couldn't get two until the late game somebody was able to get about six or seven and some others never saw a single one in the game no matter how many cards they drew and that's for an easy objective other ones here where it's like I need 10 cards with an even VP count okay well I'll draw a bunch of cards well let's see I mean that's even that's even that's odd odd odd and odd okay so I found two out of six cards and then I find oh wait but I can't play
that because that's too much soil or if I play that that hurts me in other respects you and even with like some of the ability ones like I need red abilities and you just can't find them I need ones with geographical names I just can't find them and that can be slightly annoying you can't get too attached to your cards though and that's one of the Tactical opportunities of playing this game but yeah if you're not comfortable with card luck people complain about it in Arc Nova it's a warranted uh warranted pushback people complain about it in wingspan it's a warranted pushback the same applies here though you cannot give those two games grief and not give this game the same amount of grief now does the luck aspect kill the game no because the game is short enough that that luck aspect does not hurt as much and say something like art Nova as my just I love that game I gotta admit it's a three hour Euro game and the luck can have a you know a trigger effect but I tend to find that I can get past it and mitigate it in other ways here you can mitigate it in other ways as well and because a lot of stuff scores you points if you're not doing quite as well with the cards you should be able to do well on other aspects although not doing the objectives is kind of asking to lose the game really I mean you can score like for 40 to 45 points on this with a you know we're doing three of the four objectives pretty well or pretty quickly that's not an insignificant amount of points when your score is somewhere between the 180 to 240 mark you know the difference of going well I get a couple of growth cubes fine two points not a big deal
getting four yield plus points for those objectives though you can't really ignore them and if luck directly dictates that you can't have the courage you want for them it hurts bro this time John Wayne does not walk off into the sunset with Grace Kelly yeah so to quickly touch on the solo mode the solo mode basically has you play against Gaia an AI opponent you play your game pretty much exactly as you normally would with the slight tweak that the actions that you do at the top of your board have an effect that attributes to the AI the AI has their own board and basically you know whenever they get soil or composted cards or growth cubes or the uh the different tree trunks they basically just put them on their board and it gives them a bunch of points although this may look kind of bare bones to you that's because it wants you to put all the trees on separately and all the cubes on separately do not do that that's fiddly as a get out just capped with a cabin SP once it's got filled and use one Cube to track the number of sprout cubes it has not every cube in the Box okay it just gets ridiculously fiddly at that point but it's a very simple AI it basically is a timer you have effectively minimum 12 turns depending whether you go on beginner or expert difficulty it has a small deck of six cards to which pertain to the objectives and the other four pertain to the different color actions you Shuffle it you flip a card and you resolve part of it and Gaia gets the other bit and this goes through twice and if you haven't finished by the time
this deck runs through twice that's the game end otherwise it ends when you complete your Grid in beginner mode you skip guys turns a couple of times so you probably get somewhere in a region of about 16 turns in the game but if you play on expert mode you probably only get 12 Max and I wish it wasn't quite so time constrained but in beginner mode you tend to finish your Grid or at least have a decent grid by the time the game finishes now the rules for the solo mode aren't quite as good as the as the normal multiplayer one there's definitely an FAQ for this somewhere but I think the rules in here with regards to explaining gaia's actions are written quite poorly in some respects it's not particularly clear how it works and there's one aspect with regards to um like how Gaia responds to the actions you take that's written incredibly poorly in fact to the point where I think it's wrong now the solar mode plays very well easy to Pilot the AI challenging even on beginner mode in fact I dare say expert mode is probably too punishing actually but on beginner mode you will lose some games and you will win some games and you get to do all the cool stuff you normally do in the multiplayer game just with a slight time constraint but yeah I really enjoy playing this as a solo mode more than multiplayer you know yes you get lack of downtime in multiplayer but again like I said it doesn't matter who's there at the table because you have no care what it is they're doing so you might as well just use Gaia frankly but I get to use the objectives the
ecosystems have my own Island and climb it and do whatever I want with this grid and the cards just with a couple of little tweaks as to what I'm doing for Guyer because you don't want to give her High VP cards and stuff like that and the more you gain the more Gaia gains it's pretty cool system and yeah honestly if I was to choose how I want to play Earth primarily I'd probably play it solo more than multiplayer this is why Superman works alone where Earth truly sings is all this ability triggering down here all these things are going right I can pay this to get this doing this to get this this gets me a bunch of soil this gets to this it feels fulfilling and satisfying and because the theme is something more appealing than say pay coal to get iron or whatever like something from furnace here with the nature theme and the photography that just pops off the table all the ability triggering just feels feels fun it's had a lot of Buzz it's had a lot of Praise And there's certainly pros and cons to talk about but I gotta give credit where credit's due I really do enjoy this game subject to those caveats I've mentioned I'm giving Earth a well-deserved distinction level 9 out of ten it's not a 10 out of 10 level those those problems I've mentioned do drop it down a Mark I do think the solo rule should have been written better it is fully multiplayer Solitaire and I wish there was at least a little bit of care that I had for other players at the table because I kind of just want to bring this out for myself and occasionally for other
players maybe like one or two more rather than ever wanting to bring this out with four and certainly never five again yeah there's little to no downtime but there's just too much going on too much triggers going all over the place and too many people to wait for that playing this multiplayer with four or five just doesn't seem worth it but a great solo mode a great gameplay system and just a nice appealing theme and a Simplicity level of setup and takedown that is unparalleled in most games these days definitely gives this game a distinction level rating this is in no way going to replace any of the other games that I've mentioned I love already this is not a replacement for wings man okay they're different enough wingspan is a bit more streamlined in terms of its abilities and stuff going on and it certainly probably is a bit more visually appealing but wingspan feels different enough from Earth that I would happily have both of them on my shelf and in no way does this like you know replace something like art Nova art Nova is so fundamentally different to this game and it's one of my favorite games ever that art over is easily going to surpass Earth for me you know but it's a different enough game that you shouldn't really even compare the two now where I mentioned Aries Expedition before yeah I wasn't exactly that amazed with Aries Expedition but frankly Aries Expedition might as well be trashed at this point because that's the game I compare more to this one one and this one just completely creams it in every way shape or form so you know some of you might
disagree with some of the comparisons I'm making to the games here and I'd be interested to know your thoughts on some of those you know particularly there's other games I haven't mentioned but overall Earth is a really great game now I don't think that you should be ignoring some of those flaws I mentioned you know a lot of people aren't saying anything bad about this game and I think that's doing a disservice Earth is an excellent game it's a distinction level just bear in mind those caveats I mentioned and see if this is the game for you but for me it's on my shelf and it's gonna stay there for some considerable time so that's it for me on this episode of the broken meeple if you like what you see please remember to thumb it up on YouTube but also thumb it up on Board Game Geek let's see if we can get it into the Hut review section if possible but until next time you can check out more content on the channel including reviews I have done for 10 Penny Parks or recalcum Goblin vaults and so much more but take care and remember as always regardless of which of the nature theme games out there you're interested in whether it's wings man over Earth or the plethora of others just remember regardless of which ones you love and hate they're still only games so take care and bye for now