Codenames: Critical Role Adventures review - One Stop Co-Op Shop
Transcript
Hey everybody, this is Mike with the One-Stop Co-op Shop, and today I'm reviewing Codenames: Critical Role Adventures, a cooperative spin on the Codenames formula with some D&D flavor. And disclaimer that I got a review copy of this one. So, Critical Role Adventures is in some ways a regular Codenames game. There are series of words out. One player is giving clues to the other players, so it is fully cooperative, no opposing teams. They're trying to find the good cards, these ones with gold, while avoiding gray and red, and of course the black assassin card that's going to end the game immediately. But like I said, there is a lot of D&D flavor added on top of this. You have three characters in your party, not controlled by any one player, and you're having to manage your characters' life when they have wrong guesses. You're unlocking special abilities and equipment, trying to progress through three campaigns with varied scenarios and rules. So, let's discuss five key things to know about Codenames: Critical Role Adventures. So, starting at number five, the least important point to know, but still important or I wouldn't mention it, is the accessibility of the game. And this is a mix for my taste. I don't know about you all, but Codenames, Codenames: Pictures, Codenames: Duet, one of the reasons I keep these games around is because I can throw them down with just about anybody. They are very casual friendly. I've played them with my kids, I've played them with my students. And this still sort of has that. The core Codenames formula is still in here. But you've got these characters with special abilities, special restrictions. You got to roll a D20 to have things activate. And each of the scenarios has special rules and kind of changes things up. You have to keep track of leveling up, of health. And the very fact that it is a campaign formula
means that it's not as friendly to just sitting down and playing one thing. You kind of want to play six to 10 games in a row. So, I still think the game is great. I've still played it with my kids, but I do think you need somebody who kind of knows what's going on and can lead everybody else on both sides of the table, the clue giver and at least one of the players. Next, my number four point is that the game is Codenames. There's not a lot to say here. If you haven't played Codenames before, you are again giving clues. You give a one-word clue and a number. So here, let's say I said army three, then there would be three words related to armies. Maybe that would be general, trebuchet, and knight. But is it also gauntlet? And players are going to pick one word at a time, they'll find out if they're right or wrong. That's the tension of the game, that's the core concept. It still works as advertised here, which means it's still great, and also it still has the potential problems. So this is still a pro for me, but it might not be for everybody, cuz there is some inherent swinginess in Codenames. Sometimes perfect clues kind of materialize, words just go nicely together, and sometimes every clue you want to give is undone by some other word you're not supposed to tell them that is very related to the clues. But I love the core Codenames formula. If you do too, it's basically intact here, and it's still a fun time.
My number three point is another full-on pro, and that is the placement of characters. So even though it is regular Codenames, instead of just picking words, putting your finger on them, instead you are taking one of your three party members, your three characters, and putting them on the words. And if you're right, they'll usually gain an experience point, which is going to help them level up and unlock their skills. If you're wrong though, they're usually going to take some damage. And if somebody loses all of their hearts, then you lose the mission immediately. So there's a nice tension in figuring out which clues are safer, more confident, less confident, who you want to send to which. Sometimes you want to send somebody to a lot of ones to get them experience cuz they're under-leveled or can unlock a really good ability. And speaking of abilities, as they get their powers, sometimes placing them somewhere will also affect the rest of the board, give you clues about future things. So there's lots of interesting things added to the basic Codenames formula here with this character placement. Next number two is the campaign structure and the scenarios. This is also a full pro for me. So there are three campaigns to play through, each of them has multiple scenarios. They have some fun story that has a bit of the Critical Role humor and flavor to it, if you're familiar with the D&D streams or the Amazon show. But even if you aren't, I'm not really, still these are rollicking D&D adventures. Each scenario changes up how things work just a little bit. Maybe you have more rounds but fewer words to guess. Maybe there are special rules like some things will hurt you if you do them in the wrong way. And there's also sometimes branching, so depending on a choice you make and depending on what you do in a scenario, you might play a different one the next time, which is great for replay, but you can also just replay the same campaigns over and over
because even with the same scenario rules, the way it plays out is going to be different game to game with different characters, different words, different clue givers, etc. Finally, the number one point, easily my favorite thing about the game, are the characters themselves and their special powers. This is a full-on pro. So yeah, you've got seven different characters to try out. Each of them levels up differently. They have different modifiers to their die rolls, different health, different powers, and you only use three per campaign, so the variety in combining the characters, how their powers work together, is just great. And it's just a lot of fun to unlock things because as much as I said the game might not always be accessible, you don't have that much to worry about in the first scenario, but then you'll quickly get these powers unlocked, but you have kind of a chance to learn how they work as you go. Additionally, we'll get money you can use to buy items to equip your characters with, so there's even more variety in powers on display. And some of these powers can do really interesting things. Like the game almost becomes a core of discovery or Minesweeper cuz you'll have a character that you place and you'll find out that there are two gold cards adjacent to that card, and then a different character will find out that the black card that'll end your mission immediately is adjacent to one of the cards he's on. So you get more player discussion, more logical deduction, just really, really neat stuff again on top of this pretty simple and straightforward Codenames formula. So overall, you might want to check out Codenames: Critical Role Adventures if you like limited information games, if you like cooperative adventure experiences, or of course, if you like the original Codenames because it's basically that leveled up with a lot of cool new stuff. On the other hand, you
might want to avoid this one if you hate Codenames, obviously, but also if the only way you ever play Codenames is in quick casual settings, here like I said in the review, there's a bit more rules overhead to deal with and you need a bit more commitment from your group to get through a full campaign. Thanks for watching everybody. Good gaming and I'll see you at the next stop.