Skip to main content
Loading video...

First Giants is for the dinosaur lovers in all of us - TCbH Review

Transcript 8:10

Hey everyone, this is Jack from The Cardboard Herald and today we're doing another off-the-cuff review of Matthew Dunstan and Brett J. Gilbert's First Giants, a game that can just be summarized by calling it nice. Like, it's just really nice from its presentation to its game flow. I don't know. Like, I just come away going like, nice. So, what is this game? This is a pretty simple card game in which you and other players are paleontologists who are competing to have the best exhibit of fossils. And on your turn, you're going to take one of your tokens and put it onto a dig site that doesn't already have one of your tokens. You're not blocking other players, but you are blocking yourself from going to that same dig site, claiming a card, which then goes into your like research zone. It has a specific name, but for the life of me, no matter how many times I play this, I cannot remember what that zone is. Your study? Your research academy? Your zone on top of your tableau? And then that dig site is refilled. And when it comes back around to your turn, you can either put out another one of your beautiful bespoke tokens onto one of the other dig sites that doesn't have one of yours, or you can recall all of your tokens, which of note, not only do the cards have a color and number, which represents that what sorts of suits you're going to be putting them into as part of the set collection game, more on that in a bit, they can have immediate effects for pulling them, persistent powers, or

triggerable effects so long as they are face up in your zone, including things like the herd icon where if anyone pulls a dinosaur with the herd icon, then everyone activates all of their dinosaurs with herd icons. But, when you recall all of your tokens, you either get one amber or the ability to flip one of your dinosaurs from the study into the exhibit for each token that you recall. So, if you put out more tokens, then you're going to get more of that amber and flips. Now, when you are flipping them over, you are putting them into sets that are all of the same number, but different colors, or into sets that are different numbers, but the same colors. There are five different colors, there are three different numbers, and that gives you the main goal for what you're trying to do.

Because in this game, every set that is a junction between at least two cards gets a little display token, and then if you complete the set, all of those flip over and are suddenly much more valuable. A card on its own does nothing, but once it begins making a set, then you're getting a lot of points out of it. Not only that, but you're also pushing towards these noteworthy bonuses, the publications, the international news about paleontology is writing about your exhibits. And if you have the biggest exhibit now of a particular type of set, then you grab that token, which is bonus points at the end of the game. Now, there are a couple other effects in the game that will reap you points, either from the instant or persistent powers. There's also a bunch of considerations about economy that are going to drive the decisions that you make, because the amber that you get is needed to flip over dinosaurs. Though, there are a bunch of different effects throughout the game that might impact what dinosaurs you choose. And I keep on saying dinosaurs, but this extends much more beyond just specifically dinosaurs.

There's a whole mammalian group, I think it's purple. Once a certain number of display tokens, the junctions between different sets are claimed, that's going to trigger the end game, and then the player with the most points, the little leafy icons, wins. And [clears throat] this game All I can say is it's just really nice. I first played it at PAX Unplugged at like the Asmodee showcase where they were showing up some of their lineup for the upcoming year and both Eric and I walked away from that going like, "Wow, that that game was really the standout there." It would just flowed well, had great components, it made you want to play it, and there were lots of neat levers within the game. And my subsequent plays, once I actually got my hands on it, have really reflected the same thing. There is a little bit about it where I don't want to say that it's imbalanced, but there's just not enough reliability in the random display of cards that come up for you to really execute on leaning into specific strategy. So, it doesn't really have the depth that I would want from some of my favorite games, but it's light enough that I can excuse that. There's also a thing that kept on nagging at me that I didn't like about the game, which is probably in there by design, but sometimes you're like, "Man, I don't want any of these dinosaurs on display except for maybe this one. I guess I'm going to get that one." And you put your

token down and then when it refreshes with another card, then it's the card that you exactly want to get, but you will never be able to back-to-back pull the exact same card again because you will have to go all the way around to your turn and then refresh all your tokens and then go all the way around and at that time it's most likely gone or you've at least burnt a lot of time to get the one card which you might actually want. It doesn't always happen, but at least once during each game I've had that feeling and it's just like a

[sighs]

"Are you kidding me?" which is never a feeling that you really want to have in a game, but those are the low elements of a game that otherwise I've had just a really enjoyable time playing. It's so attractively put together, the adherence to cardboard organization that's elegant but also not ostentatious is really nice as well. And it's a game that, you know, like the ubiquity of dinosaurs and fossils is just such an interesting thing that I think human beings of all types are inherently going to want to get their hands on. So, this is a great game that could bridge the gap to some of your non-gamer friends or some of your more casual gamer friends where it really does have a lot of interesting things that hint at more hobby games, triggerable effects, persistent powers, timing, sequencing that are all really important and some cool levers for when you may want to retract all of your tokens, when you want to invest in something. The There are cool things going on here, but at its core, it's so simple of a mechanism and so elegantly produced that I think this is going to be an easy sell to anyone who likes card games, even the most simple card games, and who likes dinosaurs. And what's not to love there? So, as far as it goes, it didn't bowl me over by any

means, but it did continually make me go, "Yeah, this is nice." And the people that I played it with had the same experience. My family, my friends at the local pub game night, it's just a game that we overall enjoyed. That's our review. But let me know, what is your favorite just nice game where everything comes together nice, it's not too heavy, it's something that makes you want to play, and the presentation just elevates the whole ordeal. Put in the comments below. And as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, no money ever changes hands from publishers to us. We rely on you for the likes, subscribes, comments, the shares on social media platforms, and of course, checking our Patreon, where we give away free games, and we give updates, and just generally rely on that for helping grow the channel. If you like what you see, then go check that out. But, above all else, thanks for just being an amazing community. You know that I've been Jack for The Cardboard Herald.

Progress saved