Skull Review
Transcript
welcome to John gets games today I'll be reviewing skull this is a bluffing game akin2 Liars dice where each player has a small amount of information that they know but they need to make more and more grandiose statements about the overall table State until it just becomes too much and there's only one person left standing there are some definite differences to this game from Liars dice I will first show you how the game plays and then I'm going to jump into my review here's the starting setup for a four player game of skull each player grabs one of these square tiles as well as these four coasters each set of coasters has three coasters with the same flower symbol on it and then one with a awesome skull on it at the beginning of every round each player simultaneously selects one of the coasters that they have left and they put it face down on their tile and now starting with the first player which is this pink orange player down here they either put one of their remaining coasters down which right now we see is two flowers and a skull or they can immediately stop and challenge so for instance this player may take another one of these roses put it face down here and that ends their turn it would now be the blue player's turn because we go clockwise they could once again either put one coaster down or they can start a challenge so let's say they put this coaster down here and that would now make it the green player's turn they could put a coaster down or challenge but let's say that they challenge challenges are pretty easy the player simply States a number and that is the number of coasters they think they can flip over without revealing a skull you always must flip the coasters in front of you however so it's going to dictate maybe what you know you've put down in front of you so the green player might
for instance say two as a challenge number at this moment there are currently six coasters in play because both green and red only have one and they're essential saying they can flip over two of these coasters without revealing a skull but again they have to flip this one over first but they do know what this is so now it's the red player's turn and since the green player challenged nobody can add new coasters to the play area all you can do is either increase the challenge number or pass for instance the red player may say three which would then come back to the orange pink player now they know that they put two flowers down and since you have to pick yours first well them saying four that just means they look at these two which they know and they have to guess on two others so the pink player will say four as a challenge at this point the blue player would probably pass because in order to challenge again they'd have to say five and there's only six coasters out so they would pass the green player would pass and now the red player passes it's back down to the pink player they're the only ones who haven't passed which means the challenge stands and they now have to go through with it and now the pink player must reveal four coasters without showing a skull in order to win this challenge well you must start with your own as I said so they reveal both of those their flowers that's easy now they have to reveal two more they might look over and see that blue put two down they flip the top one from Blue then they say okay I only need one more tile to be not a skull in order for me to win this round so they pick and choose they say well the red player did up the ante so let's try his they flip it over and it's a flower so that means that the pink player has now successfully gone through this challenge there's four coasters without skulls so now these all get tidy
back into players hands and the pink player would flip their sheet over to the black side to show that they've won one challenge but let's rewind time just a little bit to see how this actually could have ended up so the pink player would reveal these two they just need to reveal two more they look over the green player they flip this over and Bam it's the skull that the green player played now they challenged for four coasters but the moment you hit a skull you stop so you're not going to reveal either one of these and the peak player now fails the challenge at this point the pink player gets all four or all of their remaining coasters they shuffle them up nicely and they say to the green player because the green player's skull is the one that broke them pick one of these randomly they might take this one that goes into the middle of the table the pink orangish player here no longer has access to that coaster they keep playing as normal but now they only have three coasters and it looks like oh they got lucky they got to keep their skull but they might have lost their skull and were only playing with flowers at that point in which case they try to hide that fact from their opponents then everybody takes all their coasters back and we begin a new round and the person who was the Challenger of the last round starts the round again in this case it would be pink because they did the challenge so everybody would then take a coaster put it face down in front of them and keep going so now let's jump back to the parallel universe where the pink player was successful in their first challenge they flipped their tile over to this black side to show that they were successful and this is important because when you have your second successful challenge you win the game immediately so everybody knows the pink player is one success from Victory the only other way you can win the game is if you are the last one standing everybody else has lost all of their coasters into the middle if you have at
least one then you also are the winner all right so now let's begin the review of skull and let's start with the Positive points the first of these has to do with the fact that even as you are losing the game more and more by getting called out and losing coasters to the middle you still have a pretty good shot at winning the game I'm directly comparing it to Liars dice right now because the way you the only way you win in liar's dice is being the last one standing so it always comes down until everybody else gets eliminated but in skull you might be losing coasters and knowing less and less information but you only have to win twice and there's been a couple times where I've seen the person who wins the game has like one or two coasters left but they make the right uh bet at the right time and they're able to guess the correct situation there's definitely a bit of luck and Randomness that comes into play there but there's also just it's just great knowing that even though you were almost out you might have one coaster left you could still win the game if you haven't won any yet it's going to be a low probability but I just really like that and the other aspect to this that I like is that the game doesn't go on forever because you don't have to wait for everybody else to get eliminated sure elimination knocks people out and maybe speeds the game up a little bit but ultimately you might have somebody win on the second turn of the game based on how they bid they just might win twice so I really love that kind of innovation on this generalized bluffing structure that I really liked enlarge dice already it just it's a lot better in skull positive number two is pretty simple I just love the art in this game the overall aesthetic that they have
going on is very cohesive and it definitely works and every time I brought this game out and put it out on the table I handed everybody their coasters pretty much all of them are exclaiming about how awesome it looks and the first time they see their skull when they're flipping through the coasters like oh whoa this one looks awesome because it all does look awesome it's just a really great package the only tiny issue I have is that not all of The Coasters seem to directly color match the Square Tile that you have in front of you that Counts points but that's a really minor thing and those tiles look great as well so I just think as a general package it is a beautiful game and that definitely adds to the overall gaming experience so now let's shift into the neutral points and the first of these has to do with the teach of this game now in general bluffing games are very simple to teach in fact they're obviously designed to be played like in a bar where everybody's already somewhat intoxicated uh liar dice is definitely one of those situations where you can explain the whole game in about 20 seconds when it comes to skull almost every time I've taught it to new players I've kind of explained the rules and I've gotten a bunch of blank looks where people like don't quite get it and say you know what just put your coasters down let's just do a full turn once you finish even that first turn you're gonna get it and this is why this is kind of a neutral thing and not a negative because everybody does get it especially after the second turn then everybody's locked in they know exactly what they need to do but it does feel a touch convoluted that first time you're trying to get people into the game but fortunately you can do that quickly enough that people are able to get over that home this is more of a little warning to you as you're trying to teach the game the first time yourself you might get a
bunch of blank stares but just muscle through they'll figure it out pretty quickly and neutral number two has to do with something that honestly might just be a group thing with my friends but I've noticed that there's really nothing stopping people from immediately challenging the moment that comes around to them in fact I've seen this happen many times in fact more than half the time we start a new round nobody is going to even add a second coaster because people just immediately start saying numbers and getting that challenge going which means the challenge numbers for us have are often quite low like you will get called out at four or five whereas if it went around or two where people were putting coasters down there might be like 15 coasters out there and it'll be a little bit more granular like maybe you know how do I go to eight or nine I'm not sure it seems like in our games the the bluff almost never gets past six because there are rarely more than eight or so coasters that are out and I kind of wish even though I already mentioned that it seems like there's several more things going on in this game than uh liar's dice might have I wish there was some tiny little mechanic added in there to not cause that to happen every time I'm not sure what the solution to that is and this does not hurt the overall game but there are many times where we'll start the round and someone maybe puts one coaster down and then someone starts the challenge and I'm just in my head thinking that put the coasters down let's put some more stuff out there let's get a little bit more information a little more craziness going on than almost every round being at what point do I stop between three or six so that is definitely a group thing situation for us but it might be something that you
might uh end up seeing as well and here's the point where I would discuss some negative points to the game but I haven't been able to come up with any of them the only issues I possibly have with this game I already explained as neutral points because they don't really drag the game down they're not really problems they're just tiny little things that get to me so let's move on the replayability of skull to me is quite large and I think that's because I just straight up really enjoy playing it it's a very simple game you're gonna be playing the exact same game every time you play there's nothing hidden in the Box there's no random assortments of shuffles everything is out really what you're doing is playing the people around the table with a couple pieces of cardboard that you have in front of you that facilitate that Medium so playing it with different people is definitely going to shake up the overall experience but I've honestly found playing with many of the same people over and over again that has still just been really fun and so when you think about replayability the idea is at what point have you played it so many times that it's not fun anymore and I played skull I think about six times now but I've played liar's dice like 20 or 30 times and to me skull pretty much completely replaces Liar's Dice and I still sometimes want to play liar's dice so looking at these simple bluffing games I see it having a very long feature I see myself having it for a very very long time and playing it somewhat sporadically just going for through the years I think it's quite high for me but but if you are not into this kind of bluffing game you're going to get a replayability of one because you're just gonna say well there's nothing new that's coming out the second game you have to really enjoy what you see that
first game in order to really even play the game a second time all right now let's discuss the player counts that skull plays the box says it plays three to six players and I think it's a pretty smooth sliding scale from uh best to worst is six to three uh I haven't actually played it three players I think it probably plays fine in that situation but the more players you can get into this game the better I've mostly played it six players I played a couple five player games maybe a four player game I'm not sure but I just think the more people you have the more fun this game is going to be the biggest attractor to a game like lighters dice which I've mentioned many times is that it could drag on too long because the only way you win is by being the last one standing this one mitigates that by allowing someone to win by just getting two of their challenges successfully through so I say throw more people at it I would play this game with eight or ten people if it had the components to do it only the 10 might be a little much but I think you get the idea this game facilitates lots of people being engaged all the time very well and so I think six players best uh if you only have three people give it a shot but somebody else comes in I would definitely try to get that player count as high as you can in conclusion I really enjoyed playing skull and it's not just me pretty much everyone I've introduced this game to has really enjoyed it it's been requested many times since I started teaching it to my group and I think that it's just a really fun package it mixes that great bluffing aspect which is different from lying if you know my taste very well you'll know that I kind of hate lying in games but bluffing is
different because you don't know for sure that the number you're saying is wrong or not and you might say a number that you pretty sure is wrong trying to lead people into going even higher and get themselves in trouble but ultimately you don't actually know that number that six or eight that you might have just said it could be legal it just would be hard to get through um so I just really enjoy that also this game is like rock is fun it's loud laughing kind of fun there have been a couple times where we've been asked to quiet down just a little bit because other people playing games in the other room are trying to concentrate on their Euro Cube Pusher and we are just laughing like crazy you know every time a skull gets flipped looked over when you were doing a challenge everybody just bursts out laughing and it seems like for some odd reason skulls usually get flipped on that last number like if somebody bid six they're good the sixth one is going to be a skull they've been three that third one's gonna be a skull I'm sure that's not the case but it feels like it and that just adds this extra tension that's just wonderful we have had tons of fun playing skull I could not recommend this game enough as I mentioned in the uh replayability bit I think I'm gonna be keeping this one for a long time maybe forever we'll see how that goes but I could not recommend this enough if you'd like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and Vlogs please subscribe to my channel also you can directly support the channel at patreon.com John getsgames thanks for watching